Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DH being unrealistic...when are kids most expensive??

343 replies

Keha · 31/05/2022 18:11

Having a big debate with DH. He thinks we should move to a more expensive house in next couple if years. Currently have DD aged 2 and am 30 weeks pregnant. Things would be tight financially, but DH reckons it will be much easier financially once kids are in school/getting 30 hours nursery. In his words "they'll never be as expensive as they are now".

I think he is being unrealistic. Yes nursery is a lot, or in our case we both work part time to provide child care so our income is reduced. But even at school surely we'll spend a fortune on wrap around care, activities, hobbies etc. And as they get older they'll eat more, want more. We've just come back from our first proper family holiday and it was eye opening looking at entry prices for older kids etc. I don't want to be scraping by for the next 20 years to have a slightly bigger house.

So who is right? When were you kids the most expensive? Pre school? Primary? Teenagers??

(For context, our jobs are such that we don't expect huge increases in salary over the years)

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 07:18

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 07:09

I was one of the posters that said surely the younger yrs were more expensive as you pay thousands for childcare. I can't see myself spending that much on teens. And I don't think it's a bad thing to not buy my dc a car, driving lessons, loads of clothes etc even if I can afford it. Clubs aren't an issue and I will pay for that. School trips likewise but they don't have to do all of them.

No tenji they don’t.

If you look at my post, I didn’t factor in seixing lessons as a cost, but it’s all the other stuff too.

It adds up day, by day, over time.

Half term treat of cinema and dinner tomorrow night for five of us here - guess how much that’s going to cost? It’s minor stuff like this that is a treat he’s but entirely reasonable to pay for when you have teens on occasion: it adds up.

Don’t kid yourself about the extra cost of teens.

Howbkixh is your childcare per child per month on average?

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 07:18

I'd pay for DS's driving lessons if I could afford it personally. They're very expensive nowadays.

I paid for my own & they were expensive then. I only learnt in my late 20s, being a Londoner I really didn't need a car & it will be the same for my dc. But I understand depending on where you live it may be more of a priority.

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 07:17

Most of mine are grown. In my experience they get more expensive steadily over the years.

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 07:15

@Caspianberg I had a Saturday job from the age of 17 on Bond street & loved it. I worked the holidays too & then at uni got a Saturday job in Oasis, again a good experience although granted uni may have changed.

There is a middle ground for teens I agree. But also, if I have the choice, time and money, I would want to give mine the best leg up in life I can.

I suppose it's also how you were raised. So my parents were tight in some ways but prioritised education & house deposits. I wouldn't have been able to buy in London without that help. I will do the same for my dc. I'm less inclined to fund lots of clothes & tech.

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 07:15

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 07:11

I'd pay for DS's driving lessons if I could afford it personally. They're very expensive nowadays.

My eldest got those for his 17th.
Lessons, his provisional, and we’ll pay for one go each at his theory and practical too.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 07:13

Caspianberg · 01/06/2022 07:02

There is a middle ground for teens I agree. But also, if I have the choice, time and money, I would want to give mine the best leg up in life I can.

I remember working from 14 years at weekends and evenings. To afford bus to school, social life, clothing, driving lessons, essentials. It just meant I never had much freetime to do nicer hobbies and also was always behind on school work and study compared to friends who had the whole weekend free.
Also if they go to uni the same applies, many courses now say they don’t recommend working alongside course, so if you have to your always going to struggle compared to others.
Working in the summer holidays each year, and parent support if possible seems a good compromise

Agree with this.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 07:11

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 06:55

A joyless teenhood just because it’s optional to do more sounds pretty bleak.

Surely there's a middle ground between giving them the best life can offer & a joyless experience? My parents could afford to buy me driving lessons but thought it important for me to pay for somethings myself.

I would think it must be quite difficult to be a teenager/young adult & have thousands spent on you each month to then having to support yourself as the vast majority of teenagers won't land 100k jobs so won't have loads of excess cash a month.

I'd pay for DS's driving lessons if I could afford it personally. They're very expensive nowadays.

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 07:09

I was one of the posters that said surely the younger yrs were more expensive as you pay thousands for childcare. I can't see myself spending that much on teens. And I don't think it's a bad thing to not buy my dc a car, driving lessons, loads of clothes etc even if I can afford it. Clubs aren't an issue and I will pay for that. School trips likewise but they don't have to do all of them.

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 07:03

Of course tenji

My kids aren’t decked out head to toe in designer gear with the latest everything as it comes out, and that’s not what I said was standard, nor the point I was responding to either.

But paying for no clubs and buying no clothes that are fashionable and that a teen wants, is UR if you can afford to do so, on occasion.

Where did your figure of thousands per month come from? Who has suggested that this isn’t norm and/or reasonable?

Caspianberg · 01/06/2022 07:02

There is a middle ground for teens I agree. But also, if I have the choice, time and money, I would want to give mine the best leg up in life I can.

I remember working from 14 years at weekends and evenings. To afford bus to school, social life, clothing, driving lessons, essentials. It just meant I never had much freetime to do nicer hobbies and also was always behind on school work and study compared to friends who had the whole weekend free.
Also if they go to uni the same applies, many courses now say they don’t recommend working alongside course, so if you have to your always going to struggle compared to others.
Working in the summer holidays each year, and parent support if possible seems a good compromise

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 06:55

A joyless teenhood just because it’s optional to do more sounds pretty bleak.

Surely there's a middle ground between giving them the best life can offer & a joyless experience? My parents could afford to buy me driving lessons but thought it important for me to pay for somethings myself.

I would think it must be quite difficult to be a teenager/young adult & have thousands spent on you each month to then having to support yourself as the vast majority of teenagers won't land 100k jobs so won't have loads of excess cash a month.

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 06:47

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 06:45

They are a choice, you're right. But as long as I can afford it and I'm not scrimping on food or heating then I want to give DS the best of what life can offer, I'm sure most parents feel the same. I wouldn't buy a more expensive house if it meant I had to sacrifice other things for DS, my current house is perfectly fine.

Completely agree.
A joyless teenhood just because it’s optional to do more sounds pretty bleak.

We all only need to buy supermarket clothes and value food too by that reasoning as well.

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 06:45

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 06:36

But expensive hobbies and clothes are optional - surely you're only paying for those things through choice?

Whereas childcare is a must for most people if you need to work.

You could make your kid a social pariah and not buy things you can afford, not put them in any clubs, not pay for school trips, nor the cinema etc just because you don’t want to spend it, but I don’t know many who would and why would you anyway 🫤

A bored teen is a destructive teen and like the saying goes ‘ the devil makes work for idle hands’ They’ll eventually get money from somewhere and that’s best avoided.

One of the best ways to keep your teen out of trouble, and I mean proper trouble is to get them involved in clubs/hobbies etc - this costs money.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 01/06/2022 06:45

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 06:36

But expensive hobbies and clothes are optional - surely you're only paying for those things through choice?

Whereas childcare is a must for most people if you need to work.

They are a choice, you're right. But as long as I can afford it and I'm not scrimping on food or heating then I want to give DS the best of what life can offer, I'm sure most parents feel the same. I wouldn't buy a more expensive house if it meant I had to sacrifice other things for DS, my current house is perfectly fine.

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 06:41

What I don’t get is why on here people often bang on about the cost of food and how expensive it is, but ignore that massive increase in cost for teenagers. It’s crazy how much teen boys can eat. My middle DS will eat multiple eggs on toast as a snack after school and still eat supper and then bed time snacks too (and there’s no wasted fat not on him, just a big muscles, athletic boy).

I have three teenage boys, I’ll break down just some of the costs, for others it will be different and varies year on year but it’s a lot more.

-Bus fare to and from school per day (per child) - £8

-Men’s size clothing; trousers/shirts/jumpers/shoes/trainers - they grow constantly and this needs replacing not infrequently and all at different times. Adults clothes cost way way more than those of tinies and you don’t have spares to pass down very often and so this needs to be bought repeatedly per child over the teen years. One of my sons outgrew his PE kit twice in one school (I.e. I bought it three times).

-ex curric club fees/kit/boots/weekly costs - £500 per season and that’s just one sport, one boy (mine play circa 2-3 each)

-massive additional cost in petrol (and time) to all excurric games/practices and school games/practices

-fees for things like school trips (biology/field trips etc) - this school year for one son it’s £1000 probably more and that doesn’t include full D of E fees another trip.

-massive increased cost of school supplies and additional study resources. This is state school and yes, this is needed, £25 per month

I haven’t included the costs of tech (phones, laptops etc), the utterly insane increased cost in food per child, the extra month to do things together as a family, or their socialising money/pocket money, the general increase in cost for non-school uniform clothes, the money they have per day for incidentals etc at tuck shop after school
etc

Even their items for leisure activities cost more. An art set for a tiny costs pence unless you’re buying adult stuff for them to draw with (why would you). A proper art set costs more for an older kid. Ditto for bikes, footballs, etc

I am told teen girls costs way more too. I can believe it.

I haven’t included the half of it here - cost of family holiday for example once they’re >12 is same as adult. Cost to do things is way more when they’re older. Sitting on a beach with a plastic bucket and spade with an ice cream periodically for 7 days doesn’t cut it - activities cost way more.

And until they’re older, you do still have some
childcate costs, it doesn’t just disappear when they’re 11.

I spend so much more now than I did when my three were young and I worked had a nanny.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/06/2022 06:36

FrangipaniBlue · 31/05/2022 23:08

DS14 has fewer clubs/after school care/kids parties etc so he is cheaper in that regards HOWEVER he has expensive hobbies and taste in clothes both of which far outweigh his costs in primary school!!!

But expensive hobbies and clothes are optional - surely you're only paying for those things through choice?

Whereas childcare is a must for most people if you need to work.

xxlostxx · 01/06/2022 01:48

Teenagers are by far the most expensive in my experience.

Vikinga · 01/06/2022 01:42

zafferana · 31/05/2022 18:14

They're always expensive!

0-4 you've got nursery
5-11 you've got wraparound/holiday childcare
12-18 you've got tech/clothes/school trips/pocket money/more expensive to take on holiday

Yep

BlusteryLake · 01/06/2022 01:37

Having children is a constant stream of expense, but I would say the primary school years are the least expensive. Pre school and teenage costs depend on your set up. If you aren't paying for pre school childcare then teenage is definitely more expensive, but as PP have said, pre school childcare is often inflexible in terms of discretionary spend. I found it liberating not having nursery bills, even though our spend is now back to a comparable level with teenagers.

Ikeatears · 01/06/2022 00:17

Childcare is so expensive and generally, non-negotiable if you haven't got family to help out/need to work full-time. The difference as they get older is that you have a choice about much of what you spend.

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 00:17

And even if they were, you don't buy them every month.

how often are people replacing ipads & phones & laptops? I don't upgrade mine every-time a new model comes out so I won't be doing it for the dc.

tenjishut · 01/06/2022 00:15

Mine were at nursery in the 90s though before everyone got government funding for childcare.

but everyone doesn't get government funding.

Babyboomtastic · 01/06/2022 00:14

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 31/05/2022 21:45

Sadly, technology is not always optional.

Technology isn't optional, but it being brand new and top of the range is. Same with phones. No one needs the latest duper expensive iphone. No one needs the new games console. If you can afford them great, but there are not essential to having a teenager. And even if they were, you don't buy them every month.

GetThatHelmetOn · 31/05/2022 23:20

zafferana · 31/05/2022 18:14

They're always expensive!

0-4 you've got nursery
5-11 you've got wraparound/holiday childcare
12-18 you've got tech/clothes/school trips/pocket money/more expensive to take on holiday

This ^

i think you should be evaluating the move on the basis of mortgage interest rates rather than nursery costs over the next few years at this time.

GregBrawlsInDogJail · 31/05/2022 23:18

I'm still yet to see anyone demonstrate how teenagers can cost you £1k a month each while simultaneously lopping a big chunk off your earning potential, and that's before a preschooler eats anything, wears anything, or does a single activity.

The second mine are both in school, wraparound and holiday care is available at a much lower per-hour than I currently pay and I'm also paying for about twenty-five hours less of it a week and also earning more on account of going back to FT.