Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I LOVE my engagement ring - but worried it looks tacky?

290 replies

princesspollysmum · 31/05/2022 20:23

My (for now) BF let me pick my engagement ring. Would’ve spent up to £100 on it but I knew he wasn’t having the best time financially and we have other priorities (our 1 year old, a house, car payments etc). I follow a company on Instagram and the rings she has are all cubic zirconia and sterling silver for £40-£60. Mine was in the £40 range but is BEAUTIFUL. Her rings don’t rust or turn fingers green and are really sparkly. It’s much bigger in person than the pictures made it look which is my concern … don’t want to look like a wannabe WAG (my boyfriend dies football and worried his group might say something! Or the girlfriends from the group!)

Be honest with me - if you saw this on a lady would you think it looked cheap, tacky? What would your thoughts be. And don’t say it shouldn’t matter! It doesn’t to me but want to prepare myself for what others might say to me! I love him and don’t care how much it costs.

I LOVE my engagement ring - but worried it looks tacky?
OP posts:
tillytown · 01/06/2022 00:24

It isn't tacky, but it is big. I love the design though, so would probably ask where you got it from instead of laughing at it (do people really do that?)
Congrats btw!

Hapoydayz · 01/06/2022 00:22

It’s a lovely ring. Hardly anyone can tell at a glance if it is real or not. You sound happy, now that is priceless.

IheartJKRowling · 01/06/2022 00:21

I think it's really lovely and it would never occur to me to ask if a ring is "real" or not.

I have a large jewellery collection that includes big diamonds, small diamonds, moissanite, QVC Diamonique (you should check them out they are brilliant faux diamonds) and CZ and I enjoy wearing all of them, it has nothing to do with cost.

Your ring is being bought with love and that makes it priceless. Wear it and and be proud of it.

Peachyscream · 01/06/2022 00:16

Did you buy it from phantomjewels on Instagram? The packaging looks familiar.

I have one which is pretty much the same from Warren James, and it has a matching band. My actual wedding/engagement rings are also the same but in gold. DH bought gold but when ibsaw a silver version i couldnt resist😂So yes, I do love it. Obviously mine are cubic zirconia because I preferred to save for a house instead.

Kate0902900908 · 01/06/2022 00:15

Ring is beautiful ❤️
I chose to buy a simulated diamond and spend the money on house stuff
yours is much nicer be proud of it ❤️

mindutopia · 01/06/2022 00:13

I wouldn’t say it’s tacky, though it’s not to my personal taste. My only concern would be how you plan to wear it with a wedding band. These style of rings don’t sit flush with another band. Ultimately, if you plan to continue to wear both and on the same finger, I’d want them to look good together and be comfortable to wear.

Dexy007 · 01/06/2022 00:13

It’s lovely, congratulations! Agree with the others I’d know it’s costume jewellery based on it’s size but that is NOT the same thing as being tacky, far from it. Lots of women adore costume jewellery, myself included.

if you want people to think it’s a real diamond swap for something much smaller but I’d that doesn’t matter to you (and it shouldn’t) then crack on!

When I saw your OP and the word ‘tacky’ I was nervous and was expecting something quite different! It’s a genuinely pretty ring. Enjoy it.

Sarah3587 · 01/06/2022 00:06

@princesspollysmum its beautiful and price doesn’t matter. someone else commented on the size being a giveaway that it’s not a real diamond but who’s to know (apart from those that know you lol) that it’s not an expensive real diamond and that you’re not wealthy.
Personally I’d rather a have a big cubic zirconia then a tiny little pathetic diamond that give its away that you’re a wannabe diamond person that can’t afford a proper big diamond.

Seren85 · 01/06/2022 00:00

I think it's lovely! Doesn't even cross my mind if it is 'real' because you're wearing it, it is clearly real. Gorgeous.

Gonnabegrandma · 31/05/2022 23:56

I think it’s really pretty and if I saw it on someone I would love it and be envious! Enjoy it and your engag

Mamanyt · 31/05/2022 23:54

First, anyone with the temerity to comment on it is beyond tacky, and not worthy of consideration. Second, my own engagement ring (now handed on to my son when he got engaged) was just as large, and VERY real, thanks to great great grandparents (the next generation most thoughtfully ran through the family money), so don't ask me. I KNOW very large rings can be real, and not always affordable to those who wear them.

