Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to confront an old school bully?

90 replies

Lifegavemelemonade · 31/05/2022 11:57

Back in secondary school I had a very close friendship group. I went to an all girl school and it started off as just me and Sussy being best friends. Then Jane joined our group and finally another girl joined who came down from Japan mid Yr. I became good friends with her and eventually brought her into this friendship group, let's call her Vic. So me and Vic got very close and I suspect Susy, my original friend got jealous. She got very close with Jane and Vic eventually left the country at the end of the year.

The remaining school years then consisted of Susy and Jane sticking together, pairing up for everything and consistently pushing me out. It was a weird sort of passive aggressive silent hatred towards me as they never outwardly treated me differently but would always go out together and never invite me or talk about things and leave me out but we still all stuck close together in school.

If didn't stop there. Although Vic left the country I remained in touch with her and realised she started to become off with me. When I asked her why she said it was because I was talking bad about Susy and Jane to her (I was expressing how I felt pushed aside) and that they had said I was talking bad about Vic to them which couldn't of been further from the truth. At the time Vic felt like my true and only friend but unfortunately I lost her as she said she felt she had to chose and she chose Susy and jane.

So here is the thing, I left that school and that was that. However Jane has stayed in touch with a lot of people from our school and I stayed in touch with the same people (mutual friends). I'm now 24 and they have all asked to meet up. Originally I said yes and was delighted but now I've started thinking about the past and how things played it, how miserable and alone I was made to feel. I ended up making a different best friend after a while which really got to them both but I will never forget the feeling of how unfair it all was.

Since Jane will presumably be there do I finally confront her? I know it was in the past but I never had the courage to stand up for myself back then and I feel like I owe it to myself to find out exactly why things happened like that. Its not that I want an apology as I feel too much time has passed for that but an explanation would be nice? Or do I let it go and accept the fact that it's been so many years these things happen and she could potentionally be a different person now. I don't know how I will feel when I see her. I honestly thought when I left I would never have to see Jane or Susy again and they was part of the reason why I left my secondary school when so many people stayed on in sixth form.

Yabu - do not confront her
Yanbu - confront her

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 31/05/2022 15:50

I also suspect they’ll recall events differently. It’s quite possible that Susy sees it that you dumped her for Vic, but suddenly you wanted back in and demanded to be accommodated because Vic left. The fact that Vic eventually said ‘enough’ and pulled away from you is quite telling imo.

CoralBells · 31/05/2022 15:48

It's good that you made a new friend after a while. Maybe Vic spoke to Sussy and Jane after she'd moved and told them what you'd been saying about them and Sussy and Jane decided to get revenge by lying that you'd been criticising Vic when you hadn't?

whumpthereitis · 31/05/2022 15:43

Even if it was bullying, I’m not sure how confrontation will help you. I highly doubt you’ll get anything in terms of acknowledgment or apology tbh, they’re more likely to tell you to fuck off again. How would that make you feel?

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 31/05/2022 15:40

So you were best friends with Sussy. Jane joined the group. Vic came along and you became best friends with Vic whilst Sussy and Jane became best friends. Vic left, so you joined Sussy and Jane. Sussy and Jane were best friends and you were on the outside. You bitched to Vic about the situation and Vic got pissed off with you. I understand you feel hurt but everything sounds very tit for tat, and is no way bullying. At the time it would have been a huge deal but you were 15 / 16. You are 24 now, and have to realise how childish this all looks. Just go along, enjoy your night and reestablish old friendships.

AngelinaFangelina · 31/05/2022 15:35

I can guarantee you won't get the reaction you want from "confronting" them. They will either be confused, brush you off , completely deny anything happened and think you are a bit bonkers or have a different recollection of how things happened. It's unlikely anything that happened has stuck in their brains as much as it has in yours.
Just go and enjoy yourself with other people. Or don't go (nothing could drag me to a school reunion and I actually had a good time at school). Life is too short to get stuck on shit like that, it was petty typical teenage nonsense that's happened since the time schools opened.

lanthanum · 31/05/2022 15:22

Move on from it.

You perhaps focussed too much on your friendship with Vic, Susy and Jane therefore paired off and became closer. Then you wanted to rejoin because Vic had gone, but threes are very often awkward, and they were quite happy continuing as a twosome. You kept moaning about them to Vic, which was awkward for her. It's not clear what they told Vic you said, so maybe there was something unfair they did there, but it may be that Vic wanted to distance herself because of you moaning about them as much as anything. Having moved so far away, she was probably forming new friendships there and so wasn't as invested in her friendship with you.

wanderingscot · 31/05/2022 14:35

Really, most folk has some sort of dramas at secondary school, have put it past them and grown up since, so they don't take that kind of pointless angst into their adult lives. School is all about the pecking order - and it's a very artificial situation. Just put it behind you and forget about. It's so insignificant in the grand scheme of things

CulturePigeon · 31/05/2022 14:28

OP, I think i get it. The things which happened were probably 'under the radar' to outsiders - a common girl-bullying technique, with the annoying problem that others just don't see it and will minimise it. But yes, I would say anything which involves emotional manipulation and the positive enjoyment of someone else's misery or isolation is actually bullying.

