Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend was apparently overpaid

37 replies

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 31/05/2022 19:58

My friend started a new job a month ago so just received her first proper monthly wage but they are claiming to have paid bet twice. She’s been checking her bank account every 5 minutes but she can only see one payment. They are adamant she received an extra one (totally their fault they have stated) but she says she hasn’t. What can she do? Can they forcefully take money from her account? I’ve told her to speak to ACAS but she won’t hear back for a while and is getting really upset over it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notfatundertall · 02/06/2022 06:14

I bank with barclays and can search using say a company name for all transactions.

Could she do thus then there is no need to redact anything. You can't filter anything out so it should show every transaction including date and value?

I know she shouldn't have to but it may be the quickest way to solve it.

DogWithMyOwnRoom · 02/06/2022 05:47

@ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor
hope your friend is reassured and her company is sorting it out?

DogWithMyOwnRoom · 02/06/2022 05:42

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 31/05/2022 20:12

I suggested a print out of her statement but as others have said she feels it’s an invasion of her privacy as they could see other transactions.

How would they be able to prove it was paid twice @DogWithMyOwnRoom ?

Very easy for their payroll/finance team - they will know how to do it if she asks them to.

Various different ways (depending on which bank, BACS transfer method etc) but trust me - after doing this for over 25 years - it is not hard. The onus is on the company to prove it happened. It’s very hard to ‘prove a negative’ ….

I do agree though that redacting information on her statement will do almost the same job - but they could always claim that she has hidden/filtered what she doesn’t want seen.

They made the error - and it is very easy for them to fix.

DogWithMyOwnRoom · 02/06/2022 05:35

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 31/05/2022 21:22

One month all our tax got worked out wrong. They never told us and the next month we were all underpaid. We only found out why when they asked so yes they can deduct it.

No - taking a deduction from your NEXT pay is very different to being able to take any amount back from your actual bank account.

Herejustforthisone · 31/05/2022 22:48

I’m not sure I understand her reticence to download/screengrab an image of her statement, showing only incoming payments? It would entirely solve her problem…?

SarahSissions · 31/05/2022 22:16

They can’t take money out of her account, but if it’s a new job she probably wants to come across as helpful and not be obstructive. I’d print out a bank statement for the payment week and black marker the retailers and just leave the amounts and dates. Do it proactively and then ask them to investigate from their side

PatAndFrank · 31/05/2022 21:41

Paddingtonthebear · 31/05/2022 19:59

Surely she can just get a statement from the bank confirming only one payment was made by her employer?

That would be far too easy!

LoveActually89 · 31/05/2022 21:29

What does her payslip say?

Irishfarmer · 31/05/2022 21:27

No they can't take money out of her account.

I've worked in payroll, if an employee told me they had not been paid twice I would go back through my bank transactions to see if I made a mistake. If it still looked like 2 payments went to Sarah Ryan I would request bank confirms from my bank to trace where the payments went.

Basically it's payrolls problem and they can sort it out/ prove she did get it twice.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 31/05/2022 21:23

Sorry didn't read properly well if she has only received it once then surely they can't.

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 31/05/2022 21:22

One month all our tax got worked out wrong. They never told us and the next month we were all underpaid. We only found out why when they asked so yes they can deduct it.

SueDeNeem · 31/05/2022 21:13

Useranon1 · 31/05/2022 20:15

She can blank out the other transactions , just leave the amounts so they can see anything credited is not from them

They only need to see what's going in, not whats coming out - she can redact everything that's going out

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 31/05/2022 20:54

Thank you everyone for your replies. She’s been really concerned they would forcefully take her wage. I’ve passed on all your suggestions and hopefully she can get clearer answers tomorrow

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 31/05/2022 20:50

No, no, no. THEY need to provide her evidence of the overpayment. SHE doesn't need to do anything until they provide evidence

burnoutbabe · 31/05/2022 20:48

It can happen

Let's say smaller company and salary payments done by faster payment. I'd have to go in and select each employee then add the amount (later on we could use a template)

So quite possible to pay say e smith one amount then misread f smith and select e smith again but use f's amount

But the company can show proof that they sent the payment twice!

BritInUS1 · 31/05/2022 20:47

She needs to tell them it hasn't been received and ask them to sort it out with their bank - they should be able to trace the payment and see where it actually went

Tiffbiff · 31/05/2022 20:45

Hi OP, we had this with my husband but the other way round- they said they paid him but it never arrived into the account- eventually we had to get the ombudsman involved and ultimately it was a bank problem. So maybe get them to speak to the bank in the first instance with a verification code- once you have this your friend can take it further if need be

Seraphinesupport · 31/05/2022 20:44

Definitely search for the particular transaction and if she wont do that then she is being suspicious.

gianaInfertilitySucks · 31/05/2022 20:43

provide them with printscreen of online bank statements and contact her bank to make sure they cant just money out of her account

Titterofwit · 31/05/2022 20:42

Well they cant take money from her bank account but they can certainly deduct the amount they say she has been overpaid by straight from her wages. She does have to agree to this happening but it might already be part of her contract .She should negotiate with HR how the deductions are calculated.
She needs to talk to HR and if they arent helpful maybe she can check with HMRC for what has been reported as paid to her. It should only be one payment per pay period but if there is extra HMRC will want to know whats going on.

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 31/05/2022 20:31

Apparently it’s for different amounts, very similar but maybe £50 odd off a difference. I’ve had problems myself before not receiving a payment but never heard of someone supposedly being paid twice! Is this a common problem?

I have no idea about how how BACS etc work for employees and she’s not much better. I’ve told her to search for the particular transaction as @Iamnotamermaid has suggested.

OP posts:
HSKAT · 31/05/2022 20:27

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 31/05/2022 20:12

I suggested a print out of her statement but as others have said she feels it’s an invasion of her privacy as they could see other transactions.

How would they be able to prove it was paid twice @DogWithMyOwnRoom ?

Can just blank out other transactions

BeforeGodAndAllTheFish · 31/05/2022 20:22

I was just about the post what has been said above.

The bank will flag it as a double payment and return it to them. It will be showing on their accounts as having gone out, but will then show as a returned debit and theyll get an email from their bank telling them a duplicate payment was returned but if it was intentional then to call to make the payment again.

MissCalamity · 31/05/2022 20:19

Get the employers to show their bank details to your friend sending it twice, I'm assuming it's on a BACS run with other employees? They can blank out the other transactions.
And no, they wouldn't be able to get this back from her account.
Double check how much they think she should have been paid to how much your friend thinks she should have been paid as well!

HiJenny35 · 31/05/2022 20:17

Has she spoken to her bank? I've had this myself, what happened was the bank that the money was coming from flagged it as a double payment of the same amount and stopped the payment in a holding account to check it, I never received it, it appeared to have left the companies account however it was just held by the bank and then returned to the company. Its nothing to worry about, the company can't take from your friends account without permission. The banks will be easily confirm she hasn't received it.