Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
Calafsidentity · 31/05/2022 14:26

cantkeepawayforever · 31/05/2022 13:37

It does depend on the recipe books you yse, too. My ‘go to’ recipe books for cheap family teatime treats is my mother’s old BeRo book, early 1960s at a guess, possibly earlier as it was her mother’s before her. I have a Good Housekeeping and a Mrs Beeton from the same era. All make good wholesome cakes / biscuits with a minimum of rich / expensive ingredients, and with cooking times and temperatures that fit in with other dishes baked at the sane time.

I've got my mother's old Be-Ro book too Grin. It's the idea with Katie Stewart on the cover.

My mother was an adolescent during the war, so were some of my home economics teachers for that matter (or they were post-war generation - rationing went on until about 1952 I think?) Anyway, I've picked up good ecomical cooking habits from them and am always shocked when I see meal plans on here and people are eating different meals every night, especially things like salmon, followed by chilli, followed by chicken, followed by burgers. It seems really extravagant to me.

We unashamedly enjoy leftovers. (You used to get sneered at by some posters on Mumsnet for saying that!) Or we deliberately cook once and eat twice. And we usually make the protein element 'stretch" a bit. I don't think it's a bad thing if people have to go back to that. It saves on food waste for ine thing.

3WildOnes · 31/05/2022 14:25

Haven't read all 8 pages so likely repeating other people. On another thread people were talking about their weekly food budget and mine seemed to be lower than a lot of others (£100 for amily of 5 ) I think part of tat was we cook from scratch a lot.
I can make three loaves of bead in the bread maker a week for about £1.50 , thee loaves store bought would cost more.
I can make 4 pizzas for about £4.
Of course It helps that I have a fully stocked store cupboard.

Eeebleeb · 31/05/2022 14:25

It's not more expensive to cook from scratch and it sure as HELL tastes better if you are a semi-decent cook! Supermarket sauces etc are way too sugary, I can't bear them. My husband makes way better bread, pizzas and curries than you can buy except in a good restaurant. Suppose it depends WHAT you cook from scratch - we are vegan and used to being poor from a long time back so beans, pulses, lentils feature heavily. Parsley pesto from a bunch of parsley, oil, garlic. Do buy dried pasta but make it sometimes too. Make our own seitan and sometimes tofu. Naan, roti, chole, dal - all cheap to make. Chilli, stews, obviously. Home-made wheat tortillas and refried beans and a chopped salsa - with homemade guac if you're feeling like splashing out on an avocado - all expensive and less good premade.

I eat more varied now because DH is good at more things and can make them quickly, but I still cooked from scratch and ate healthily before I met him, just a bit more simply.

You do have to be able to get these things though, food deserts are real and not only that but some things are so much cheaper in the Chinese supermarket, Indian store etc and you pay a stupid premium for them in some locations. Costco has been useful for us and we can get stuff there that we used to have to order online (bulk flour etc) but it's largely useless if you don't drive/ have a car which is obviously a privilege in itself.

I still ate the same way before a car though, when I lived in little rural towns and shopped out of the co-op. Not so many dishes, but plant-based from scratch. It was the cheapest way to eat even then.

Menora · 31/05/2022 14:24

Kids mealtimes is kind of defined by that place they go to all day between 9-3pm

please do not pedal all the keto rubbish I am sure there is another forum for all that nonsense where everyone who isn’t a scientist or doctor talks about their interpretation of science. People who are diabetic should worry about ketosis and those who are not should just focus on eating a balanced diet and not having an excessive sugar intake

kids are fat from processed foods, they aren’t nutritionally balanced, have too much salt and sugar in them. If you fed a kid veg and pasta every day this would be better than chicken nuggets and pizza every day.

BellePeppa · 31/05/2022 14:23

drspouse · 31/05/2022 14:04

Who do you know in poverty who buys lots of junk food and takeaways?
As a treat, Macdonalds is pretty reasonable for children's meals.
But cabbage, potatoes, carrots and dried pasta is not a balanced meal for a child.

Haha I wasn’t handing out a dinner recipe😁 I got my info from documentaries on poorer (and usually larger) people whose diets are bad, not judging, just saying they’re more expensive ways of eating.

