Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think that £60 maintenance per week is adequate

82 replies

nelittled · 31/05/2022 21:34

To pay RP. Spends eow with MRP and some evenings per week and a few weeks holidays per year.
Not in UK and child has mild SN.
RP In receipt of approx £280 per month for sn support, a grant of £1600 per year, approx £190 per week as carers payment , free medical card and contributions to electric/ fuel. Free tv licence, housed by council, free breakfast club, book rental and wraparound care and free transport.

Child is mostly independent and attends mainstream school full time .
No private therapies to pay for as none needed.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ClaudiusTheGod · 01/06/2022 20:37

How many other children do you have, OP?

MountainClimber22 · 01/06/2022 20:32

I think it sounds like a decent amount but I am basing it on what I get, which is about £5. If it's what has been calculated you should pay then I'm sure it's fine. If you can afford more, then do.

Youseethethingis1 · 01/06/2022 20:04

Yet another thread that seems to assume that an NRPs time with a child is absolutely free and they don't spend a single penny above maintenance on the child.
Running a home large enough, providing what the child needs during contact time, days out, gifts, transport to parties and clubs etc etc etc all free to the NRP but financially crippling to the RP.
Interesting.

Willyoujustbequiet · 01/06/2022 17:59

It's nowhere near enough.

What she does or doesnt get from the state is not your business and doesn't negate your responsibility to pay for your child.

If she did work I'm presuming you would pay half the childcare costs?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 17:10

StressedMumm1e · 01/06/2022 16:25

No, £120pw is not enough to raise a child. Your £60pw is definitely not enough.
The income of the rp has no bearing on the what the nrp should pay.
are you saying that because the rp has, in your opinion, enough income from other sources, that you shouldn’t have to financially contribute to the upbringing of your child?

aren’t you a prince!

I don't necessarily agree with this to be honest. It can be dependent on different situations. For example, I receive tax credits that pay for the majority of DS's childcare. I wouldn't expect my ex husband to foot half the childcare bill when I already get most of it paid for. He can foot half of the remainder of what I have to pay myself which is about 15% of the total cost.

FloydPepper · 01/06/2022 17:03

nelittled · 01/06/2022 10:07

I'm
Asking if I'm
Being unreasonable . If this is enough

unfortunately you may need to ask on a different site.

you’ll get some balanced responses but for some, as a man, you’ll never be paying enough.

fwiw I think as a % what you’re paying sounds fair. I think you’re a bit hung up on what else she gets from the state and you should probably make your peace with her getting what she gets.

FloydPepper · 01/06/2022 16:54

LilacPoppy · 31/05/2022 22:24

So you want to spend 80% of your income on yourself and 20% on your child? And you can’t see an issue with that.

People say things like this but forget about tax.
20% pre tax is more like 1/3 of take home.

StressedMumm1e · 01/06/2022 16:25

No, £120pw is not enough to raise a child. Your £60pw is definitely not enough.
The income of the rp has no bearing on the what the nrp should pay.
are you saying that because the rp has, in your opinion, enough income from other sources, that you shouldn’t have to financially contribute to the upbringing of your child?

aren’t you a prince!

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 15:51

CornishGem1975 · 01/06/2022 10:22

Dont forget the RP will be organising and sorting a lot of the behind the scenes stuff, organising and attending dr appointments, school issues, reduced opportinities for full time employment

Rubbish. That's not exclusive to the 'RP'. My DH's ex is classed as RP as she has them 60% of the time. The other 40% of the time they are with us. If they need to go to the drs or there are issues at school who do you think sorts that? We don't send the DC back for her to deal with it. If it falls on our time, we sort it. If they need childcare when sick or during school holidays and it's in our 40% of the time, we also cover that so the full-time employment thing also applies to us. We still do 40% of the school runs. Being RP doesn't make you solely responsible.

That's your situation though. My ex husband has DS 2 or 3 nights a month and does fuck all to do with doctor appointments, school appointments, trips, etc. I do it ALL.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 01/06/2022 11:25

You mention your child having wraparound care - do you mean before and after school care that could enable your ex to work and which would cover emergencies? I will say here as the mother of a DD with ‘mild’ SEN that I find it very difficult to enroll her in any kind of wraparound care (as she needs a lot of attention and therefore effectively 1:1 support) and this is why I haven’t and am not able to work.

Likewise. One of mine has what OP would probably characterise as mild SEN. They'd struggle with wraparound because it would be overwhelming after a full school day: could be done if necessary, but would be detrimental to their welfare. Part of the reason they'd come off as mild SEN is because we run our lives in the way most conducive to that. There is a financial cost to this.

I do work, as does DH. We are in an extended family and both have flexible jobs, so it's doable. But it pretty easily could be a problem, and that's with a child whose needs wouldn't qualify us for any dedicated benefits.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/06/2022 10:57

trevthecat · 01/06/2022 10:50

Your ex's situation is not relevant in this at all. The legal minimum is on the csa calculator. Stop listing what she gets for your child and step up.

It is relevant because if the state is already providing certain things for a child, then neither parent needs to, resident or not.

The RP doesn’t need money twice to pay for the same thing once.

And the CMS calculator only applies to people in the UK, which the OP clearly stated he isn’t.

RewildingAmbridge · 01/06/2022 10:55

You sound critical of your ex partner's choices but you've had more children knowing you are on a very low wage and are now complaining about paying for the one you don't live with?
We put aside £200 a month for spending for DS this is sometimes the odd treat or day out (we pay for the big things but his allowance covers aquarium pass, local farm etc) but it's mainly, shoes, clothes, swimming lessons, other things he needs, that doesn't include his share of food, bills, mortgage which just come out of our normal joint account nor does it cover childcare. Some months that money is spent, some months it rolls over and we can put any extra towards birthday/Christmas. So it doesn't seem a huge amount to me. We choose to have one child so we can afford to give him the lifestyle we would want floor our family, you've chosen to have multiple children you need to pay for them.

ChocolateHippo · 01/06/2022 10:50

So essentially your ex does the majority of the day-to-day parenting and you think £3,120 per year is more than enough to discharge your financial responsibility to your child?

Hardly qualifies you for father of the year, does it? But then society has a low bar for fathers so many people will tell you this is fine.

I'm assuming that if your ex gets a full-time job as you seem to think she should, you will be fully supportive of her by helping with sick/inset days and holiday and afterschool childcare?

trevthecat · 01/06/2022 10:50

Your ex's situation is not relevant in this at all. The legal minimum is on the csa calculator. Stop listing what she gets for your child and step up.

Songoftheseas · 01/06/2022 10:44

Based on what you have told us, I don’t think you are being unreasonable with regard to your financial contribution.

You mention your child having wraparound care - do you mean before and after school care that could enable your ex to work and which would cover emergencies? I will say here as the mother of a DD with ‘mild’ SEN that I find it very difficult to enroll her in any kind of wraparound care (as she needs a lot of attention and therefore effectively 1:1 support) and this is why I haven’t and am not able to work. I’m sure other people think I am really lazy now that she is in full time school but I am literally the only person who can drop and pick her up from school - husband works full time and we have zero family support - and it is very difficult to find working hours to suit our circumstances.

I ask re the above as you sound very critical of your ex’s choices and lifestyle and this won’t be helping your coparenting relationship going forward. It may be justified but it may not, remember there is an awful lot to contend with behind the scenes when you have a child with any type of SEN which may not be obvious to others. My husband doesn’t have a clue just how much I have to organise/keep on top of and like your child my DD’s additional needs are relatively mild.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/06/2022 10:36

Not to mention putting money away for school trips, higher education, holidays, driving lessons etc

A NRP doesn’t need give money to their ex to save up for their own child’s higher education or driving lessons and they can take their children on their own holidays. They have no obligation to contribute to holidays the ex takes with the child.

