Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you forgive someone if they'd said this to you?

112 replies

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 22:52

"You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money" (meaning inheritance)

And "you only used to do A for them because they were paying you"

I'm due to see the person that said these things to me tomorrow after almost 6 weeks of NC and I feel like I will just be expected to forgive and forget it all, but I don't know if I can. I can go into more detail if anyone wants/needs to know anything more to make an accurate judgement on if they could themselves forgive, but what they said is very much not true and it hurt me very much.

OP posts:
fUNNYfACE36 · 01/06/2022 02:07

HeddaGarbled · 01/06/2022 00:17

They would moan about them constantly, about having to do things for them, if they couldn't remember things, if they asked the same questions over and over. They were in a care home for the last 2 years of their life and the person who said these things to me didn't have to do a thing for them, but was such a martyr about going to visit, but was on the other hand overly lovey dovey with them (it was actually a bit cringey to watch)

Ah, I think you may both be misjudging each other from a position of extreme stress.

Having a parent with dementia is so so hard and distressing. Everything you say about this person here, could be said about me by someone watching from the sidelines without genuine understanding of how hard it is. None of us are saints.

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

For this other person too, of course, but they did it, didn’t they? Doggedly, until the end. And out of their trauma, came some anger, and some words they may now regret.

Don’t turn this traumatic and painful episode into a feud.

This poster has nailed it

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 01:09

BreadInCaptivity · 01/06/2022 00:48

As I said above, my DH strongly dislikes them, but even he can see they love our kids and wants them to have a relationship. He would be the first to stop any contact if he didn't think it was a good idea. He cut off his own DM for not bothering with DS1 when he was a baby, she'd go 6-8 weeks without seeing him or even texting/calling to ask after him. He cut off his DB for similar.

As a family you seem to be cutting off quite a few people out of your lives.

Perhaps there is more of a back story here than you've written about, but perhaps consider that communication is a good way to resolve issues rather than blanking people from your life by being continually offended by people not meeting your standards.

Did your mother say some horrible things - yes she did. But I'm assuming it was one of her parents who died and that had a significant emotional impact.

Talk to her about how you feel (without losing your rag) and go from there.

IMHO people go from 0-60mph far too fast in making life changing decisions about family and contact without taking the time to discuss the issue at hand.

It's ok to feel hurt by what she said, but based on what you posted, you and your DH are very quick to cut people out of your lives that don't meet your expectations.

There is much more of a back story with regards to DH and cutting off his own family tbh, that was just the final straw before he cut his DM off. There's a long history of growing up neglected, in a home full of domestic violence, physical child abuse, alcoholism and a lot more I'm sure even I don't know about. As a result, he does not stand for people's bullshit, he is very much a "things are black or white" type person. He doesn't do wishy washy, or shitty excuses. If you don't make an effort with me or my kids, then he won't make an effort with you. Which is why he won't cut my DM off from them. He knows that she cares, would do anything for them and will always make an effort with them.

I am a lot more for giving people the benefit of the doubt. It's one of the things he thinks I need to work on, but again, that's for another thread 🤣

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:58

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:45

@OhHiRocco

So wait....it's your mother who's complaining? So I assume that piggy in the middle is your dad.

"Make it make sense."

Honestly, if the relationships are what they think I are, I can't make it make sense unless your mother is, shall we say, not a very kind/nice person. I guess I can see your reason for wanting to continue to be around her, for your dad's sake, but honestly it would be very hard for me after such ugly words.

The best I would be able to do is be icily polite. I just couldn't play happy families or accept a fake apology, it would be too false to myself. And if she dared to say anything about the 'situation' I'd say "Do NOT bring that up. If you do, you will be asked to leave".

I'm sorry you're having to deal with this. It's really shit in the midst of your grief.

Yes, it's my Mum, her Dad is the one who passed away. And Piggy in the middle is my Dad.

She is, in all honesty, a deeply deeply unhappy person. She has a long list of health issues, that I am not denying is difficult to live with, but she is just so negative and bitter, it's hard to be around her sometimes. She acts like everything is the worst thing in the world, it's always such a drama. She acts as if our family gets all the bad luck and nothing ever goes right for any of us, and that life is just sooo sooo hard, and she makes absolutely everything about her and her feelings. She sees problems that aren't there and makes up ridiculous "what ifs" in her head. It's draining. My dad is a very mentally stable and reasonable man, how they've been together for almost 40 years, I'll never know.

I'm thinking for tomorrow at least, of just being civil and polite, but like you say, not engaging regarding what she said.

OP posts:
SinisterBumFacedCat · 01/06/2022 00:53

I suspect she is using your children to isolate you further, saying look I can have a wonderful relationship with my grandchildren but not you. It’s another form of bullying and your children are just pawns.

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:48

".....are what they think I are". This is what happens when you don't proof read and you're trying to type as fast as you're thinking

"....are what I think they are."

BreadInCaptivity · 01/06/2022 00:48

As I said above, my DH strongly dislikes them, but even he can see they love our kids and wants them to have a relationship. He would be the first to stop any contact if he didn't think it was a good idea. He cut off his own DM for not bothering with DS1 when he was a baby, she'd go 6-8 weeks without seeing him or even texting/calling to ask after him. He cut off his DB for similar.

As a family you seem to be cutting off quite a few people out of your lives.

Perhaps there is more of a back story here than you've written about, but perhaps consider that communication is a good way to resolve issues rather than blanking people from your life by being continually offended by people not meeting your standards.

Did your mother say some horrible things - yes she did. But I'm assuming it was one of her parents who died and that had a significant emotional impact.

Talk to her about how you feel (without losing your rag) and go from there.

IMHO people go from 0-60mph far too fast in making life changing decisions about family and contact without taking the time to discuss the issue at hand.

It's ok to feel hurt by what she said, but based on what you posted, you and your DH are very quick to cut people out of your lives that don't meet your expectations.

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:45

@OhHiRocco

So wait....it's your mother who's complaining? So I assume that piggy in the middle is your dad.

"Make it make sense."

Honestly, if the relationships are what they think I are, I can't make it make sense unless your mother is, shall we say, not a very kind/nice person. I guess I can see your reason for wanting to continue to be around her, for your dad's sake, but honestly it would be very hard for me after such ugly words.

The best I would be able to do is be icily polite. I just couldn't play happy families or accept a fake apology, it would be too false to myself. And if she dared to say anything about the 'situation' I'd say "Do NOT bring that up. If you do, you will be asked to leave".

I'm sorry you're having to deal with this. It's really shit in the midst of your grief.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:41

Meredusoleil · 01/06/2022 00:02

I was in a similar position to you OP when my dad died. I'm still NC with my sibling as a result. My children still ask to see their cousins and family. Dh never wants to see them again but won't stop us. I don't think I'll ever get over it (wasn't just hurtful comments, but more lies and back stabbing/secrecy).

Sorry that you have had to go through a similar situation Flowers

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:37

Figstar4eva · 01/06/2022 00:23

I had a similar situation. It beyond hurt me and belittled by relationship with the deceased but I choose to forgive, rise above is as I knew the person didn't mean it and was lashing out from the grief. I haven't forgotten though.

Yes, this is exactly how it felt, like they have belittled my relationship with my own grandparent!

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:31

HeddaGarbled · 01/06/2022 00:17

They would moan about them constantly, about having to do things for them, if they couldn't remember things, if they asked the same questions over and over. They were in a care home for the last 2 years of their life and the person who said these things to me didn't have to do a thing for them, but was such a martyr about going to visit, but was on the other hand overly lovey dovey with them (it was actually a bit cringey to watch)

Ah, I think you may both be misjudging each other from a position of extreme stress.

Having a parent with dementia is so so hard and distressing. Everything you say about this person here, could be said about me by someone watching from the sidelines without genuine understanding of how hard it is. None of us are saints.

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

For this other person too, of course, but they did it, didn’t they? Doggedly, until the end. And out of their trauma, came some anger, and some words they may now regret.

Don’t turn this traumatic and painful episode into a feud.

My other grandparent also had dementia for years before they died, so I do understand how distressing it can be. But this grandparent only got diagnosed not long before they died, and it was not as extreme as what we experienced before. Mostly due to them being in the care home, and restricted visiting for a long time due to covid, so we were sheilded from it a lot. She didn't visit for a long time, as it was only 1 person allowed, and this was my sibling who was the designated person as they had POA. She went for maybe the last few months they were in the home, so it's not like she was caring for them day in day out, 24 hours a day. She has always talked about them in this way and even after they died she talked about how much she resented them and basically blamed them for ruining her life.

OP posts:
Sarah3587 · 01/06/2022 00:27

I would brush it off. Emotions are high when someone we love dies. Perhaps they do harbour negative feelings and maybe they do feel this is true about you but you can either ignore them and move on or put them right. However I wouldn’t let it upset you. Only you know the truth and the truth counts not speculation.

Figstar4eva · 01/06/2022 00:23

I had a similar situation. It beyond hurt me and belittled by relationship with the deceased but I choose to forgive, rise above is as I knew the person didn't mean it and was lashing out from the grief. I haven't forgotten though.

Boiledbeetle · 01/06/2022 00:21

"I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them"

Nah! Fuck that! You're other half is already ready to deck them! You don't want to see them. The kids will get over it.

If someone spoke to me the way you have been spoken to...like fuck would they ever lie eyes on me or the kids again. Shitty behaviour shouldn't be rewarded!

Diverseopinions · 01/06/2022 00:20

I think that saying this shows that the person has serious difficulties showing empathy and that all sorts of brakes, and checks and balances in their head, are not working properly. You just don't say bald things like this to people. It's indecent; it shows a lack of finer feeling.

I would send a message by text or whatever saying that you can't get over what they said, and you can't trust them to always behave appropriately in front of your children, but you are going to let it go for the sake of the kids. But please, don't mention other family members to you again, and keep it about creating jolly experiences for the children. You have no desire to ever again discuss what has caused you such pain.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/06/2022 00:18

“My kids are the only good thing in their lives and some days, they are the only reason they would even get out of bed.”

sorry op but this just sounds toxic also. Children shouldn’t be in a relationship with adults to meet the adults needs. Especially adults who are toxic to that child’s mother, because in reality it would be almost impossible for that person thinking so badly if you, not to have an impact on your children. Even children understand when there is an atmosphere….I’m assuming they have\will notice their father doesn’t see this person or know there is something happening that feels uncomfortable.

The only question I have is if there is some significant piece of context missing. Did you do something to wrong this person in the past. If not then I really don’t see why you allowed them in your life.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:18

Aghh · 01/06/2022 00:05

Was this your mother ?

Yes, if anyone hadn't figured it out yet Sad

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · 01/06/2022 00:17

They would moan about them constantly, about having to do things for them, if they couldn't remember things, if they asked the same questions over and over. They were in a care home for the last 2 years of their life and the person who said these things to me didn't have to do a thing for them, but was such a martyr about going to visit, but was on the other hand overly lovey dovey with them (it was actually a bit cringey to watch)

Ah, I think you may both be misjudging each other from a position of extreme stress.

Having a parent with dementia is so so hard and distressing. Everything you say about this person here, could be said about me by someone watching from the sidelines without genuine understanding of how hard it is. None of us are saints.

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

For this other person too, of course, but they did it, didn’t they? Doggedly, until the end. And out of their trauma, came some anger, and some words they may now regret.

