Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
Sleepingb · 31/05/2022 14:57

BellePeppa · 31/05/2022 14:23

Haha I wasn’t handing out a dinner recipe😁 I got my info from documentaries on poorer (and usually larger) people whose diets are bad, not judging, just saying they’re more expensive ways of eating.

Step away from Channel 5 & the Daily Fail in that case. Poverty point at its finest. Don't firm your views from sensationalist media.

Fairislefandango · 31/05/2022 14:56

I think - as is usual on threads about cooking from scratch - a lot of posters are missing the point here.

Lots of posters are not necessarily missing the OP's point, but what they are posting us often in response to other posters' comments rather than only the OP.

You're right that it's difficult to judge bought food and cooked-from-scratch food unless we specify what end of the range of either we are talking about. The point I'd stand by is that homemade food made from raw ingredients is inherently healthier, almost always tastier and can be cheaper or, at any rate, as cheap as bought, processed stuff. That doesn't necessarily mean it is usually cheaper, if you are used to cooking and spending what you fancy.

Onionpatch · 31/05/2022 14:56

Sainsburys have an aldi price match wholemeal loaf for 36p at the moment.

Beatrixpotterspencil · 31/05/2022 14:56

this thread has turned depressingly competitive.

yawn.

MangyInseam · 31/05/2022 14:56

FusionChefGeoff · 31/05/2022 14:28

As always, those with privilege can't see it from the other side.

What if your freezer breaks and you can't afford to replace it? Boom - batch cooking is now out.

What if you can't afford to buy butter, sugar, eggs this week but can afford a quid for a pack of shit shop cake?

Comparing high quality shop cake vs home cooked is pointless. If you've got a fiver to buy 'cake, bread and fruit' you can't buy the posh cake - or afford to make a good one - that's the point.

I don't think peopel are too stupid to realize this.

It's just that the OP is very general. Are we talking about very poor people? Or people who were already cooking from scratch?

I'd tend to say the latter, so chances are they already have a lot of the basic infrastructure and know-how and habits.

ForestFae · 31/05/2022 14:55

Something I think worth noting as well is things like this are always harder for disabled families. Some people can’t cut vegetables and peel them, some people have sensory issues with taste and texture, some have allergies. This also further limits what you can do. I’m only mentioning it as I haven’t seen anyone really talk about how rising prices will impact disabled people worse than non disabled ones.

cramitin · 31/05/2022 14:54

Katypp · 31/05/2022 14:47

I think - as is usual on threads about cooking from scratch - a lot of posters are missing the point here.
I haven't read the full thread, but I have read up to page 4, and the usual things are being trotted out:
Bought stuff is:


  1. Not as healthy

  2. Not as tasty

  3. Not as good quality

That's not what the OP said. She said it was cheaper to buy than cook from scratch, and I think, in general, she is right.
We're not talking about whether a Charlie Bingham fish pie is more expensive than your own deluxe fish pie with king prawns, monkfish tails and salmon (it probably is), we're talking about - I think OP? - day-to-day items that fill up your family when cash is in short supply.
Every thread about saving money always features someone airily saying make homemade cakes and bread because they are cheaper. A loaf of bread can be bought for 65p and a box of mini rolls for £1.30. I don't think you could produce a loaf of bread or a cake that cheaply. I know homemade is better etc etc etc but in absolute terms, the bought item is cheaper than the homemade equivalent.
To take an example on this thread: 'Making tomato sauce is always cheaper than buying it' and 'Making your own pasta sauce with a tin of tomatoes an onion some garlic and dried herbs is cheaper than the equivalent jar, surely?'
Bought: Tesco Chunky Vegetable Pasta Sauce 500g 70p
Homemade:
Tin of tomatoes (cheapest) : 28p
Half a red pepper @ 48p = 24p
Half a courgette @ 40p = 20p
Half a yellow pepper @ 48p = 24p
= 96p, without adding olive oil, tomato puree, garlic or herbs and without factoring in the cost to cook it, not just heat it up.
I think there is a tendency to completely underestimate the cost of home cooking, but if you do the costings (which I have from time to time) you will get a nasty shock, I guarantee.

Completely agree, I cook from scratch and it's not cheap.

ivykaty44 · 31/05/2022 14:53

Katypp There are a few TikTok showing meals under a £1, where the extra ingredients are limited due to cost. Jack Munro’s cookery was based on not having anything but basics as they were living on benefits & didn’t have the extras

ivykaty44 · 31/05/2022 14:49

I think quite a few posters have acknowledged that you need a functioning kitchen, a fairly well stocked store cupboard, and a reasonable basic income , with accessible local shops, and spare time in order to be able to prepare good nutritious but fairly economical meals.

agree with this ^

plus knowledge of how to cook, where to get ingredients

it would be great to have community kitchens where cooking could be completed, taught, learnt and shared

Katypp · 31/05/2022 14:47

I think - as is usual on threads about cooking from scratch - a lot of posters are missing the point here.
I haven't read the full thread, but I have read up to page 4, and the usual things are being trotted out:
Bought stuff is:


  1. Not as healthy

  2. Not as tasty

  3. Not as good quality

That's not what the OP said. She said it was cheaper to buy than cook from scratch, and I think, in general, she is right.
We're not talking about whether a Charlie Bingham fish pie is more expensive than your own deluxe fish pie with king prawns, monkfish tails and salmon (it probably is), we're talking about - I think OP? - day-to-day items that fill up your family when cash is in short supply.
Every thread about saving money always features someone airily saying make homemade cakes and bread because they are cheaper. A loaf of bread can be bought for 65p and a box of mini rolls for £1.30. I don't think you could produce a loaf of bread or a cake that cheaply. I know homemade is better etc etc etc but in absolute terms, the bought item is cheaper than the homemade equivalent.
To take an example on this thread: 'Making tomato sauce is always cheaper than buying it' and 'Making your own pasta sauce with a tin of tomatoes an onion some garlic and dried herbs is cheaper than the equivalent jar, surely?'
Bought: Tesco Chunky Vegetable Pasta Sauce 500g 70p
Homemade:
Tin of tomatoes (cheapest) : 28p
Half a red pepper @ 48p = 24p
Half a courgette @ 40p = 20p
Half a yellow pepper @ 48p = 24p
= 96p, without adding olive oil, tomato puree, garlic or herbs and without factoring in the cost to cook it, not just heat it up.
I think there is a tendency to completely underestimate the cost of home cooking, but if you do the costings (which I have from time to time) you will get a nasty shock, I guarantee.

ivykaty44 · 31/05/2022 14:46

3WildOnes

I think cooking for more becomes cheaper per head, so cooking for 5 is cheaper than cooking for 2 proportionally

making 4 pizza you can but several toppings & use them all on the 4 pizzas. But cooking two pizza you need to be more restrictive to get the same value, so less choice iyswim

i used to whip up a pizza dough in bread machine for Dd and make her a simple quality pizza for under a £1 but use frozen ingredients to give variety

a loaf of bread made each day was approximately 50pence but that was 6/7 years ago using flour from a mill which charged £10 for a sack of bread flour 12.5 kilo ( just looked it’s now £13.50 for same size, so still cheaper than supermarket) and they’d deliver the flour locally

i liked the roasted Mediterranean vegetables ( freezer department of Sainsbury) for putting on pizza, with goats cheese or feta

Calafsidentity · 31/05/2022 14:39

FusionChefGeoff · 31/05/2022 14:28

As always, those with privilege can't see it from the other side.

What if your freezer breaks and you can't afford to replace it? Boom - batch cooking is now out.

What if you can't afford to buy butter, sugar, eggs this week but can afford a quid for a pack of shit shop cake?

Comparing high quality shop cake vs home cooked is pointless. If you've got a fiver to buy 'cake, bread and fruit' you can't buy the posh cake - or afford to make a good one - that's the point.

I think quite a few posters have acknowledged that you need a functioning kitchen, a fairly well stocked store cupboard, and a reasonable basic income , with accessible local shops, and spare time in order to be able to prepare good nutritious but fairly economical meals. I've lived in rented accommodation in the past with an electricity meter and running an oven is extortionately expensive in those circumstances.

ClassicGreen · 31/05/2022 14:38

Doofas · 31/05/2022 14:05

I've noticed s couple of people have said they are ditching the milkman, I was just wondering why, as we've been thinking about starting to use a milkman, missing so we don't have that. It's breakfast time and we've got no milk! Ahhhh!!!!

Having a milkman has saved me money in unexpected ways.

I don't need to pop into our local shop as regularly when we run low on milk and come out with a dozen other things I didn't go in for!

We don't drink as much as I'm careful it lasts till our next delivery. We only get deliveries three times a week.

It has cut down our plastic waste massively.

I like the taste and pushing down the foil lid on a fresh pint.

Shrugs shoulders and shuffles on in search of a milk monitor badge...

Smartsub · 31/05/2022 14:38

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 14:31

As for things like pesto, home made pesto might be nicer, but it is extortionately expensive to make.

