Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is grief an excuse?

62 replies

ostrichneo · 01/06/2022 05:12

If someone has recently and suddenly been bereaved, can they be excused for lashing out and physically hurting someone?

I just want to clarify, no one has hurt me and I haven’t hurt anyone. I just know about the situation.

Both sides have told me their side of the story. The one who was hurt just wants to move on and forget. The one who hurt them is struggling with a whole host of emotions.

I just have no idea what to think or do. So far I haven’t really ‘done’ anything. Not really sure what I can do. I’m struggling to decide if grief is an excuse for their behaviour.

So, I wanted to get other’s opinions but didn’t really want to ask anyone I actually know.

YABU - grief is no excuse
YANBU - grief is/ can be an excuse

OP posts:
ostrichneo · 01/06/2022 08:03

If I am honest I don’t have the best relationship with the father. However, the circumstances around the death was horrific. I feel for them but the whole situation has left me very uncomfortable.

I have spent a lot of time with the son since and I have explained that what the father did was very very wrong and their father should have never done it. The son however always sees the best in people and as far as they are concerned they have forgiven their father and that is that.

I am asking for opinions because quite frankly I don’t always trust my own judgement. However, you have all helped. I am going to encourage the father to seek help and keep an close eye on the son.

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 01/06/2022 08:01

Grief can be a reason for behaviour, but it doesn't excuse it.
I tend to give people a lot of leeway when they're grieving, but it's important that they own their behaviour and apologise for it afterwards.

clarepetal · 01/06/2022 07:51

To be Frank, no.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 01/06/2022 07:50

No it's not an excuse. I'm assuming the one being violent is not the only person grieving. Others will be too and can control themselves from getting physically violent. If someone behaves like that, grief or not, they need to sort themselves out. That type of behaviour should never be accepted nor grief used as a reason to physically assault a child.

Ladyofthepeonies · 01/06/2022 07:48

@LakieLady so sorry for your loss. are you on the list for Cruse? Also not an ideal solution but if you can afford it I found monthly counselling helped me (it was all I could afford at the time).

Porcupineintherough · 01/06/2022 07:41

Grief can certainly mean you don't have a stock of patience and understanding to give. Not an excuse but a reason. And, if this is the case, then steps need to be taken to ensure that set of circumstances don't happen again.

RodiganReed · 01/06/2022 07:38

OP I'm going to he really, really honest.. by removing the power dynamics from your first post, and by describing the son's (your son's?) SEN and him being 'quite full on' - it seems like you're trying to justify the father's behaviour?

What is it that's stopping you from being able to draw a very firm line on the sand and saying 'that was unacceptable'? There are no grey areas here, a child was assaulted. What message are you sending to the child by entertaining the idea that this assault may have been justified?

Random789 · 01/06/2022 07:35

We tend to think in a strange dichotomy: Either someone has done something very bad, or they face difficulties that amount to an excuse and therefore what they did wasn't (so) bad.

The reality is that always, always, when a bad thing is done there are causes, difficulties, etc, behind the action. Always, always, there is value in compassionate understanding alongside judgement .

Of course grief may be among the causes of this person's action. Grief does all sorts of different things to people. In the situation described in the OP, it is like the victim and the perpetrator each hold one side of the ideal reaction to what happened -- one is understanding, the other judgemental. But each of those does not exclude the other, and it might possibly be helpful for them if they could find a way to blend their reactions.

Googlecanthelpme · 01/06/2022 07:26

Well there’s no justification that makes physically assaulting someone acceptable however grief can completely consume you and drive you to do things you’d never think you would.
I was suffering with traumatic loss a few years back and the anger I felt was all consuming, I was not a nice person to be around. It did not escalate to violence but I can’t say that given the “right” circumstances it might not have. I was in extreme pain and I was filled with rage. I’d basically lost my rational and normal mind.

