Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you forgive someone if they'd said this to you?

112 replies

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 22:52

"You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money" (meaning inheritance)

And "you only used to do A for them because they were paying you"

I'm due to see the person that said these things to me tomorrow after almost 6 weeks of NC and I feel like I will just be expected to forgive and forget it all, but I don't know if I can. I can go into more detail if anyone wants/needs to know anything more to make an accurate judgement on if they could themselves forgive, but what they said is very much not true and it hurt me very much.

OP posts:
Meredusoleil · 01/06/2022 00:04

Oh and as my kids are older now, I've explained what happened and why we don't see that side of my family any more, so they kind of understand better.

WibblyWobblyJane · 01/06/2022 00:02

I’d probably “forgive” if it was one of my parents. Probably not if it were an aunt or uncle. Probably stay civil and very distant if it were a sibling. But from any of these people I would just expect more abuse later and be prepared to deal with it. Unless they have a very sincere apology and explanation.

Whoever it is, they are an asshole. I’ve limited contact with relatives who are messed up like this. They don’t contribute anything to my life and I certainly can’t help them (jerks like this that say or do such hateful things are beyond help.)

Meredusoleil · 01/06/2022 00:02

I was in a similar position to you OP when my dad died. I'm still NC with my sibling as a result. My children still ask to see their cousins and family. Dh never wants to see them again but won't stop us. I don't think I'll ever get over it (wasn't just hurtful comments, but more lies and back stabbing/secrecy).

Mamanyt · 01/06/2022 00:02

Well, I'm generally a big proponent of forgiving people...but NEVER of forgetting. Forgiving allows you to move forward, no longer tied to the hurt. No need to tell the other party that you have forgiven them...most of the time they think that their comments were justified, and it wouldn't make any difference.

We swallow a lot for our kids. We really do. Do your best to not have any interaction with the person while they are there, and hope for the best.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/06/2022 00:00

Why you care about what this person thinks or has said is a mystery. This is all about them and how they feel about themselves. You're just their punching bag.

me4real · 31/05/2022 23:58

I think the kids are loving someone who is highly likely to upset them, as the person has you.

Kids can love all sorts of people; it doesn't necessarily mean that having anything to do with them is the best thing for the child. x

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:54

DPotter · 31/05/2022 23:43

I'm sorry but I don't understand why you would want to allow this person to see your children. Whoever they are, they have deeply insulted you, and now they want to play nicey-nicey with your children. And your DH doesn't want to see them either.

I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them

I could sort of understand it if you said you were allowing this meeting FOR for children.

Personally I wouldn't be accepting the gift, even through a 3rd party, wouldn't allow the meeting and that's that. You've be NC for 6 weeks, keep it going, don't step back into their sphere of influence now. The only other person who matters in this decision making is your DH and he doesn't want to see them.

My kids aren't old enough to understand why they wouldn't see this person on one of their birthdays, especially my eldest. The kids have been to their house since the conversation was had, which was facilitated by piggy in the middle so they don't really know there is anything wrong right now.

My DH has very strong opinions on this person and that could be another thread entirely in its own right. He would have gone to their house and given them a mouthful the day it happened if I'd not made him promise not to. But, he is happy for them to see the kids and knows it would kill them not to be able see them and as much as he dislikes them, he knows my kids love them very much.

OP posts:
me4real · 31/05/2022 23:47

I completely understand you being offended @OhHiRocco . I think someone saying something like that would upset me more if it were untrue than if it were true, as they're making a false personal attack on you and probably slurring your reputation falsely to others too.

Buying someone's shopping and them rounding it up a couple of quid or insisting on paying for petrol you use isn't the same as being paid for it anyway.

This person sounds really nasty in many ways- not just to you but also about their sick parent in the past. I would have as little to do with them as possible, and can only imagine how unpleasant it is to see them after what they said to you. Sad

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:44

2pinkginsplease · 31/05/2022 23:34

For me it would depend if there was an element of truth to what they said.

are you only bothering now cause of the money and did you only help out to be paid?

The whole "only bothered now" thing doesn't really make sense to be honest, because this relative died 6 months ago, so in a sense, there is nothing to bother with now if you see what I mean?

I've explained above about the whole "being paid" thing. I did some weekly shopping and the added a couple of quid on for my DS and would offer money for petrol that again, they would give to DS if I refused to accept it. It wasn't like I was getting an hourly rate.
I did it because I wanted to. I barely had to go out of my way, I would do my own weekly shop at the same time, take theirs to them (2 mins up the road) put it away for them, stay and have a chat, run the hoover round, and check if they needed me to do anything before I left (they had carers 4 times a day so very rare anything needed doing). I only stopped doing it because covid happened and I was heavily pregnant. I had a c section and couldn't drive after, then shortly after that they went into hospital then the care home.

OP posts:
G0forit · 31/05/2022 23:43

This person holds beliefs about you that are hurtful. Are they likely to change their mind? Probably not. I don’t think I’d want to meet up with this person but would do so briefly to keep the peace. If there’s any more bs projection about your character I’d be inclined to tell them that it says more about them than you.

DPotter · 31/05/2022 23:43

I'm sorry but I don't understand why you would want to allow this person to see your children. Whoever they are, they have deeply insulted you, and now they want to play nicey-nicey with your children. And your DH doesn't want to see them either.

I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them

I could sort of understand it if you said you were allowing this meeting FOR for children.

Personally I wouldn't be accepting the gift, even through a 3rd party, wouldn't allow the meeting and that's that. You've be NC for 6 weeks, keep it going, don't step back into their sphere of influence now. The only other person who matters in this decision making is your DH and he doesn't want to see them.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 31/05/2022 23:42

I am guessing this was said by a parent, who has a long history of being mean to you. I would be careful about contact between them and your kids, so they don't transfer this behaviour to them. As for what is said - it was not in the first throes of grief, it was a mean and nasty statement designed to make you feel bad about yourself. I think it says more about the person saying it than you, and I would tell them that - these kind of statements reek of projection. I would not reconcile- they sound toxic, whoever they are.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 31/05/2022 23:39

with the additional context you’ve given, no I wouldn’t forgive and I’d also consider if contact with them was really beneficial in anyway.

Is this your children’s aunt/uncle?

the reason I ask is because of your mention of the relationship between them and your children. Is it really possibly for this person to think so lowly of you, and apparently to think bad of you since you were a child, but to also be a positive person for your children to have a relationship with?

namechangedlikeeveryone · 31/05/2022 23:36

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:09

I don't know if I would believe an apology is genuine. And I do think that this is something they truly believe. They have always had a very low opinion of me in a way, always called me selfish and sneaky since I was a child, I was constantly told that I was just like another relative that they absolutely hate.

I just thought that opinion had changed now, and they would see that I am not the same person I was at 16. I am almost 32 years old and not a self absorbed child anymore.

I think there’s quite a lot in the second paragraph here to unpick- but there’s clearly a lot of history on both sides.

I don’t know whether I would forgive them straight away. But as a bare minimum this person did the care home visits, and is making an effort with your nuclear family now. They’re trying - which makes me think that down the line something might be possible.

2pinkginsplease · 31/05/2022 23:34

For me it would depend if there was an element of truth to what they said.

are you only bothering now cause of the money and did you only help out to be paid?

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:30

I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them. And it's difficult for the piggy in the middle not to be the piggy due to the relationship iyswim? They want us to make up, and they partly feel responsible as they half forced the conversation that lead to the comments that were made.

I'm not angst, I'm just pondering how to deal with any attempt to reconcile and wanted some opinions.

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:23

Penguinsaregreat · 31/05/2022 23:08

Why did they wish this person dead?
Was it out of sheer nastiness or coups it have been because the deceased was suffering and in pain.
Its hard to know without more details.
I think I would do whatever is necessary, be civil but don’t make any other small talk. Then leave.

Basically because they were just too much hassle and too demanding. Sorry for being vague on the relationship, but the person who died was their parent. They would repeatedly say, I wish they would have died instead of Y (their other parent who died 7 years ago), Y should have never been the one to go, X should have. X doesn't deserve to be here, they don't care about anyone but themselves. And even just out and out say, I wish X was dead. They would moan about them constantly, about having to do things for them, if they couldn't remember things, if they asked the same questions over and over. They were in a care home for the last 2 years of their life and the person who said these things to me didn't have to do a thing for them, but was such a martyr about going to visit, but was on the other hand overly lovey dovey with them (it was actually a bit cringey to watch). They told me they wouldn't hold it against me for not going often but they evidently did. I have 2 kids, soon to be 3, and was diagnosed with a serious health condition last year, and tbh I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see.

For a bit more context on the "being paid to do A", before they went into a care home I would do their weekly shopping for them and take it to them. It wasn't a problem and I didn't mind doing it. I would pay on my card and give them the receipt, and they would give me the cash. If it was say, £17.50, they would round it up to £20, and tell me to put the £2.50 in my child's money box (I was pregnant with DC2 at the time). And then every few weeks they would give me £5 for petrol that I would tell them wasn't necessary at all and if I refused to accept it they would just give it to DS.

OP posts:
DeeCeeCherry · 31/05/2022 23:17

It is one of my kid's birthdays and they want to see them to give a card and gift, they are coming with someone else who I am still on good terms with and who knows what was said and thinks they were out of order for it

The piggy in the middle person needs to come and drop the present off alone - s/he isnt joined to the other person at the hip presumably? & then stop being piggy. Too much drama.

Honestly if you dont want to see someone, then dont. Why all this angst? Life's too short. I bet said person + piggy in the middle know you're stressing, yet they'll still show up at your door regardless

Presents can be posted there is such a thing.

I cant see why you're allowing this, much less letting it get to you. Id have knocked it on the head at the outset, maybe your child will miss out on a present but so what?

Penguinsaregreat · 31/05/2022 23:10

Sorry cross posted.
Still just be civil but nothing more than that.

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:09

I don't know if I would believe an apology is genuine. And I do think that this is something they truly believe. They have always had a very low opinion of me in a way, always called me selfish and sneaky since I was a child, I was constantly told that I was just like another relative that they absolutely hate.

I just thought that opinion had changed now, and they would see that I am not the same person I was at 16. I am almost 32 years old and not a self absorbed child anymore.

OP posts:
Penguinsaregreat · 31/05/2022 23:08

Why did they wish this person dead?
Was it out of sheer nastiness or coups it have been because the deceased was suffering and in pain.
Its hard to know without more details.
I think I would do whatever is necessary, be civil but don’t make any other small talk. Then leave.

rnsaslkih · 31/05/2022 23:06

Hard to say. If it was not true, I would have told the person that right away to their face. We completely fell out with dh sibling when PIL were old/dead. Sibling did nothing to help us with PIL when they were alive. When we fixed problems, sibling criticised us on the phone to PIL. And when PIL died, sibling was no longer too busy/far away, sibling was at the house on the bloody take.

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:05

BracedlnEndIessJanuary · 31/05/2022 22:58

Why do you have to see this person?
Are you on their own with them 1-1 or is it a family event?
Do you have back-up or are you going to be ganged up on?
In your shoes, I would be civil/speaking when spoken to if relevant to paperwork etc but I would not be tolerating abuse or snark, nor would I be playing happy bloody families. Get in, do the job/reason you are there, get out again.

It is one of my kid's birthdays and they want to see them to give a card and gift, they are coming with someone else who I am still on good terms with and who knows what was said and thinks they were out of order for it. They are piggy in the middle tbh. I have said I will be civil for the sake of my children so they can see them. My DH refuses to see them because he will absolutely blow his lid at them so in that sense it is just me.

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:01

Gazelda · 31/05/2022 22:56

Even if I could eventually forgive, I don't think I'd ever forget.

Was it said immediately after the death of the person in question, ie in the heat of the moment? Was the person saying these things left out of the will? Was the person saying these things perhaps talking out of guilt from their own lack of effort towards the deceased?

It was said about 6 months after the death when a property was being sold and everything being finalized. This person was the executor of the will, and one of the 4 people who would benefit.

I think there may be an element of their own guilt, as they wished this person dead many times in the years prior to their death and only did the bare minimum out of obligation.

OP posts:
Nein9 · 31/05/2022 23:01

Nein9 · 31/05/2022 22:58

I suppose it might depend on who it was. If it was, for example, my grandma who had died and my mum said it due to not coping well and being overcome with grief causing her to lash out, I could probably forgive her. If it was someone saying it purely to have a go, then I probably wouldn't.

I'm guessing you did something for this person and they did pay you, but that wasn't your main reason to do it. Could it be that this person has misunderstood your motives?

I've said "this person" a lot about different people! I mean, could the person accusing you have misunderstood your real motive for helping the person who died, and mistakenly think it was solely down to money.