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:21

Oh and I’ve tried the milkman twice but had to cancel as they’ve unreliable.

tkwal · 31/05/2022 14:20

I am/will be buying more frozen fruit and vegetables and more own brand items. I'm already buying less meat and using lentils etc to bulk it out. Making sauces I use passata in Indian and Italian dishes along with whatever tomatoes I have already . Chop them up and only remove the skin if it's thick or tough. Dried herbs are much more economical than fresh
Basic plain porridge is easy to make in the microwave and you can flavour it with jams, sugar dried or frozen fruit, honey , spices or cocoa powder

I'm afraid though that no matter how much we try to economise we will be in for a rough couple of years with heating becoming ever more of a luxury and cooking/eating to survive rather than for leisure

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:20

E.G last night dinner for 3 adults:
wholewheat pasta twists(less than one 500g bag) with one small tin tuna, 400g tin of tomatoes, a red pepper, half tin sweetcorn, chilli flakes, onion, garlic, dried herbs.
Took less than half an hour, 10 mins prep, 20 simmering sauce.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 31/05/2022 14:19

If people want to cook everything from scratch, then good for them! But I don't like people 'looking down their nose' at people who don't.

As PPs have said, I don't get that vibe from this thread. It's an interesting discussion on how to economise, some of the skills that have become less widespread and how our expectations of food have changed over the last couple of generations.

I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch.

Well you can believe what you like but I cook from scratch all the time, and completely. I'm looking at my shopping list for the week and my most 'non-scratch' item is tomato puree and some flatbreads. (And wine, I don't brew my own Grin )

I mean, why on earth WOULD you?

If you need to economise and you want to eat well, why wouldn't you? As it happens I also enjoy cooking (and I'm a very outdoorsy person too; it's possible to do both) but whatever the reason there's no need to be so snippy.

Overthewine · 31/05/2022 14:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:15

I do t really eat cake but would bake one for birthdays as always far nicer than shop bought imo.

MintJulia · 31/05/2022 14:15

Not all ingredients have risen in price. Potatoes, veggies, salad and dairy have either fallen in price or remained steady. Beef, lamb, chicken and wheat products have gone up.

I choose whatever is lower price on the day, cook for one adult, one teen and usually spend £45 a week. Almost all cook from scratch. This week has been.....

Ham, cheese & tomato omelettes with 3 medium eggs each ( slo-cooker ham)
Sweet peppers stuffed with sausagemeat, served with garlic bread.
Seafood risotto, using frozen mussels, shrimp and hake. served with peas
Chicken thighs with leeks & fennel, served with new potatoes
Shop bought pizza (I have Friday night off cooking) & garlic bread
Pan fried pork steaks with onions, garlic, grilled plums and sauted potatoes
Baked trout stuffed with herbs, with potatoes, lemon and broccoli.

Only the risotto and the sauted potatoes took more than 10 minutes prep. Pudding is normally fruit and creme fraiche in our house.

Dixiechickonhols · 31/05/2022 14:14

Doofus we have a milkman for milk and eggs but he’s a lot more expensive than buying a plastic carton of milk in supermarket. I like to support local business, glass bottles and he was great in pandemic but he’s not cheap option.

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:14

I don’t think cooking from scratch is more expensive. If you have basics from the store cupboard and limit meat or buy cheaper cuts it can be very cheap. I shop at Aldi and spend £80 -£90 for 3-4 adults.

Vikinga · 31/05/2022 14:09

Lovinglondonlife · 31/05/2022 14:00

I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)...Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

I do cook from scratch most of the time. I do use a few jars but not on a daily basis. If I do roasts, curry, lasagne, Bolognese, it's always from scratch. I can't remember the last time I bought a ready meal. I buy shop bought cake but I do love to bake, we don't have cake very often but it's about 50/50 shop bought/homemade.

I also cook from scratch. I don't make my own mayonnaise but I'm going to try and make a vegan one. I don't buy store bought cake because noone likes it. Will sometimes buy biscuits and mini rolls type things for the kids packed lunch. I will buy ready made pizza but usually add extra toppings (olives, red pepper, onion, mushroom). I rarely make my own bread even though I have a bread maker. I have never tried to make my own pasta. Even hummus I rarely buy because i prefer the one i make and it is very quick. I do buy tinned chickpeas and beans as I don't want to remember to soak them overnight.

I also cook a lot of foreign meals that aren't easily available here.

CupidStunt22 · 31/05/2022 14:08

Doofas · 31/05/2022 14:05

I've noticed s couple of people have said they are ditching the milkman, I was just wondering why, as we've been thinking about starting to use a milkman, missing so we don't have that. It's breakfast time and we've got no milk! Ahhhh!!!!

Because its much much more expensive.

Doofas · 31/05/2022 14:05

I've noticed s couple of people have said they are ditching the milkman, I was just wondering why, as we've been thinking about starting to use a milkman, missing so we don't have that. It's breakfast time and we've got no milk! Ahhhh!!!!

drspouse · 31/05/2022 14:04

BellePeppa · 31/05/2022 14:02

Cooking from scratch is usually cheaper - carrots are practically free, potatoes and cabbage cost very little, dried pasta is cheap etc. I’ve always found it strange that people who are considered in poverty buy lots of junk food and takeaways because they are very expensive.

Who do you know in poverty who buys lots of junk food and takeaways?
As a treat, Macdonalds is pretty reasonable for children's meals.
But cabbage, potatoes, carrots and dried pasta is not a balanced meal for a child.

letsnotdothat · 31/05/2022 14:04

Once you have basics in the house it’s definitely much cheaper but you obviously have to build up those staples first I.e flour, herbs, seasoning, oil etc. I don’t think it’s more expensive to cook from scratch for a whole family, I can’t even imagine buying everyone in our family a ready meal each because it would cost a fortune (7 of us). Maybe cheaper for a single person or couple to eat junk, I’m not sure.

BellePeppa · 31/05/2022 14:02

Cooking from scratch is usually cheaper - carrots are practically free, potatoes and cabbage cost very little, dried pasta is cheap etc. I’ve always found it strange that people who are considered in poverty buy lots of junk food and takeaways because they are very expensive.

Lovinglondonlife · 31/05/2022 14:00

I also don't believe most people DO cook from scratch most of the time. Many claim they do, on these kind of threads, but I don't believe them. They probably do the easy stuff I mentioned, but rarely do most stuff from scratch. I mean, why on earth WOULD you? As has been said, it's more expensive, it's time-consuming, AND most 'shop-prepared stuff' tastes just as good - (and sometimes even better!)...Also, why the fuck would you spend so much time, energy, money, and gas/electric on making your own cake? You can buy one for pennies!

I do cook from scratch most of the time. I do use a few jars but not on a daily basis. If I do roasts, curry, lasagne, Bolognese, it's always from scratch. I can't remember the last time I bought a ready meal. I buy shop bought cake but I do love to bake, we don't have cake very often but it's about 50/50 shop bought/homemade.

drspouse · 31/05/2022 14:00

To the poster saying I was being too fancy cooking with butter with DD:
12 Sainsbury's fairy cakes: 85p, Aldi price match: £1.70 for 24
In this recipe I'm assuming small pack sizes (if you have nothing in, and need not to spend much):
Glace icing fairy cake recipe, also Sainsbury's products (makes 24 but they'd be tiny)
125g self raising flour: 10p
125g soft butter (Sainsbury's soft baking spread) 25p
125g caster sugar (this is a 500g non fair trade bag) 30p
2 eggs medium or large 34p
1 tsp vanilla extract (this is £1.50 for a bottle, OK let's say 10p for a tsp as the bottle is 60ml)
24 x bun papers 12p
200g Icing sugar 40p

Total: £1.60 for ingredients assuming you'd use the vanilla (in particular) again (the others are more usable in different recipes). Then you have to bake them. This is about 20p - the electricity cap i.e. if you are on a prepayment/non direct debit meter.

So if you are DEFINITELY going to use up all of the rest of the ingredients (and use them exactly - the flour, marge and caster sugar use 1/4 of the packet, the icing sugar uses 2/5 of the packet and the vanilla and cake cases use about 1/10 of the packet, and if you don't use them you'd have to throw them away hence wasting money)... it is almost exactly the same to make 24 very small fairy cakes at home.
If there is any wastage (I assume most of us have tried cooking with DCs!) and if you don't use up the ingredients before they go off (you could bake more fairy cakes every week of course) then it's not bad as an activity but hopelessly time wasting as a way to get fairy cakes!

Vikinga · 31/05/2022 13:58

I make mostly plant based meals and it is quite inexpensive. I grow my own herbs now which make a difference.

Onionpatch · 31/05/2022 13:58

SpiderVersed · 31/05/2022 13:41

What were you doing @Onionpatch , that hummus wasn’t cheap as chips?

Tin of chickpeas, dollop of tahini, slosh of lemon juice, oil, bit of garlic and salt/pepper.

A tub of tahini lasts a good year, chickpeas are around 50p, and you can adjust the seasoning/thickness to your taste. We must make it twice a week - it’s the teen’s current snack of choice.

I am in one of those food deserts, so tahini was really difficult to get hold of it was about £3.60 and not in my usual supermarket. It worked out at 35p a dollop. My supermarket sells chickpeas at 60p. So thats 95p before my slosh of lemon, oil, garlic, seasoning etc. The hummous i buy is £1. Its just something i thought seriously want worth making.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 31/05/2022 13:57

Like for like YABU.

pasta sauce costs £1-2. A couple tins tomatoes an onion and a pinch of herbs costs less than that.

you can compare ready made meals, but the affordable ones are generally made with very little meat content and bulk out on cheap ingredients. So it’s not comparable quality/price unless you’re also bulking out with cheap ingredients like oils, flours, thickening agents etc.