Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In a difficult position - upsetting

289 replies

chippys · 31/05/2022 12:30

I've had to change a few details or this would be outing.

I was with my ex for 6 years and we both have daughters the same age (pre teens). We didn't live together. During those 6 years his DD was diagnosed with a very serious illness. After a whole year of treatment she was given the all clear.

At the end of last year my ex broke up with me out of the blue with no explanation or reason, was rather mean to my DD on his way out the door and I didn't hear from again. Until this week. I received a text to say that his DD had had her usual 6 month scan and the illness had returned, with the outcome this time being that she's not likely to get better, even with treatment. Of course, I'm devastated.

My ex said that the last few weeks his DD had been asking to see my DD (this was before the scan results) and would I be ok to meet up with them for a play date.

This is where I'm stuck. I know my DD would love to see his DD again, however, the way he left us with no explanation, and the way he spoke to me and my DD at the end was awful. I had to console my DD for months when he left as they were very close.

It seems that he wanted to arrange a play date even before he found out the terrible news. I would have said no then, but now I feel like if that's what his DD wants then I should of course say yes. I genuinely don't know what to do.

OP posts:
Beseen22 · 31/05/2022 15:45

I think I would probably seek some advice from a professional to be honest.

They were referred to as step sisters for a period of time, you describe them as close and your DD was there for her through her treatment. I think the initial reaction for every parent is to protect our child from all hurt and would absolutely be to just keep it from her. If you read all the advice from macmillan/Winstone wish/sue Ryder this is every parents initial reaction. Obviously over the shorter term this shields them from the pain but over the longer term this can cause more damage.

All advice seems to be to be honest and simple in explanations, at 9 they have an understanding of the concept of death. Children are very well in tune with their parents and she may already have picked up that you are a bit stressed/sad about a terminal diagnosis for a child you were at one point close to. When they pick up that parents are stressed they can begin to imagine what might be wrong and become anxious.

You just have to glance at the stately homes thread to see what affect decisions our parents made in childhood/teenage years have on our mental health for years to come. What happens if she stumbles across a photo of her and the other girl when she's 16 and finds out the full story and that you didn't allow her the choice to say goodbye?

When I did placements in hospice we often had kids visiting and i personally feel it is a positive thing and allows them to see a deterioration and its not such a sudden shock but I'm aware that's a very controversial opinion. I would consider having a chat with someone at school who has training with potentially traumatic situations to try and find out the best way to support her.

Walkingalot · 31/05/2022 15:43

I'm also suspicious of the timing. I think he misses the support you and your daughter gave and is looking to establish that again. It would be a no from me. I wouldn't, as others have suggested, have the girl round yours with no contact from him. How would that work when she gets sicker? Your DD isn't old enough to handle this herself.

Hallyup89 · 31/05/2022 15:42

If you only broke up at the end of last year then you're only talking 6 months ago. Your daughter and your ex's daughter were 'sisters' for half their lives before that. Surely it'll be upsetting for your daughter regardless of whether you let them see each other again.

I'd say yes, but on the basis that you have the girls at your house by yourself. Your ex might be an idiot, but give the kids a break.

chippys · 31/05/2022 15:42

@Floralnomad They went through a hell of a lot together and your only concern is that I've called her a step sister when they didn't live together?!

OP posts:
Testina · 31/05/2022 15:40

@ddl1 “but I would rather risk being manipulated in this way than risk refusing a child one of her dying wishes.”

I don’t think it helps to phrase it emotively in terms of “dying wishes”.

If the father is telling the truth, she asked for a play date before the scan. So not a dying wish at all.

Testina · 31/05/2022 15:37

Beatrixpotterspencil · 31/05/2022 15:10

If it was me, I think I would allow the girls to meet and have literally nothing to do with this man outside of that one single issue.

This is entirely do-able, but only if you trust your own resolve not to fall for his bullshit or if you still harbour feelings for him. This here is the real problem - he can only have a negative impact on you if you let him. You are in control here.

I also appreciate how seeing him again may cause your DD some distressing memories. I would honestly ask her if she wanted to or not, with no pressure, and an open mind. Then do whatever DD wants and keep this man at a very, very full arms length. Don't allow him any way in.

I don’t see how it’s possible to guard against this man’s potential future behaviour having an impact though.

Sure, if OP says she’ll host play dates only without him.

What does she say to her 9yo when she says, “but why can’t we all 4 go to Alton Towers together?” (or the girls with him)

And say OP is strong through that and explains why not (good luck with phrasing that in a way that doesn’t make a 9yo feel awkward and dragged into adult issues).

What then is the 9yo becomes close to the other girl again, and dad decides to end the relationship between them (non cynical version: because he can’t cope with a same age girl who is healthy or cynical version: because OP doesn’t want to be his emotional support or even girlfriend again) and cuts off the play dates.

Yes sweetie, I know Amelia is dying and you want to be with her, and she’s become your bestie, but her dad says no.

That’s not about boundaries. OP’s boundaries can’t control this man’s potential behaviour.

whumpthereitis · 31/05/2022 15:35

Difficult, but I wouldn’t. Your daughter was deeply hurt and it took her time to get her equilibrium back. By reintroducing her you run the risk of destabilizing her again imo, as she’ll be in the position of having to watch as she loses her friend to illness.

FuchsAndMöhr · 31/05/2022 15:31

5128gap · 31/05/2022 14:35

Of course. But OPs DD wants to see the other child and if the child dies and DD hasn't been allowed to see her that's potentially very harmful too. Are you suggesting that terminally ill children should all be made to end their days without seeing their friends, so their friends can be shielded from the fact of illness and death?

Absolutely not but the OP’s daughter doesn’t even know the illness has returned let alone said she wants to see her.

This is absolutely not about the child but the ex!

RobertaFirmino · 31/05/2022 15:31

It really isn't on for a 12 yo to have all this responsibility dumped on them. It might seem like 'just a play date' but the reality is that your DD would be forced to relive many negative feelings. A dying persons happiness cannot be dependent on a pre-teen.

ddl1 · 31/05/2022 15:28

I am sorry to hear all this.

I do wonder if he is exaggerating the situation to blackmail you - but I would rather risk being manipulated in this way than risk refusing a child one of her dying wishes.

And in particular I think it is wrong to deny a sick child the company of friends because they might find it hard to cope if the child died. That would be adding isolation to the sick girl's pain; and might result in your own child feeling even more distressed in the long run.

That being said, don't let him use this to get you back. Let the children meet with as little contact with him as possible. If you can make the contacts through the girl's mother, even it feels a bit socially awkward, that would be much better than the alternative.

Testina · 31/05/2022 15:28

@PrisonerofZeroCovid the girls are only 9.

My daughter’s BFF (complete with many sleepovers) from Y5 is now someone she hasn’t spoken to from Y6-Y8. Sometimes they do actually move on quickly from friendships created by convenience based on familiarity rather than true friendship. Not always, but I think it’s worth keeping in mind that just because they spent a lot of time together, doesn’t mean they have that deep a relationship.

youlightupmyday · 31/05/2022 15:27

My daughter of a similar age would want to help her friend and has a small part in the decision process. However I would not agree with his involvement.. Only through her mother or not at all. He does not deserve more.

I also assume that you cared for her too, so this is hard on you as well. I would go by the mantra as do unto others etc.

Good luck and a quick non MN hug

MarvellousMay · 31/05/2022 15:27

I would say no.

honeybeetheoneandonly · 31/05/2022 15:27

I would block him on everything and not tell DD about the diagnosis either.
If you do want to reply you can say your peace.
"Hi Alan, I'm sorry to hear about Chelsea. That's really awful news.
It does not change the fact that you walked out on us without an explanation. You clearly didn't care about us or the aftermath you caused. It took DD and me a long time to move on. I will not be opening that door again."

FlowerDee · 31/05/2022 15:26

“I’m so sorry to hear that x is unwell again. Wishing all the very best for her treatment. On balance, I don’t think that it’s a good idea to reopen old wounds and reconnect the two of them. Take care.”

Floralnomad · 31/05/2022 15:25

Stop calling this child your child’s ex step sister , according to your OP you didn’t live together so at best she was your boyfriends daughter , yes they may have been great friends but they were not family . Your daughter is 9 don’t make this an issue for her .

GenderAtheist · 31/05/2022 15:25

Testina · 31/05/2022 13:14

Although I’m in the no camp, you could reply, “<sympathetic part of message> given our history I don’t want to resume contact with you. Let me have <mum> number, and I’ll think about contacting her directly.”

If he’s contacted you purely because he wants his daughter to see her friend, no selfish motivation, he’ll give you the number.

