Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To enjoy Love Island

287 replies

minutesturntohours · 31/05/2022 20:30

I've watched every series, I really enjoy it. It's a great hour each evening.

I know people generally look down on programmes like this but don't actually watch them. I can't be the only one?

OP posts:
ForestFae · 02/06/2022 12:11

brookstar · 02/06/2022 12:09

I do judge people by their actions. If I think something is harmful, then I'd potentially judge it. Do you genuinely not think shows like Love Island, can be harmful to young teens?
As standalone programmes- no. I think parents have a responsibility to talk to their teens about the themes that are raised on and surrounding programmes such as love island. It's an opportunity to talk about the reality of being on a programme like that.

I used to work as a careers adviser and I would get young people (girls mainly) who would talk about their careers in terms of reality tv and social media. It was an opportunity for us to break that down and look at the reality of that type of career and consider values, career progression etc.

Do you not think it sad that young girls would talk about that? And that it would mainly be young girls who’d bring it up, not boys? Yes parents have a responsibility, but kids pick things up from other kids - my eldest son found out about TikTok from another child, for example. I think it’s fair to say some things have a negative consequence in society.

brookstar · 02/06/2022 12:09

I do judge people by their actions. If I think something is harmful, then I'd potentially judge it. Do you genuinely not think shows like Love Island, can be harmful to young teens?
As standalone programmes- no. I think parents have a responsibility to talk to their teens about the themes that are raised on and surrounding programmes such as love island. It's an opportunity to talk about the reality of being on a programme like that.

I used to work as a careers adviser and I would get young people (girls mainly) who would talk about their careers in terms of reality tv and social media. It was an opportunity for us to break that down and look at the reality of that type of career and consider values, career progression etc.

loomband · 02/06/2022 12:09

This is why I don’t like it also. I think, as a society, we should be elevating artists, poets, craftsmen, researchers, there are so many people who make a difference and who are talented. We shouldn’t be making out that being famous is the ideal, or that being materialistic and shallow is.

And I support this wholeheartedly hence why I'll try to avoid this year.

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 12:08

BreakAwayTime · 02/06/2022 12:07

Do you genuinely not think shows like Love Island, can be harmful to young teens?

I think there is a potential for a minority of teens or don’t have other real life role models and support to be affected or influenced, but I also think that can be said of most things, like magazines, films, the news, other adults, musicians etc. I think social media posts and participation in that is potentially more harmful than a television programme. There are dangerous influences everywhere nowadays that teens cannot be shielded from. Instead they need to be educated about why some elements of different things might be dangerous, how to cope with them and how to be secure in themselves.

I also agree social media and magazines are harmful. It’s not just reality TV.

loomband · 02/06/2022 12:08

I'm not "spitefully" judging anyone. I think shows like Love Island are harmful. They reinforce that only pretty slim people are worthy of being on TV and being famous. I believe they send a message to teens, especially young women that being social media influencers is aspirational and it's all focused on good looks and manipulating the general public. So I do question why people watch and support shows like that. I did not say anything nasty about people who watch these shows or call them names.

That makes total sense, it's the 'only people unhappy with their lives watch it/get a hobbyI' type comments object to. I passionately don't care because it's not true - it's not true of me and a large number of its viewers (who are mostly young people)... but 🤷🏻‍♀️

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 12:08

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 12:05

I'm not "spitefully" judging anyone. I think shows like Love Island are harmful. They reinforce that only pretty slim people are worthy of being on TV and being famous. I believe they send a message to teens, especially young women that being social media influencers is aspirational and it's all focused on good looks and manipulating the general public. So I do question why people watch and support shows like that. I did not say anything nasty about people who watch these shows or call them names.

This is why I don’t like it also. I think, as a society, we should be elevating artists, poets, craftsmen, researchers, there are so many people who make a difference and who are talented. We shouldn’t be making out that being famous is the ideal, or that being materialistic and shallow is.

BreakAwayTime · 02/06/2022 12:07

Do you genuinely not think shows like Love Island, can be harmful to young teens?

I think there is a potential for a minority of teens or don’t have other real life role models and support to be affected or influenced, but I also think that can be said of most things, like magazines, films, the news, other adults, musicians etc. I think social media posts and participation in that is potentially more harmful than a television programme. There are dangerous influences everywhere nowadays that teens cannot be shielded from. Instead they need to be educated about why some elements of different things might be dangerous, how to cope with them and how to be secure in themselves.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 12:05

BreakAwayTime · 02/06/2022 12:00

I think personal preferences, such as “I don’t really like tattoos” or “I’m not a fan of reality tv” can be expressed without using words that are nasty or designed to make others feel bad or somehow lesser.