Suprima · 31/05/2022 23:49

It’s definitely WAG-ish- a diamond equivalent would be over £50k with that size and setting.

I’d also worry about the robustness of something of that size. An engagement ring should be worn forever, ideally- and with that raised profile, it would chip or be knocked out of setting really easily. It might not turn your finger green, but it’s not going to have much longevity.

If I wanted my boyfriend to spend as little as possible for something that would last- I would get a smaller CZ ring, or just put the money towards a nice wedding band?

ijustcouldntthinkofausername · 31/05/2022 23:47

It is a beautiful ring and honestly don't give a fuck what anyone else thinks as long as you love it that's all that matters xx

Congrats ❤️

ValerieCupcake · 31/05/2022 23:45

KatesMott · 31/05/2022 22:14

Good for you getting that humble brag in 🙄 Mine was also 'real', I'm assuming you mean real
diamonds as opposed to a real ring as the OPs ring is clearly 'real' too?! Mine was a similar price to yours, but a much smaller stone so I must presumably have a better 'real' diamond- does that make you feel better? No? You can just say its a lovely ring and looks like the real deal without mentioning the astronomical price of yours, knowing it cost so much more than the OPs or most other peoples. It's vulgar. Why not say mine is diamond and looks the same so fantastic choice, without adding your price tag

Always one, isn't there?

WhimsicalGubbins · 31/05/2022 23:45

Honestly? I have no opinion at all.
But I have no opinion about anyones ring, it’s not my place to. Don’t get me wrong, I make all the appropriate noises if someone shows a ring off to me, but the ring really isn’t important. It’s what it means that matters. And yours means that your boyfriend loves you enough to want to spend the rest of his life with you-and for that I will say congratulations on the engagement!

My husband chose my ring, and in all honesty, it isn’t what I would have picked myself, but I love it. He asked me some years ago if I wanted an ‘upgrade’…
good god no! What would be the point? It would no longer be my engagement ring.

However, he seemed to take that ‘no’ as “never buy me diamonds ever again”
So perhaps I should have been less forceful with my answer

adhdforme · 31/05/2022 23:43

Judging from the title and the post I was expecting something really very tacky, but the ring is lovely OP. Very classy. Congratulations on your engagement!

Cherryblossoms85 · 31/05/2022 23:32

It's a lovely design. The main thing though is that you guys sound like a great team with the right priority, and I'm sure you will live a long and happy marriage.

Sumshinebound · 31/05/2022 23:11

Lovely ring would just go for a smaller stone personally

PerfectionValley · 31/05/2022 23:09

I think it looks nice and much more expensive than it was.

Does it look oversized on your finger?

Nein9 · 31/05/2022 23:05

I like it, and the sensible price tag! I cringe at the thought of tens of thousands being spent on rings, I'd say no if my partner proposed after spending £1000s on a flipping ring. 😂

TabithaTittlemouse · 31/05/2022 23:02

It’s not something I would wear but if you like it that’s all that matters!
It’s a bit too bling for me.

Grandmum1 · 31/05/2022 23:00

It’s gorgeous, congratulations x

ManateeFair · 31/05/2022 22:56

Congratulations!

I think it’s a lovely ring and certainly not tacky. Really pretty and I bet it looks lovely on.

(What IS tacky, though, is people being judgemental about other people’s engagement rings. Anyone who sneers at someone else’s engagement ring is absolutely devoid of class.)

I much prefer silver to gold and most real diamonds are really unethical. I think you’ve made a really nice choice. I’ve got silver rings that I’ve been wearing for 30 years and they’ve lasted beautifully. I just take them off for dirty/manual jobs - but I’d do that with any ring.

CambsAlways · 31/05/2022 22:54

It’s not my taste! But hey you love it and wear it with pride congrats ,why would it concern you what other people think!

MintyCedricRidesAgain · 31/05/2022 22:50

I'd probably be able to tell it wasn't the real thing but it's really pretty, definitely not tacky and anyone worth worrying about will just be delighted that you're happy and love your ring.