Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL questioning me.

189 replies

biiianxa · 31/05/2022 18:38

AIBU to think my MIL is going too far?

I try to keep the peace and often do things that my MIL suggests to avoid any unnecessary dilemmas, but it's starting to annoy me that any time i do things MY way with MY child, she's questioning them.

DS has a tendency of chewing on his hands, probably teething commencing and he does this 80% of the time. often, he'll get rid of dummy to replace it with his fingers, after multiple times telling MIL he's not hungry, she insists he must be as his hands are always in his mouth.

we've more or less fell into a routine of feeding every 5 or 6 hours, which works brilliant with us! but anytime we visit her, or we leave him with her, she's trying to feed him every 2 hours.

it's currently 18:30, and feeding time for DS, we have started him on solids and i have a strict "no solids after 19:00" to ensure he doesn't go to bed on a very full tummy and it doesn't disrupt his sleep. he'll have his usual 6 ounces before bed.

MIL has insisted that DS is sleepy and starts shaking him to sleep after i precisely said it's feeding time and he can take a nap after. whilst i was sterling his utensils for feeding she has rocked him to sleep, his food is prepared and everything is sterilised. I'm very close to having a go at her, because she needs to understand things aren't going to go her way, this isn't her child.

it's obviously not DS fault, so i have let her put him in his crib and sleep now, but it has really irritated me that she went against my wishes.

AIBU for getting annoyed that she keeps trying to do things her way?

OP posts:
Andouillette · 01/06/2022 09:21

Good grief OP, I am sorry to see that you seem to have acquired a load more MILs answering your post! Theories on feeding babies change all the time and as with most things 'baby' the NHS is often a bit behind. There is plenty of evidence that weaning earlier than 6 months IS suitable for some babies as shown in a link I will attempt to post below. 6 months is a reasonable rule of thumb for most and all parents/caregivers should try and be aware of the signs of readiness. There is also a growing body of evidence that a varied diet of solids before 12 months is valid for preventing allergies.
Personally one of my 3 was stealing food from my plate at less than 4 months, chewing it an swallowing it. She was just... like that. Her paediatrician wasn't fussed at all. She crawled at 4.5 months too though was bang on average with later milestones like walking and talking, so not some sort of weird super baby! My youngest was different again, she was needing 10 oz bottles 6 times a day at three months and that was a nightmare. With GP and HV approval she started purees and cereals shortly afterwards and it was so much better for her. Middle DD was text book. She wouldn't even look at solids at all till 7 months. Or to put it another way, babies gonna baby and as long as professionals (HV, GP, paediatrician) are involved and keeping an eye on them they should be absolutely fine.
OP says in her first post that her HV is happy and that her baby's weight is fine. She has a slight MIL problem, not a baby problem.
www.uhcw.nhs.uk/download/clientfiles/files/Patient%20Information%20Leaflets/Clinical%20Support%20Services/Dietetics/118833_Allergy_-Introducing_milk_free_solids_to_your_baby(1578)_-April_2019(Final).pdf

Portiasparty · 01/06/2022 09:19

I can't believe there are all these people piling on to tell OP she's doing it wrong when the baby is happy and the paediatrician has agreed with the routine. Unbelievable! And please note that the OP has explained that the solids include formula, so the baby is getting formula every three hours, not six.

I'm wondering OP if you're just not being assertive enough and you also need your DH to back you up. The rocking to sleep would have really annoyed me. And I'm old enough to be a MiL! Try and be a bit more confident, it seems like you're doing fine. Despite people's obsessions with only one way of doing things (safety issues, aside, as obviously being essential), different styles end up with the same result, healthy, thriving adults!

Phobiaphobic · 01/06/2022 09:14

So many interfering future MILs on this thread. Ignore them, OP. As long as your baby is healthy and happy, you're doing well.

Your MIL is the problem. Your DS is YOUR baby, not hers. Why is she so involved in your life? The first thing I'd do is distance yourself, and explain why. She'll soon get the message.

MRex · 01/06/2022 08:50

By the way, for some perspective, I have a 4 year old and we don't expect him to go without any drink for more than 3 hours except in the night. He's also allowed a small snack in the morning or afternoon between meals and most days has one; fruit or an oat bar or pancake slice. Your baby is 5 months old with a tiny tummy, feed accordingly!

Skinnermarink · 01/06/2022 08:50

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 01/06/2022 08:44

Your feeding routine is fine (exactly what I did 20 years ago and I suspect there are younger mums on here that just follow more up to date ideas, doesnt mean that they are right though). Get your DH to talk to his mum and get her to lay off (oh and stop her coming round so often)

The thing is often things change because more research and studies have been carried out so we understand things better. The benefit of waiting until six months is the gut maturity of the baby and less risk of choking if baby-led as better grip on the food you give them but even then it’s expected that almost every calorie is obtained through milk.