“Judging” someone in a spiteful way for behaviour different to yours or for not having similar standards to you doesn’t consider the other person at all. Just as you have had your standards and values instilled in you by various influences, so have others. Acknowledging that everyone comes from a different place, having had different experiences and different influencers to shape their behaviours can help reduce levels of spiteful judgement.

I’m not a fan of animae. I gave it a go but have reached the conclusion it’s not my thing. I can appreciate the work that goes into it though and I don’t judge people who like it.

If you're comfortable with your choices why care if someone is judging you for them?

Equally, if you genuinely feel good about yourself, your behaviours and your life why do you feel the need to make judgements on others?

I'm not "spitefully" judging anyone. I think shows like Love Island are harmful. They reinforce that only pretty slim people are worthy of being on TV and being famous. I believe they send a message to teens, especially young women that being social media influencers is aspirational and it's all focused on good looks and manipulating the general public. So I do question why people watch and support shows like that. I did not say anything nasty about people who watch these shows or call them names.

BreakAwayTime · 02/06/2022 12:00

I think personal preferences, such as “I don’t really like tattoos” or “I’m not a fan of reality tv” can be expressed without using words that are nasty or designed to make others feel bad or somehow lesser.

“Judging” someone in a spiteful way for behaviour different to yours or for not having similar standards to you doesn’t consider the other person at all. Just as you have had your standards and values instilled in you by various influences, so have others. Acknowledging that everyone comes from a different place, having had different experiences and different influencers to shape their behaviours can help reduce levels of spiteful judgement.

I’m not a fan of animae. I gave it a go but have reached the conclusion it’s not my thing. I can appreciate the work that goes into it though and I don’t judge people who like it.

If you're comfortable with your choices why care if someone is judging you for them?

Equally, if you genuinely feel good about yourself, your behaviours and your life why do you feel the need to make judgements on others?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 12:00

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:57

They're different, but I'm just pointing out that anyone who says they don't judge people is probably lying.

Of course everyone makes judgements but, like another poster pointed out, it's how you react to the judgments you are making.
Do you consciously make an effort to mentally take a step back and assess why you are making those judgements and assumptions and make sure you don't say/do anything that is going to belittle the other person? Or do you just openly judge, making the assumption you are better/in the right.

The judgements we make are based on our own life experiences. I do a huge amount of work around challenging biases so it really frustrates me when I see people outright judging people just because they look different or have different interests to them!

I've been judged my whole career - apparently women with platinum blonde hair, who wear make up and heels don't look like they are clever enough to be a university academic. 🙄

Yes, that's judging by appearance which is silly. I never judge anyone's appearance.

I do judge people by their actions. If I think something is harmful, then I'd potentially judge it. Do you genuinely not think shows like Love Island, can be harmful to young teens?

pedropony76 · 02/06/2022 11:58

This is not something you should have asked on MN lol. Everyone loves it on my Twitter so it really just depends where you’re asking the question

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:57

They're different, but I'm just pointing out that anyone who says they don't judge people is probably lying.

Of course everyone makes judgements but, like another poster pointed out, it's how you react to the judgments you are making.
Do you consciously make an effort to mentally take a step back and assess why you are making those judgements and assumptions and make sure you don't say/do anything that is going to belittle the other person? Or do you just openly judge, making the assumption you are better/in the right.

The judgements we make are based on our own life experiences. I do a huge amount of work around challenging biases so it really frustrates me when I see people outright judging people just because they look different or have different interests to them!

I've been judged my whole career - apparently women with platinum blonde hair, who wear make up and heels don't look like they are clever enough to be a university academic. 🙄

Fairislefandango · 02/06/2022 11:55

It is not the job of a television programme to set an example for kids or teach them right and wrong.

Of course it isn't. Nobody said it was. That doesn't mean we can't judge whether the content kids (or adults) consume has a positive, neutral or negative effect on them (or on society in general) or even what people's choice of content says about them. I don't think those are the kinds of judgments we should be trying to avoid making. They are quite important.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:49

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 11:46

Not the case.

How is it not the case?

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:48

GirlInACountrySong · 02/06/2022 11:30

Er, plenty of the contestants apply for love island just after they have completed their degrees

It seems university isn't a breeding ground for this show

Well, the cynic in me would say that's probably because they can't be arsed to look for a real job and would rather choose the quick way to make money. Which is fair play, but a waste of time and money doing a degree that you're not going to use.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 11:46

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 09:52

That's true. However they still have the "acceptable" type of bodies for TV. They aren't thin women, but they have flat stomachs, boobs and curvier hips and thighs, much like the Kardashians. They don't have flabby bellies, stretch marks and bingo wings.

Not the case.

OP posts:
ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:46

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:43

Yeah, I've been judged on all sorts. I was judged for having a baby at 22 years old. Judged because I decided to stay on benefits for 4 years after having said baby instead of working. Judged because I have tattoos on my hands. Judged because I don't limit the amount of screen time DS has!

People do judge things, not much point in pretending they don't. People will say they don't judge people and then a tattoo thread starts on here and people fall over themselves to say how rough and common tattoos are. Humans are all flawed. I don't really care who judges me on what personally, I'm not going to bother wasting my time trying to get them to change their minds.

I have tattoos on my hands as well, I find it funny someone said earlier they thought I’d be upset if my kids ever got a tattoo 🤣 People judge others. What we should be teaching our kids is that if you are happy with yourself and your life, you really shouldn’t care. You shouldn’t need approval or validation from others, let alone total strangers.

I don’t care if someone doesn’t like my tattoos, or my hobbies, or anything really.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:45

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:43

I absolutely do judge people in certain scenarios though. I judge men who rape women. I judge people who abuse animals and children.

That is very, very different to judging someone for watching reality TV though isn't it? They aren't comparable.

They're different, but I'm just pointing out that anyone who says they don't judge people is probably lying.

I'm not pretending I'm a perfect holy person who doesn't judge anyone, because I'd be a liar and hypocrite if I said that. Just as people probably judge me for all sorts. If you're comfortable with your choices why care if someone is judging you for them?

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:44

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:43

I absolutely do judge people in certain scenarios though. I judge men who rape women. I judge people who abuse animals and children.

That is very, very different to judging someone for watching reality TV though isn't it? They aren't comparable.

It depends whether you believe the behaviour is harmful doesnt it? If you think it’s unethical, and that by watching to it people are contributing, then you don’t see it as something harmless and benign.

If you view it as “just entertainment” then obviously that will seem like an overreaction.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 11:44

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:17

Lol I’m heavily tattooed and pierced, why would I care if my kids are? And I don’t have an issue with drinking either - don’t make assumptions about people perhaps!

You are really patronising and snobby.

Telling me I need to look at my life 😂

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:43

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:28

I don’t get why people care that someone else “judges” them anyway. I said earlier in the thread that I watch anime, there are an absolute load of people who think anime watchers are sad basement dwelling neckbeards. I don’t really give a crap though. If you enjoy something, own it and stop giving a shit what strangers think.

Yeah, I've been judged on all sorts. I was judged for having a baby at 22 years old. Judged because I decided to stay on benefits for 4 years after having said baby instead of working. Judged because I have tattoos on my hands. Judged because I don't limit the amount of screen time DS has!

People do judge things, not much point in pretending they don't. People will say they don't judge people and then a tattoo thread starts on here and people fall over themselves to say how rough and common tattoos are. Humans are all flawed. I don't really care who judges me on what personally, I'm not going to bother wasting my time trying to get them to change their minds.

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:43

I absolutely do judge people in certain scenarios though. I judge men who rape women. I judge people who abuse animals and children.

That is very, very different to judging someone for watching reality TV though isn't it? They aren't comparable.

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:40

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:39

Well, yes, which is what I have been saying the entire thread.

I absolutely do judge people in certain scenarios though. I judge men who rape women. I judge people who abuse animals and children.

Yes. There’s a clear difference between judging someone for something they can’t help, like appearance or ethnicity or sexuality, and judging someone for their behaviour. The latter is fine, the former is not. Idk why people don’t get that.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 02/06/2022 11:39

brookstar · 02/06/2022 11:25

Everyone judges people to some extent. Otherwise no one would have any opinions on anything.
Having an opinion and judging someone are two different things.

It's possible to have an opinion on something and not judge others for having a different opinion.

Saying that you personally don't like reality TV because you feel it's unethical is not the same as saying people who watch reality TV are stupid.

Well, yes, which is what I have been saying the entire thread.

I absolutely do judge people in certain scenarios though. I judge men who rape women. I judge people who abuse animals and children.

ForestFae · 02/06/2022 11:37

I “judge” people who watch reality tv because I think it contributes to a net negative to society, and makes the world a worse place. If you think that says something about me, that’s fine. You can think that. But the reason I dislike it is because I think the world doesn’t need more shallow, materialistic people in it and shows like this simply add into the shallow, materialistic culture that seems to be in fashion at the moment.