Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you ever go out of your way to save the life of a stranger in this day and age/if it risked your own safety??!

86 replies

NellesVilla · 31/05/2022 18:28

Was having a think about this the other day and really wondered to myself: would I do this now in this day and age???!

I was a lot braver in my youth and would have tackled men shouting at women in the street, adults smacking their kids in public etc etc. I also contributed towards helping people in peril quite a few times: I grabbed a child out of a river; performed first air on someone (no rescue breaths but every other step); jumped in front of a bus to alert the driver he was about to run over an old man who had basically fallen under the back wheel of his vehicle etc etc.

These days, I think to myself; is it worth it? I’ve never received any thanks for it; indeed some people seemed a bit put out by me ‘interfering’ (all instances on my list above felt like this).

Also, is it worth risking your own safety? I would never give rescue breaths to anyone (apart from my dog- half joking) because I’d be worried about causing more harm.

Anyone here who’d jump into a deep river to save a kid whilst the parents looked on gormlessly or just hope that someone else would come to the rescue??

OP posts:
jamfirstcreamsecond · 31/05/2022 22:15

Not sure if I actually saved a life but one evening during lockdown I talked a young girl off a motorway bridge. I was in my daily govt mandated walk and noticed a young person sat on the wrong side of a bridge over the M61. I couldn't walk on so stopped and sat with them. Transpired it was a young girl of about 15 and clearly troubled. Spent about an hour with her just chatting shit, managed to get her over the right side and she then went on her way. I have no idea what happened to her after but hope she left knowing that someone gave a damn.

AgentJohnson · 31/05/2022 22:12

Folajimi Olubunmi-Adewole dived into the Thames last year to rescue a woman but sadly lost his life. I suspect he acted on Adrenaline and instinct and therefore didn’t have time to weigh up the pro’s and con’s of his actions.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 31/05/2022 22:12

I like to think I would, yes, I have before. I remember years ago watching a documentary about a group of girls that beat another girl unconscious on a crowded bus in the middle of the day and none of the adults did a thing. They broke the girl's skull. The Mum was interviewed in tears asking why on earth nobody tried to help her daughter. I thought - and still think - how could everyone just sit and watch?

zafferana · 31/05/2022 22:08

Oh and it's never a good idea to jump into deep water to try and rescue someone! Much better to use rescue aids from the bank, such as a life belt, a long pole, a piece of clothing, etc. The number of have-a-go heroes who then have to be rescued themselves is quite high! Always assess the situation and try to think clearly. Don't just jump in and worry about the consequences later. Stop. Think. Act. And often the best action you can take is the call the emergency services.

Passtheduchyonthelefthandside · 31/05/2022 22:05

NellesVilla · 31/05/2022 18:28

Was having a think about this the other day and really wondered to myself: would I do this now in this day and age???!

I was a lot braver in my youth and would have tackled men shouting at women in the street, adults smacking their kids in public etc etc. I also contributed towards helping people in peril quite a few times: I grabbed a child out of a river; performed first air on someone (no rescue breaths but every other step); jumped in front of a bus to alert the driver he was about to run over an old man who had basically fallen under the back wheel of his vehicle etc etc.

These days, I think to myself; is it worth it? I’ve never received any thanks for it; indeed some people seemed a bit put out by me ‘interfering’ (all instances on my list above felt like this).

Also, is it worth risking your own safety? I would never give rescue breaths to anyone (apart from my dog- half joking) because I’d be worried about causing more harm.

Anyone here who’d jump into a deep river to save a kid whilst the parents looked on gormlessly or just hope that someone else would come to the rescue??

If a person needs rescue breaths, they are likely to die if you don't give them. Basic first aid should be a skill the majority of people should have.

If I could help someone who was hurt, I would. I wouldn't put my life at risk for them though.

zafferana · 31/05/2022 22:04

I just renewed my first aider certification last week and as a first aider your first responsibility is always to yourself. You are NEVER advised or under any obligation to put yourself into a harmful situation in order to help others. You are also never under obligation to give rescue breaths while performing CPR. You are ADVISED to, but never obligated to if you'd rather not. As a trained first aider I can tell you right now that the only people I'd put my mouth to mouth on would be my own family or perhaps a close friend. Total stranger? No fucking way.

JaceLancs · 31/05/2022 21:58

Probably! I think instinct kicks in and I would probably act without thinking
DP saved someone from drowning in rough seas nearly 40 years ago and got a bravery award - the person contacted him years later and told him how rest of her life turned out - he was pleased but embarrassed
I was very privileged recently to bump into someone who claimed I’d saved their life (during a MH crisis) in my day job x I was teared up for days

CockSpadget · 31/05/2022 21:53

I have, and received a police commendation for doing so. I don't think I could ever be in a position to do so and just stand by.

NortieTortie · 31/05/2022 21:47

Like a lot of previous posters, I'm not near good enough at swimming to actually help anyone so that's a straight no.

I like to think I'd help in other circumstances but I do tend to freeze. I guess you don't truly know unless you're in that position.

Bluebellsand · 31/05/2022 21:44

My body would most likely freeze so I would most likely to be useless. If my body let's me react, I hope I try to rescue someone.

I don't know how to swim so I would only give the real rescue workers a bigger job.

Echobelly · 31/05/2022 21:43

Depends on situation.

I think I'd risk shouting and saying I've called the police (even if I haven't) if I witnessed some violence because I know that just knowing someone's seen them can put a lot of people to flight as they don't want to get caught. As I'm a small, middle aged woman I probably wouldn't seem like enough of a threat to attack, so probably not a life risk.

I wouldn't try to save someone, say, in trouble in water as I am a weak swimmer (and, as I said also small) so it's likely I would just create more difficulty by attempting to do so and need rescuing myself.

hangrylady · 31/05/2022 21:41

Diving into water I don't think I would as I'm a weak swimmer so would probably end up drowning as well! Angry man with a knife? No unless he was threatening my kids. I just don't really know as I've never been in that situation.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 31/05/2022 21:39

I'm one of those people who, instead of freezing, rubbernecking or turning away because 'it's none of our business', feels completely calm and focused.

I always check for danger before helping. OK, DP would say that my assessment of risk is significantly lower than his, but I'm looking at likelihood of quick escape as well as imminent death. Hopefully, it's been worth it for the assorted people I've picked up, stopped traffic from squishing, given first aid to, put into the recovery position or retrieved from upended cars. Even if DP ages five years everytime because he knows by the time it's registered with him that something is happening, I'm already halfway over there and looking to give him and anybody else around instructions.

I don't do rescue breaths, though, vomit or no (unless it were a child/baby, then I'd do it). And I would never jump into water or between people in a fight. I'm calm and confident, not suicidal.

Dancingwithhyenas · 31/05/2022 21:39

No question and I have, more than once. I think most people would when it actually comes to it. It’s not a decision.

Onemoresleeptogonow · 31/05/2022 21:38

As a young boy my now exh fell into a river. An elderly man happened to be looking out his landing window and saw him. He rushed out in just his pants and caught dh as he floated past...

Absolutely stroke of luck
.
Or maybe not.
Exh....

SmellyWellyWoo · 31/05/2022 21:37

I didn't think I would but I helped a teen who was being physically bullied in a local park the other week. I think some maternal instinct kicked in for the poor lad. Probably quite risky but I just couldn't stop myself.

swapcicles · 31/05/2022 21:25

I'm not sure I'd jimp into a river but instinctively I'd try and help,
The other day I saw an elderly gentleman collapse in the car park at work I was 20 meters away ish and just ran to help.
Also recently I went to help a man lying on the ground at 3am nearby the house. Presumed he was drunk and he was but didn't know that before I got to him. Managed to get him home and he was a nice guy thankfully just very drunk and it was a cold night so not the best night to have a kip in the tarmac!
Sometimes instinct just takes over.

Onemoresleeptogonow · 31/05/2022 21:20

Quite heavily pregnant I jumped in a pool to get ds out of a play ring as he was going under and trapped...
Once pulled over and dragged a teen driver out after her car hit a trees and was billowing smoke.
Never gave either incident a thought just did it.
Can't imagine not getting involved regardless of risk.

dudsville · 31/05/2022 21:15

Like you, in my youth i jumped in a lot more, but those were Chaotic times, things have been calmer for decades. I've not been tested. I do pick up broken glass in parks. Things that dogs might eat that's deadly (chewing gum pieces) Etc. Does that count?

Rubyroseyposey · 31/05/2022 21:11

Yes.

LeniGray · 31/05/2022 21:11

I’ve defused aggressive people, and I was the only one that reacted helpfully when a young woman collapsed near me and smacked her head on concrete. I’ve learnt that I can be calm in moments of intense stress … I think I would’ve made a good police officer if certain things in my life had panned out differently. I couldn’t physically do much to help now (I’m disabled) but I’m not someone who would stand by in an emergency, I’d do whatever I could to help.

NellesVilla · 31/05/2022 21:09

I kind of feel the same, @TimeTravelSickness- animals are so pure and innocent. My dog is my world.

And @KvotheTheBloodless , that’s just awful. Poor woman; horrid man. Too
many of those.

OP posts:
TimeTravelSickness · 31/05/2022 21:04

When I was younger, I would and did. Now, no. I’ve realised that most people are arseholes and aren’t worth me getting hurt or worse for. I will risk my life for animals though, they’re much more deserving of my help.

KvotheTheBloodless · 31/05/2022 20:57

Yes - in fact I intervened yesterday in a street fight in Central Sheffield in Broad daylight, an awful man stamped violently on a woman's head and threatened to stab her. NOBODY else did anything so I had to stop him. I yelled at someone to call the police mid-tussle and he just stood there looking gormless and shocked. It was OK in the end, police & ambulance came etc.

I think if there are a lot of people around, they tend to assume someone else will sort it and they don't have to. And some people go into shock. I really don't think most folk are bad people, just a mix of bystander paralysis and freezing with fear.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 31/05/2022 20:55

I don’t know how I’d react but I think I’d find it difficult to just stand by and do nothing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread