Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
becausetrampslikeus · 03/06/2022 08:54

I suspect that there comes a point in poverty whereby cooking from scratch becomes expensive

... when you don't have spare cash to buy bulk, buy extra to freeze when price is low, keep a stock of herbs and spices
... when you don't have much cash for actually heating the food
... when you live in a very poor area with no low cost supermarket in walking distance and can't run a car/ pay bus fare to go round a few stores for the best deals , the average coop or nisa is way more expensive than Aldi but it is all that sone have access to

However there are also people who don't have much but can at least manage to cook cheaply and healthy.

Poverty is not a competition

ThrallsWife · 03/06/2022 08:41

As a student 18 years ago I used to be able to live on £10 a week - and that included hygiene products. I did this through careful meal planning every week (my flat mates and I used to share a group bus fare once a week to shop together as the nearest supermarket was too far to walk) and cooking from scratch all the time.

When I started working this had to stretch to £20/w, but included feeding a baby/ toddler and a pack of nappies a week.

We ate very nutritiously and healthily and nothing was wasted. Friday evening was meal planning day so that Saturday's weekly shop was fully covered.

My menu would look something like this:
-cereal with milk (every morning) or homemade porridge from oats/ milk/ sugar
-sandwiches (using any leftover meat/ cheese on toast/ peanut butter) for lunch
-spaghetti bolognese (using peas/ peppers/ carrots/ onion to stretch the meat)
-chilli using leftover sauce from the day before
-pasta bake with mixed vegetables (see above - peas, carrots, peppers, tinned sweetcorn)
-omelette/ eggy bread
-toad in the hole/ bubble and squeak/ leftover curry with noodles/ leftover pizza (it's amazing what can be thrown onto a pizza base and taste delicious - we'd even have leftover chilli pizza)
-leftover stir fry

I'd drink water or tea with the occasional homemade hot chocolate of one of us had bought cocoa powder for baking. We baked about once a week on a rotation, so often had sweet treats as a snack - cheap and healthy, such as a fruit crumble topped with porridge oats to save on butter.

The two of us who could cook (ironically, both raised outside of Britain, so grew up in cultures where cooking from scratch was the norm) were financially way better off than the three who couldn't, so I make sure my kids know how to cook from a young age before they leave the nest.

Having said all that, fast food is insanely cheap over here. Where I grew up you'd pay double or triple of what a normal takeaway over here costs, save for some street food, which would be comparable to the prices I'd see for a delivery here.

40andlols · 03/06/2022 06:46

thanks @autienotnaughty I appreciate you doing that Smile

silentpool · 03/06/2022 05:01

In my situation (live alone, budget not unlimited) cooking from scratch is cheaper. I don't think it's as black and white as people are saying though. It's cheaper if you plan, nab bargains when you see them, buy in bulk and avoid convenience, single serve or branded foods. It requires work but over time becomes easy.

Build up a store cupboard, week by week and eventually you will be able to take advantage of specials etc rather than buying when you need it. Butter freezes very well for example. I buy flour and rice in 5kg sacks when on sale etc. I buy spices and dried beans, nuts etc from an Indian wholesaler. Jars and containers are easy to get at charity shops.

Stretch any meat meals - one small 1kg joint will feed me multiple times (slices of roast meat, then leftovers which become for example beef stroganoff, curry, toasted sandwiches etc). Meat should be treated almost as a condiment, for flavour.

I only buy cheap cuts, generally whole chickens, roasting joints and marinade them or put them in the Instant Pot to tenderise them, if required. I don't buy chicken breasts, steaks etc as they are more expensive on a per 100gm basis.

Visit the supermarket when they do yellow stickered markdowns - great for meat to freeze or vegetables/fruit, sacks of potatoes, herbs etc.

Make your own fast food. I make pasta sauce - 500gm mince gets stretched with 2 cans of tomatoes and chopped veg etc. I get 8 portions - 7 of which then go into the freezer for other meals - it's the base for lasagne, a quick pasta or gnocchi sauce etc. Pizza dough is a 5 min job and can be started before you leave for work.

No waste ever. Make stocks, compotes, puddings etc.

sashh · 03/06/2022 04:17

PerkyBlinder · 02/06/2022 11:31

YABU My eldest at uni eats really well on very little per week with really cheap spices and clever shopping at Aldi/Lidl. She cooks from scratch and she’s commented the reason she can eat way more cheaply than her house mates is because she rarely buys convenience food or junk food.

  1. She doesn’t have a well stocked kitchen but just a few herbs and spices.
  2. She has just a drawer of freezer space.
  3. She doesn’t have a lot of free time as is an athlete at uni juggling a job, uni, and training
  4. She does have worries about energy and has had the heating off most of the winter
  5. she doesn’t have spare cash but it’s cheaper to bulk buy where possible such as 12 pack of chicken instead of two pack.

So fit and healthy, I'm guessing she walks to uni and her work so no daily busfare or car to run.