I mean the advice used to put tiny babies on their stomachs to sleep with cot bumpers and pillows and all sorts in a different room and we know that’s no longer a good idea, don’t we?

Strictlyfanoftenyears · 01/06/2022 08:44

Your feeding routine is fine (exactly what I did 20 years ago and I suspect there are younger mums on here that just follow more up to date ideas, doesnt mean that they are right though). Get your DH to talk to his mum and get her to lay off (oh and stop her coming round so often)

Calphurnia88 · 01/06/2022 08:39

diddl · 01/06/2022 08:29

But perhaps he didn't need it that day?

If he's still having all the milk feeds he wants & not relying on solids then it surely doesn't matter if he misses one?

This reply was in context of PP justifying MIL interference by saying OP wasn't feeding DC enough, but MIL interference meant he missed a feed...

FWIW the gaps between feeds do sound long to me, but my LO is a few months younger so I am feeding more often (and no solids).

MRex · 01/06/2022 08:37

I can understand why your MIL is asking questions, I'm confused too and would be concerned enough to ask questions if your DS was my young relative. Most importantly, why on earth are you putting formula into food? You need heat to kill bacteria, there's a huge risk of you getting the mix quantities wrong and he isn't learning what real food is. Feed him actual food plus milk on the side, that's much easier and better for him.

Next, that's such an unusually long gap in the morning for such a young baby. You don't seem to have the same gap in the afternoon, so why are you making him wait in the morning? You'll just make him demand more in the afternoon and an over-full tummy is not good, little and often is the trick. It might be worth looking at some typical schedules with meal plans and copying those until you get in the swing of things.

ChickensandCows · 01/06/2022 08:37

biiianxa · 31/05/2022 21:33

he has a fruit purée with 4 ounces of milk at 12. i make sure to always add formula to his purées, so in some way he's still having his feeds. i don't leave him from 7am to 3pm without milk!

Up the formula. Reducd the solids. Way too early and totally unnecessary.

ChickensandCows · 01/06/2022 08:33

Skinnermarink · 31/05/2022 19:25

That’s early to be on solids. I assume as he’s so little he was tired enough to sleep, so he wanted to sleep. 5/6 hours between feeds sounds a bit mad to me at that age too. Maybe he is hungry.

I agree with this. That's too long between feeds especially at only 5 months and only 6 ounces. He probably is hungry. I agree with your MIL.

THisbackwithavengeance · 01/06/2022 08:30

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 01/06/2022 07:25

Sounds like your mil is right to be worried. Firstly you are giving solids too early, so young food is literally for tasting/playing with up until 12 months. It cant be that long since you introduced food so how have they got the hang of it so quickly? I cant see a doctor telling you to give solids at 4 months old so its been what a week/2 weeks since you started solids? You are feeding milk every 6 hours, what other drinks are they having? They shouldn't be drinking water at that age so you are only offering drinks every 6 hours? I breastfed granted but at 5 months I was feeding every 2 hours, it didn't really stretch out much until beyond 12 months as they don't actually swallow much food. Sterilising utensils is a bit daft if you are feeding them food? I've had 3 children and the youngest is only just 1 so it's not like it's been ages since I had a baby the same age! Sounds like you are saying it was on doctors advise to stop people questioning what you are doing.

This.

diddl · 01/06/2022 08:29

Calphurnia88 · 01/06/2022 07:17

I noticed this too!

But perhaps he didn't need it that day?

If he's still having all the milk feeds he wants & not relying on solids then it surely doesn't matter if he misses one?

Toddlerteaplease · 01/06/2022 08:23

5/6 hours between feeds at 5 months is a bit mean. It's also very early to start solids. Did you think he was ready because he's always hungry, when actually he just needs milk. Many adults would struggle with that gap between meals and drinks.

dementedpixie · 01/06/2022 08:18

Our health advisor recommended rice powder in the bottle on the last feed before bed to help not being hungry in the night although my kids are teens now so this might have changed

You should never add anything to the milk. This shouldn't be recommended by anyone let alone a health advisor

SatinHeart · 01/06/2022 08:15

I'm very close to having a go at her, because she needs to understand things aren't going to go her way, this isn't her child

She's not going to understand unless you tell her. You are parenting differently to how she would/did, so that gives you 2 options:

  1. Explain the rationale behind why you are doing things the way you are and try and get her to buy into it

  2. be firm that if he wants to spend time with her grandchild she mustn't undermine your parenting.