My advice would be: think hard about whether you want to go to this event and if you think it might make things worse, don't do it. If you do go, breeze in with a smile and if you are put in the position of having to greet these women first, then just smile, say 'Hi, how are you?' and move on fast. Focus on other people and be too busy to worry about them. If they approach you, stay reserved but smile politely - there's no need to be warm and enthusiastic! Keep your encounter brief.

I wouldn't suggest any kind of confrontation - you will end up being the one in the wrong. Show them you've moved on, even if you haven't. As a PP said, the best revenge is living well. Good luck with whatever you decide to do.

Johnnysgirl · 31/05/2022 14:18

Lifegavemelemonade · 31/05/2022 12:10

@Aprilx Also they did things to deliberately leave me out. One prime example was that they kept pairing up for things so when I brought it to their attention they both promised the next paired assignment I could be with one of them. It came around and they both joined up behind my back and smirked at me about it. I remember being in the middle of class and beginning to cry, but then my (soon to be new best fiend) at the time came up to me and asked if i wanted to pair with her. She saved me out of that humiliation

But if there were three of you there was always going to be one left out in a pairing off situation?
You don't seem to grasp that they were probably just better friends with each other than either were with you.
It's not bullying in any sense.

AskingforaBaskin · 31/05/2022 14:14

And if they laugh?
Or come back with some things you did?

Don't put yourself in the firing line. It won't end well.

Either stay away or just get over it.

ladydimitrescu · 31/05/2022 14:13

You'll gain nothing from it.
"You left me out in high school", will if anything, make you look really silly. They were entitled to pair up. You got close to the other girl, it's not their fault she moved away and you then wanted to back in your old group. They moved on. It's not bullying. You were speaking to your other friend about these two purposely leaving you out, true or not is talking about them behind their back, in a negative manner.

It's all bitchy teenage girl rubbish.
I really think If it's still bothering you so much, it would be beneficial to speak to someone - but not Jane.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 31/05/2022 14:12

They don’t sound like they were good friends to you. It’s good that you made a new friend and moved on. Friendships fade and girls can be bitches when that happens.

they clearly upset you at the time, but as far as real bullying goes this is quite minor. I don’t want to minimise your experience. It was clearly not very nice for you at the time. But I do think the way it’s still affecting you is out of proportion, you need to just let it go.

go to the reunion if you want, don’t go if you don’t want. But I wouldn’t confront these girls. Yes they weren’t nice. But teenage girls can be like that. I’m sure they’ve grown into perfectly nice human beings now and if they haven’t you never have to see them again.

but it’s not as if they were ambushing you every day after school to beat the crap out of you or constantly humiliating you on a daily basis in front of the whole class as some bullies do. They were just bitchy girls. Let it go.

RoseGoldEagle · 31/05/2022 14:12

It sounds like they were horrible to you OP, doesn’t really matter that it’s ‘normal bitchy teenage behaviour’ it’s still crap. Friendship groups drifting apart is one thing but this sounds more than that from what you’ve said.

They may have turned into lovely adults who feel a bit bad about it, they may barely remember it, they may not be very nice people, who knows. I wouldn’t be going along to the reunion hoping for an explanation- there’s unlikely to be one, other than simply some people like the power trip of leaving other people out.

Go if you want to reconnect with other people. I’d just be prepared to remain civil with Jane and Susy, friendly enough like you might be to a stranger, but disengage from talking to them as soon as you can. If a big part of you going is hoping some kind of explanation/apology will be forthcoming- I’d stay at home.

Marvellousmadness · 31/05/2022 14:10

Why bother
Its in the past

SlashBeef · 31/05/2022 14:07

It wasn't bullying. You undermine the horror of actual bullying by saying this. I definitely wouldn't confront anyone. I don't think you would gain anything from it.

riesenrad · 31/05/2022 14:03

I don't appreciate everyone undermining and invalidating my feelings here. This was more and went way beyond just a simple friendship dying out

OP if you feel like that there is nothing to be gained by seeing them. Having a go at them will upset you more than them. Find new friends, move on and make a success of your life - that is the best revenge.

Suzysuz · 31/05/2022 14:00

You said:

Before this they never crossed my mind as they really aren't relevant to my life anymore. I have a lovely dc now and my life has progressed alot more since then

So I would say don't go and process whatever you need to draw another line under it, you won't get any 'resolution' out of this and it may be that they have a different recollection of the past, no good can come out of it, so just leave it where it already was, a part of the past.

