Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 04/06/2022 10:44

I imagine a typical WC family in the 70s had dad working full time and mum at home full time or working part time for 'pin money'. So mum usually had time to cook and probably local shops.

there weren’t ready meals or snacking like today, it was invented to take people away from cooking and make money - this has been a success

Food tastes were much simpler, chops and vegetables with potatoes, fish and potatoes, simple meals that were easy to prepare.
england eas much of a laughing stock regarding our culinary skills as it was so unrefined. Bread and butter with most meals past birmingham.

yes cottage pie and hot pot have been made into ready meals but much of our 1970s style menu has been left behind in exchange for other cuisine
the ready meal market hasn’t made its money on ready cooked •meat and two veg•

BellePeppa · 04/06/2022 10:08

sashh · 04/06/2022 08:55

We were a typical 1970s working class family and every day we had home cooked meals. It’s only because there is so much junk and ready meals available now that some people forget there were times when they barely existed.

I imagine a typical WC family in the 70s had dad working full time and mum at home full time or working part time for 'pin money'. So mum usually had time to cook and probably local shops.

I remember an ASDA opening up in the next town and running a free bus from our town, that would be late 70s early 80s.

There were some ready meals, although I think they were mainly M and S and OK the take aways would be fish and chips and Chinese if you were lucky.

But modern life is different. More single parents, most families with 2 parents have both working. Children do not all attend their local school and many have sports or clubs after, life is so much busier now.

No, both parents worked full time but in low paid jobs. We were ‘latch key’ kids 🙂

sashh · 04/06/2022 08:55

We were a typical 1970s working class family and every day we had home cooked meals. It’s only because there is so much junk and ready meals available now that some people forget there were times when they barely existed.

I imagine a typical WC family in the 70s had dad working full time and mum at home full time or working part time for 'pin money'. So mum usually had time to cook and probably local shops.

I remember an ASDA opening up in the next town and running a free bus from our town, that would be late 70s early 80s.

There were some ready meals, although I think they were mainly M and S and OK the take aways would be fish and chips and Chinese if you were lucky.

But modern life is different. More single parents, most families with 2 parents have both working. Children do not all attend their local school and many have sports or clubs after, life is so much busier now.

BellePeppa · 04/06/2022 08:04

When I was growing up there weren’t really any ready meals available anyway so no matter how poor you were you had to cook pretty from scratch. Not counting supermarket pies and ready made sausages the only ready meal I ever remember as a kid were those Vesta dried curries in a box, I had about two in my entire life. We never had takeaways (too expensive) and very rarely ate out. We were a typical 1970s working class family and every day we had home cooked meals. It’s only because there is so much junk and ready meals available now that some people forget there were times when they barely existed.

Fizbosshoes · 04/06/2022 07:40

The town I live in has no cheap supermarkets but there are nearby towns that have Aldi/Lidl, markets and Asian grocers that would all be cheaper. However it would cost at least £4 on the bus or £3 on the train (plus walking to those places from station or bus station) so if you are short on money or time (or both) then you may well end up buying the smallest/cheapest items in the co-op, which won't be anything like as good value.

MibsXX · 04/06/2022 04:29

sashh · 04/06/2022 03:15

A very large bag of rice means your per portion price is about a quarter of your Tesco price. Proper red curry paste is cheaper in a larger tub and stronger so you use less. Coconut milk cheaper etc etc. - you are assuming people on a very tight budget are happy to shell out a fairly large amount of money for very large bags of rice and large tub of curry paste. I don't know the cost of these things at an Asian grocer, but if I can assume for a moment, £10 for rice and £5 for curry paste? That's £15, which is a chunk of cash for someone on say, £50 a week budget. It is cheaper in the long run, obviously, but many don't have that luxury - I didn't.

Another thing you may not have if you live in poverty is a safe place to store your large bag of rice / chickpeas / lentils.

If you are living in poverty you are probably renting and not all landlords are good, so you may well have vermin accessing your home, or you are a family of 4 sharing a room in a B and B or shelter and your only storage is one cupboard in a shared kitchen or your bedroom.