Number one usually works on my MIL but we have had to move to number 2 a few times. Less as time has gone on.

ittakes2 · 01/06/2022 08:10

I think it confused people because you said you were feeding him every 5-6hrs whereas you are giving solids every 5-6hrs but milk more often. I noticed you are giving him milk at 9pm and midnight. Are you dream feeding him to help him sleep through? Our health advisor recommended rice powder in the bottle on the last feed before bed to help not being hungry in the night although my kids are teens now so this might have changed.
I can see you’ve had extra stress due to your hubby being sick I guess his mum is extra stressed too. You getting baby’s food ready and her putting him to sleep is not on and you need to tell her at a time when baby is asleep and you are both free that that’s not ok. Except please don’t sterilise the plates etc. Babies need their immune system challenged so they can deal with germs when they start crawling and licking things off the floor.

stuntbubbles · 01/06/2022 08:08

girlmom21 · 01/06/2022 05:56

You said he sleeps through the night but now you're giving him milk at 9pm and midnight. That's certainly not sleeping through the night.

How is this relevant to the OP’s issue, though, which is that her MIL pulls tricks like rocking the baby to sleep at his set mealtime?

DameHelena · 01/06/2022 08:03

Everyone who's questioning OPs routine and food choices, fucking lay off. OP, where is your husband? Is he happy for his child's routine and feeding to be interfered with?

Bluedabadeeba · 01/06/2022 08:03

I mean for the PP who said the advice has changed re starting solids.. can never seem to quote!!

Bluedabadeeba · 01/06/2022 08:02

I don't think this is accurate... Do you have research/ advice links for it?

user1498572889 · 01/06/2022 08:01

This post is not about how much she feeds her child or how she does it. It’s about her MIL not respecting the decisions she makes with her own child. OP you need to put your big girl pants on and tell your MIL that what she does is very annoying because it disrupts the routine you have with your child and unsettles them. If she chooses to disregard what you say you know she is doing it on purpose and she needs to be told that it isn’t her child and things will be done your way.

clarepetal · 01/06/2022 07:48

JLQ1020 · 31/05/2022 19:46

NHS guidance is to sterilise up to a year so poster is right with this.

Ur MIL sounds like a nightmare

Totally this. And I wish people would stop questioning OPs routine. Totally not the point or helpful, her baby, her choice.
Your MIL sounds tres annoying.

Sceptre86 · 01/06/2022 07:41

Where are you based?You mentioned having a paediatrician so that made me think somewhere other than the UK? The NHS advice is to sterilise utensils if baby is under your months of age when you start weaning so if you are in the UK that is following up to date guidance. Even if you are based elsewhere if your baby is under the care of a paediatrician then they can sway from any guidelines as their advice is based on professional judgement and what is right for your child. I think your routine is fine and your baby is a great weight for a 5 month old.

You asked about the mil overstepping and I would ask whether she lives with you or you use her for child care? If you use her for childcare I'd stop. If she lives with you then you and your oh need to be on the same page regards parenting first of all. I would then raise it with her in a respectful but firm way. That you are the parent and all parenting decisions are yours, you will not accept any interference no matter how well meaning. You have a routine that works well for you and you are sticking to that, it will change as and when your son dictates. You both need to say this on repeat until it sinks in. She may well challenge you and you both need to be firm bit respectful in laying out your boundaries. She'll get the message eventually if you are both consistent.

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 01/06/2022 07:25

Sounds like your mil is right to be worried. Firstly you are giving solids too early, so young food is literally for tasting/playing with up until 12 months. It cant be that long since you introduced food so how have they got the hang of it so quickly? I cant see a doctor telling you to give solids at 4 months old so its been what a week/2 weeks since you started solids? You are feeding milk every 6 hours, what other drinks are they having? They shouldn't be drinking water at that age so you are only offering drinks every 6 hours? I breastfed granted but at 5 months I was feeding every 2 hours, it didn't really stretch out much until beyond 12 months as they don't actually swallow much food. Sterilising utensils is a bit daft if you are feeding them food? I've had 3 children and the youngest is only just 1 so it's not like it's been ages since I had a baby the same age! Sounds like you are saying it was on doctors advise to stop people questioning what you are doing.

Calphurnia88 · 01/06/2022 07:17

DysmalRadius · 01/06/2022 06:50

All those up in arms about the feeding schedule and using that to justify the MIL's interference, you know that the baby was going to get LESS food the MIL's way right? She was trying to get him to sleep instead of feed!!

I noticed this too!