So don't have pesto. Make a veg curry or a bolognaise instead.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 31/05/2022 14:37

As always, those with privilege can't see it from the other side. What if your freezer breaks and you can't afford to replace it? Boom - batch cooking is now out.

There are other ways to cook cheaply, for example you can batch cook to a degree by storing things in the fridge although obviously you'll have to use them up more quickly and that may well mean eating the same thing (or a variation of it) again.

What if you can't afford to buy butter, sugar, eggs this week but can afford a quid for a pack of shit shop cake?

Then buy the shop cake if that's what you want, it's not a competition as to who can eat the healthiest or who can go the longest without ever eating anything less than ideal. The scenarios you mention are quite specific, and I think one of the threads that runs through this conversation is that flexibility is one of the keys to the issue.

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:35

Banana cake with very ripe bananas that you might not eat uses hardly any butter and only one egg. Just saying.

viques · 31/05/2022 14:35

MarvelMrs · 31/05/2022 11:27

I noticed a lot of mentions of flour and sugar but that isn’t the expensive items in cakes. The costly items are eggs, butter, icing sugar, cocoa powder, chocolate, dried fruit, coconut, vanilla essence, glacé cherries.

You don’t have to put all those in. 😀

venusandmars · 31/05/2022 14:34

I think one key challenge is that making good tasting home-made cake (for example) would use sugar, butter, eggs. Making ultra-processed cake that PRETENDS to taste good, uses all kinds of emulsifiers, stabilisers, flavourings, which are not actually eggs or butter but are chemically manufactured so the mouthfeel and taste is similar.

Ultimately it is cheaper to produce the pretend food than the real food Sad

Ditto the pretend meat, and the pretend cheese.

Benjispruce4 · 31/05/2022 14:33

I make pesto with fresh spinach, avocado and sunflower seeds, garlic and olive oil which I have anyway as DD is allergic to nuts.

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 14:31

As for things like pesto, home made pesto might be nicer, but it is extortionately expensive to make.

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 14:29

Doofas · 31/05/2022 14:05

I've noticed s couple of people have said they are ditching the milkman, I was just wondering why, as we've been thinking about starting to use a milkman, missing so we don't have that. It's breakfast time and we've got no milk! Ahhhh!!!!

Because it is much more expensive. Milk from the modern milkman costs 75p a pint and that’s about to go up. So that’s £3 for 2l vs cravendale which is £2.25, and cravendale is the more expensive supermarket milk, plus there’s a delivery charge added to the milk delivery.

My 8 pints of milk costs me £8. The same amount of cravendale will cost me £4.50.

OP posts:
Smartsub · 31/05/2022 14:28

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:21

I think it depends on what you’re cooking though.

I agree that bulk cooking is definitely the way to go, but things like baking certainly aren’t cheaper. I just bought butter, and even on offer it was £1.70. Given you then buy flour and sugar and the electricity/gas on top of that you could buy a shop-bought cake for less. And while someone like me happily doesn’t need to eat cake, if you have small kids then you might want to.

So it’s not just the meals but all the added bits. Iyswim.

None of the cheap cakes you buy have butter in though.

ForestFae · 31/05/2022 14:28

3WildOnes · 31/05/2022 14:25

Haven't read all 8 pages so likely repeating other people. On another thread people were talking about their weekly food budget and mine seemed to be lower than a lot of others (£100 for amily of 5 ) I think part of tat was we cook from scratch a lot.
I can make three loaves of bead in the bread maker a week for about £1.50 , thee loaves store bought would cost more.
I can make 4 pizzas for about £4.
Of course It helps that I have a fully stocked store cupboard.

We spend about the same for a family of 5. We get an Odd Box of fruit and veg, meat from a local farm shop. We do do some quick meals but by and large I cook from scratch. I thought £100 was quite expensive, so I’m surprised others spend more.

FusionChefGeoff · 31/05/2022 14:28

As always, those with privilege can't see it from the other side.

What if your freezer breaks and you can't afford to replace it? Boom - batch cooking is now out.

What if you can't afford to buy butter, sugar, eggs this week but can afford a quid for a pack of shit shop cake?

Comparing high quality shop cake vs home cooked is pointless. If you've got a fiver to buy 'cake, bread and fruit' you can't buy the posh cake - or afford to make a good one - that's the point.

Smartsub · 31/05/2022 14:27

I'll just add my voice. Cooking from scratch isn't more expensive. Batch cooking will work out much cheaper than any ready meal or jar.

Swipe left for the next trending thread