If you read that thinking - no he won’t - then you have your answer about his motivation.

I’d do this - contact the mum first.

Thne once I had more information I would talk it all through with my DD. I’d be honest with her about the diagnosis and realistic about what the end might be like for the other child.

id explain there’s no easy choice here for you DD.

  1. she says no to any contact and she feels guilty when the other girls dies
  2. she tries limited contact, finds she’s doesn’t like it / can’t cope and stops. Then as above.
  3. she get completely involved, supports the girl to the end and has to deal with her own grief and loss. And the the family might cut her out at the end ( that often happens to childrens friends ).
  4. you don’t tell her and she’s furious at you when she finds out.
i think a play date as a first option is WAY too much. It should start with texts o and then phone / zoom calls so both girls can see how it goes.

Whatever happens, I’d trying to go via mum if possible and minimise contact with dad.

BTW I’ve been in both situations - having a terminally ill child and then years later a child’s friend being critically ill.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 31/05/2022 15:24

Apologies- I thought you meant pre-teens when they met. I now see that she's 9. In that case, no, I wouldn't permit the rekindling on any basis.

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 31/05/2022 15:21

Honestly, this could be out of a Jodi picquet novel in terms of being a total no win situation fraught with emotional trauma. In a way I can see why the relationship faltered- hard to live with someone who has a daughter the same age as yours who has a LL illness and not wish the situation was reversed and then hate yourself for thinking that. Doesn't forgive his behaviour at the end, and I'm not sure how this can end well. However, presumably the girls are now in their teens and capable of having an independent relationship. I'd ask DD if she'd like the other girl's number and leave it at that, having made is abundantly clear to the father that he's not to be involved in this friendship at all.

TheOrigRights · 31/05/2022 15:19

I have only read OP's posts and based on those, no I would not agree to the playdate.
I would be sceptical that his DD asked for this playdate prior to her (very sad) diagnosis, rather that your ex's situation is not ideal and it would suit him nicely to get back together, or at least in contact, using the girls (in particular his DD) as pawns. That puts him in a very bad light, but from what you've said he didn't consider the feelings of your DD (a child close to his own DD) at all.
That doesn't set a good precedent.

Meraas · 31/05/2022 15:17

He's a user. Don't let him to your lives again. Your dd matters too.

Crumbleburntbits · 31/05/2022 15:17

This man is the reason the block and delete options exist on social media and mobile phones. He’s shown you that he’s capable of being cruel and unpleasant to your child. It’s sad about his daughter but she isn’t part of your life any more. He told you he wanted no more contact so it’s ok to ignore his message and block him.

DPotter · 31/05/2022 15:14

This is a tricky situation to be sure.

Whatever you decide about the playdate, I think you need to explain to your DD that his DD is unwell. I've seen the fallout of a situation where the death of a friend wasn't shared with a child and that child found out - 6 degrees of separation is a real thing. Children can be very matter of fact about illness and death - if they are prepared for such. There are charities which offer support to siblings in just this situation, eg www.lullabytrust.org.uk/bereavement-support/supporting-brothers-and-sisters/. Might be worth checking out their suggestions.

The only think i would suggest about the playdate - contact her mother to say you have heard the DD is unwell again and would she like meet. Even if you don't know her very well, she will know the girls have spent a lot of time together.

billy1966 · 31/05/2022 15:14

OP,

Also, 5 months after his child had been through such a rough year, a year that both you and your daughter were a kind strength, he brutally cut HIS daughter off from this source of support, that had been through so much with her, who understood what she had gone through?
.

Honestly, who would do that to their child?

It is unbelievable that a parent would do that to their own child.

He put himself so far ahead of what was best for his own child.....not to mind his deliberate unkindness in having a break up conversation in front of a child.

He sounds so self absorbed.

Beatrixpotterspencil · 31/05/2022 15:10

If it was me, I think I would allow the girls to meet and have literally nothing to do with this man outside of that one single issue.

This is entirely do-able, but only if you trust your own resolve not to fall for his bullshit or if you still harbour feelings for him. This here is the real problem - he can only have a negative impact on you if you let him. You are in control here.

I also appreciate how seeing him again may cause your DD some distressing memories. I would honestly ask her if she wanted to or not, with no pressure, and an open mind. Then do whatever DD wants and keep this man at a very, very full arms length. Don't allow him any way in.