She lives near enough to a couple of the cheaper supermarkets and isn't reliant on deliveries which have to be over a certain amount.

I'm assuming she is in a house / flat share because of the 1 freezer drawer. Does she pay for electricity or just heating?

What happens if the freezer breaks? Or what happens if another student leaves the freezer door open (my brother did this on a visit to me, I didn't notice for 2 days and I cried)?

autienotnaughty · 03/06/2022 03:54

@40andlols ok so I shop at Aldi caus I find it v cheap. I buy a bunch of veg (as listed) on a Monday chop it all up and then use it Monday to Thursday a sample menu would be-
Veg fried with soy, rice vinegar and chilli powder. Served with rice.
Veg fritters- Grated onions , carrots, courgettes , s&p, paprika and lemon mixed with egg and flour. Served with a jacket potato and peas.
Veg pasta- courgette, onions, mushrooms, garlic, peppers, carrot, tin of toms, s&p oregano, with pasta
Tray bake- roast veg and sweet potatoes with S&P, rosemary and thyme.
Veg curry- fried veg, cauliflower, toms, coconut milk, cumin, garam, chilli powder , veg stock served with rice
Tomato soup - onion, carrot, tin toms, lentils, garlic, veg stock. Served with bread.
Veggie bulgar wheat- fried veg, lemon, Greek yog and bulgar wheat.

Weekends we have meat (mostly mince, pork or chicken) tend to do bolognaise, curry, chilli , soups, stew. Rice, lentils, pasta , bulgar wheat are all fairly cheap bulkers. Lots of veg as it's cheaper than meat.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/06/2022 00:45

You aren’t comparing like with like.
A cheap shop bought Victoria sponge doesn’t contain any butter. Cheap jarred pesto doesn’t contain olive oil. If you make these products at home using similarly cheap ingredients, it would be cheaper than buying in the shop, especially if you bulk cook.

I also think you are buying from expensive sources - it’s great to use a milkman, but it’s expensive compared to supermarket milk.

If you buy food in a supermarket (either low or mid range or a mix), use a market, bulk order for store-cupboard, then it’s cheaper to cook from scratch, the ingredients are going to be healthier and you can decide where you want to sacrifice quality and where you aren’t.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 03/06/2022 00:11

Katypp · 02/06/2022 08:52

And 7, have plenty of fridge and freezer space to store batch cooking

(and Tupperware etc for storage(

40andlols · 02/06/2022 23:09

autienotnaughty · 02/06/2022 22:42

Cooking from scratch is cheaper. I buy oniions , mushrooms, peppers, courgette and garlic and that will cover four meals . One with eggs, one pasta one rice and one with sweet potato. Then mince will do two nights one chilli one bolognaise and then a chicken on Sunday with carrots and potatoes.

would you mind breaking this down a bit? It sounds so simple and organised... i want to get involved!

autienotnaughty · 02/06/2022 22:42

Cooking from scratch is cheaper. I buy oniions , mushrooms, peppers, courgette and garlic and that will cover four meals . One with eggs, one pasta one rice and one with sweet potato. Then mince will do two nights one chilli one bolognaise and then a chicken on Sunday with carrots and potatoes.

Chamomiltea · 02/06/2022 22:36

Yabu.. I have definitely not read the thread but as I still make about 1 million meals (according to my eldest) from approximately 2 packs of mince.. think bolognaise, lasagna, chilli, taco fries etc etc.. then we freeze the leftovers to just keep the endless joy of homecooked dinners going 🤣so you are definitely being unreasonable 🙂

Roxy69 · 02/06/2022 22:17

I'm never going to stop cooking from scratch as I like to know what's in my food and in any case I'm sure its cheaper. Hell will freeze over before I buy a jar of sauce.
I shall cook more in my slow cooker and already use my mini oven much more (instant heat).

Crikeyalmighty · 02/06/2022 19:12

@Katypp excellent post Katy-- I've been there many years ago in a similar situation and having no money means you don't always think logically , you think in the here and now and simply getting through that day

becausetrampslikeus · 02/06/2022 18:33

They cook fine in the microwave, just have a lack of colour

Lovely13 · 02/06/2022 18:16

Apparently there are recipes for cakes baked in the microwave. Which would reduce fuel costs. Haven’t tried them though. 🤷‍♀️

Katypp · 02/06/2022 16:40

@MibsXX I hear you, I honestly do. There was a time a few years back when our business failed when we literally had £70 in the bank with no obvious means of any more coming in, to cover mortgage, heating, food etc. Luckily tax credits arranged for me to get our end of year adjustment early, but I'll never forget those few days when I honestly didn't know how we were going to get by. The relief when I looked on online banking and discovered the money had come in was incredible - I'll never forget it. And that was well before the price hikes we are seeing now.
I always thought I was a careful cook and I would have probably thought home-cooking was cheaper back then - until I was staring poverty in the face and the reality hit me.
Until you've been in the situation, it's difficult to grasp what it's like - as many posts on this thread prove. It's all 'just pennies' and 'next to nothing' and 'it might cost £5 but you've got it in for next time'. They haven't a clue.

ivykaty44 · 02/06/2022 16:38

And this is why community kitchens should be available for people to use, many churches have decent kitchens in their halls

MibsXX · 02/06/2022 16:07

blackheartsgirl · 31/05/2022 16:56

I do think people are missing the point somewhat.

yes we all know that cooking from scratch is healthier blah blah but when you’ve only got 2 quidon the meter and only a couple of pounds to buy a jar it’s a no brainer. Jar all the way, only takes five minutes or less to heat up the jar versus wasting the rest of your electric that has to last you another 2 days I’d be choosing the jar.

that’s the reality now for many people, they can’t afford the fuel to actually cook!

It's the universal assumption from many that us poor folks are either lazy, incompetent or fussy. Trust me, from the poorer side of the fence, some of us do know full well HOW to cook lovely tasty meals from scratch, but two years plus of covid restrictions to shopping and finances, followed close on the heels with this money grubbing exercise from the big profit making companies that we have absolutely no control over, has left a lot of storecupboards more than bare and no way to replenish. I often end up with the ingredients, through deals or gifts, but have no way of actually turning these into edible wholesome meals simply through lack of means to cook. Or the reverse, like this week, a bit of money went on the meter, out shopping with a strict list, which mostly didn't happen as prices shot up soo much from two weeks ago for the very same items. The news that there will likely be power blackouts this winter fills me with more dread than the bills going up even more, anything I have managed to bulk cook and freeze will be lost. If anyone has any no or low cook ways to serve up swedes, I am all ears , raw in sticks it was not a winner, made us all quite ill. In the space of 3 months, our rent went up 50 a mth, our meter eats 4 x what it did, despite us using far less, heating oil for hot water and heating soared from 270 last delivery last sept, to last quote in feb was 1,400 for the same amount as last time so that didnt happen. Getting to work and school costs 48 a week more, all the other bills went up by quite a chunk in some cases, yet income went down by a third. The only area we have any real control over costwise is food, and the only way to control that is by simply buying very little. It is draining and demeaning to be constantly working out if a meal can be afforded, if using up the little left on the meter to cook a meal will leave us with no power to wash clothes, or no lights to do homework by etc. So yes, to the PP who pointed out that a family sized ready meal that is microwaveable in minutes would be the only option, if I had a supermarket near me that sold those I would be all over that in a heartbeat so we all could eat together and feel full rather than hiding skipping meals and everyone feeling miserable.
When the pots empty, cooking decent meals from scratch or growing your own is a very expensive hobby that is so out of reach it feels like a lottery win scenario, self sufficiency and all that, if only I could afford a ticket!

Simonjt · 02/06/2022 15:16

Katypp · 02/06/2022 14:00

@ivykaty44 .I honestly don't think people have a clue what it's like to manage on a small weekly budget.
Eg, using Tilda rice as an example, it's £2.60/kg if you buy 10kg, yet £5.80/kg if you just buy 500g. The downside is the10kg bag (which I KNOW will last a lot longer, obviously) will take a £26 chunk out of your budget for that week.
By the way, before I get jumped on, I know much cheaper rice is available but Tilda Basmati was the only thing I could find quickly where direct comparisons could be made between small and big packs. I know you can buy rice for 45p.

Yep.

When I was younger my entire weekly food budget was £12 and it remained that way for about three years. For about six months of that I didn’t have a freezer either, so I couldn’t take advantage of cheap frozen veg.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 02/06/2022 15:13

PerkyBlinder What's her food budget per week?

ivykaty44 · 02/06/2022 14:31

rice is only cheap if you can get to the bargain stores without a car, otherwise you’ll be left shopping in the local stores where the prices are inflated

Katypp · 02/06/2022 14:00

@ivykaty44 .I honestly don't think people have a clue what it's like to manage on a small weekly budget.
Eg, using Tilda rice as an example, it's £2.60/kg if you buy 10kg, yet £5.80/kg if you just buy 500g. The downside is the10kg bag (which I KNOW will last a lot longer, obviously) will take a £26 chunk out of your budget for that week.
By the way, before I get jumped on, I know much cheaper rice is available but Tilda Basmati was the only thing I could find quickly where direct comparisons could be made between small and big packs. I know you can buy rice for 45p.

ivykaty44 · 02/06/2022 13:48

Katypp

thing is if you only have £25 for food you can buy 7 pot noddles but that’s not the bulk buying they mean which is beyond price, carrying home, able to cook and use quick enough without freezer

Xenia · 02/06/2022 13:00

Depends what you eat. I don't like sauces so my cooking from scratch would be something like put fish in olive oil in pan and add veg.

Katypp · 02/06/2022 12:58

I am also laughing at the amount of people who have sagely advised that it's cheaper to buy in bulk.
Is there anyone anywhere who doesn't know that?
The advice would be more useful if they could suggest how you can accommodate £10 of bulk buying into a grocery budget of £50 for the week.