Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To now be terrified of losing my job on top of everything else (Civil Service Cuts)

29 replies

Themidnightpig · 31/05/2022 11:45

Like many families we are feeling the pinch of the cost of living crisis. Our fuel and food prices have gone insane and I'm currently only getting maternity pay.

I'm just returning to work from mat leave amid all the news about the cuts of 90,000 civil servants and now I'm feeling utterly terrified that I will be one of them.

AIBU to think this is a terribly irresponsible thing for the government to be doing when we are at the beginning of what's promised to be one of the worst economic crises ever? I feel sick frankly.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Themidnightpig · 31/05/2022 19:26

BigChesterDraws · 31/05/2022 17:53

I understand your worries but, in the nicest possible way, those of us in the private sector live under this possibility all the time. Any company could go bust, be sold, relocate and there is nothing the employees can do about it. I’ve always worked in the private sector. I’ve been made redundant 4 times in my working life so far. And I’ve survived.

Yes agreed, have worked in private myself and survived two rounds of reduncies but although it was an uncertain time I didnt feel as anxious as I do now.

I suppose its partially having a family yo support now and partially the scale - in private it was only a handful of people being let go so they found new jobs easily enough. The numbers seem huge!

OP posts:
caringcarer · 31/05/2022 19:12

In the Civil Service they will be having a recruitment freeze so as people retire they won't hire replacement. A few will no doubt be begging for early retirement as CD has a very very generous package and some temp will go on fixed term contracts and any others will sit in redeployment pool and be moved into other jobs. If you have a permanent job you will be fine. As usual the ones sat in jobs with great skills will be allowed to go then they can't recruit replacement then once hiring resumes they will have to pay a lot to attract suitably qualified people in.

Tomikka · 31/05/2022 17:57

You’d have thought so ….. but ‘Defence’ covers the 3 commands of Air, Army & Navy, the joint Strategic Command, nuclear, support agencies such as DE&S. (And we also had a space command long before Trump made his own Space Force - or rejiggered and change the badges of USAF space command)
They all consist of regular & reserves, civil service, short term consultants, contractors , sub contractors and more

The target revolves :
1)big army/navy/Air Force is too expensive (at least the Army was in the middle of this recently)
so take routine UK tasks from the regulars and get civilians to do it.
2)Theres far too many of those pesky Whitehall civil servants (let’s cut them by 90,000)
3)But we still want the work doing so contractorise them
4)How much does it cost to call out a contractor at midnight ? Shocking, let’s use a soldier because they are paid 24 hours a day ….
and repeat

Currently MoD Army are in both 1 & 2 right now

Redundancy / VERS didn’t go too well - it cost money to get rid of people and was followed by recruiting people

Its not certain what routes will be taken, with talk about natural wastage, not extending fixed term (they shouldn’t have been fixed term in the first place if the intent is to extend) not filling vacancies etc

Its not unreasonable to be worried, but those of us who have been around have seen it all before

I’m verging on the point of watching for VERS announcements. But that is still just a tweak of my retirement package
(Note that if VERS gets offered do look carefully and consider your departments prospects - you would think that compulsory redundancy pays more than voluntary …. Not necessarily so as the rules were changed allowing it to be lower on the basis that a ‘better’ voluntary deal has been offered)
If there are going to be any VERS or redundancy’s then watch for any proposals to change the rules

The VERS / redundancy terms that existed when I joined would be very attractive with 40 years service, but the rules were changed years ago prior to one of the VERS offers.

If I take a voluntary VERS then it’s now capped at 21 years, and compulsory is capped at 12 years

www.civilservicepensionscheme.org.uk/media/txmh0d2u/cscs-key-facts-and-q-and-a-document-october-2017.pdf

BigChesterDraws · 31/05/2022 17:53

I understand your worries but, in the nicest possible way, those of us in the private sector live under this possibility all the time. Any company could go bust, be sold, relocate and there is nothing the employees can do about it. I’ve always worked in the private sector. I’ve been made redundant 4 times in my working life so far. And I’ve survived.

adlitem · 31/05/2022 17:17

I'd imagine Defense is not an area that is of high risk of cuts at the moment....

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 31/05/2022 16:15

They announced this to throw read meat to their base. The truth is not a penny will be saved. Costs will go up. They’ll get rid of the 90,000 then those same people plus more will return to their departments as contractors or consultants earning two or three times as much as before.

This is because those jobs are required to get us through Brexit transition and the additional red tape and to prevent services truly falling over as we don’t have a proper functioning government. However, their headcount won’t be counted as they aren’t perm staff. It’s all bollocks.

Fernticket · 31/05/2022 16:15

@Themidnightpig . Snap! I'm MOD as well. I don't think we have grown as much as some of the other departments have in the past few years. I remember when they last had a VERS programme and they were overwhelmed! As other posters have said a lot of it will probably be natural wastage.

Countdown2023 · 31/05/2022 15:59

As an economy we need to boost the private sector. We have a huge public sector some of whom have very good t&cs compared to the private sector. As a nation we can’t afford to be ‘top-heavy’.

You should be okay coming back from maternity leave given the focus will be natural wastage and those in temp posts.

dottiedodah · 31/05/2022 15:57

This does seem very unfair. However many industries are doing similar.There are very few "safe " jobs out there ATM. If you were to be made redundant could you get redundancy ? If you have been in your job a while then you have built up good skills .These would be welcomed by a new employer .Hopefully your job will be safe ,but if not you should have a good chance of a new one

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 15:31

Thing is that there’s no such thing as a job for life any more.

The civil service has been one of those organisations where your job was likely more secure than others, but a lot of roles have been created to fill Brexit and COVID jobs so those will automatically go.

Plus recruitment freezes and the freezing of the fast track scheme.