Or in the case of rooms with shared kitchens, or insecure room locks, others who will not think twice about helping themselves to any food stash you try to accumulate

sashh · 04/06/2022 03:15

A very large bag of rice means your per portion price is about a quarter of your Tesco price. Proper red curry paste is cheaper in a larger tub and stronger so you use less. Coconut milk cheaper etc etc. - you are assuming people on a very tight budget are happy to shell out a fairly large amount of money for very large bags of rice and large tub of curry paste. I don't know the cost of these things at an Asian grocer, but if I can assume for a moment, £10 for rice and £5 for curry paste? That's £15, which is a chunk of cash for someone on say, £50 a week budget. It is cheaper in the long run, obviously, but many don't have that luxury - I didn't.

Another thing you may not have if you live in poverty is a safe place to store your large bag of rice / chickpeas / lentils.

If you are living in poverty you are probably renting and not all landlords are good, so you may well have vermin accessing your home, or you are a family of 4 sharing a room in a B and B or shelter and your only storage is one cupboard in a shared kitchen or your bedroom.

Charles11 · 03/06/2022 21:01

Sorry ignore my previous post. I misunderstood the original post and thought £15 budget was for after the pasta and rice etc.
That would obviously be a more generous budget!

Charles11 · 03/06/2022 20:59

"Then I would buy:
20 sausages @ £1.25
2 tins baked beans @ 20p = 40p
Pasta sauce @ 39p
Frozen mixed veg 69p
15 cheese slices 75p
2 tins tomatoes @ 28p = 56p
15 yorkshire puddings @ 50p
Jam @ 31p
Tea bags 55p
10 fish fingers £1.20
Bag chips @ 99p
Stock cubes 55p
2 tins fruit @ 70p = £1.40
2 onions @ 10p each = 20p
1 jelly 70p (to set in small tubs for lunchboxes)"

I wouldn't buy any of that except tins of tomatoes and onions and probably 1 more of each.
3 tins of tomatoes 84p
Onions 1 kg 49p
chicken thighs £2.40
beef mince about £2.60
Carrots 40p
Courgette 40p
Cucumber 50p
Cream cheese £1
Flour 70p
12 Eggs £1.85
2 tins of chick peas 80p
Tinned tuna £1.25

ivykaty44 · 03/06/2022 19:51

Previous generations also spent a much higher percentage of their budgets on food.

in the 1970s a third of homes were council, with council rents at a fair price

food might have taken more out of our smaller disposable income, but the rent was much cheaper

MibsXX · 03/06/2022 18:52

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 17:43

It must be exhausting having to budget down to your last penny for long periods.

The exercise above was just an exercise for me and I don’t know how many people are on that kind of budget. But I expect that a lot of people are turning their hand to feed their families in ways that we can only imagine.

Yup, several carrier bags of animal feed destined swedes donated.....

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 18:15

Onion - not at all. As I said , it must be exhausting to constantly have to budget within an inch of your life.

But if you have a family to feed you have to find ways to do it.

Porridge oats is nutritious and filling although ideally added fruit would be more balanced. But at least your child would be able to concentrate a bit better at school without an empty tummy and with a slow release of energy.

I used to have a stand off every morning with one dd over porridge - she hated it and I felt it was a good start to the day (not because she couldn’t have had cornflakes etc).

I eventually gave up but she wouldn’t have had much choice if I was cash strapped.

Onionpatch · 03/06/2022 18:02

Kids havent been on schools meals in the summer traditionally, although I dont know if Marcus managed to change that. And some people on the threshold dont get help at all.

I priced up porridge and 50/50 milk and it was 16p a serving with no sugar/fruit/cinnamon/tumeric etc. I cant see it being very nutritious longer term.

I worry threads like these make people believe it is almost desirable to make dinner for 20p and its just laziness and lack of skills that makes it cost more and it keeps benefits low.

I believe that a balanced, nutritious diet that keeps you full costs quite a lot of money to be honest.

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 18:02

We’re saying it’s extreme but if you have families on that budget then that’s what it is. We hear talk of food poverty but what does that actually mean in pounds and pence to the people at the sharpest end?

kavalkada · 03/06/2022 18:00

Of couurse not, you can not feed a family of four for 10-15 pounds a week (unless you're very, very lucky with yellow stickers). But the point of this thread should be if you're so desperate and have only that how to make that money last longer and not spend it all on one realy meal dinner.
I'm lucky and have enough to feed my children, but my mother was one of those who had to stretch that money to last long enough.

