Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is DH being unrealistic...when are kids most expensive??

343 replies

Keha · 31/05/2022 18:11

Having a big debate with DH. He thinks we should move to a more expensive house in next couple if years. Currently have DD aged 2 and am 30 weeks pregnant. Things would be tight financially, but DH reckons it will be much easier financially once kids are in school/getting 30 hours nursery. In his words "they'll never be as expensive as they are now".

I think he is being unrealistic. Yes nursery is a lot, or in our case we both work part time to provide child care so our income is reduced. But even at school surely we'll spend a fortune on wrap around care, activities, hobbies etc. And as they get older they'll eat more, want more. We've just come back from our first proper family holiday and it was eye opening looking at entry prices for older kids etc. I don't want to be scraping by for the next 20 years to have a slightly bigger house.

So who is right? When were you kids the most expensive? Pre school? Primary? Teenagers??

(For context, our jobs are such that we don't expect huge increases in salary over the years)

OP posts:
3WildOnes · 01/06/2022 14:16

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 13:53

I had a nanny.
£20k a year for many, many years all those years ago. Circa £1600 a month, give or take.

I really didn’t just sling my mum £200
for full time childcare contrary to what’s repeatedly being asserted here regarding costs to those of us who did this years ago.

The £200 comment was in response to some who said that their nursery fees abroad were just that!
A nanny would cost you 40k+ now, including all your costs as an employer, I know thats what I was paying. A full time nursery place would be more than 1.6k a month where I live. I just don't think the majority of people spend 20k a year per teenager!

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 13:53

3WildOnes · 01/06/2022 13:30

@JustLyra I don't understand your different experiences point. Isn't @SynchOrSwim saying just that, that the people who are saying that teenagers are more expensive most likely had a different experience in that they didn't have high childcare costs?

I had a nanny.
£20k a year for many, many years all those years ago. Circa £1600 a month, give or take.

I really didn’t just sling my mum £200
for full time childcare contrary to what’s repeatedly being asserted here regarding costs to those of us who did this years ago.

Kite22 · 01/06/2022 13:46

Much of this will also depend on what you gain from "a more expensive house" of course.

If that puts you in catchment for a better school - then that is an investment worth getting on board with in most people's eyes.
If that gives you more bedrooms - then that will depend on family circumstances .....how many dc you plan to have...if you have relatives that live far away and want to stay with you when they visit....if you need a home office...... etc
If that gives you a drive to park on rather than not being able to even park close to your house some nights, then that is worth a lot to many people
If it gives you a decent size garden or an extra living room etc etc - wiill all be more important to some than others.

Personally, extending ourselves when we were young has been 100% the right decision for us but - as this thread shows - people have different priorities in life and what is valuable to each of us differs from one person to the next.

3WildOnes · 01/06/2022 13:30

@JustLyra I don't understand your different experiences point. Isn't @SynchOrSwim saying just that, that the people who are saying that teenagers are more expensive most likely had a different experience in that they didn't have high childcare costs?

SynchOrSwim · 01/06/2022 13:28

JustLyra · 01/06/2022 13:13

Or, you know, people could just have different experiences to you…

Yes, as I said, they either didn't have high early years childcare fees or spend huge amounts more on their teenagers than most people.

Keha · 01/06/2022 13:26

I do really appreciate all the responses on here. Obviously this is not the only factor in deciding whether to move but a lot of food for thought. From doing a bit more research and knowing our situation I dont think primary school age will cost as much as preschool, but maybe only by £200-300 a month. But teenagers likely to be a different story. I don't think I can cope with thinking that far ahead, except to say we probably need to concious of not overspending during primary and may need to look at promotions/earning more in the longer run (which we may be keener to do by then).

OP posts:
JustLyra · 01/06/2022 13:13

SynchOrSwim · 01/06/2022 12:45

I don't think people are lying just that they can't have spent much on nursery fees if teenagers are more expensive or they spend a very large (and optional) amount on their teens which doesn't apply to the vast majority of people.

Full time at nursery is about a grand and you're still paying for clothes, food, activities (musical bumps, puddle ducks, ballet tots, rugby tots) plus things like nappies, car seats, pushchairs on top.

I can see that clothes, activities, tech, food etc for a teenager is a lot more than for a toddler but there's not an extra £1000 on top of that when averaged out surely?

Or, you know, people could just have different experiences to you…

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 13:11

WakeWaterWalk · 01/06/2022 12:21

Later on choose any hobbies carefully. Dancing can get horribly expensive if it progresses with demands to pay for many outfits and loads of competitions.
Scouts, football and hockey were a bargain.

