Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you forgive someone if they'd said this to you?

112 replies

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 22:52

"You didn't give a fuck about X when they were alive and you're only interested now because you're getting their money" (meaning inheritance)

And "you only used to do A for them because they were paying you"

I'm due to see the person that said these things to me tomorrow after almost 6 weeks of NC and I feel like I will just be expected to forgive and forget it all, but I don't know if I can. I can go into more detail if anyone wants/needs to know anything more to make an accurate judgement on if they could themselves forgive, but what they said is very much not true and it hurt me very much.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 13:48

Thelnebriati · 01/06/2022 12:24

There are two meanings to the word 'forgive'; the first is that you move past what they did, and things go back to how they were before.
The second is that you accept them the way they are and don't expect them to change, and this second meaning allows you to change the way you relate to them.

You don't have to forgive and forget it all. Accept your mother is not there for you and has no right to continually hurt you, and take steps to protect yourself. Perhaps after you get through this, you might also want to consider why she is so nice to your children.

Yes, I definitely don't think everything can go back to how it was before. Not from my side anyway.

I won't ever forget what she said, and it has definitely changed the way I feel about her and our relationship.

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 13:42

So, they have been and gone and I'm happy that the kids had a good time with them. They helped keep things light and fun, and my Sister also arrived at the same time, so it was more of a group conversation rather than any 1 on 1, so it wasn't awkward. I did answer questions politely when my Mum spoke to me directly, which was mostly just questions about the kids/baby.

There was no attempt to discuss what had happened which I think is because of the kids being around and her not wanting to say anything in front of them which I do appreciate. But, knowing her, I do think that I will get a text later saying something along the line of, thank you for letting me come round and see the kids, as she said it about 3 times on the way out. And I predict she may use that as a precursor to an apology. We will see.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 01/06/2022 12:24

There are two meanings to the word 'forgive'; the first is that you move past what they did, and things go back to how they were before.
The second is that you accept them the way they are and don't expect them to change, and this second meaning allows you to change the way you relate to them.

You don't have to forgive and forget it all. Accept your mother is not there for you and has no right to continually hurt you, and take steps to protect yourself. Perhaps after you get through this, you might also want to consider why she is so nice to your children.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 01/06/2022 12:03

OhHiRocco · 31/05/2022 23:30

I'm doing it for my kids. I won't punish this person by not allowing them to have a relationship with them. And it's difficult for the piggy in the middle not to be the piggy due to the relationship iyswim? They want us to make up, and they partly feel responsible as they half forced the conversation that lead to the comments that were made.

I'm not angst, I'm just pondering how to deal with any attempt to reconcile and wanted some opinions.

Being given money for fuel /giving kids a couple of pounds is in NO WAY BEING PAID!!

If you were getting nmw per hour... That would be being paid!!

This person sounds bizarre!

Thebeastofsleep · 01/06/2022 11:58

If it isn't true then I'd look at why they said it. Are they hurting? Feeling guilty? I wouldn't assume they believed it unless I had other reasons to. So yes, I'd probably forgive them if our relationship was otherwise good.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 10:43

Meredusoleil · 01/06/2022 10:33

My mum is also a bitter twisted old woman. But, despite not being around for me when I was growing up, she adores her grandkids and treats them way better than she ever did me! I have had to reduce contact with her since Covid (from once a week to once every school holiday), but hope to never have to cut it completely. My kids would be just as upset not to see her as she would be not to see them.

It's hard isn't it when you see them for who they truly are and your sweet innocent kids don't and hopefully never will have a clue.

OP posts:
Meredusoleil · 01/06/2022 10:33

My mum is also a bitter twisted old woman. But, despite not being around for me when I was growing up, she adores her grandkids and treats them way better than she ever did me! I have had to reduce contact with her since Covid (from once a week to once every school holiday), but hope to never have to cut it completely. My kids would be just as upset not to see her as she would be not to see them.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 10:08

BracedlnEndIessJanuary · 01/06/2022 10:02

She has lashed out, out of anger, grief, resentment, jealousy, bitterness: take your pick. If she is a good grandma, then enabling her relationship with your children is a nice thing. Repairing your relationship with your Mum depends on being the better person. It might happen in time, it may not. Just do baby steps for now.

Yes, I think baby steps is the best approach in this situation.

I just can't imagine saying something like that to someone. Even if it was what I thought, I'd never say it out loud.

OP posts:
BracedlnEndIessJanuary · 01/06/2022 10:02

She has lashed out, out of anger, grief, resentment, jealousy, bitterness: take your pick. If she is a good grandma, then enabling her relationship with your children is a nice thing. Repairing your relationship with your Mum depends on being the better person. It might happen in time, it may not. Just do baby steps for now.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 10:01

Sushi7 · 01/06/2022 09:37

So the deceased was your grandma and she split her money 4 ways. Was this equal? Did you, your sibling, your mum and the other person (your auntie/uncle?) get an equal share?

I'm not sure why your mum is angry that her mum left you and your dc some money. You’re her granddaughter and great GC ffs. Are you sure you think it would be healthy to allow your dc contact with this woman?

It was my grandfather, and the money was split into 4 equal shares that went to my Mum, my Dad, me and my sister, after care home fees were paid and money left to my kids was put aside too. There is no other extended family, no aunts or uncles, that is literally my entire family.

For all her faults, she does love them and they do love her, they'd be devastated to not be able to see her again, I can't do that to them. She's an entirely different person with them than she ever was with me, I've never seen that loving side to her before.

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 09:56

RunningFromInsanity · 01/06/2022 09:49

This isn’t something I would cut my mother out of my life for.
From her point of view, you visited regularly, and got money out of it. Then when it got hard and he was in a home, you admit you couldn’t hack it and distanced yourself (no matter what your later backtracked posts say).
You don’t/shouldn’t really get to opt in and out of family life when it gets hard. You and your DH seem to have a habit of it.

My child got the money, not me, and as I said, it was a couple of pounds here and there. And that was because SHE didn't want to do the shopping.

Not sure what you mean by back tracked posts, if you look back I actually said, she said she wouldn't hold it against me for not visiting OFTEN. I didn't say I didn't visit at all, and I've clarified that multiple times. And for a majority of the time as I have repeatedly said, there were Covid restrictions anyway, so I couldn't have gone even if I'd have wanted to. I clearly didn't distance myself or opt in and out when things got hard so I don't know where you have gotten that idea from?

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 09:51

LoveLabradors · 01/06/2022 09:23

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

To be blunt though - do you honestly think anyone relishes going in to care homes / or visiting sick people they love? It is distressing and draining. If everyone took this attitude nobody would be visited and comforted. Very often care falls to one person - everyone else makes excuses as to why they can’t and in the end it boils over in to deep resentment following loss. It is a complex situation but not unusual.

And also just to add, as I didn't take in the last bit regarding care falling to one person the first time. She was NOT one person doing everything to be able to resent me or anyone else. I did his weekly shopping, my dad did other bits of shopping for him and fixed things when needed. He had carers 4 times a day and a weekly cleaner. In the 6 months before he went into the hospital/care home, she did nothing for him, she had an operation and couldn't drive for a long time and absolutely loved using it as an excuse to back off completely. She didn't even see him in this time, and only spoke to him on the phone. After I had my youngest, my sister took over my role doing his shopping and helping him with bits and bobs (tbh, she didn't really see him much or do anything for him before this point), and then when he became very unwell, she got POA for him as she is very level headed in a crisis and has some medical knowledge so she was the main point of contact iyswim. My sister was the only person allowed to see him in the care home for a long time, she dropped things off for him regularly etc. We all helped clear his house to sell (before he died, to pay for the care home fees) including my DH and my sister's DH.

She was not left to deal with anything on her own. If anything, she had the least amount of involvement in the last 2-3 years.

OP posts:
RunningFromInsanity · 01/06/2022 09:49

This isn’t something I would cut my mother out of my life for.
From her point of view, you visited regularly, and got money out of it. Then when it got hard and he was in a home, you admit you couldn’t hack it and distanced yourself (no matter what your later backtracked posts say).
You don’t/shouldn’t really get to opt in and out of family life when it gets hard. You and your DH seem to have a habit of it.

Munchies123 · 01/06/2022 09:48

Gosh, this really resonates with me. I was previously very close to my family member, but he has said and done some extremely hurtful things. I know he is grieving but I don't feel he's taken my grief into account and has made me feel even worse (if that's at all possible). I've gone v low contact and I cant ever see the relationship recovering. I'm sorry for your loss and that you're having to deal with this extra unpleasantness. It's horrible, and you have my full sympathy.

Sushi7 · 01/06/2022 09:37

So the deceased was your grandma and she split her money 4 ways. Was this equal? Did you, your sibling, your mum and the other person (your auntie/uncle?) get an equal share?

I'm not sure why your mum is angry that her mum left you and your dc some money. You’re her granddaughter and great GC ffs. Are you sure you think it would be healthy to allow your dc contact with this woman?

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 09:35

LoveLabradors · 01/06/2022 09:23

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

To be blunt though - do you honestly think anyone relishes going in to care homes / or visiting sick people they love? It is distressing and draining. If everyone took this attitude nobody would be visited and comforted. Very often care falls to one person - everyone else makes excuses as to why they can’t and in the end it boils over in to deep resentment following loss. It is a complex situation but not unusual.

As I've said more than once in previous posts, I did go when covid restrictions eased and visiting was allowed. I just didn't go every single week. I found it really hard to go again after the very first time, as I was so shocked and upset at the state of him (I don't mean that in a nasty way btw) after not physically seeing him for so long, and I probably left it longer than I should have, but I did visit and facetime. I even took my kids once as the eldest was desperate to see him, and thankfully that day was the one good day he'd had for a very long time (and the last good day unfortunately), so they have a nice last memory of him.

OP posts:
LoveLabradors · 01/06/2022 09:23

I just do not like care homes and cannot stand seeing people I love unwell. They were frail and skinny and couldn't remember me in the end, it was too devastating to see

To be blunt though - do you honestly think anyone relishes going in to care homes / or visiting sick people they love? It is distressing and draining. If everyone took this attitude nobody would be visited and comforted. Very often care falls to one person - everyone else makes excuses as to why they can’t and in the end it boils over in to deep resentment following loss. It is a complex situation but not unusual.

mam0918 · 01/06/2022 09:16

I was disowned as a baby by my father, most of his family followed suit.

Dispite this a random cousin decided to get in contact upon the death of my grandma (only member who didnt turn their back on me) to tell me I was 'stealing their inheritance'. I have no idea what they expected of felt entitled to get from the inheratence but I can state as a fact I got sweet fuck all.

All I wanted was the photos of me and my grandma when I was a baby (I lived with her for a year as a baby and she had a photo album full of photos of me and her) and the family binned them just to spite me... I certainly got no money so no idea what they think I 'stole'.

I also looked after this grandma for 6 months when she first got sick (about 3 years before she died) before she went into a care home, cousin never did any such thing... maybe thats why they assumed I got something but I didnt and doubt I ever will get anything from that side of the family.

CrotchetyQuaver · 01/06/2022 09:15

Are you me and is that my brother calling you things?!
My family all think he's an arsehole so we roll our eyes and bitch about him when I tell them the latest ridiculous comment. He's very very nasty, a proper keyboard warrior in the messages he sends. Apparently for example I killed our DF by wearing him out inviting his friends over to see him (as per dads wishes) after he was diagnosed with advanced cancer. Dad loved those 2 afternoons of visitors, he always loved a party. Meanwhile brother had left/run away and left me to get on with looking after my father. Dad had 12 days from being diagnosed to dying, it was a very rapid decline. Brother came back 2 days before dad died once he was admitted to the hospice. Promptly started screaming and shouting about "My fathers dying" and the fact Id chucked out a cracked vase that apparently was worth thousands. It was horrendous. In front of and also turned on my adult daughters which was a new low. I bought him another identical one off eBay for £100 to shut him up.

House is on the market now, he's buggered off back to the EU country he lives in after coming home without any warning sunglehandedly getting the place ready for sale according to his version of events told to me by the neighbour.
I comfort myself by thinking once this house is sold and the contents dealt with, I don't have to see him or speak to him ever again if I don't want to. He would be the loser in that as my family is all he's got, he's never been in a long term relationship I wonder why or had children
You have all my sympathy OP, it must be lovely to be part of a nice normal family who discuss things calmly and rationally rather than it always being creaming and shouldering and literally ending in tears. I have done my utmost to change my own family dynamic so history doesn't repeat itself.

IncompleteSenten · 01/06/2022 09:15

Why do you want your kids around someone who will in all probability say these fucking awful things to them?

Tbh, next time they started I would say I'm not the person who said... Then reel off all the awful things they said. Don't take your guilt out on me.

Fuck them. You don't need that shit.

OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 09:10

queenMab99 · 01/06/2022 08:57

They were projecting their guilt about how they felt about the person who died. It sounds as if they are not very mature emotionally despite their age, and have a lot of baggage about their upbringing and this has repeated its self, in the way they treat you. You can break this cycle and it doesn't have to be by going nc. Just bear in mind that they are not emotionally stable, and can be toxic. Dont let their outbursts and nasty words affect you, but if that is impossible then you will have to withdraw from them.

I think you have hit the nail on the head with this, thank you!

OP posts:
OhHiRocco · 01/06/2022 09:08

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/06/2022 08:39

How old are your children op.
I wonder, if your mum speaks so badly of her own mother and child, how long will it be until she acts like this with your children. If they are young right now they might meet her needs (to be loved, cuddled etc). I wonder how she will feel as they get older, if the don’t visit her as much as she’d like, or if they get back chatty.

They are 2 and 6. DC3 will be here next week. You raise a good point about when they are older and mqrdy teenagers. My eldest is already a bit cheeky.

To those who have mentioned it, she wouldn't dare bad mouth me to my kids, she knows that would be it from us if she did, she knows that we could cut off contact just like that.

It was my grandfather she spoke so badly about. She speaks very fondly of my grandmother, almost puts her on a pedestal tbh. Yes, she was an amazing grandmother, she was funny and quirky and so so caring, but it's only been since she died that my Mum seemed to speak or think of her the way that she does. When she was here, she was treated like an inconvenience much like my grandfather was. She became even more angry towards him after she died, but as many have said, caring for someone with dementia is awful and traumatizing and he did really struggle with it. He was absolutely devastated when she died and my Mum felt it was faux grief and that he didn't really love her or miss her as much as he said he did. They were married for 55 years fgs, he was so depressed after she died!

He was her dad and deep down she loved him, but she hated him.

OP posts:
queenMab99 · 01/06/2022 08:57

They were projecting their guilt about how they felt about the person who died. It sounds as if they are not very mature emotionally despite their age, and have a lot of baggage about their upbringing and this has repeated its self, in the way they treat you. You can break this cycle and it doesn't have to be by going nc. Just bear in mind that they are not emotionally stable, and can be toxic. Dont let their outbursts and nasty words affect you, but if that is impossible then you will have to withdraw from them.

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 08:50

Zpoa · 31/05/2022 22:54

Usually, if something isn't true - than it doesn't hurt me.

Was this a family member?

I tend to agree but it's not the whole picture. If someone you care about says something like this then you can still be upset they'd think that of you even if it isn't true.

Brefugee · 01/06/2022 08:48

OP i would never forgive and never forget because they sound awful. Why do you want to facilitate a relationship with them and your DC even though they were awful to you, you don't like them and your DH doesn't like them?

In what way will they enrich your child's life beyond what you can give your child? It's batshit.

But if you insist: Just answer any questions they ask with brusque yes and no answers, don't ask them any, don't offer them refreshments etc etc.