Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re babysitting half siblings

136 replies

lovelilies · 31/05/2022 19:42

Who IBU in this scenario?

Dcs age 5 and 8 have a half sister, nearly 17, who they live with with their mum. The smalls stay 2 nights every week at their Dads.

The dad has a new job and didn't take into account childcare for his first day which was on the Monday of half term so asked their older half sister to look after them for him. It was her only 'day off' that week.
He offered to 'buy you guys lunch' and wanted her to look after them 11-2.

The sister and the grandmother (who drove) took them to a soft play area and bought lunch which came to £39 in total.

Their mum was working nights so couldn't have them.

He originally gave the sister £10 in cash which paid their entry into the play area.

He came home 2.30pm.
He asked how much it had cost and she said £30 ish. Then he said "let me know how much your food cost and message me".

Later he messaged the GM to see what it all cost but she wasn't sure as she hadn't paid any of it.

Then he PayPal'd the mother £15 to give to sister with a message that he didn't feel it was reasonable and they were taking advantage of him by taking the kids out and expecting him to pay.
Sister didn't ask for any money but kind of expected it as he had offered to pay for lunch.

The Dad earns nearly a 6 figure salary just to be clear.

So who IBU?
The sister for assuming the smalls' Dad would remunerate her for the cost of outing or the Dad for not covering the costs of the outing or paying the sister for babysitting.

OP posts:
Notcreativeatall · 01/06/2022 06:42

He's being unreasonable. I'm guessing it was easier for her to take them out that sit in his house anyway - and he obviously expected her to take them out for lunch so it wasn't as if he said spend nothing. TBH she should have been paid for her time as well.

TheGetaway · 01/06/2022 06:28

I think the involvement of the grandmother threw everything into question really and confused the matter.
The Dad paying for lunch would be a nice gesture.

HelloSpringIveMissedYou · 01/06/2022 06:28

The Dad is being unreasonable in my opinion.

The 17 year old did him a favour and he should've set a budget or given her cash. If I sent my 17 year old out for shopping for example he'd spend a fortune so I'd give him a maximum budget.

Days out cost a fortune and they had a lovely time with their sister, he needs to cough up and move on.

WhatNoRaisins · 01/06/2022 06:23

If he's on a six figure salary I'd expected him to have the disposable income to suck this up

Blarting · 01/06/2022 06:15

Nahnanananahna · 01/06/2022 05:30

I'm another one who doesn't think the father is being entirely unreasonable. It depends how much lunch would normally cost for the step sister and two kids but in that situation I wouldn't have taken the kids to soft play without checking with him as it hadn't been discussed/agreed that he was happy to pay for it. That said he should pay up and chalk it up to experience given she helped him out of a tight spot - this is not worth the argument when she did him a massive favour! Next time he should set a clearer budget.

Not sure if texting someone about such a minor thing on their first day in a new job is a great idea?

I'd only want to be contacted in an emergency.

The SD, used her initiative to entertain two young children, for someone so stupid he didn't arrange childcare on his first day?

Yet he expects exemplary forward planning and checking from everyone else?

Notfatundertall · 01/06/2022 06:11

I think grandma should probably pay for her own and the dad should pay the rest as a possible compromise

But dad sounds a dick.

OLP2019 · 01/06/2022 05:56

Do agree in principal that father should have set boundaries but as it sounds like he can afford it he should write it off and be grateful

Nahnanananahna · 01/06/2022 05:30

I'm another one who doesn't think the father is being entirely unreasonable. It depends how much lunch would normally cost for the step sister and two kids but in that situation I wouldn't have taken the kids to soft play without checking with him as it hadn't been discussed/agreed that he was happy to pay for it. That said he should pay up and chalk it up to experience given she helped him out of a tight spot - this is not worth the argument when she did him a massive favour! Next time he should set a clearer budget.

PinkSyCo · 01/06/2022 05:27

He should be grateful that the 17 year old went out of her way to give her sisters a nice time. She could have just stayed home keeping half an eye on them while sat on her phone. The dad is a horrible, ungrateful tight arse.

MumsnetPremium · 01/06/2022 05:24

He should pay her and sort out his childcare properly.

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 01/06/2022 05:18

Whose grandmother was it?
I would have expected her to pay for herself and if they are all her grandchildren for them all

HoppingPavlova · 01/06/2022 05:11

He needs to pay 40 as expenses plus babysitting money. And he very very grateful, not act like a dick.

TheLadyDIdGood · 01/06/2022 05:06

Well it's between £20 - £50 for half day childcare per child so for two children that would be £100 max in my area. The cost depends on whether it's a childminder, nursery or activity club. The father is taking advantage of the teenager. He is also being a tight fisted arse particularly because he's a high earner.

OLP2019 · 01/06/2022 05:02

But would be curious to know who's idea the play centre was ? Kind of sounds like grandma said come on let's take them out and tire them out and she went along with it
Either way a 17 year old should not be out of pocket for helping especially as sounds like he can well afford it and next time should give a budget or set expectations! Personally I'd be thrilled my kids got taken out and wouldn't hesitate to pay for it

OLP2019 · 01/06/2022 04:58

He's basically saying he wanted her to babysit but didn't sign off on the trip out so doesn't see why he should have to pay ! But he's being totally unreasonable and should pay for it all plus paying for her time
Would advise her to never help again !!

CJsGoldfish · 01/06/2022 04:19

Going against popular opinion it seems, I don’t think he is being unreasonable.
i wouldn't decide to take my nephew out and then bill his mother after
Same.
I've often agreed to look after my nephew and then decided we'd go do something fun together. I'd never bill my brother and sil for it. Wouldn't 'charge' for lunch because it would never occur to me 🤷‍♀️

I've also never been asked to pay when others have looked after my children and then chosen to go somewhere. Just seems weird to me

Newestname002 · 01/06/2022 03:53

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 03:03

The father should pay. If the cost is an issue for him, he should pay this time and learn to set a limit in advance next time.

You are right - he absolutely should pay. The 17yo did him a favour at short notice and his children were well taken care of so he was out at very little effort to himself, except to pay for the costs incurred which, judging from some PP comments, were reasonable.

That favour is now unlikely to be repeated (I wouldn't, in her shoes) and he'll now need to find someone else to look after his children when the circumstances arise in future. Ungrateful and short-sighted of him. 🌹

timeisnotaline · 01/06/2022 03:25

Everyone involved should ensure the teen is fully empowered to tell him to piss off next time, that she was out of pocket last time she did him a huge favour and if he ever took his own children out he’d know how much it costs and now he can also find out how expensive childcare or taking time off work is. If it helps her, our nanny charged £13 an hour. Plus any entry costs or buying food for dc of course.

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 03:03

The father should pay. If the cost is an issue for him, he should pay this time and learn to set a limit in advance next time.

lovelilies · 01/06/2022 02:56

He's not her dad, tbh she doesn't like him, was a rubbish 'step dad'.
GM is the mothers mother, elderly with lung condition not able to manage 2 boisterous kids by herself.
The elder sister has babysat siblings for mum a good few times but in their own home where her stuff is etc. and is usually paid in cash or takeaway.

Thanks for all the input though- I was of the view that the sister was doing him a favour and even if it cost more than he anticipated he should've just coughed up without the drama

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 31/05/2022 21:50

Vsirbdo · 31/05/2022 20:54

I don’t entirely understand how he ended up paying for the grandmothers lunch too; that’s the only part I might be surprised at if I was him. I do wonder how much he thought lunch would be for 2 kids and an adult though

Because she was the adult who drove the kids there and was overseeing the older child.

Remember 17 is legally a child.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/05/2022 21:29

The dad sounds a right dickhead.

If I’ve understood this correctly, the 17 yo isn’t even his dd, although presumably he was her step dad at some point?

So he’s asked his ex wife’s child to mind two siblings, one of them very young, for the day for free, but just offered to “cover lunch”. I’d have expected him to pay her on top tbh! Especially as it’s her only day off. Knobhead. At least she’ll know never to say she’ll babysit again!

Im assuming grandma is not his Mum either?

Blarting · 31/05/2022 21:15

whatstheteamarie · 31/05/2022 20:16

She should send the Dad the receipt to prove the cost and he should pay her back.

She should also let him know that by questioning her integrity in this way he's lost all chance of her ever babysitting again.

She took time, petrol and got nothing from it except a question over her morals and a dent in her bank balance.

Very shitty of the Dad, if there was a set budget he should have stated that from the start.

This! What a stupid arsehole dad is. Best hope he doesn't fuckup again.

Earns a six figure salary but forgets childcare duties? Idiot!

rookiemere · 31/05/2022 21:10

He offered to pay for lunch. Granted it is probably more than he expected to pay, but he should have established the facts in a non judgemental way, then paid up.
If I were her, I'd not be child minding again.

NortieTortie · 31/05/2022 21:09

SnackSizeRaisin · 31/05/2022 20:54

So where you are you can get lunch for£5 each and softplay is free entry? Or costs £2 per child and lunch is £4? Interested to know how it is split

Entry is £4.95 per child with a kid's meal from a selected menu included.

Adult meals around £5, drinks £1-2.

They have a table with perishables they're unlikely to use before the best before date that are free to take too, so we often come home with a bag of croissants or a loaf of bread for the freezer 😁

Swipe left for the next trending thread