By the teen years things like dancing are often beyond the hobby stage. What if they want to make it their career? Would you tell them to choose something else or find a way to get them into a dance school that will give them the training they need?

Goldencarp · 01/06/2022 13:10

My kids are teens and are expensive now. I can’t really compare to when they were little as I’ve always been a stay at home mum. They want expensive clothes and trainers And money every time they leave the house.

RedGazelle · 01/06/2022 13:06

Also just to clarify I am not saying anyone else has to live as we do, I’m not saying everyone should spend as little as we do, I’m just saying that our teens do not currently cost us thousands a month for these reasons. They’re still expensive but not close to the amount of childcare costs for babies/toddlers.

RedGazelle · 01/06/2022 12:48

@bumpytrumpy well we live in town so they don’t have bus fares to pay. I expect them to go to the beach with friends, go to a friend’s house, have friends round here…I certainly don’t blow money on a Costa every week so don’t see why they should. The £10 is in addition to their normal allowance as well so it’s not like they literally have £10 for the summer.
And like I said if there’s something specific that they want to do (ice skating, cinema etc) then we give them extra to pay for them to do it.

@EarringsandLipstick I’ve just seen your other post about food. I’m sorry that you interpreted my comment about the bolognese as snide, it wasn’t intended to be at all

SynchOrSwim · 01/06/2022 12:45

I don't think people are lying just that they can't have spent much on nursery fees if teenagers are more expensive or they spend a very large (and optional) amount on their teens which doesn't apply to the vast majority of people.

Full time at nursery is about a grand and you're still paying for clothes, food, activities (musical bumps, puddle ducks, ballet tots, rugby tots) plus things like nappies, car seats, pushchairs on top.

I can see that clothes, activities, tech, food etc for a teenager is a lot more than for a toddler but there's not an extra £1000 on top of that when averaged out surely?

JustLyra · 01/06/2022 12:34

One of the big reasons that teens cost more now than they did before is because of the lack of jobs for teens in many places.

It used to be a right of passage for teens here that they worked in the theme park or a local amusement arcade. Now a lot of those jobs are taken by people who’d previously been retired or the likes. The few paper rounds that are left are done by older people.

there is less paperwork and restrictions when you don’t employ teens. They don’t disappear off to Uni if they’re older, they’ve often got more flexibility because they’re available school/college/Uni hours.

RedGazelle · 01/06/2022 12:29

EarringsandLipstick · 01/06/2022 09:38

I don’t think I’ve ever bought my son brand new football boots but he’s often had ones that have never been worn and the ones that have have been worn so little you can barely tell.

My GAA & soccer playing son is on his 3rd pair of boots. He wears them every day.

Families are different, you know

I know families are different, that was the point of my post to show that not everyone has to spend as much as some previous posters had quoted. My son also wears his boots every day and gets through several pairs a season, doesn’t mean I can’t get them either new or barely worn from eBay 🤷🏻‍♀️

WakeWaterWalk · 01/06/2022 12:21

Later on choose any hobbies carefully. Dancing can get horribly expensive if it progresses with demands to pay for many outfits and loads of competitions.
Scouts, football and hockey were a bargain.

WakeWaterWalk · 01/06/2022 12:18

I remember encouraging a friend of mine who was worrying about spending money (which she had but she was used to saving some every month) that the young kid stage was a time to loosen up the purse strings a bit to make their lives easier. Because it is a very busy time of life and potentially overwhelming.

WakeWaterWalk · 01/06/2022 12:11

Well if you work on a time is money principle then yes, pre school years unless you have free childcare from grandparents I guess.
If they go to university and are living away from home then that's the next huge cost.
And the teenage food and power bills can be a nasty surprise! 😂

Kite22 · 01/06/2022 12:04

RedGazelle · 01/06/2022 07:55

To counteract some of the points about teenagers.

Ours are not allowed to just eat the dinner food as a snack, or the packaged lunchbox type snacks. We buy a lot of bread, porridge oats, apples and eggs. Also own brand biscuits. These are snacks. They would never dream of eating their way through a pan of bolognese and would wait to check with me before serving themselves dinner.

They get an allowance that they have to use for trips out with friends etc, they also buy birthday presents for friends out of it but these are increasingly rare and usually only token gifts. This is not a particularly generous allowance, they get an extra £5 ‘holiday money’ in school holidays (£10 in summer holiday). They can also earn more by doing jobs around the house. Occasionally we’ll give them a little bit extra to do something specific with friends but this is only 3/4 times a year maximum not a monthly occurrence.