Don’t turn this traumatic and painful episode into a feud.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:15

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:04

Chances are I'd never want to see that person again. Why would I want to be around someone who has such a low (and false) opinion of me? And I wouldn't want them around my children either because I wouldn't know what that person might say to, or in front of, them. They can keep their gift and their card. If they don't care about me, their mother, then they need to be around my my children.

What I don't get is why, since they received an inheritance too, they feel you shouldn't have gotten one. Do they think they did 'more' than you and that the inheritance should have been 'portioned out' based on the amount of time spent with the deceased or how much work one did for them? Did you receive a larger portion? Or perhaps you're a more distant relative or friend and the executor feels that only 'their level' of relative (children? siblings?) should have received an inheritance?

I don't think it's even about the money. It was split equally between 4 relatives. So them, piggy in the middle, me and my sibling (this may make the full relationship clear now but oh well).

I think it was more to do with how quickly they believe that I had planned to use the money. Before the comments were made was a conversation about us selling up and moving house (we need more space, having DS3 in a week).

We don't actually even need the inheritance money to move, after getting it valued we have a lot of equity and having received asking price offers before we've even had any viewings.

This is also despite the fact that they themselves have marketed, sold and had an offer accepted on another property before we had even put ours on the market.

Make it make sense.

OP posts:
expat101 · 01/06/2022 00:11

I can think of a similar situation between two siblings, although there will not be an attempt at reconcillation.

The comment came from a place of anger and frustration where there was fraud within the family (one sibling helping themself to deceased parent's bank account prior to estate settlement) with that same sibling wanting a quick cash out from the estate's funds to purchase another vehicle they had their eye on.

So to the other sibling, it just seemed like the deceased parent was still being used as a cash cow.

This may or may not assist you in understanding why the comment you received was said and may be an inappropriate comparison. However I don't think I would be presenting myself in front of the sibling ever again.

I am aware in the situation that I know of, that person will never forgive nor forget and its best that all parties move on.

Who organised the party and thought it a good idea to bring the pair of you together?

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:11

...then they DON'T need to be around my children.

HellonHeels · 01/06/2022 00:09

Your children are unlikely to benefit from having any relationship with a toxic individual.

How would they feel f the person starts speaking to them about you in this way? That would be very unsettling and worrying for young children.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:06

me4real · 31/05/2022 23:58

I think the kids are loving someone who is highly likely to upset them, as the person has you.

Kids can love all sorts of people; it doesn't necessarily mean that having anything to do with them is the best thing for the child. x

I do understand where you're coming from, I really do, but as horrible as they have been to me, they are completely different with my kids to how they were with me growing up. My kids are the only good thing in their lives and some days, they are the only reason they would even get out of bed.

As I said above, my DH strongly dislikes them, but even he can see they love our kids and wants them to have a relationship. He would be the first to stop any contact if he didn't think it was a good idea. He cut off his own DM for not bothering with DS1 when he was a baby, she'd go 6-8 weeks without seeing him or even texting/calling to ask after him. He cut off his DB for similar.

OP posts:
Aghh · 01/06/2022 00:05

Was this your mother ?

WibblyWobblyJane · 01/06/2022 00:05

And please accept my sympathy 💐

My neice that I barely know and was trying to forge a relationship with called me a crook recently. It was a bit like calling me a giraffe actually as I have no idea of any basis. I actually think she’s just crazy. But it still made me so very sad.

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 00:04

Chances are I'd never want to see that person again. Why would I want to be around someone who has such a low (and false) opinion of me? And I wouldn't want them around my children either because I wouldn't know what that person might say to, or in front of, them. They can keep their gift and their card. If they don't care about me, their mother, then they need to be around my my children.

What I don't get is why, since they received an inheritance too, they feel you shouldn't have gotten one. Do they think they did 'more' than you and that the inheritance should have been 'portioned out' based on the amount of time spent with the deceased or how much work one did for them? Did you receive a larger portion? Or perhaps you're a more distant relative or friend and the executor feels that only 'their level' of relative (children? siblings?) should have received an inheritance?