Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re babysitting half siblings

136 replies

lovelilies · 31/05/2022 19:42

Who IBU in this scenario?

Dcs age 5 and 8 have a half sister, nearly 17, who they live with with their mum. The smalls stay 2 nights every week at their Dads.

The dad has a new job and didn't take into account childcare for his first day which was on the Monday of half term so asked their older half sister to look after them for him. It was her only 'day off' that week.
He offered to 'buy you guys lunch' and wanted her to look after them 11-2.

The sister and the grandmother (who drove) took them to a soft play area and bought lunch which came to £39 in total.

Their mum was working nights so couldn't have them.

He originally gave the sister £10 in cash which paid their entry into the play area.

He came home 2.30pm.
He asked how much it had cost and she said £30 ish. Then he said "let me know how much your food cost and message me".

Later he messaged the GM to see what it all cost but she wasn't sure as she hadn't paid any of it.

Then he PayPal'd the mother £15 to give to sister with a message that he didn't feel it was reasonable and they were taking advantage of him by taking the kids out and expecting him to pay.
Sister didn't ask for any money but kind of expected it as he had offered to pay for lunch.

The Dad earns nearly a 6 figure salary just to be clear.

So who IBU?
The sister for assuming the smalls' Dad would remunerate her for the cost of outing or the Dad for not covering the costs of the outing or paying the sister for babysitting.

OP posts:
Clymene · 01/06/2022 11:00

He's begrudging paying her £40 for a days childcare for two kids? What a tightwad. And a stupid one too because she's not going to want to do it again

zingally · 01/06/2022 10:13

Dad is being an arsehole.

But 17 year old will remember that, and that'll be the last time she ever does dad a favour with babysitting!!

ChocolateHippo · 01/06/2022 10:00

JurassicShay · 01/06/2022 09:49

The dad is a twat, he might of offered to pay for lunch but so he should they're his bloody kids! He should pay for her lunch anyway she's 17, what did he want her to do sit and watch them eat? Also why is he not paying her for her time?

A 17 year old bailed out a fully grown man & he can't even respect that with remuneration, what a bellend.

Sadly many people (mostly men, I have to say) not only don't view 'caring' as being primarily their responsibility but also resent being faced with the real costs for buying in 'caring' responsibilities and aren't properly appreciative of those who help them out.

Not having any family nearby to help, I would give my eyeteeth for a responsible teenager in the house who was willing to help out with childcare (and would always pay a decent rate). But then I remember having to explain to my DH that unfortunately yes it was going to cost us £200 to get a qualified babysitter to look after our 2 year old for 14 hours on a day that I was working away late and he couldn't come home early to cover it because that's just what decent babysitters cost. He was gobsmacked and I was 🙄at him for completely failing to understand how much outsourcing basic tasks relating to childcare actually costs. He has a better understanding now (for example, if we want someone to do the school-run for us, that's going to cost us £45 unless we can get a kind friend to help) but at the time it seemed to me that he was living under a rock.

JurassicShay · 01/06/2022 09:49

The dad is a twat, he might of offered to pay for lunch but so he should they're his bloody kids! He should pay for her lunch anyway she's 17, what did he want her to do sit and watch them eat? Also why is he not paying her for her time?

A 17 year old bailed out a fully grown man & he can't even respect that with remuneration, what a bellend.

FreetheKhalo · 01/06/2022 09:46

I like how he’s offered to pay for lunch as if there was any suggestion he shouldn’t have to. What a hero, feeding his children, on his day to have them.

TanquerayTickles · 01/06/2022 09:38

He's out of order. 17 year old gave up her free time to save his arse and now she's out of pocket to boot. I don't imagine 17 year olds have that much spare cash either.

He sounds like a right asshat.

ChocolateHippo · 01/06/2022 09:31

Your 17 year old is undercharging for her time.

I pay a neighbour's teenager £8 per hour to come and play with my DC at my house when I need quiet time to work upstairs and I don't want to sit my DC in front of the TV (I wouldn't leave DC alone with them - for a qualified babysitter, I pay £12-15 per hour).

On top of that, I provide food (something easy that can go in the oven or microwave) and snacks.

If step-daughter is in sole charge of two children and taking them out places, £10-13 per hour would seem a reasonable rate to charge 'non-family' customers such as her ex-step-dad.

He should give her instructions as to what to do with them (soft play, park etc.) and pay for any entry costs and food and snacks.

The next time he asks, step-daughter should start the conversation with 'Here are my babysitting rates...' and end with 'Take it or leave it'.

bellebeautifu1 · 01/06/2022 09:29

Many years ago my teenage niece use to babysit DD in the school hols and I would give her extra cash some days (on top of the paid babysitting) that would shout her and pay for my DD to have McDs / cinema. My niece did me a massive favour because it was more convienent than DD being in holiday clubs all the time so no way would I be tight.

I def think the dad should cough up though, he's on six figures so he can afford it, and she did a massive favour (esp unpaid). Valuable lesson learnt for future babysitting in terms of expectations of fee paying activities / lunches.

ManateeFair · 01/06/2022 09:05

CordeliaLOVEScocktails · 31/05/2022 20:09

Personally if it was my own family (favour or not) I'd cover any non agreed optional costs. Why couldn't teen have them at home and make them lunch?

Why should she? She was doing him a favour and he wasn’t paying her for her time. He just offered to ‘buy you guys lunch’ so she got an adult to give them a lift to somewhere they could play and have lunch.

(She isn’t even quite 17 yet so it’s not like she could drive them somewhere herself.)

The dad in this situation is very much the beggar and is in no position to be the chooser in terms of how she entertained his kids (on her only day off) when he wasn’t paying her for the babysitting. She’s not his daughter and she’s certainly not his bloody nanny.

theobligatorynamechange · 01/06/2022 09:04

She may be their half-sibling, but that doesn't mean she enjoyed going to soft play! So, she paid out of her own pocket for the privilege of spending her time doing something she didn't want to do. I'm sure as a teenager she had better offers!

£39 might be more than many people would casually drop, but the man can afford it, and everyone knows it. If someone agrees to cover expenses, you consider who's paying.

But also... she's a teenager. How was she to know it was £39 until she got there?

He didn't have a plan for looking after his own kids, she did him a massive favour and didn't just do the bare minimum: she gave them a lovely day out.

The man is an idiot. No more favours for him.

ManateeFair · 01/06/2022 08:57

The teenager gave up her one day off to look after her siblings, thus getting the dad out of a childcare problem of his own making. The least he can do is cough up a few quid - which he can easily afford - for her to take them out for the afternoon. He’s a massive dickhead and if I was their sister I wouldn’t be helping him out again.

bellabasset · 01/06/2022 08:55

Whether he thought it expensive it was a last minute arrangement so he should pay up.

slashlover · 01/06/2022 08:49

mangodreams · 01/06/2022 08:47

Everyone is saying it's reasonable to pay £39 for entry and lunch to softplay but if understood the OP correctly the £10 that the dad have covered the entry price and then £39 was just for lunch which is hugely expensive for a soft play centre!

I think both are a little unreasonable - if dad offered to pay for lunch he should have given at least a ball park figure. From his point of view he probably thought - lunch for two little ones plus 17 year old would be about £20 at most. He is now being asked to pay £39 on top of the £10 cash already given, I can see why he doesn't want to pay. Plus grandma should pay for her own.

That said he is getting free childcare so £49 for 3 hours of childcare, lunch and softplay isn't totally unreasonable. He should just pay this time.

Lesson for future:

  • Dad - be specific about what you will pay for any costs and organise childcare so you don't have to rely on teenage step daughter
  • Daughter - make sure you have agreed an upfront amount to cover costs before paying anything out of your own pocket

It was £39 total and he had already given her £10 so £29 balance as He asked how much it had cost and she said £30 ish. Then he said "let me know how much your food cost and message me".

mangodreams · 01/06/2022 08:47

Everyone is saying it's reasonable to pay £39 for entry and lunch to softplay but if understood the OP correctly the £10 that the dad have covered the entry price and then £39 was just for lunch which is hugely expensive for a soft play centre!

I think both are a little unreasonable - if dad offered to pay for lunch he should have given at least a ball park figure. From his point of view he probably thought - lunch for two little ones plus 17 year old would be about £20 at most. He is now being asked to pay £39 on top of the £10 cash already given, I can see why he doesn't want to pay. Plus grandma should pay for her own.

That said he is getting free childcare so £49 for 3 hours of childcare, lunch and softplay isn't totally unreasonable. He should just pay this time.

Lesson for future:

  • Dad - be specific about what you will pay for any costs and organise childcare so you don't have to rely on teenage step daughter
  • Daughter - make sure you have agreed an upfront amount to cover costs before paying anything out of your own pocket
littlefireseverywhere · 01/06/2022 08:22

The father should pay, utterly ridiculous! The 17 year old is going to be busy next time then!

Bournetilly · 01/06/2022 08:21

Dad is being unreasonable. She’s only 17. He wouldn’t of been able to work if she hadn’t babysat for him and I don’t think he would find cheaper childcare at that short notice for 2 children.

DonnyBurrito · 01/06/2022 08:08

Ha! What a tight arse. £40 for a day out for 2 adults and 2 kids is cheap!

Reminds me of my dad when I was a similar age... well paid aerospace engineer, but expected me to drive him 15 miles to work to get there at 6am, and be picked up again when he finished... but baulked at what driving 60 miles a day cost me in fuel! 🤦‍♀️ He seemed to think he shouldn't have to pay the extra 30 miles that I drove there and back again whilst he wasn't in the car.

Well paid men often are tight arses. It's how they stay well off.

billy1966 · 01/06/2022 07:53

He sounds awful and unbelievably short sighted.

Of course she should be reimbursed, with thanks.

She need never obliged him again, that's for sure.

Trafficjamlog · 01/06/2022 07:47

He should cover the full costs of taking the children out. A sister looking after siblings doesn’t need paying, that’s being a family.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 01/06/2022 07:39

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 07:22

@Blarting - possibly, he forgot to pick me up from school once!

But even though he forgot to pay for childcare, that doesn't (IMO) mean he should stump up for whatever activity they choose for the day without at least having it run by him him first 🤷🏻‍♀️

On his very first day at a new job, when he's presumably trying to create a good impression rather than looking like someone who can't manage to organise his own childcare without interruptions during working hours?

prettytoes · 01/06/2022 07:39

16 year old gives up her time to help her ex-stepdad out without payment and ends up out of pocket. On what planet should he not pay?
He should pay the £39 plus around here at least £8 an hour for her time.
His kids had a good day out and were looked after despite the fact he'd forgotten to make sure that would be the case.
He's being a total arse and pp comparing this to an adult voluntarily taking nieces out for the day are ridiculous, situation is totally different.

rookiemere · 01/06/2022 07:35

Sounds like the DF doesn't take his DC out much so doesn't know how much it costs.

Shame that he has managed to sour what would have been a great back up childcare plan that his own DCs would enjoy.

Hapoydayz · 01/06/2022 07:28

He should pay and stop being so tight. Well next time he needs help with babysitting he will have lost that option. I wouldn’t do it again as it’s not really what a 16 year old wants to do on their day off. Does the dad not want his children to have a fun time together? He will find professional rates much higher.

Blarting · 01/06/2022 07:25

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 07:22

@Blarting - possibly, he forgot to pick me up from school once!

But even though he forgot to pay for childcare, that doesn't (IMO) mean he should stump up for whatever activity they choose for the day without at least having it run by him him first 🤷🏻‍♀️

Bad parents that forget their children are open to having to deal with the consequences p, in this case a bill for soft play and lunch. Not sure what consequence your DF had, but I'm sure if someone had brought you back on the bus he wouldn't have refused them the fare?

Blarting · 01/06/2022 07:22

TheBolterdahling · 01/06/2022 07:19

My 15 year old is babysitting her 8 year old full sibling from 11am to 4pm today and I’ll be paying her and her friend £15 each plus entry to a soft play or trampoline place plus lunch / drinks money whilst they’re out. He is as tight as fuck! It’s not fun for teens to babysit, you have to pay for them to entertain or suck it up and find something else. I want them to do it again so I will pay them!

Oh stop being all fair and organised and respectful of the help, some MNs won't like that!

Swipe left for the next trending thread