Why would you assume that saving for the child’s future is something that can only be done by the RP?

inmyslippers · 01/06/2022 10:31

My ex pays a grand total of £25 a week and loves to tell me it's more then the cms calculator. If £60 is what you genuinely can afford I think it's enough. Can't take what's not there.

CornishGem1975 · 01/06/2022 10:23

Not to mention putting money away for school trips, higher education, holidays, driving lessons etc

But NRP also do that. Such sweeping generalisations.

CornishGem1975 · 01/06/2022 10:22

Dont forget the RP will be organising and sorting a lot of the behind the scenes stuff, organising and attending dr appointments, school issues, reduced opportinities for full time employment

Rubbish. That's not exclusive to the 'RP'. My DH's ex is classed as RP as she has them 60% of the time. The other 40% of the time they are with us. If they need to go to the drs or there are issues at school who do you think sorts that? We don't send the DC back for her to deal with it. If it falls on our time, we sort it. If they need childcare when sick or during school holidays and it's in our 40% of the time, we also cover that so the full-time employment thing also applies to us. We still do 40% of the school runs. Being RP doesn't make you solely responsible.

DahliaDreamer · 01/06/2022 10:21

InChocolateWeTrust · 31/05/2022 21:54

Its not only about what covers the child's expenses.

It's also about how much your income is and your child benefitting from that income wherever they live.

Does £120 a week really cover half their

  • food
  • clothes
  • housing need
  • electricity/gas/water usage
  • activities
  • gifts at Christmas and birthdays
  • social costs (attendance at friends parties, school discos etc)
  • books, toys, sports equipment
  • health & sanitary needs

Really?

Not to mention putting money away for school trips, higher education, holidays, driving lessons etc

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 01/06/2022 10:16

nelittled · 01/06/2022 10:07

I'm
Asking if I'm
Being unreasonable . If this is enough

asking if the amount of money you provide for your child is enough is one thing.

stating to the penny the amount the child’s primary carer gets from other sources is quite another.

you mentioned evenings during the week. Do you mean over nights? And you do the school run to on those days?

how much of the actual parenting do you do? If you’re also sharing the parental load and doing doctors appointments, you know when these appointments are, have a hand in arranging them, attend them, know what care-plan they are on, take them to the hairdressers, dentists, shopping with them for clothes, buying school supplies etc etc and dont have to be told when these things should happen, then that might improve your relationship with your ex. If she feels like she does all the parenting and holds the whole parental load, and you just think you pay too much, then she will get annoyed.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 01/06/2022 10:11

If you can’t afford to pay more at the same time as maintaining yourself and providing a home suitable for your child to stay with you in, then that’s that. You can’t afford it and your ex can’t take, or expect to take what you don’t have.

It doesn’t sound like you and the ex will ever agree on what’s the right amount, especially if the ex doesn’t want to work so there’s no point trying to convince her that you’re providing enough because she will never agree.

If you know you’re paying an adequate amount and that your child is provided for sufficiently, then just focus on that.

LorenzoVonMatterhorn · 01/06/2022 10:10

If you are a low earner, and that’s the best you can do and is 20% of your income, then that’s all you can do, other than skill up and job search.

The excuse now is that there needs to be an adult available at all times for our child but our child is in full time mainstream education and has wraparound care and transport
That is necessary with a child with SEN though. Ive a couple of friends who are both married and cannot work due to the SEN needs of their children. One was frustrated she couldn't even hold down a volunteer job at a food bank because she wasn't reliable due to phone calls from school asking for a child to be collected, or for the seemingly endless meetings with different agencies.

how many children do you have?

nelittled · 01/06/2022 10:07

I'm
Asking if I'm
Being unreasonable . If this is enough

OP posts:
StormTreader · 01/06/2022 10:06

This is an odd thread - what exactly are you trying to get out of it?
You've said what you're paying, that you think its plenty and that you can't afford any more.
What's there to ask?