And there’s an awful lot of dead wood in the civil service who will snap their hands off for redundancy. Rarely are there compulsory redundancies in the civil service, because people are clammering for voluntary.

Themidnightpig · 31/05/2022 15:24

Fernticket · 31/05/2022 13:49

As a fellow CS, I know how you feel. It's easy to say, but try not to worry too much,a lot of it will probably be done by natural wastage. What Department do you work in?

Defence. I initially read natural wastage too but that isn't the rumours going around.

OP posts:
Doubleraspberry · 31/05/2022 15:22

They won't need to do VER in most places. The civil service is huge so 20,000 people will leave or retire in the next few months regardless.

Doubleraspberry · 31/05/2022 15:21

You can actually 'save' jobs by designing a new function/team and then not recruiting to it. Top tip.

LakieLady · 31/05/2022 14:36

When these cuts were first announced, I read an article that said iro 70k staff had been appointed on temp contracts to work on Covid-related stuff, so the bulk of the jobs would go by simply not renewing those contracts. I strongly suspect that the other 20k will be voluntary redundancies.

Mind you, if they stick with the bonkers notion of going to the imperial system of measurement, they'll need loads of staff!

adlitem · 31/05/2022 14:34

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/05/2022 14:16

It’s very depressing.

I’m a civil servant, but not Westminster, I work for a government agency.

We worked all through out the pandemic without any option of furlough. Those with children had to home school whilst wfh as at least in the first lockdown there was no prospect of being classed as key workers.

Weve had a real terms pay cut over the course of many years.

Its so depressing and now we’re being told our jobs aren’t even secure.

Isn't this just the case with any job at the moment though? Certainly everything you say applies to my job too (private sector, profession). I don't think anyone feels safe at the moment.

OP, as PPs have said most will be through hiring freezes and potentialyl voluntary redundancy schemes - this is a far cheaper and less risky way to cut work force than actual redundancies. Also there's an awful lot of demand for employees and only a limited number of employees around with skills and experience (thanks to Brexit). While of course not ideal, it's not the worst time in history to be unemployed, even if things do go the wrong way for you. But I'd not worry too much unless your specific department is at high risk.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 31/05/2022 14:16

It’s very depressing.

I’m a civil servant, but not Westminster, I work for a government agency.

We worked all through out the pandemic without any option of furlough. Those with children had to home school whilst wfh as at least in the first lockdown there was no prospect of being classed as key workers.

Weve had a real terms pay cut over the course of many years.

Its so depressing and now we’re being told our jobs aren’t even secure.

Doubleraspberry · 31/05/2022 14:00

It’s absolute window dressing to please the tub thumping anti-public sector teeds. As others have said, the number will come from the end of Covid roles and natural wastage. There’ll be a recruitment freeze. And then we all get on with things.

GrandyPandy · 31/05/2022 13:56

LavenderfortheBees · 31/05/2022 12:06

The majority will be through hiring freezes and natural wastage. There may be some reorganisations with voluntary redundancy programmes. Involuntary redundancies will be unlikely as older and more experienced staff will take the good packages and go elsewhere, leaving the departments with massive skills gaps. Later, they will realise this and go on a mass hiring programme.

Twas ever thus.

Indeed.
OP have you not worked in CS for very long? These things come round every few years.

Fernticket · 31/05/2022 13:49

As a fellow CS, I know how you feel. It's easy to say, but try not to worry too much,a lot of it will probably be done by natural wastage. What Department do you work in?

AnnaSW1 · 31/05/2022 13:13

I'm a civil servant and it hasn't crossed my mind to be honest. As others have already said , it will be covered by natural wastage, accommodation changes etc.

MintJulia · 31/05/2022 13:02

OP, this month, for the first time since records began, there are more vacancies than there are unemployed people, so try not to worry too much.

If you have any transferable skills at all, you'll be snapped up. We have vacancies in admin, accounts and sales that we are struggling to fill.

Plus, if you are returning from mat. leave, you should be ok.

maxelly · 31/05/2022 12:56

The civil service has on the face of it grown massively since 2016 but this is in large part down to roles specifically created to manage Brexit and Covid - many, many of these were only ever temporary so will naturally fall away anyway, and you'd know if yours was one of those jobs. If you're in a stable department/job that existed pre 2016 and is still doing its thing, you're likely absolutely fine.

Even in departments which may need to make cost savings, if redundancies are needed at all (and likely they can simply reduce recruitment/freeze vacancies), it's pretty much universally true across the CS that because CS redundancies are so generous for long servers, departments will have their hands snapped off as soon as they open a scheme. It's always been my experience in the CS (in the complete reverse of how it is everywhere else lol!) that it's far more of a problem having to turn lots of people down who desperately want to be made redundant (usually because they're near retirement age and eligible for a lucrative early retirement option, but these are the skilled and experienced staff you really want to keep on) than it is having to compulsorily select someone who wants to stay in the job. So I wouldn't panic OP, even if you are tremendously unlucky and do end up in a role that goes you will definitely get plenty of notice of it, nothing happens quickly in the CS!

balalake · 31/05/2022 12:25

The ending of the fast track scheme this year at least for new entrants suggests that it will be by natural wastage. It won't be 90,000 job losses in any case, it is another 'dead cat' story designed to put off more coverage of the parties in Downing Street.

riotlady · 31/05/2022 12:23

As others have said I think they’ll make the numbers by freezing recruitment, end of short term contracts (there were loads of job coaches who had temp contracts during covid and didn’t get renewed- bet they count them in the numbers despite it being before the announcement!), people retiring etc etc. I strongly doubt they’ll be axing people on permanent contracts who don’t want to go.

Onprozacandmyhighhorse · 31/05/2022 12:16

If you were in a permanent role prior to going on Mat leave you should be alright.

Swipe left for the next trending thread