Kris02 · 31/05/2022 13:49

Why bother going? Nothing on earth could persuade me to attend a school reunion. I was relatively lucky with bullying, in that I pretty much escaped until I was 13. Even then it wasn't too bad (just low level nastiness - a nickname that stuck, occasionally being tripped up, etc). Still, it was enough to ruin my final three years.

A few years ago, I bumped into someone I'd known at school. She'd joined in a bit - gleefully repeating the nickname, and so on. But she greeted me like a dear old pal and suggested meeting for a drink. And it wasn't an act. She genuinely had no memory of what she'd done. I don't like arguments and confrontation, so I just nodded and said 'sure', all the time thinking "the minute this conversation ends, I'm going to avoid you for the rest of my life."

If I was you I'd cut them loose. Make some new friends - people who don't bring back bad memories. Personally, I'd be quite happy to never see a single person from school ever again.

Sittingonabench · 31/05/2022 13:43

The problem with these types of situations is that you are both viewing it from a child’s perspective and both of you may not have been aware of the consequences of your actions and the impact on others. For example by making a new friend and bringing her into the group (which is a nice thing to do) you changed the dynamic from a 3 to a 4. Pairings are easy in a 4, and likely you would pair with your friend. When it went back to a 3 you expected room to be created for you however it may be your friends we’re feeling hurt by what they saw as you leaving them for someone else and so didn’t want to make that room for you and felt you were feeling what they had felt. As an adult these things seem so trivial but you are holding onto the feelings you had as a child which can still hurt. By bringing it up you will both go back to a child’s mentality and not get anywhere. The best thing to do is go and have adult relationships with those there- that might include her or it might not but wanting an explanation for her behaviour will lead to a you did this you did that type of conversation which I suspect will upset you and will cause unneeded drama which is disrespectful to those organising the party.

Spanglemum · 31/05/2022 12:40

If you still live in the same area the only reason I would go is to see about making new connections with other people going. If they are SAHM as well with kids your age etc. I would be polite but distant with your old friends. You were treated badly. Being excluded on purpose is bullying.

GentlemanJay · 31/05/2022 12:38

Lifegavemelemonade · 31/05/2022 12:15

I don't appreciate everyone undermining and invalidating my feelings here. This was more and went way beyond just a simple friendship dying out. They did things to make me upset and made sure I remained left out. They went out of their way to do this. That was vindictive on their behalf. I have moved past it but I don't know if finally facing one of these girls means I should stand up for the 15 year old me and get my deserved reason or just smile sweetly and be friendly towards her even though she doesn't really deserve it.

Kids do horrible things. No violence was used. If you are not sure then don't go.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 31/05/2022 12:38

Op you still sound very hurt by their behaviour. I'm sorry but i agree with others that this isn't so much bullying more just teen difficulties, growing up and navigating friendships. 3 is a very difficult number as there is always 1 person 'left out'. High school can be brutal and as you're 24 it's still fairly recent.

In your situation i don't think i would bring this up but if you feel it would help you could. Just be prepared for their recollection of events to be different from yours and you may feel worse. At best they may say sorry and put it down to teens can be horrid but i don't think this would satisfy you as you have already said your feeling are bring minimised here.

If you try to rise above it and enjoy yourself, as you say your life has moved on and you're happy 😊

Thelnebriati · 31/05/2022 12:36

I agree with you about their behaviour and you've had some odd replies.
But I don't think you will gain anything by confronting them, and you will most likely end up feeling worse. Either don't go, or go and be happy.

ShirleyPhallus · 31/05/2022 12:35

I think this is pretty typical bitchy teen behaviour. I found that some of my “best” friends and I were awful to one another around that age.

That said, I have absolutely no desire to reconnect with my former school friends as my life has moved on so much then and I really have any sense of wanting to see them or missing them etc.

So do what you want - go if you’re comfortable but I really wouldn’t be pulling them up on what happened years ago, I suspect their recollection of events will be much different to yours with blame at your door and you’ll feel worse for it

Lifegavemelemonade · 31/05/2022 12:31

I think singling someone out and making sure they remain alone but pretending to still be their friend is manipulative. Maybe its bullying maybe its not but its mean regardless. I don't understand this behaviour.

But I get the general gist is just to go and enjoy the night and so I will. For what it's worth I don't actually hold her to it. But I did want to ask her about why these things happened and not pretend that it didn't. But it what's ever I think I will just go for the right people and if Jane is there I will give her a chance to see if she is a different person now or not. I'm not wasting to much energy on this as it really isn't that important to me I just wanted some insight as to how others would navigate this type of situation

OP posts: