Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I LOVE my engagement ring - but worried it looks tacky?

290 replies

princesspollysmum · 31/05/2022 20:23

My (for now) BF let me pick my engagement ring. Would’ve spent up to £100 on it but I knew he wasn’t having the best time financially and we have other priorities (our 1 year old, a house, car payments etc). I follow a company on Instagram and the rings she has are all cubic zirconia and sterling silver for £40-£60. Mine was in the £40 range but is BEAUTIFUL. Her rings don’t rust or turn fingers green and are really sparkly. It’s much bigger in person than the pictures made it look which is my concern … don’t want to look like a wannabe WAG (my boyfriend dies football and worried his group might say something! Or the girlfriends from the group!)

Be honest with me - if you saw this on a lady would you think it looked cheap, tacky? What would your thoughts be. And don’t say it shouldn’t matter! It doesn’t to me but want to prepare myself for what others might say to me! I love him and don’t care how much it costs.

I LOVE my engagement ring - but worried it looks tacky?
OP posts:
fallfallfall · 01/06/2022 19:51

why do women not value themselves? she has set the bar very low, her man does not have to inconvenience himself what so ever over 40 quid.
i suspect he won't rise to the occasional anniversary, christmas or mother's day gift either. why should he, plastic tat is fine for one of the most important decisions of a lifetime.

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 01/06/2022 19:41

Dirtylittleroses · 01/06/2022 17:14

So bemused by these comments, I assume people are just being kind. She’s worried about people who know them and what they will think. And one hundred percent they will all know immediately she’s wearing a cheap copy, they will clearly know they are not so wealthy as to spend tens of thousands on a ring. And there is a potential she will feel uncomfortable when they say let’s see the ring then and she shows them that. She’s also going to have comments and be forced to either lie and look like a twat or say god no it’s just cubic zirconia. All of them will have seen those rings on line.

Only strangers will not be sure, but every single person who knows her will know immediately , and it’s not right to pretend they might think she’s Got thirty grands worth of ring on her finger. So she might be better going for something more believable.

it’s also not going to be a ring that lasts her forever, it’s costume jewellery. If that’s what she wants then fine, but otherwise she’s better going for something that will last a life time.

You are wrong and what an awful post. Most people aren't small minded. Not everyone is snobby and sees £ signs when they see engagement rings. Most are extremely happy for the couple.

BTW the person I know who had an extremely expensive ring (more than the figure you quoted), the marriage didn't last 3 years. Give me a cheaper ring anyday.

OP it's lovely and suits you

HenBob · 01/06/2022 19:37

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:27

Roll on the day when women don't judge other women based on the value of their engagement ring. Judging by this miserable post we have a way to go.

@orwellwasright right?! You are spot on to highlight this.

What's the need for such a long winded critical comment. Just because something isn't worth 30 grand doesn't make it tacky. Absolutely not. The attitude displayed by dirty is tacky.

PurpleButterflyWings · 01/06/2022 19:36

Dirtylittleroses · 01/06/2022 17:14

So bemused by these comments, I assume people are just being kind. She’s worried about people who know them and what they will think. And one hundred percent they will all know immediately she’s wearing a cheap copy, they will clearly know they are not so wealthy as to spend tens of thousands on a ring. And there is a potential she will feel uncomfortable when they say let’s see the ring then and she shows them that. She’s also going to have comments and be forced to either lie and look like a twat or say god no it’s just cubic zirconia. All of them will have seen those rings on line.

Only strangers will not be sure, but every single person who knows her will know immediately , and it’s not right to pretend they might think she’s Got thirty grands worth of ring on her finger. So she might be better going for something more believable.

it’s also not going to be a ring that lasts her forever, it’s costume jewellery. If that’s what she wants then fine, but otherwise she’s better going for something that will last a life time.

Urgh, what a vile post. Sad

HenBob · 01/06/2022 19:34

It's suits your hand...

I think you are wise not to waste money on material items like expensive jewelry and focusing on what's really important. If only there were more people like you x

Antarcticant · 01/06/2022 19:31

Roll on the day when women don't judge other women based on the value of their engagement ring

Quite. Mine was inexpensive - from Argos in fact - but I still like the design of it 17 years later.

orwellwasright · 01/06/2022 19:27

Dirtylittleroses · 01/06/2022 17:14

So bemused by these comments, I assume people are just being kind. She’s worried about people who know them and what they will think. And one hundred percent they will all know immediately she’s wearing a cheap copy, they will clearly know they are not so wealthy as to spend tens of thousands on a ring. And there is a potential she will feel uncomfortable when they say let’s see the ring then and she shows them that. She’s also going to have comments and be forced to either lie and look like a twat or say god no it’s just cubic zirconia. All of them will have seen those rings on line.

Only strangers will not be sure, but every single person who knows her will know immediately , and it’s not right to pretend they might think she’s Got thirty grands worth of ring on her finger. So she might be better going for something more believable.

it’s also not going to be a ring that lasts her forever, it’s costume jewellery. If that’s what she wants then fine, but otherwise she’s better going for something that will last a life time.

Roll on the day when women don't judge other women based on the value of their engagement ring. Judging by this miserable post we have a way to go.

fallfallfall · 01/06/2022 19:27

you're right @TheFoxAndTheStar i agree with @Dirtylittleroses sorry for the mix up.
nothing wrong with the design. and it's not about a diamond vs other stone.

TheFoxAndTheStar · 01/06/2022 19:19

OMG @fallfallfall that is not what I was saying at all!

I think OP’s ring is lovely.

fallfallfall · 01/06/2022 18:52

i agree with @TheFoxAndTheStar .
if you want cheap go straight to the source with the ali express link or wish?
why even bother with the 40 expense when the true value is more like 4.
i don't know to many men would would be proud to show off that purchase either. they will be telling their friends it's just a joke.