She'd probably buy things like
potatoes - 36p/kg (4 kg - 1.44 pounds)
chicken drumsticks 1.89 pounds /kg (2 kg - 3.78 pounds)
frozen broccoli & Cauliflower 89 p/kg (2 kg - 1.78 pounds)
onions 1 kg - 49 p
long grain rice 0.45 p/kg
one chicken 2.89 pounds
bread 0.65 and jam 0.90 for breakfast
15 eggs 1.29 pounds
plain flower 1.5 kg 55 p
milk 1,2 l 1 pound

I remember she used to make us pancakes a lot because they were cheap and they were are dessert.

I'm not saying this is the way it should be, but she tried to strech that money. And yes we had oven, fridge and cooker.

The only spice she used was salt and pepper and those lasted a lot, I remember.
She would buy sunflower oil to cook. And she would buy everything on sale.

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 17:56

Onion - that’s if you’re considering 3 meals/day for 7 days. Kids are probably on school meals and porridge/diluted milk is going to cost a lot less than 40p person each day.
But it’s likely that parents are skipping some meals (lunch or dinner) so that their kids can eat.

Katypp · 03/06/2022 17:53

@Onionpatch It's theoretically possible but not much fun. I think it's pretty extreme to be honest, although it was an interesting challenge @Maggiethecat .
It also illustrates how much you spend on bottles of this and jars of that - the things that turn ingredients into meals. On £10-£15 a week, all of those would go out of the window, so your Bolognaise would just be mince, onion, tomato and a stock cube possibly. I would normally add carrot, celery, mushrooms, tomato puree, garlic, wine and sugar to mine, but that would just cost far too much.

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 17:43

It must be exhausting having to budget down to your last penny for long periods.

The exercise above was just an exercise for me and I don’t know how many people are on that kind of budget. But I expect that a lot of people are turning their hand to feed their families in ways that we can only imagine.

Nothappyatwork · 03/06/2022 17:37

Onionpatch · 03/06/2022 17:25

Can people really feed a family of 4 for £10-£15 a week. Isnt that about 18p per person, per meal. I'm struggling to do a serving of porridge with watered down milk for that.

No they cannot and there’s various studies and procurement documents around the demonstrates that actually you can’t feed prisoners or care home residence for less than 40p per meal per person it wouldn’t be legal.

Onionpatch · 03/06/2022 17:25

Can people really feed a family of 4 for £10-£15 a week. Isnt that about 18p per person, per meal. I'm struggling to do a serving of porridge with watered down milk for that.

drspouse · 03/06/2022 17:23

We had spag bol on Weds. Sainsbury's ready meals 85p each= £3.40.
1kg spaghetti 46p = 12p for 250g
2 tins tomatoes = 56p
Smallest bottle of oil = £1.70 for 250ml. So that's about 7p but you have to have that much to get the bottle.
Onion £1/kg so maybe 20p for one
Garlic 25p per head, so 5p
Mince - Pork mince is on offer or plant based mince is also £1.75 for 500g
So that's £2.75 if you have the money for the bottle of oil and don't want herbs.

Katypp · 03/06/2022 16:55

I did say it was a very quick go @Maggiethecat
Dahl would be a good call, but my children would not eat that, unfortunately. I did factor in lunchboxes, but if I didn't have to accommodate them, I would go crazy and buy the lentils as well as the mince!
Looking at the lentils, there's a good example of bulk buying. 500g is £1.15 (£2.30/kg) but 2kg is £3.50 (£1.75/kg). It's so frustrating knowing you could save money but just not being able to afford to do so. £3.50 would take far too big a hole out of a £15 budget, unless you have a family who would eat dahl for a few days a week so you didn't have to buy other things (I wish ...)

Maggiethecat · 03/06/2022 16:44

@Katypp - I wasn’t thinking of school lunches included (presumption that kids would get free school meals).

I’d probably replace the fish fingers and chips with mince and try to stretch that to 2 meals - use one portion to make a bolognaise (use one of the canned tomatoes and get another pack of pasta if you’re going to use the other pasta with the jar pasta sauce) and the other half of mince used with canned beans for chilli to be used with the rice.

Since I had rice I’d try to replace something- Yorkshire puddings/jelly perhaps - with lentils to make daal which I could get a couple of meals out of.

Trying to mix in a few home made ‘more nutritious’ meals is daunting but not impossible.

Katypp · 03/06/2022 16:07

They were all off the Tesco.com website this afternoon @Billandben444

Billandben444 · 03/06/2022 16:06

@Katypp do you mind me asking where you can shop at those prices? Pasta etc has shot up in price recently.