Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's being unreasonable me or DH?

62 replies

BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:02

Regarding contraception.

One child together, husband wants no more, I probably would have another if he were on board but not desperately bothered by having one.

I have said I'm absolutely done with being responsible for contraception. I'm sick of adding hormones to my body which are not side effect free or having doctors sticking things in me. I've done the pill, the implant, the injection, I do not want a coil. I just don't want anything else in me, physically or hormonally. Since our child I've had nothing and I feel so much better about it.

Told DH he should get the snip for two reasons really.

  1. I've been responsible for contraception up until now, why should he not be?
  1. He's the one who's dead against another child. (He really doesn't want another one, there is no way he'll change his mind so it's not a case of holding off because he's not sure).

He thinks I'm being unreasonable because all I have to do is 'take a pill' whereas he has to have a procedure and he doesn't want to. No other reason than he just doesn't want a procedure done. He doesn't like condoms so whilst we'll use them he doesn't want them to be a long term option if possible.

Who's being unreasonable? I want to keep leaving it at his door whereas he wants me to just give in and 'just take a pill'.

YANBU - he should get the snip.

YABU - you should sort it.

OP posts:
Palease · 01/06/2022 10:48

I wouldn’t want my DH to get a vasectomy. The risk of chronic pain is high. That’s why I opted for the copper coil, no hormones.

I get you don’t see why it has to be up to you, well if condones work for you I don’t see the issue.

BaBun · 01/06/2022 10:37

No coercion or manipulation from my side, as I've already said I'm quite happy with Condoms, it's him who doesn't even want to use them and thinks I should 'just take a pill'. If he's got a problem with Condoms, maybe he should 'just have the snip' is my point.

Condoms maybe? Would you consider a tube tying or sterilisation? Would he consider abstaining?

I'm fine with condoms, he doesn't like them. And no I'd never consider tube tying, because I'm not the one who's dead against having another child. He is.

To the PP who asked his age he's 37.

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 01/06/2022 10:35

I totally agree with you, OP. My DH had the snip for this very reason. He actually said he didn't want me taking any more additional hormones and I didn't want to either. Neither of us got on with condoms so it was vasectomy or celibacy.

"Just take a pill" is naïve bollocks really. They are hormonal and there can be significant risks and side effects for a sizeable proportion of us, especially as we age.

Nothing is entirely risk free for either women or men, but for women there is the extra risk of an unwanted pregnancy, and pregnancy is certainly not risk free.

thewreckofthehesperus · 01/06/2022 10:34

You both get to decide what you are or aren't doing to your own bodies, you don't want to take hormonal contraception and he doesn't want the snip. His only other options are condoms or abstinence, I'd be making it very clear to him that those are his only options and that if you were to fall pregnant that you would be keeping it.

If he tries to put pressure on you I'd ask him why it's ok for him to push decisions about what happens to you body but not ok for you to insist he has a vasectomy.

Tell him to jog on with his double standards.

TibetanTerrah · 01/06/2022 10:34

BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:07

Apparently if there was a pill that he could take he'd do it but luckily for him there isn't.

Easy to say when you know there isn't though imo!

I saw a video recently where men on the street were given the list of side effects for hormonal contraception, and told it was for the new "male" pill. Once they'd read them and asked if they would take it, it was a resounding HELL NO Grin men really have no idea.

Years ago there was a trial of a male pill which was scrapped because of the mood swings, weight gain etc that men experienced, exactly the same side effects as women but of course it's ok for women but unacceptable for men to suffer.

I've had the vasectomy conversation in jest with many men, and they're so weirdly protective of their junk but interestingly their knee jerk reaction is almost always, "the woman should get sterilised".

I've heard fairly recent talk of a male pill and a male cream/serum thing they can apply daily, but honestly I'm not sure I'd trust most men to be consistent with either.

Schwarz · 01/06/2022 10:32

toastofthetown · 01/06/2022 10:28

Neither of you is being unreasonable to not want to take medication or have a surgical procedure you don’t want to have. Anyone who tries to pressurise someone else into taking medication or undergo medical procedures they don’t want is unreasonable.

This sums up what I was going to put!

I don't think because you did it previously (I'm assuming without coercion?!) he now has to do it as it's "his turn".

Condoms maybe? Would you consider a tube tying or sterilisation? Would he consider abstaining?

millymollymoomoo · 01/06/2022 10:31

I hate these threads. Everyone will always like on the guy about his unreasonableness but vasectomy is permanent removal of fertility. It’s not the same as taking contraception

ultimately a couple should be able to sit down together and rationally discuss contraception options, one of which is vasectomy,

how old is he?

Miffee · 01/06/2022 10:30

Just stop taking the pill. I had similar issue with DH. He was happy to get the snip but just couldn't be arsed. I had my implant removed, we then used condoms for the next 5 years because he still never got round to it.

I then told him I would get the implant again as soon as he went to GP and got his referral. That finally worked.

toastofthetown · 01/06/2022 10:28

Neither of you is being unreasonable to not want to take medication or have a surgical procedure you don’t want to have. Anyone who tries to pressurise someone else into taking medication or undergo medical procedures they don’t want is unreasonable.

