Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
emmaluggs · 31/05/2022 13:20

I make tomato sauce from scratch with tinned toms, much tastier and cheaper than jar

AnnaMagnani · 31/05/2022 13:20

I do cook from scratch and know I am lucky to have been taught by my DM, who learned as a post war farm girl when as PPs have said, things had to be cheap.

I'm also time poor so I do a mixture of longer meals at the weekend, when I have more time and enjoy it, making everything with a leftover portion that goes in the freezer, and quick meals for evenings when I come home from work.

Everything is planned though - I do a meal plan on a Saturday before we shop and if it's not on the plan, it's not bought. After 10+ years of meal planning it doesn't take me long and we don't eat the same things every week.

I've rarely eaten a bought cake that tastes as good as a home made cake. Not everything I cook is great but it beats most jars and ready meals.

My garden is however forlorn and unloved.

EarringsandLipstick · 31/05/2022 13:20

Sallygoround631 · 31/05/2022 12:38

A carrot cake or carrot cake muffins:

60p bag of grated carrot
£1 small bag of mixed fruit and nuts
£1 couple of small oranges
£1 good flour (extra £ for organic)
Bit of oil form cupboard.
£1.80 free range eggs
£1 brown sugar
£1 tbsp ginger
£1 tbsp cinnamon

Topping:
£2 Icing sugar and butter
£1 optional cream cheese

Half hour oven time.

Cost = nearly £10 for your cake!

This was the cheapest i could source online if you needed to get the ingredients in. I already have them as built up over time but as a one off this is super costly compared to a sainsburys carrot cake.

I think it pays to grab one cupboard staple a week, or a couple per month, so over time you have everything at hand at no extra cost. I do this and prefer it to shop bought but the initial outlay does cost.

You don't need all those items at those cost for one cake tho! Eg the spices will be at most 2 or 3p per cake, not £1

That £10 would make many cakes!

ivykaty44 · 31/05/2022 13:19

I cook at home rather than buying ready meals or jars of sauces, I find it much cheaper this way and cook things in bulk and freeze excess to keep cooking costs and time free.

Making a tomato sauce for pasta will cost 2 tins of tomatoes and a few herbs along with a tin of anchovies - £1.20 for 4 dishes

cooking shepherds pie or chicken in tarragon this week and it will be cheaper than purchasing a meal for 2 ready meals in the similar flavours styles - especially if I double up and freeze the other half of the meal, which gives me 3 meals for next week already in the freezer.

cracking two eggs and cooking of some mushrooms for an omelette is not difficult and far nicer and cheaper than a frozen omelette in the microwave

Time and know how

Onionpatch · 31/05/2022 13:17

I take from this that people eat a lot more cake than I do!

I do scratch cook but I also buy lots of pre-prepared stuff. I think things like a tin of baked beans is cheaper than buying beans and making a tomatoe sauce for them.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 31/05/2022 13:16

We cook every meal from scratch, Eastern European food is cheap and healthy, DP makes the meals in bulk, so the food lasts for weeks and the ingredients last for months.

prescribingmum · 31/05/2022 13:15

PurpleButterflyWings · 31/05/2022 13:00

YANBU. Apart from the odd spag bol and chilli con carne (made with quorn mince as me and DH don't eat red meat,) and omelettes, stir fries, pasta, and pancakes (and obviously easy things like beans on toast, jacket potatoes, salads, and sandwiches etc, ) I don't 'do' cook from scratch.

I CBA. Most stuff already made (ready meals/microwave meals/oven chips/frozen pies/frozen veg etc,) are just so much easier to do/prepare, and are often as good as cook-from-scratch. Morrisons do a lovely Indian takeaway AND a Chinese takeaway for 2 people, for £6-7. (Costs £15-17 for the equivalent from the takeaway.) Also, it would cost a LOT more to do from scratch, AND would take a lot more time!!!

If people want to cook everything from scratch, then good for them! But I don't like people 'looking down their nose' at people who don't. I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)

Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

Then again, I am an outside person, and not someone who chooses to spend half my waking hours in the kitchen. I would rather spend 6 hours in the garden, (pottering about/weeding/planting flowers/trimming the bushes and trees etc,) or going for a walk along the canal or through the woods. Life's too short to spend half of it bloody cooking!

Meh, each to their own!!! But I do find the 'I'm better than you, a higher social class, and clearly better educated - because I cook from scratch' brigade quite hilarious and farcical.

It is clear from your post that YOU feel inferior because you don't cook from scratch. I couldn't give a damn whether you or anyone else does, it is none of my business. I just do what I enjoy and that is cooking! Unlike you, I am not judging and saying that some else is wasting their time by choosing something else to do

As for your cake, the supermarket ones are absolutely vile, far too sweet and full of crap. We don't eat much cake at home as it is an occasional treat. When we do, it will be one that has been made from scratch at home. The children and I get a lot of enjoyment from planning how we will make it, making it, decorating and then eating.

Edderkop · 31/05/2022 13:14

Fortunately both me and my partner enjoy cooking. We do most things from scratch because I'm coeliac so a lot of processed foods are off limits. We do still have lazy meals, but it'll be a jacket potato with tuna and salad for example, rather than a ready meal.

woodhill · 31/05/2022 13:14

Less packaging cooking from scratch

Also trans fats & palm oil in shop stuff,

ForestFae · 31/05/2022 13:13

prescribingmum · 31/05/2022 13:08

100% this! I am much younger so sadly had very limited HE lessons in school (was in school 20 years ago) but my grandmother lived with us shortly after we got married and I was absolutely amazed at how resourceful she was when cooking. She would make sure there were multiple things in the oven as you mention, when using a pressure cooker, she had ways of using steaming baskets or other dividers so multiple items cooked simultaneously, when the electric hob was turned off at the end of the meal, she would use that heat for another purpose. Also, the stock example I gave earlier - using all leftover veg trimmings when cooking main meal to pre-make stock.

There is also an element of ensuring all ingredients are used - in our convenience lifestyle, if we don't feel like eating something that involves using up the bits leftover from the previous day, we don't and will make/buy something new. By using up all the last bits, we are being so much more resourceful

If these skills are taught and used, there is no doubt making at home is much cheaper and healthier.

Fully agree with your post and the one you quoted.

LeaveYourHatOn · 31/05/2022 13:12

I think actually that ready-made processed crap may become more expensive and people will have to go back to learning how to cook proper food from real ingredients. Only once we realise that butter, meat, out-of-season fruit and vegetables etc are actually really expensive will we learn how to use them sparingly and appropriately. We've become quite used to having eg chicken breast a few times a week or fresh asparagus and peppers in January. It's not really a sustainable way of eating (on so many levels) and it needs to change.

Homemade compared to bought is only fair if you too are using the same cheap ingredients. The point though is that if you're cooking or baking from scratch you can choose to use better quality ingredients - which may cost more, but then you'll adjust for that, so not have cake/meat/etc so often, and instead make much cheaper, more nutritious meals.

ForestFae · 31/05/2022 13:11

PurpleButterflyWings · 31/05/2022 13:00

YANBU. Apart from the odd spag bol and chilli con carne (made with quorn mince as me and DH don't eat red meat,) and omelettes, stir fries, pasta, and pancakes (and obviously easy things like beans on toast, jacket potatoes, salads, and sandwiches etc, ) I don't 'do' cook from scratch.

I CBA. Most stuff already made (ready meals/microwave meals/oven chips/frozen pies/frozen veg etc,) are just so much easier to do/prepare, and are often as good as cook-from-scratch. Morrisons do a lovely Indian takeaway AND a Chinese takeaway for 2 people, for £6-7. (Costs £15-17 for the equivalent from the takeaway.) Also, it would cost a LOT more to do from scratch, AND would take a lot more time!!!

If people want to cook everything from scratch, then good for them! But I don't like people 'looking down their nose' at people who don't. I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)

Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

Then again, I am an outside person, and not someone who chooses to spend half my waking hours in the kitchen. I would rather spend 6 hours in the garden, (pottering about/weeding/planting flowers/trimming the bushes and trees etc,) or going for a walk along the canal or through the woods. Life's too short to spend half of it bloody cooking!

Meh, each to their own!!! But I do find the 'I'm better than you, a higher social class, and clearly better educated - because I cook from scratch' brigade quite hilarious and farcical.

You don’t believe it because you don’t do it? Bizarre. I cook from scratch because I enjoy it - yes, some of us enjoy cooking! I also think it tastes better - I don’t like most shop bought cakes and I enjoy caring for my family by preparing nourishing food.

I’m also an outdoor person - we grow our own vegetables, another reason I enjoy cooking from scratch.

Sometimes we’ll do a quick meal, but I don’t use ready meals personally. I don’t like them. Each to their own but don’t disbelieve people just because you don’t like cooking

ImplementingTheDennisSystem · 31/05/2022 13:11

Why is this thread so focused on cake! We're in the midst of an obesity epidemic - the least concern should be how cheaply families can bake vs buy cakes.
For what it's worth, we cook everything from scratch APART from cakes - I don't have the time or inclination to do so.
Simple home cooked food made with potatoes, pasta, lentils, beans, oats, noodles is still typically cheaper than the ready-meal equivalent.

gumballbarry · 31/05/2022 13:10

@Calafsidentity oh, you're so right about the Asian food shops. You can buy bulk spices and sauces from places like Wing Yip so much cheaper (it's novel enough to keep the kids interested while walking around the aisles too).

Calafsidentity · 31/05/2022 13:10

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation
What fresh veg do you cook in your air fryer if you don't mind me asking? I am really interested in this as I tend to use it mainly for teen "beige" food like frozen fries and scampy. I'd love to use it for other healthier things too ... .

ReviewingTheSituation · 31/05/2022 13:10

@Sallygoround631 - but that's not the real cost of the cake. It doesn't cost £10 to make a cake, and MOST people are not going to buy all of the ingredients in one go. Even if you don't have cinnamon/ginger, you are probably already buying eggs, have flour in the house, have sugar already (maybe not brown but the world wouldn't end if you used white)...

The real cost is more like:
Carrots - c50p per kilo, so maybe 20p for the cake
Oranges - not completely necessary - use a splash of orange juice if you've got that already
Sultanas - 45p max for a cake (totally guessing at quantities)
Flour - 20p max
Oil - 60p
Eggs - 60p
£1 brown sugar
Ginger/cinnamon - pennies (also not completely necessary)

Topping:
optional

That's about £3 for your cake (before fuel). Yes - more than a bought cake will be, but much nicer.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 31/05/2022 13:09

I can't see how its a class thing to cook from scratch, I did it because we were dirt poor. It was cheaper to buy bargain ingredients from a walk round all the pound shops than it was to buy ready meals which we could definitely not afford. We might have a bought pudding once a month as a treat but on the whole we never ate cake or puddings because we couldn't afford them.

prescribingmum · 31/05/2022 13:08

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 31/05/2022 12:11

I think we need to reassess the way we cook. When I did home economics at school 40+ years ago we got marked down if there was space in the oven when using it. We had to plan to use all the shelves, what goes on the top one and the bottom, plus using it as it cooled down afterwards. Now I heat up my 50% bigger oven just to cook a couple of chicken breasts. My old teacher will be turning in her grave.

100% this! I am much younger so sadly had very limited HE lessons in school (was in school 20 years ago) but my grandmother lived with us shortly after we got married and I was absolutely amazed at how resourceful she was when cooking. She would make sure there were multiple things in the oven as you mention, when using a pressure cooker, she had ways of using steaming baskets or other dividers so multiple items cooked simultaneously, when the electric hob was turned off at the end of the meal, she would use that heat for another purpose. Also, the stock example I gave earlier - using all leftover veg trimmings when cooking main meal to pre-make stock.

There is also an element of ensuring all ingredients are used - in our convenience lifestyle, if we don't feel like eating something that involves using up the bits leftover from the previous day, we don't and will make/buy something new. By using up all the last bits, we are being so much more resourceful

If these skills are taught and used, there is no doubt making at home is much cheaper and healthier.

gumballbarry · 31/05/2022 13:07

@PurpleButterflyWings I'm really not getting that vibe from this thread. There are people out there who really like cooking and enjoy the organisation and the challenge of cooking something which others enjoy. There are phases where I do everything from scratch but then after a couple of days I'm back to pretty much what you described above. Nothing wrong with either approach.

I do however have loads of weeds in my garden and I'm fed up with gardeners looking down their noses at me😉

DressingPafe · 31/05/2022 13:07

It definitely does depend what you cook. I make macaroni cheese from scratch and just the cheese is expensive. I then also add some bacon/onions. I could get frozen portions from Iceland for £1 each. Wouldn't be anywhere near as nice but would be cheaper. I sometimes have the Tesco frozen pepperoni pizza at £1.45. I definitely couldn't make my own any cheaper.

I do actually do most of my cooking from scratch but it can be more expensive. I don't want to eat a bolognaise that's bulked out with lentils for example. So if I make one then I do have the cost of the meat to factor in. I'm lucky in that I only have myself to feed now so don't need to stress too much.

CupidStunt22 · 31/05/2022 13:06

reesewithoutaspoon · 31/05/2022 12:58

my post screwed up. so the comaprison recipe was missing, but even your cheap ingredients still come to £3:53 and aldi cream cheese is 75p not 50p so you underestimated.
A sainsburys lemon swirl cheesecake is £3:50 and no faff making it.

That sainsburys cheesecake is going to be half the size and with preservatives and all kind of crap. The bigger, better, nicer one is the exact same price and the "faff" could be you teaching your kids how to make it!
Thanks for proving my point for me.

Calafsidentity · 31/05/2022 13:06

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 12:10

Not sure why people are fixating on flour when it’s the other ingredients which cost the money.

So if you’re making a cake which contains, as a rule, 8 oz butter, then the butter alone is going to cost you somewhere in the range of £1.70 (assuming you can get it on offer.) the eggs are around £1.40 for 6, so approx 90P for the eggs. So even if your 1kg bag of flour makes 4 cakes, add in the butter and eggs, and those 4 cakes have already cost you over £10, without factoring the sugar, vanilla extract, gas etc into the cost, and assuming you’re only making a plain cake with no filling or icing.

Yes prices are going up steeply but a whole sandwich cake, for example, even a 23cm one, is much, much bigger than anything you tend to buy in a shop, and weighs more. Shop bought cakes are surprisingly small.once you have lost the packaging, they are usually divided in to small portions full of additives. Even a rectangular plain bought loaf cake, like a madeira cake, is pretty small. You can halve a home made Victoria sponge cake for example and freeze one half for later. I'm.always surprised by how far ingredients go when cooking from scratch.

Generally I find it's much cheaper to buy and cook seasonally, and avoid supermarkets for some things as they are always out to add value (for themselves) . We've cut down on meat, we usually eat veggie four times a wk, and when we do have chicken for example, I buy a whole bird and use every bit, and make stock.from leftover carcass. I use the bread machine and soup machine a lot too. I try and never let any dhop bought vegetables go to waste.

It's helpful to buy a lot of staples from middle Eastern and Asian shops. I have saved so much money not buying wanky small supermarket boxes of rice, lentils, chickpeas etc. So much cheaper to buy kilo bags. Spices are fresher and cheaper too. I admit that doesn't work if cooking for one though.

Also, I have gone back to buying some tinned fruit (but in sugar free or sugar light juice). I've wasted so many fresh pears and nectarines that go from rock hard to woolly in a day. A tinned pear or peach works well in hot puddings and is never wasted. Ditto glass jars of good quality apple or rhubarb compote etc.

Fairislefandango · 31/05/2022 13:06

I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)

Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

Confused You think most people are lying about cooking from scratch? We cook from scratch because we quite like doing it, and because it tastes a million times better! Bought cake is mostly shit,unless it's really expensive, high quality handmade stuff that tastes like homemade.

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 31/05/2022 13:05

I cook virtually everything from scratch and it's been easy since I got my airfryer. I'm eating tons of vegetables now and almost everything goes in together, so less faff. It's cheap to run too.

Sleepingb · 31/05/2022 13:05

PurpleButterflyWings · 31/05/2022 13:00

YANBU. Apart from the odd spag bol and chilli con carne (made with quorn mince as me and DH don't eat red meat,) and omelettes, stir fries, pasta, and pancakes (and obviously easy things like beans on toast, jacket potatoes, salads, and sandwiches etc, ) I don't 'do' cook from scratch.

I CBA. Most stuff already made (ready meals/microwave meals/oven chips/frozen pies/frozen veg etc,) are just so much easier to do/prepare, and are often as good as cook-from-scratch. Morrisons do a lovely Indian takeaway AND a Chinese takeaway for 2 people, for £6-7. (Costs £15-17 for the equivalent from the takeaway.) Also, it would cost a LOT more to do from scratch, AND would take a lot more time!!!

If people want to cook everything from scratch, then good for them! But I don't like people 'looking down their nose' at people who don't. I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)

Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

Then again, I am an outside person, and not someone who chooses to spend half my waking hours in the kitchen. I would rather spend 6 hours in the garden, (pottering about/weeding/planting flowers/trimming the bushes and trees etc,) or going for a walk along the canal or through the woods. Life's too short to spend half of it bloody cooking!

Meh, each to their own!!! But I do find the 'I'm better than you, a higher social class, and clearly better educated - because I cook from scratch' brigade quite hilarious and farcical.

I do it because it's healthier and I enjoy it.

Life's too short for gardening, imo.

I never buy ready meals and with the exception of the odd frozen pizza, we cook with ingredients every day. If you don't, that's ok. But it doesn't make me wrong any more than it makes you wrong!

No need to be rude.

Swipe left for the next trending thread