Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you ever go out of your way to save the life of a stranger in this day and age/if it risked your own safety??!

86 replies

NellesVilla · 31/05/2022 18:28

Was having a think about this the other day and really wondered to myself: would I do this now in this day and age???!

I was a lot braver in my youth and would have tackled men shouting at women in the street, adults smacking their kids in public etc etc. I also contributed towards helping people in peril quite a few times: I grabbed a child out of a river; performed first air on someone (no rescue breaths but every other step); jumped in front of a bus to alert the driver he was about to run over an old man who had basically fallen under the back wheel of his vehicle etc etc.

These days, I think to myself; is it worth it? I’ve never received any thanks for it; indeed some people seemed a bit put out by me ‘interfering’ (all instances on my list above felt like this).

Also, is it worth risking your own safety? I would never give rescue breaths to anyone (apart from my dog- half joking) because I’d be worried about causing more harm.

Anyone here who’d jump into a deep river to save a kid whilst the parents looked on gormlessly or just hope that someone else would come to the rescue??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
maddy68 · 14/02/2023 23:27

I would hope so

Beesandhoney123 · 14/02/2023 23:26

I hope I would, as under extreme conditions not sure how I would react to various situations. It depends if its something I could help with or just make it worse. I am very practical though, and not given to high drama.

Once I helped someone out of crashed car, the air being thick with petrol. They fell asleep at the wheel and crashed, rolling their car.

Lucky we were behind them. Boyfriend at time surprisingly to me, panicked like chicken licken and was yelling their car would explode and to stay away. I, with the confidence of youthful immortality, ignored him and carried on.

Letsrunabath · 01/06/2022 14:33

I would, I’m fit and healthy so if I had to perform resuscitation until HCPs arrived I could, I have also intervened when a very drunk man was being abused by youths for the fun of it. My Dad talked someone down from committing suicide and he was 76 at the time, so I think social responsibility is something you learn from parents.

FrecklesMalone · 01/06/2022 04:20

NellesVilla · 31/05/2022 19:08

No @Octomore , I wasn’t expecting thanks and doing it on a condition of receiving it, but my point was that so many people seem affronted that I got involved, I suppose.

Most people won't be affronted. They are likely to be in shock if it genuinely was a near death experience. They will be in survival mode not ready to say thank you.

bluetongue · 01/06/2022 04:06

Depends.

I have had one situation in my past when a stranger ended up stabbed outside my home. I was inside and had no idea if the offender was still around and if the victim was off their face on drugs. Could see that they were bleeding from chest but was not willing to risk my safety to reassure him or give first aid seeing as I was already inside. I called emergency services of course who came within minutes .

If there was a car crash or something that happened while I was walking or already out and about it would be different.

Maybebabyno2 · 01/06/2022 04:06

By nature I'm a bit of a fixer, so although I have never been in a situation like this, I think I would probably just do it without thinking.

I would jump into a river to save a child, but I know im a strong swimmer and would probably be okay. I would want someone to do the same for my child too.

But you never really know until you are actually in the position what your response will be.

Phrenologistsfinger · 01/06/2022 03:51

TimeTravelSickness · 31/05/2022 21:04

When I was younger, I would and did. Now, no. I’ve realised that most people are arseholes and aren’t worth me getting hurt or worse for. I will risk my life for animals though, they’re much more deserving of my help.

Yup, hard agree

Momtotwokids · 01/06/2022 03:21

I would save someone but not in water, I can't swim and would do more damage.

HikingforScenery · 01/06/2022 00:01

No I wouldn’t put myself in harm’s way to save a stranger.
I don’t know if you remember that story where that poor kid jumped into the river to save a girl, who then survived with the other guy and the kid died, leaving his elderly parents on their own?

I took the opportunity to teach my children to call for help in a situation like that instead of risking their lives. I hope they listen, especially DS, who would give his last meal to a stranger. His life is precious too. There’s no need risking it for someone else’s.

Pre-children, I’d be straight in but not these days

Carrotten · 01/06/2022 00:00

I once saved a child from drowning in the sea but I didn't really think about it. Was more of a oh fuck moment. I don't think I could have just watching the child drown, equally was already in the sea and am a strong swimmer so the danger to me was low.

I really don't know what I'd do in a truelly dangerous situation, like a fire or something. I like to think I'd do my best

Vikinga · 31/05/2022 23:55

I'd jump.into a river to save someone but I'm a strong swimmer. I wouldn't risk my life I don't think but I would help if I could in any situation. I wouldn't need gratitude though.

I've never been in a situation yet so can't predict how I'll react but I'm usually calm in a crisis.

Cherms · 31/05/2022 23:50

I came to the conclusion that if I could live with myself for the possible consequences of not stepping in then perhaps I'd think twice and not do it. But if it was the right thing to do, nobody else was doing it and it did have to be done then yes I couldn't not.

jackstini · 31/05/2022 23:40

I think it's something you can't control

in my younger days I smashed a bottle to hold back a man at arms length who was beating his girlfriend so she could get away

I also took some car keys out of a drunk blokes hand who wanted to drive his wife and kids home. I threw them down the drain and she looked so relieved (then ran off quickly as he was a massive angry f-er)

This was over 20 years ago before kids though and I do wonder whether my automatic reactions would be the same now

JeanieGenie · 31/05/2022 23:30

My instincts have always been to help if I can - I've helped a struggling swimmer to shore, stopped a drunk man hitting his girlfriend, provided emergency first aid to a bike accident victim until someone more qualified showed up etc. But all of this was before I had children and I think I'm now significantly less likely to attempt anything heroic if I would be at risk.
When I was a child I watched my Dad run into a burning building to save the life of a disabled woman and it was horrific seeing him disappearing into the blaze and not knowing if he'd come back out. I was incredibly proud of him afterwards though.

Letsrunabath · 31/05/2022 23:11

I picked up a drunken man who was being taunted by a gang of kids. I thought about the horrible cases of kids killing vunrable people. I gave him a lift home and he was really thankful
yes it could have turns out badly but it didn’t I’d id still do the same thing again.

Paq · 31/05/2022 22:57

LondonQueen · 31/05/2022 18:56

I probably would instinctively, but wouldn't choose to do it as I have two young children and a DH I'd rather not leave without a mother and wife.

I've done it instinctively. For random people and animals. I didn't think about it analytically at the time and at least once my actions could have had life changing consequences for me. But it all worked out ok.

Siepie · 31/05/2022 22:53

Twice I've run into the road to grab small children (not mine) who had darted out in front of cars. Both times it was purely instinctive. The first time, the parents were grateful. The second time, the mum shouted at me for touching her child, but it wouldn't stop me doing it again.

However, when I saw a woman getting hit by a man, I called the police and didn't intervene myself. I wouldn't have known what to do and would have probably just made the situation worse.

DilemmaBlah · 31/05/2022 22:45

I’ve saved a fair few lives in the day job and some outside of work. I’m also trained in water rescue and various other weird rescue stuff as part of a previous job role. I wouldn’t necessarily jump in to water straight away but I’d be more likely to than others I think, giving my training, and I’m a strong swimmer.

re the rescue breaths thing……most adults who collapse in public do so suddenly and the most common cause is a heart issue. A collapse that sudden means they were breathing and therefore getting oxygen right up to the collapse so they will have a fair amount of oxygen in their circulation. Our cells only extract about 25% of oxygen from circulating blood in health so there is usually a reserve left over that can be used. The compressions are needed to move that blood around the body to the vital organs though. Those patients don’t necessarily need rescue breaths from the public and can wait until the ambulance arrives as long as effective compressions are administered. Using a public access defibrillator should also take priority in sudden collapse too.

The ones who absolutely need rescue breaths are those whose breathing was compromised in some way prior to collapse (asthma, anaphylaxis, drowning etc) and all children.

MrOllivander · 31/05/2022 22:42

Depends how much danger to me I guess. I go icy calm in a crisis and just do stuff then adrenaline hits after
I've pulled someone out a smoking crashed car, done CPR on a stranger (successfully) etc but there wasn't any danger to me as such
If your leg is hanging off, you want me. If there's a bird in your house or DIY needs doing, don't call me Grin

Kite22 · 31/05/2022 22:39

It does depend on the situation, but I'd like to think I would.
Until you are actually there, in the heat of the moment though, I don't suppose any of us know how we would actually respond. Instinct - or in some cases training - kicks in.

pinkstripeycat · 31/05/2022 22:23

There was a teacher at a local school who stood between her pupils & their parents and a threatening man with severe MH issues and a large knife.
She receive a police commendation award.

SweetSakura · 31/05/2022 22:21

I did, this winter. And have done several times in the past. For me it's instinctive, I couldn't have walked in by in those situations. Although I did momentarily pause and plan the safest option in each instance.

And a school friend died protecting a stranger. He was only 19 when he died. So I am well aware of how wrong it can go. But I just couldn't walk on by.

theobligatorynamechange · 31/05/2022 22:20

It depends on how likely I thought I'd be to succeed, I think.

I wouldn't get involved in breaking up a fight, because I'm a short weakling and I'd end up getting myself killed and not helping.

I'd do CPR without a face mask (no, not one of those face masks, the ones designed to protect you from exchanging fluids during CPR) if I thought the rescue breaths were necessary. I'd hate it, but I'd do it anyway, because in that moment, the risk to me wouldn't feel as big as the risk of the person dying.

I'd always call for help, even if it was a call of quietly dialling 999, pressing 55 and not saying anything.

CupidStunt22 · 31/05/2022 22:20

BeyondMyWits · 31/05/2022 18:34

If it was a situation where I know I could help, of course I would.

Last year, I stopped a man thumping a woman (his partner!) in the street with pure shame... it did help that many moons ago I was his midday supervisor at school... and he knew it.

Nice outcome, but not guaranteed. I intervened in a similar manner and got punched in the face by not just the man, but also the woman I was trying to help.

I'd be less likely to try and help next time.

pinkstripeycat · 31/05/2022 22:17

Wickywickyyow · Today 18:51
It's instinctual isn't it? My DH would, his flight/fight response is fight (metaphorically speaking) and he's a police officer.

My DH is police too. It’s almost as if they have an invisible superpower. They don’t think about themselves. They go in to job mode as they are often the most confident and capable person there and know how to take control.
They are always so calm in an emergency