Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you forgive someone if they'd said this to you?

112 replies

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 22:52

"You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money" (meaning inheritance)

And "you only used to do A for them because they were paying you"

I'm due to see the person that said these things to me tomorrow after almost 6 weeks of NC and I feel like I will just be expected to forgive and forget it all, but I don't know if I can. I can go into more detail if anyone wants/needs to know anything more to make an accurate judgement on if they could themselves forgive, but what they said is very much not true and it hurt me very much.

OP posts:
Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/06/2022 08:39

How old are your children op.
I wonder, if your mum speaks so badly of her own mother and child, how long will it be until she acts like this with your children. If they are young right now they might meet her needs (to be loved, cuddled etc). I wonder how she will feel as they get older, if the don’t visit her as much as she’d like, or if they get back chatty.

Lobelia123 · 01/06/2022 08:36

Your mother sounds like a deeply unpleasant person who must be exhausting to be around....sounds like she can suck the joy out of almost any occasion. So unnecessary, does browbeats and depresses everyone around her and it sounds like she often oversteps the line between being unpleasant and being downright offensive and nasty. It sounds like shes gotten away with this vile behaviour for a long time. As tempting as it is just to say, cut her off, I know in real life the complexities and web of family relationships make that really hard. If it were me, I would allow the contact but supervise it really closely to make sure she doesnt start imposing this poison on your kids. And keep it to a minimum . If she ever opens her mouth to say such vile things again, do not allow it to go unchallenged - that implied its true and you agree. stand up for yourself and state the truth.

frazzledasarock · 01/06/2022 08:21

Why on earth would you allow a woman who is so bitter and nasty contact with your young impressionable children?

what if she starts bad mouthing you to your children and manipulating them?

I don’t see this going well as they get older.

Sswhinesthebest · 01/06/2022 08:21

Just be civil and polite, for your dads sake.

Everyone knows the truth.

itsnice · 01/06/2022 08:12

Why you want your kids to have a relationship with a person who says such things about their close family members?

middleeasternpromise · 01/06/2022 08:11

I think you have already drawn a boundary with your mother by not speaking to her for several weeks since your fathers ill fated attempt at mediation. If you have decided the part of your mother that performs well as a grandmother is worth keeping and you see value for your children, then that sounds like a decision. You don't have to pretend that things haven't changed though by being polite and civil, you can still be a respectful communicator but now speak from a place of honesty. Tell your mother her words to you were unforgivable in your opinion, you will support your children's relationship with her so long as she treats your children well. You have reflected on the relationship you both have and are saddened that she has said/held very negative beliefs about you and you will no longer be tolerating that. She needs to speak kindly or keep her angry hurtful views to herself, if not she can leave. A very honest and boundaried opportunity awaits you - you have nothing to lose from what you say as the next option is to cut her off but in so doing your father is probably put in a difficult place of choosing and he sounds like he would struggle to do that. Not every position has to be all or nothing but neither do you have to tolerate the intolerable,

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 08:06

Mashinga · 01/06/2022 06:48

You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money
Is it true though? I said this to several family members when my aunt died. They hadn’t visited her for over a decade but they turned up and cried at her funeral. And obviously they put their hands out and took the money.

If you'd read all of my posts you would see that what she said is not true. We are an extremely small and (I thought) close family, I am not some distant relative, this was my grandfather. I saw him very often, I lived a few minutes drive up the road from him. I didn't just start caring before he died so I'd get his money.

OP posts:
Tryhard40 · 01/06/2022 08:05

Your dm sounds like a narcissist.

No way on earth would I be allowing her to see my dc's - comments re death of gp nonwithstanding - she sounds like a miserable, nasty cow who has everyone jumping through hoops for her. Your dh is the only one with any common sense!

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 07:54

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/06/2022 02:59

You need to read about ring theory and circles of support.your grandparent is the centre of the crisis, your mum as close family is in the innermost circle next circle you and your siblings, next circle extended family and close friends next circle etc. The rule is that people can dump outwards, but only support moves inwards.please try to grow the emotional maturity to follow this.Your mum , as the most affected, can dump outwards on you, but in return you should give support.
It is extremely hard to have a parent suffering dementia, and I think it is pretty poor you did not visit the care home.Please try to grow up a little bit and stop making this crisis all about you

Just to clarify, I DID visit the care home when it was allowed but for a long time they restricted visiting to no one at all, then just to 1 designated person only, and then finally 2 people which is when my Mum herself first started going every week out of obligation, not out of want to see him. She went so when he died she could make it seem to other people she was the doting daughter who visited every week. I just didn't visit weekly. I even went a couple of times and was turned away because he just wasn't up to it.

OP posts:
Isthisit22 · 01/06/2022 07:29

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 00:58

Yes, it's my Mum, her Dad is the one who passed away. And Piggy in the middle is my Dad.

She is, in all honesty, a deeply deeply unhappy person. She has a long list of health issues, that I am not denying is difficult to live with, but she is just so negative and bitter, it's hard to be around her sometimes. She acts like everything is the worst thing in the world, it's always such a drama. She acts as if our family gets all the bad luck and nothing ever goes right for any of us, and that life is just sooo sooo hard, and she makes absolutely everything about her and her feelings. She sees problems that aren't there and makes up ridiculous "what ifs" in her head. It's draining. My dad is a very mentally stable and reasonable man, how they've been together for almost 40 years, I'll never know.

I'm thinking for tomorrow at least, of just being civil and polite, but like you say, not engaging regarding what she said.

Please don't inflict this person on your children! She will only add poison and negativity to their lives in the long run.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 01/06/2022 07:19

"I'm sorry but I don't understand why you would want to allow this person to see your children. Whoever they are, they have deeply insulted you, and now they want to play nicey-nicey with your children. And your DH doesn't want to see them either.
I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them
I could sort of understand it if you said you were allowing this meeting FOR for children.
Personally I wouldn't be accepting the gift, even through a 3rd party, wouldn't allow the meeting and that's that. You've be NC for 6 weeks, keep it going, don't step back into their sphere of influence now. The only other person who matters in this decision making is your DH and he doesn't want to see them."

^ this is sound common sense.

Don't allow toxic people into your life so they can drag you down.

Just because they are family doesn't give them a free pass to be nasty.

timeisnotaline · 01/06/2022 07:18

Children manage fine without grandparents and the most important thing is they have stable happy parents. So you should do what works for you- your mother has been horrible to you for most of your life and that’s a huge thing. You should not be thinking of her in any decision on contact. It would be perfectly reasonable to cut contact. If she can’t be civil to you then it would be best to cut contact.

picklemewalnuts · 01/06/2022 07:05

So, I'm in a similar position. My DM whinges about everything, nothing is enough, etc. she can't be stressed or unhappy without everyone around her feeling it too, and when she's happy it's because her needs have been met even if at the expense of everyone else. If she has a thought, even a nasty one, it falls out of her mouth. She's very critical.

My dad was a lovely, grounded man. How he put up with her for years I'll never know.

Some things to bear in mind...

I've often regretted bitterly that he died, and she's still with us. It's not fair. I'm not a nasty person, there are many reasons why this way round has been very hard on us all.

He actually chose to be with her for almost 60 years. Active choices. I have to respect that. I actually don't respect the way he pandered to her- he made an active choice to let her carry on the way she does.
So your piggy in the middle is choosing to indulge his wife's ways, remember.

We can see someone's weaknesses and choose to overlook them. Just don't make yourself emotionally vulnerable to her. You know what she's like, don't expect her to change or be different.

She's judging you on her own standards. She knows what goes on in her own head, and assumes similar in yours. That's means what she says is not a terrible insult, even if it sounds like it. It's not based on her knowledge of you. It's based on her knowledge of herself. So let it go.

Be careful of your children. Give them tools to manage unreasonable people. Just because she's lovely with them now, doesn't mean she'll cope with them when they get older and break out of her idea of what a lovely grandchild is like. DM was great with babies, awful with unreasonable toddlers. It got better for us as the DC were old enough to realise the score, and behave accordingly. For my nieces and nephews it got worse as they didn't behave accordingly (cheeky teens).

SunnyLobelia · 01/06/2022 06:48

ChampagneLassie · 01/06/2022 02:40

I think you need to have it out with your mum and consider further NC. I'd look at it like this, it sounds like your mum was and is emotionally abusive to you and in having an ongoing relationship you are allowing her to continue to hurt you. I certainly wouldn't trust how she'd be with your DC not least that she is disrespectful of and undermining of you and that your DC may well pick up on this. We tell women to leave abusive men because of how children will think of those relationships, would you want yoyr children to think being treated like this is acceptable? Denying access to DCisnt about pushing your mother, it's about protecting them from someone who could do them harm. I'd cancel the visit, say you don't feel able to meet and suggest a talk another time. Tell DC unfortunately DGP can't come. Or let your dad come alone. He doesn't have to be piggy unless he wants to be.

I agree with this. I also know how damaging it can be for children to be around toxic extended relatives especially when they know there is an issue with their mother and the toxic one. They know- they always know and if they are too young now they will come to realise it.

And you dad might be sensible and reasonable but he is also her enabler. You are considering allowing her to come because he is coming. He is facilitating access to her and has put up with her nastiness for years. This is enabling her. I have always said that everyone tiptoes around the most difficult person in the room, but you can stop that now.