Peoniesandcream · 01/06/2022 07:24

What @PinkSyCo said. Never an excuse.

easyday · 01/06/2022 07:21

No. When my husband suddenly died I certainly did a few things I regret but never ever was it physical violence. I was sad, angry, overwhelmed (my kids were small).
Lashing out can happen at any time with provocation but there's no excuse for it.

ostrichneo · 01/06/2022 07:21

Yes, the relationship between the two is father and son.

The son has a history of SEN. They require a lot of patience and understanding as they can be quite full on.

The father was sober at the time and rarely/ never drinks. They do have a short temper but have never lashed out at a person before.

OP posts:
TrailWhale · 01/06/2022 07:19

There's never any excuse for violence - grief however does do horrible things to people.

Re. "Maximum allowed limit of counselling on the NHS" - this varies; they are places that offer more than six sessions.

RodiganReed · 01/06/2022 07:18

If this is concerning a child, which I suspect it is, it's worrying that you even need to ask.

Life is hard. Distressing, profound, life-altering stuff happens - that doesn't give anyone the right or excuse to assault another person, much less a child.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 01/06/2022 07:08

It can be the reason, but it doesn't excuse it.

Has the grieving person taken responsibility for their actions and apologised genuinely? If it was completely a one off and they'd done this, depending on what exactly happened, I might try to move past it. It would need to never ever happen again.

muddyford · 01/06/2022 07:07

I think it can be a reason as often filters are down when someone is struggling with devastating bereavement. Never an excuse though and the person needs help to address the issue.

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 07:07

It depends. When I lost my child I made sure her friends were looked after. I was even gentle with the person responsible. I think I could have been justified lashing out but it didn't come naturally to me. I think sometimes it might be understandable but we're still in control of our actions and choices.

Tubs22 · 01/06/2022 06:59

Going though extreme grief and trauma right now and I get very angry and take my frustrations out on objects not people. There is no excuse

LakieLady · 01/06/2022 06:54

TheLadyDIdGood · 01/06/2022 05:23

Has the bereaved person received any counselling to process their grief. If not, then they're going to be stuck in their destructive grief cycle. I'm not excusing the violence but the grief needs to be managed properly.

Good luck with that. I got 6 sessions of counselling when my DP died 18 months ago. That was the max that was allowed on the NHS, and I had to wait 4 or 5 months for it.

I've been on the waiting list for low-cost counselling for over a year. I can't afford to pay to pay £50pw for counselling, the loss of a second income has severely impacted my finances.

thedancingbear · 01/06/2022 06:53

YABU. Men will use anything they can as an excuse to be violent.

Bigboysmademedoit · 01/06/2022 06:49

It’s not an excuse for physical action and needs addressed as this may become their default response if glossed over. My DH has issues processing emotions like grief and can be angry and frustrated but never, ever physical.

MagicTurtle · 01/06/2022 06:25

This is a tricky question. There’s never an excuse for violence, but if the bereaved person has never done anything like this before and is genuinely devastated about their actions then I guess everyone deserves a second chance. Maybe grief counselling would help?

FrenchBoule · 01/06/2022 06:18

Physically hurting someone is classified as abuse/assault.
Nothing can justify it.

girlmom21 · 01/06/2022 06:13

There is no excuse for violence and the person who lashed out needs to get some help as they're clearly an adult who's struggling very much.

daretodenim · 01/06/2022 06:13

If it's never happened before, then it could be down to the multitude of grief emotions. We think of grief as "sadness", which is almost passive, but it can be a tornado of painful emotions.

It sounds like the "hurter" is remorseful which is good but again, only if it's never happened before.

If they are truly remorseful they'll be wanting to make sure it never happens again and take steps to ensure this, probably including getting some outside help. If the remorse is more along the "poor me" lines (rather than "I can't believe I did that, I never want to do it again") then I'd be worried for the safety of the injured party.

I'm assuming this is between two adults, no children involved and the injured person not elderly/ill/significantly physically disadvantaged in comparison. In that case the remorse needs to find very significant preventative actions immediately.