We have sim only contracts on a family plan that cost £35 in total for all 5 phones: The main phone is £15/month and extras 5/month. We set an amount (think it was £150 last time) that we’re prepared to pay for a phone and they have to pay any above that. DS asked for money for his birthday so he could put that towards one. We don’t upgrade phones every year or two.

Clubs are expensive yes, but boots, kits etc can often be bought unworn or barely worn second hand. I don’t think I’ve ever bought my son brand new football boots but he’s often had ones that have never been worn and the ones that have have been worn so little you can barely tell.

For clothes I buy the clothes they need, extras they buy themselves. My son likes branded everything but luckily he doesn’t mind if it comes from sports direct rather than JD. I also get a lot from vinted and ebay again either brand new or barely worn. My son doesn’t mind because he understands that that way he gets more for the money I’m prepared to spend. He wanted a north face coat, I said ok I’d spend up to £40 on a coat so he looked on vinted and found the exact one he wanted for £35 and bargained with me to get to keep the extra £5. If he’d insisted on it new he’d have had to save up to pay the difference. My daughter is more into the process of shopping than the actual clothes so I can’t really buy second hand for her now but again I give her limits and she has to pay the difference.

They haven’t had any school trips since before covid, they weren’t huge money though. Duke of Edinburgh was expensive (but optional).

Holidays and days out are expensive, we don’t do them often and mostly go camping now (one teen still comes, the other doesn’t).

They definitely cost more than my primary aged child but I don’t recognise some of the figures quoted on here.

I recognise all of this.
People replying with "by the time they get the bus into town and then a Costa" are clearly not living in my world. If my teens want to spend money buying coffee out, then they find a way to earn that money from somewhere.

Same with people talking about going to the cinema as if it were a human right. It is a very expensive night to go to the cinema - when they were little we used to go to kids club on a Sat morning sometimes, or they look for deals (2for1 Meerkats or Cheap nights on Tuesdays etc) if there is a film they particularly want to see, or make 'movie night at home' seem more attractive in an age appropriate way.

Fill up their time with affordable things (Sports, Scouts, Cadets, etc) and they won't have hours time they need to fill with expensive things.

Driving lessons are £35 where I live. There is no way my dd could pay for those at the necessary couple of hours a week on her minimum wage job in a chip shop on a Saturday while she's doing her A levels or whilst she's at university.

... and yet thousands of young people do decide to put the money they earn towards driving lessons. Ours all asked on their 'birthday/Christmas wish list' if people would give them a tenner rather than a present, which started them off, and they earned the rest. They worked full weeks in the holidays when there was no studying (after exams, obvs, not Easter) and were all perfectly able to pay for lessons, test, licence etc.

AryaStarkWolf · 01/06/2022 11:44

They're always expensive, for me I think teenage years/young adult are most expensive (clothes, hobbies, socialising, expensive school trips, trying to get them driving, Uni fees etc) and luckily I didn't have expensive childcare cost when they were younger, we had a lot of help from my mother and were able to be flexible with our working hours

SynchOrSwim · 01/06/2022 11:40

letsnotdothat · 01/06/2022 09:44

My eldest is 12 and I can confirm they are cheapest when they’re babies and toddlers. Once they’re in secondary school they cost an awful lot. My DS has been in adult sized shoes for a few years now so that costs a lot, clothing also increases the bigger they get. On top of that secondary school uniform and school trips are extortionate. His dinner money is also at least £15 a week plus his bus fare home every day. Then there’s his phone contract every month which isn’t optional because his bus pass is on there and there has been a few occasions where he’s needed to contact us. Trips out get more expensive because they just aren’t as impressed by free or inexpensive places anymore. Their birthday and Christmas presents get pricier too because they start to ask for expensive technology or clothes.

My youngest DC are 1 and 3, they are much much cheaper in comparison. Cheap clothes, free entry to a lot of places, happy with cheaper things as presents or trips out. They just are much cheaper at this age naturally. Primary school uniform costs virtually nothing as well in comparison to secondary.

And your nursery fees? How much are they?

JustLyra · 01/06/2022 11:27

One of the biggest costs of having teens will also entirely depend on how sensible and realistic, or otherwise, the school your DC attends are with regard to uniform.

The school my DD attends has a HT who has taken the chance to reform the uniform during the pandemic. It’s currently a very sensible, can be bought anywhere, uniform. The other school locally still insists on £80 blazer, £35 trousers or skirt (in a ‘unique’ shade of grey) and £25 a time shit quality jumpers and cardigans. As well as logo-Ed shirts, PE kit, bag and jackets. It’s extortionate over the course of their schooling.

Hugasauras · 01/06/2022 11:08

Surely the only thing this thread proves is that it's entirely based on a huge amount of variables? So there's no 'right' answer, really.

bumpytrumpy · 01/06/2022 11:05

RedGazelle · 01/06/2022 07:55

To counteract some of the points about teenagers.

Ours are not allowed to just eat the dinner food as a snack, or the packaged lunchbox type snacks. We buy a lot of bread, porridge oats, apples and eggs. Also own brand biscuits. These are snacks. They would never dream of eating their way through a pan of bolognese and would wait to check with me before serving themselves dinner.

They get an allowance that they have to use for trips out with friends etc, they also buy birthday presents for friends out of it but these are increasingly rare and usually only token gifts. This is not a particularly generous allowance, they get an extra £5 ‘holiday money’ in school holidays (£10 in summer holiday). They can also earn more by doing jobs around the house. Occasionally we’ll give them a little bit extra to do something specific with friends but this is only 3/4 times a year maximum not a monthly occurrence.

We have sim only contracts on a family plan that cost £35 in total for all 5 phones: The main phone is £15/month and extras 5/month. We set an amount (think it was £150 last time) that we’re prepared to pay for a phone and they have to pay any above that. DS asked for money for his birthday so he could put that towards one. We don’t upgrade phones every year or two.

Clubs are expensive yes, but boots, kits etc can often be bought unworn or barely worn second hand. I don’t think I’ve ever bought my son brand new football boots but he’s often had ones that have never been worn and the ones that have have been worn so little you can barely tell.

For clothes I buy the clothes they need, extras they buy themselves. My son likes branded everything but luckily he doesn’t mind if it comes from sports direct rather than JD. I also get a lot from vinted and ebay again either brand new or barely worn. My son doesn’t mind because he understands that that way he gets more for the money I’m prepared to spend. He wanted a north face coat, I said ok I’d spend up to £40 on a coat so he looked on vinted and found the exact one he wanted for £35 and bargained with me to get to keep the extra £5. If he’d insisted on it new he’d have had to save up to pay the difference. My daughter is more into the process of shopping than the actual clothes so I can’t really buy second hand for her now but again I give her limits and she has to pay the difference.

They haven’t had any school trips since before covid, they weren’t huge money though. Duke of Edinburgh was expensive (but optional).

Holidays and days out are expensive, we don’t do them often and mostly go camping now (one teen still comes, the other doesn’t).

They definitely cost more than my primary aged child but I don’t recognise some of the figures quoted on here.

£10 extra to cover the 6 week summer holidays?

What do they buy for that? It barely covers bus fare to town & a costa. What do they do for the other 5 weeks and 6.5 days?

Quincythequince · 01/06/2022 10:55

Hardbackwriter · 01/06/2022 10:22

You can do anything on the cheap if you like. We can all not have extra activities, eat nothing but value food and wear cheap clothes, but that’s not really how it works is it.

Well no, you can't do childcare on the cheap, really - there are more or less expensive options but if you want full-time childcare for a two year old where I live it'll cost at least £900, and that's for the cheapest childminder. Most childcare would cost £1k or more. Of course I believe that I'll spend more on food, activities and clothes for teenagers than I currently do on those things for my young children but I don't believe that I'm going to spend more on food, activities and clothes for a teenager than that £12k a year on childcare, I just don't.

I was referring to the activities that it costs parents of teens which everybody says is optional, not childcare costs themselves.

But thanks for your, explanation. I have a DSD and 3DS and am a professional working mother and have been there and some that. Am fully aware of rhe types and costs associated with each.

And you don’t have to believe it - of course not.

We’re all just fibbing here - just for fun 🙄

WildCoasts · 01/06/2022 10:25

Hardbackwriter · 01/06/2022 10:22

You can do anything on the cheap if you like. We can all not have extra activities, eat nothing but value food and wear cheap clothes, but that’s not really how it works is it.

Well no, you can't do childcare on the cheap, really - there are more or less expensive options but if you want full-time childcare for a two year old where I live it'll cost at least £900, and that's for the cheapest childminder. Most childcare would cost £1k or more. Of course I believe that I'll spend more on food, activities and clothes for teenagers than I currently do on those things for my young children but I don't believe that I'm going to spend more on food, activities and clothes for a teenager than that £12k a year on childcare, I just don't.

What if your preteen is discovered to have a super talent for something and wants to make it an occupation? Not something they can put off, but something that must be built on from that age? I'm thinking of one example which is about 20k at least in special training fees, per year.