TarpaulinEyes · 01/06/2022 17:38

It's lovely, wear it with pride

TheFoxAndTheStar · 01/06/2022 17:22

@Dirtylittleroses I think it’s more that people are reassuring OP that it doesn’t actually need to be a diamond. MANY people these days choose something other than a mined diamond for ethical reasons.

The fad of an engagement having to be a diamond was relatively short lived in the grand scheme of things. Before the De Beers adverts in the 40s and 50s people generally chose emerald or sapphire.

Its a bit old fashioned to look at an engagement ring and assume diamond.

Dirtylittleroses · 01/06/2022 17:14

So bemused by these comments, I assume people are just being kind. She’s worried about people who know them and what they will think. And one hundred percent they will all know immediately she’s wearing a cheap copy, they will clearly know they are not so wealthy as to spend tens of thousands on a ring. And there is a potential she will feel uncomfortable when they say let’s see the ring then and she shows them that. She’s also going to have comments and be forced to either lie and look like a twat or say god no it’s just cubic zirconia. All of them will have seen those rings on line.

Only strangers will not be sure, but every single person who knows her will know immediately , and it’s not right to pretend they might think she’s Got thirty grands worth of ring on her finger. So she might be better going for something more believable.

it’s also not going to be a ring that lasts her forever, it’s costume jewellery. If that’s what she wants then fine, but otherwise she’s better going for something that will last a life time.

PurpleButterflyWings · 01/06/2022 15:28

ValerieCupcake · 01/06/2022 12:56

I like this story more than the smart alecs spending £13K+ on a ring like some Z lister!

I was JUST about to say the same! @Marston01 that's a lovely story. Flowers And many congratulations on losing the 10 stone. 😘👏🤗 No worries about the old rings not fitting. Happens to lots of people, usually because they have gained weight though, not lost it! Grin Wearing the new ones and keeping the other ones on a chain, or just safe in a jewellery box is good too.

Idhrenniel · 01/06/2022 14:40

It's a beautiful ring and all that matters is that you love it and love your boyfriend. Can I ask the name of the company please? Would love to see more examples of their work

Jokie · 01/06/2022 13:38

That was for @princesspollysmum !

Jokie · 01/06/2022 13:38

Can I ask you to link me to it?... I want one too... 😆

ValerieCupcake · 01/06/2022 12:56

Marston01 · 01/06/2022 10:12

1st of all congratulations & it looks absolutely beautiful. When I got engaged 24 years ago we had zero money so my Husband got a cheap but beautiful 2nd hand 9ct gold engagement (with the tiniest diamond) & thin gold wedding band & we also choose to get married on the cheap at the local registar office. We had the most amazing day. On our 20th Wedding Anniversary my wonderful Husband surprised me with a new Engagement & Wedding ring (mainly because I've recently lost 10 stone & my rings no longer fitted) but it was such an amazing surprise & I my old rings have now been passed down to my Daughter's. Who cares what other's think, the main thing is you love it & it looks amazing. Maybe once the Children are grown up & you're better off financially you could do replace it, only if you want too. I was so upset when I could no longer wear my old one's (we had them re-sized twice) & we we're told the engagement ring couldn't be made any smaller. I still love them just as much as I did 24 yrs ago & glad my Daughter's are going to use them. Even my new rings are 2nd hand as you get so much more for your money. Enjoy your engagement & show that amazing ring off.

I like this story more than the smart alecs spending £13K+ on a ring like some Z lister!

Billandben444 · 01/06/2022 12:19

OP, are you coming back to tell us whether you've thought about whether the ring will be hard wearing enough?

SabrePrattler · 01/06/2022 11:46

Sure, Jan.

KatesMott · 01/06/2022 11:41

To the posters criticising me, I said mine cost 'a similar price' and I directed it to the poster who had to bring the cost of her engagement ring into it, not the OP. I DO think it's vulgar to come on a thread written by a poster asking advice about her ring, which cost less than £100, by immediately bringing up the exorbitant price of their own ring and seemingly using the post as a vehicle to boast about this. I made a comparison, again with @Foxglovesandlilacs86 not the OP, suggesting it's like me saying I must have a better quality diamond than hers and stating its not a nice thing to do. I wasn't trying to set up a pissing competition, merely pointing out the rather tone deaf response isn't great. I didn't come on to tell the OP all about my ring complete with cost breakdown, nor does anyone know what it cost, nor do I expect anyone to give a shit either way 🤷🏼‍♀️

InPraiseOfBacchus · 01/06/2022 11:38

I love the silver. It's very nicely constructed.

It would look terrible on me (very dull minimalist, doesn't wear colour) but I imagine it fits your look well if you love it. Nothing worn with style and consistency can ever look tacky.

Make sure you get the matching earrings for your anniversary! ;)

EmeraldShamrock1 · 01/06/2022 11:33

Foxglovesandlilacs86 is absolutely entitled to share her experience.

I agree with the POV it's a lovely ring but wouldn't fool anyone into thinking it was a diamond especially friends and family whose aware of the OP'S financial situation.

I doubt the OP expects to fool anyone, its a lovely ring within their budget.

erinaceus · 01/06/2022 11:11

It looks lovely on your hand. I do not think anyone will think it is a precious stone, but I do not think that matters. My concern would be the practicality and durability of it. I am not sure it is going to last a lifetime, but that might not matter to you as you could take it off sometimes, and you might find you need to upgrade it in some years' time or something.

Many congratulations!

Iwantmyoldnameback · 01/06/2022 11:05

A family member was wearing a really ott ring (not classy like the OPs) and we all assumed it was fake - we were wrong. So it works both ways those boasting about their expensive rings.

Swipe left for the next trending thread