Give yourself a breather and some space. Read up on some of the very excellent books for adult children of absuive parents. Figure out what you want to do when you have had a chance to separate yourself emotionally a bit. You are so stuck in the grooves of how you relate to her you probably cannot even see it for the full amount of toxicity that it truly is.

And no, I would never forgive that comment.

Mashinga · 01/06/2022 06:48

You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money
Is it true though? I said this to several family members when my aunt died. They hadn’t visited her for over a decade but they turned up and cried at her funeral. And obviously they put their hands out and took the money.

Moithered · 01/06/2022 06:36

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:05

It is one of my kid's birthdays and they want to see them to give a card and gift, they are coming with someone else who I am still on good terms with and who knows what was said and thinks they were out of order for it. They are piggy in the middle tbh. I have said I will be civil for the sake of my children so they can see them. My DH refuses to see them because he will absolutely blow his lid at them so in that sense it is just me.

You are beib rather unfair on your DH here; he absolutely is supporting you to the point that he would be very upset on your behalf if he saw this person again.
The fact you are allowing this person to come to your house and interact with you DD puts DH and person coming with Nasty Person in an invidious position.

Has you DD missied Nasty Person since you've been NC? If Nasty isn't important to her, you are being unreasonable to let this person come just to satisfy their own need

PinkSyCo · 01/06/2022 05:35

I wouldn’t want to be around someone who thought so badly of me ever again. Have they even apologised?

Imsittinginthekitchensink · 01/06/2022 05:28

Maybe she genuinely feels what she said is true Until you said it was your mother, my brother could have written this about me. I have a very poor opinion over how he behaved when my mother was ill and dying and that will never change, no matter how he has rewritten the story. He has now become the victim while I put up with his actions over a very long period of time but to say anything meant I was perceived as lashing out or being unfair.

ClaryFairchild · 01/06/2022 05:17

I know you've said that she loves your DC and treats them differently to how she treats you, and as a grandmother to them I can believe that. BUT, do you honestly think that she would avoid dripping poison in their ear about you? Even if it's unintentionally? I just couldn't trust them alone with my DC, and if I couldn't be there with them too (and I wouldn't want to be), they wouldn't see my DC. Actions have consequences.

Chocaholic9 · 01/06/2022 04:19

The person who said these things sounds very cynical and mean spirited, and someone who does not like or respect you. Having read everything they've said. I wouldn't have them in my life again.

fUNNYfACE36 · 01/06/2022 02:59

You need to read about ring theory and circles of support.your grandparent is the centre of the crisis, your mum as close family is in the innermost circle next circle you and your siblings, next circle extended family and close friends next circle etc. The rule is that people can dump outwards, but only support moves inwards.please try to grow the emotional maturity to follow this.Your mum , as the most affected, can dump outwards on you, but in return you should give support.
It is extremely hard to have a parent suffering dementia, and I think it is pretty poor you did not visit the care home.Please try to grow up a little bit and stop making this crisis all about you

Could you forgive someone if they'd said this to you?
ChampagneLassie · 01/06/2022 02:43

I'd also suggest read Phillipa Perry's amazing The Book you'll wish your parents read (and the book your children will be glad you read). I'm, sorry you have such a shit mum. You dsereve better and you don't have to tolerate her.

ChampagneLassie · 01/06/2022 02:40

I think you need to have it out with your mum and consider further NC. I'd look at it like this, it sounds like your mum was and is emotionally abusive to you and in having an ongoing relationship you are allowing her to continue to hurt you. I certainly wouldn't trust how she'd be with your DC not least that she is disrespectful of and undermining of you and that your DC may well pick up on this. We tell women to leave abusive men because of how children will think of those relationships, would you want yoyr children to think being treated like this is acceptable? Denying access to DCisnt about pushing your mother, it's about protecting them from someone who could do them harm. I'd cancel the visit, say you don't feel able to meet and suggest a talk another time. Tell DC unfortunately DGP can't come. Or let your dad come alone. He doesn't have to be piggy unless he wants to be.

AcrossthePond55 · 01/06/2022 02:16

"I'm thinking for tomorrow at least, of just being civil and polite, but like you say, not engaging regarding what she said."

@OhHiRocco I think that's best. And I'd try to stay away from her or not be alone with her as much as I could.

gumball37 · 01/06/2022 02:14

I'd never forgive. It actually makes it worse that it is your mother and not some random 2nd cousin or something. I also wouldn't let someone who treated me so horribly around my children. But I had an amazing mother who was my best friend and I am still devastated 7 years after her passing. A mother being so awful to her own child blows me away.