CornishGem1975 · 01/06/2022 10:26

Nobody is being unreasonable. YANBU for not wanting to take hormonal contraception, he's not BU because he doesn't want a procedure (I'd never ask my DH to have one, it's his choice.)

Just use condoms. Problem solved.

Nanny0gg · 01/06/2022 10:24

Well, he has lots of choices

Condoms
The snip
No sex

None of which are introducing hormones to his body.
And if getting pregnant isn't the end of the world to you, he's the one that's got to prevent it now.

So leave it with him

aSofaNearYou · 01/06/2022 10:20

He's being highly unreasonable, and completely ignorant, dismissive and unappreciative if the toll contraception and childbirth has on women.

He should feel free to use condoms but given he's not willing to do that, his attitude is appalling.

KittiesInsane · 01/06/2022 10:16

Got a link for that 20% increased risk of prostate cancer, Switchin?

Switchin · 01/06/2022 10:09

You're both being equally as unreasonable as each other. There is no "his turn" to do something to his body that he doesn't want to do just because you chose to do it to your body previously. You didn't have to do it before, you chose to - you consented. He's not consenting to it and it's unreasonable to force or coerce him. The same applies the other way around, he can't force or coerce you into consenting either. Both of you have said no - so condoms it is.

Just as he's not acknowledging the side effects and risks of the female contraceptive options, you (and almost every poster on here) are ignoring the risks and side effects of the snip. It causes a 20% increase in the chance he'll get prostate cancer and there's a 15% chance he'll have permanent or long-term scrotum pain - let's not pretend those won't impact you too. If he gets cancer or doesn't want to have sex for the next decade because it's painful then that's hefty for your relationship. It's bad enough when those things happen when he made his own mind up and consented fully to the procedure, but imagine the resentment if you force him into it.

Neither of you can force or coerce or manipulate or bully the other one into getting contraception that you aren't comfortable with. That's unacceptable on so many levels. Both of you need to acknowledge each other's concerns and stop undermining them. You're as bad as each other at this point.

arethereanyleftatall · 01/06/2022 08:21

Yanbu.
I'm (happily) divorced now and I look back on some things that happened during my marriage that were, with hindsight, huge red flags.
This exact conversation was one of those things. Wearing condoms meant his experience was slightly less pleasurable during sex. Slightly less, still had an orgasm every time. Whereas the contraception for me meant headaches every month. It meant mood swings which I was then in the dog house for. Looking back, how was this even a debate? (Of course, being the cool dutiful wife I took the pills for him. Wish I hadn't.)

Hold your ground op. He has the choices of abstinence, condoms, a possible baby, or vasectomy. As you said, it's his turn.

And, dismissing your concerns is pretty abhorrent.

CheshireCats · 01/06/2022 08:20

YANBU.
He is! I would be telling him it's condoms or the snip. His choice there. And tell him any subsequent whinging on his part pressuring you into taking hormonal contraception would result in you seriously going of the idea of sex at all with someone that doesn't respect your decisions.

gamerchick · 01/06/2022 08:19

BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:07

Apparently if there was a pill that he could take he'd do it but luckily for him there isn't.

Easy to say when you know there isn't though imo!

Soon though, isn't there one in the mix with human trials starting this year? Or was it binned?

I'm with you. If he doesn't want to, that's fine. But he's in charge of contraception from now on.

Lazypuppy · 01/06/2022 08:19

I'm going to be in this situation, i've mentioned the snip to my husband and he has shut it down. But i've made it clear after our next baby is born, i am not going back on any contraception. I have been on it for 15 years, given birth to 2 children, so it will be his turn. Whether that is condoms, vasectomy or no sex, decision will be his 🤷🏼‍♀️

I honestly don't understand why so many Men are so funny about the snip, its like it takes away their manhood or something

BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:16

Just be us**

OP posts:
BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:16

Oysterbabe · 01/06/2022 08:15

This is us.
I'm done with contraception. We are very happy with the 2 children that we have. It's up to him now. He is refusing the snip because he is scared of the procedure and any complications. So condoms it is for now. He hates them whereas they don't bother me. Every time he complains I say 'get the snip then'
Maybe he will one day, I can't force him.

I think this will just be use tbh. With me saying 'get the snip then ' any time he complains about the condoms. They work for me, I don't mind them.

OP posts:
MalFunkshun · 01/06/2022 08:16

YANBU. I can’t take hormonal contraception due to family medical history (and it makes me feel shit). DH and I had a similar convo where I pointed out I’d had 3x9 months of messing up my body with pregnancies, plus the births and subsequent healing. He got the snip - a combo of this logic and not wanting a 4th!

Oysterbabe · 01/06/2022 08:15

This is us.
I'm done with contraception. We are very happy with the 2 children that we have. It's up to him now. He is refusing the snip because he is scared of the procedure and any complications. So condoms it is for now. He hates them whereas they don't bother me. Every time he complains I say 'get the snip then'
Maybe he will one day, I can't force him.

Cakecakecheese · 01/06/2022 08:14

All you have to do is take a pill?! Does he think it's a tic tac? Of course it's not unreasonable to not want to take any more hormones.

BaBun · 01/06/2022 08:14

Also... I'd be happy using condoms. He doesn't like them.

OP posts: