Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Re babysitting half siblings

136 replies

lovelilies · 31/05/2022 19:42

Who IBU in this scenario?

Dcs age 5 and 8 have a half sister, nearly 17, who they live with with their mum. The smalls stay 2 nights every week at their Dads.

The dad has a new job and didn't take into account childcare for his first day which was on the Monday of half term so asked their older half sister to look after them for him. It was her only 'day off' that week.
He offered to 'buy you guys lunch' and wanted her to look after them 11-2.

The sister and the grandmother (who drove) took them to a soft play area and bought lunch which came to £39 in total.

Their mum was working nights so couldn't have them.

He originally gave the sister £10 in cash which paid their entry into the play area.

He came home 2.30pm.
He asked how much it had cost and she said £30 ish. Then he said "let me know how much your food cost and message me".

Later he messaged the GM to see what it all cost but she wasn't sure as she hadn't paid any of it.

Then he PayPal'd the mother £15 to give to sister with a message that he didn't feel it was reasonable and they were taking advantage of him by taking the kids out and expecting him to pay.
Sister didn't ask for any money but kind of expected it as he had offered to pay for lunch.

The Dad earns nearly a 6 figure salary just to be clear.

So who IBU?
The sister for assuming the smalls' Dad would remunerate her for the cost of outing or the Dad for not covering the costs of the outing or paying the sister for babysitting.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hollipolly · 03/06/2022 06:36

KatherineJaneway · 02/06/2022 14:38

however, there's a lesson in it for the DD too 'Don't spend other peoples money without checking it's ok first'

Agree.

People can be very tight

Bit different when it involves kids though! At ball pools kids get hot and sweaty. Rightly so the sister spent money.

I think the lesson is be careful who you agree to babysit for... especially the ungrateful.

KatherineJaneway · 02/06/2022 14:38

however, there's a lesson in it for the DD too 'Don't spend other peoples money without checking it's ok first'

Agree.

People can be very tight

whowhatwerewhy · 02/06/2022 14:15

He should pay her .

knockyknees · 02/06/2022 14:02

Of course the arsehole should pay his 16 (not 17) year old ex-stepdaughter! She helped him out of a tight spot 100% of his making. Frankly, he should pay her extra for her time on top of the softplay expenses she incurred whilst looking after his children.

Next time, I hope his ex SD tells him to get stuffed when he tries to take advantage of her again.

YouCantSpellAmericaWithoutErica · 02/06/2022 09:00

The dad is being a petty, tight fucker and shouldn’t expect any favours including childcare from anyone involved ever again- the older sister, the granny or the sister’s mother.

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 08:03

No worries @CordeliaLOVEScocktails you too.

CordeliaLOVEScocktails · 02/06/2022 07:59

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 07:49

You have misread, @CordeliaLOVEScocktails

I asked what you would do if YOU were the 17 year old, not whether you, Cordelia the adult, would pay for her.

Sorry for that. I wouldn’t expect to pay at 17 no. Hope that clears things up for you. I am a grandmother and you’d mentioned one was involved. So that was what I connected with. Clearly inappropriately. Will pay more attention in future. Have a great day.

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 07:49

CordeliaLOVEScocktails · 02/06/2022 07:46

I’d expect to pay for any junior family members including the 17yr old. If the dad/step dad offered me some money towards it I may/may not take it

You have misread, @CordeliaLOVEScocktails

I asked what you would do if YOU were the 17 year old, not whether you, Cordelia the adult, would pay for her.

CordeliaLOVEScocktails · 02/06/2022 07:46

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 05:52

Personally if it was my own family (favour or not) I'd cover any non agreed optional costs. Why couldn't teen have them at home and make them lunch?

What - even if you were 17, & the ex-step-dad you were doing a favour for told you he would "buy you guys lunch"?

Chinny reckon @CordeliaLOVEScocktails

I’d expect to pay for any junior family members including the 17yr old. If the dad/step dad offered me some money towards it I may/may not take it

lovelilies · 02/06/2022 07:16

Oh absolutely she won't be helping him out again.

OP posts:
EnjoyingTheSilence · 02/06/2022 06:13

Well next time he needs help the 17yr old should unavailable what a dick

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 06:02

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 07:19

@Blarting I'd never assume I could spend my dad's money without permission, no.

The lesson in my house growing up would have been "you didn't ask. I told you I'd pay for lunch - that doesn't include soft play".

And my dad wouldn't have paid either 🤣

He's not her dad.
She didn't owe him childcare,
He told her he would "buy you guys lunch" (what a prince - feeding his kids & childminders!)
He then quibbled about the lunch, & was prepared to leave his ex-stepkid £15 out of pocket.

The person making the biggest assumptions here is the dad. He assumes that he can demand a favour from his ex-stepkid, not pay her, get her to sacrifice her day off, & then insult & shortchange her on expenses.

I hope he has a ManJob vs: Parenting Quandary again really soon, calls on this 17 year old, & she tells him to piss off.

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 05:52

Personally if it was my own family (favour or not) I'd cover any non agreed optional costs. Why couldn't teen have them at home and make them lunch?

What - even if you were 17, & the ex-step-dad you were doing a favour for told you he would "buy you guys lunch"?

Chinny reckon @CordeliaLOVEScocktails

Hollipolly · 02/06/2022 05:30

Badgirlriri · 31/05/2022 19:58

Going against popular opinion it seems, I don’t think he is being unreasonable.
i wouldn't decide to take my nephew out and then bill his mother after. If she insisted she’d pay I’d ask her before her if this cost is ok etc. £39 is a lot.

The sister is only 17. At 17 £39 is a lot of money.... it can be as an adult but let's highlight the sister is 17 and this "favour" was asked last minute and the sister agreed to do it on her day off.

It was not the sisters idea to take her siblings out.... it was a favour. What would dad have done other wise?

DogWithMyOwnRoom · 02/06/2022 05:21

@lovelilies glad to hear he did pay up eventually, thanks for the update

Can you let us know how does the sister feel about babysitting for her siblings in future now? (Obvs for HIM not for their mother, sure that’s a very different scenario) You said she isn’t keen on him already… even before this drama

Rosebel · 02/06/2022 05:20

He sounds absolutely horrible as well as unreasonable.
He somehow forgot he needed childcare so got a 16 year old to bail him out.
She's nice enough to do so and then he refuses to pay for the activity she took them too.
He did pay in the end but despite being on a six figure salary moaned about it and didn't give her any extra for babysitting despite it being her only day off.
I hope next time he fucks up she tells him to piss off.

GoodThinkingMax · 02/06/2022 04:33

What a prince of a father!

Clearly childcare is a woman’s job and she shouldn’t incur any costs in doing it. And if she does spend HIS money, then it’s always to be queried and questioned, and then underpaid. This 17 year old is almost £20 out of pocket.

What an arse.

aloris · 02/06/2022 01:41

Well of course he said she took advantage of him. He's trying to get her on the back foot so he can get free childcare in the future by setting up a "You owe me" guilt trip situation. She shouldn't fall for it. HE is the one who took advantage of HER by getting her to babysit for free, saying he would pay for lunch, and then trying his best to renege on it later. She should be wary of ever babysitting for him again, as most likely he'll continue trying to find ways to get free babysitting to her disadvantage.

KettrickenSmiled · 02/06/2022 00:38

Later he gave her the last £15 after much complaining about being taken advantage of

"Taken advantage of" 😂😂 yeah, every 17 year old I have ever met has been nothing but a scam artist, preying on flaky unwary dads so they can hang out at soft play centres on their day off.

It's such a common hustle I'm amazed he fell for it, he should probably report the young woman to 101. And that grandmother is no better than she ought to be.

Jalepenojello · 01/06/2022 23:14

CJsGoldfish · 01/06/2022 04:19

Going against popular opinion it seems, I don’t think he is being unreasonable.
i wouldn't decide to take my nephew out and then bill his mother after
Same.
I've often agreed to look after my nephew and then decided we'd go do something fun together. I'd never bill my brother and sil for it. Wouldn't 'charge' for lunch because it would never occur to me 🤷‍♀️

I've also never been asked to pay when others have looked after my children and then chosen to go somewhere. Just seems weird to me

I agree. But I am an adult with life experience.

He placed his children in the care of a 17 year old who is a child with little life experience and I wouldn’t expect them to consider such things, so would adjust my expectations. If anything he should have offered more upfront for activities too. How is a child supposed to know how to plan the day and decide how finances are to be split when asked to babysit last minute?

billy1966 · 01/06/2022 20:47

OP,
This is a teaching moment for the 17 year old.

She should never oblige this waster again......unless he pre pays her top babysitting rate + costs.

He's just another waster who thinks he can screw a female for childcare.

I would NOT be having it and I would be having the conversation now, before he reaches out again to try and use and abuse her.

She owes him nothing.

Do not be silent about his trying to rip a 17 year old who was doing him a favour off...

Waster.

Starseeking · 01/06/2022 20:31

Presumably the 17 year old doesn't have a job, yet Mr 6 Figure Big Man was grumpy about paying £40 to a teenager for a lunch looking after his DC? He's out of order.

If I was the 17 year old, I'd be busy the next time he asks (and every time he asks after that!).

TitoMojito · 01/06/2022 13:33

lovelilies · 01/06/2022 02:56

He's not her dad, tbh she doesn't like him, was a rubbish 'step dad'.
GM is the mothers mother, elderly with lung condition not able to manage 2 boisterous kids by herself.
The elder sister has babysat siblings for mum a good few times but in their own home where her stuff is etc. and is usually paid in cash or takeaway.

Thanks for all the input though- I was of the view that the sister was doing him a favour and even if it cost more than he anticipated he should've just coughed up without the drama

Completely agree!!

Blarting · 01/06/2022 13:18

lovelilies · 01/06/2022 12:08

Just for clarification it was £8 for entry for both
3 x 'small' kids meals
1x 'bigger' kids meal
Coffee, 2 cokes and a 7UP totalled £31

He gave £10 cash (she told him then that she planned to take them to a soft play and her nana would drive as it was raining, he didn't say he didn't want them to go out) so she was £29 out of pocket
Then he paid the mum £15 so she was only £14 out of pocket.

Later he gave her the last £15 after much complaining about being taken advantage of Hmm

I'm glad he coughed up, at least he won't have to do it again as hopefully the SD will tell him to fuck off.

Penny pinching tight wad looking to be the richest man in the graveyard!

lovelilies · 01/06/2022 12:08

Just for clarification it was £8 for entry for both
3 x 'small' kids meals
1x 'bigger' kids meal
Coffee, 2 cokes and a 7UP totalled £31

He gave £10 cash (she told him then that she planned to take them to a soft play and her nana would drive as it was raining, he didn't say he didn't want them to go out) so she was £29 out of pocket
Then he paid the mum £15 so she was only £14 out of pocket.

Later he gave her the last £15 after much complaining about being taken advantage of Hmm

OP posts: