Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable?

631 replies

AlternativePerspective · 31/05/2022 11:14

I have always cooked from scratch, and I will be the first to admit that cooking from scratch has always been more expensive than buying e.g. jar sauces etc. However as things currently stand food prices are going up so much that cooking from scratch is becoming more and more unsustainable for many people who are struggling to make ends meet.

And in an era where we’re being told to live healthily, to cut out additives where possible, and to use the healthiest ingredients, while this has always been hard to sustain, right now for many it’s unsustainable from a financial perspective, and people are going to be forced to eat jar sauces, ready meals and various other foods with additives they didn’t want or need.

I’ve just cancelled my milkman because I can no longer justify spending the money, and it’s going to take a lot before I will ever eat ready meals or cook from a jar. But compromises are going to have to be made, and in many instances for some people, it’s not going to be possible to compromise.

OP posts:
40andlols · 01/06/2022 13:11

eeksteek i'm sorry you're in this position and that you have to contend with judgy comments about TVs and IPads.

BellePeppa · 01/06/2022 13:01

BarbaraofSeville · 01/06/2022 08:40

Oh, I hate this 'poor people only want to eat rubbish and are not interested in food that's not beige' argument. How insulting.

Plus how come it's assumed that people are able to run the oven for 20 minutes to cook nuggets and chips, but couldn't possibly use the hob to make omelettes or something like spaghetti carbonara or tuna and tomato pasta, both of which are classic 'peasant food' recipes, ie cheap, don't need fancy ingredients, a lot of cooking, or a freezer to store the beige and chips in the first place.

My finances are absolutely to the bone, I have to think about money and budgets every day. Luckily I love ‘peasant’ food. Not all poor people eat junk of course but there are statistics to back the poorer/uneducated you are the more likely you are to eat more junk (remember those mums protesting about healthy school dinners and pushing burgers through the school fences unless of course it was fake news 🤷‍♀️?). I’m poor nowadays (on UC and a low paid very part time job as am also an unpaid carer to a dementia parent). This might sound weird but I have found Gousto to be a financial life saver. It covers four days dinner for me and my son and I’ve got a big pot full of their left over spices and other bits that I can add to veg, chicken or pasta for the remaining three days all for under £35 a week. I can spend that in my local supermarket and have very little to show for it. It may not work for everyone but it’s been fantastic for me.

Maggiethecat · 01/06/2022 12:52

Eeksteek · 01/06/2022 12:11

Pasta sauce is 59p. And that’s without including the energy (either power which costs or human which may be needed to earn or care for children)

Also, home cooks can’t buy emulsifiers etc etc - we have no options but to cook to with real ingredients. So while I agree it isn’t comparing like-for-like, it’s still a realistic comparison, isn’t it?

I used to cook everything from scratch, even sausages, but having to cut my budget means having to change my diet somehow. If I’ve got £2.50 left in the budget this week I can’t buy ingredients for a bulk cook that will last me four weeks. I’ve only got this week’s budget, (and I’m often playing catch up with that). But I can treat myself to a ready made lasagne for one. I’ve mostly compromised by downgrading the type of food, but keeping the quality. I rarely eat meat or fish, often having homemade vegetable soup and homemade bread. It would be cheaper to buy the bread and soup themselves, but I’m not replacing like for like - I’m replacing a homemade lasagne. I still make pizza from scratch, but only plain cheese (and I bake my bread, some spuds and a dessert at the same time). But there does come a point where you can’t drop any more brackets.

Most people really don’t ‘just’ need to budget, meal plan and cook-from-scratch more. They need a more holistic solution that accounts for the fact that people with less money often have less energy, time, creativity, transport and fewer purchasing options than people who are not already worn to the bone by being poor. If you’re working two manual jobs, you legitimately have less inclination to dick about in the kitchen for hours with lentils and spices. (I’m not saying people can’t or don’t, just that energy is a barrier, too).

The OP's premise is that cooking from scratch 'has always been more expensive than buying eg jar sauces etc'. A number of examples have been given showing that there are ways of home made being cheaper (and likely more nutritious).

Families are experiencing varying degrees of hardship - some may only be able to use a kettle to prepare meals while others are finding their food budget significantly reduced and are therefore looking at ways of stretching things.

Cooking from scratch may work for some depending on how much time, resources, cooking skills they have etc while it may not work for others. But that doesn't mean that a whole raft of people won't be able to feed their families more cheaply using home cooked meals.

Eeksteek · 01/06/2022 12:39

You see, we are there. And being there feels very different than hypothesising about it when we when we weren’t before Christmas.

I can’t take my kid anywhere this half term. I have to limit even free outings, because I can’t buy more than one tank of petrol a month. And now I’m supposed to limit the poor kid’s telly as well, if I want to be seen as deserving poor, instead of lazy and unimaginative with poor cooking and budgeting skills. Whereas tinned hot dogs (she has them cold) or sausage rolls and a movie are about the cheapest treats I can give her. (And yes, I think they’re vile too!). Yet when I didn’t have to worry about the electric bill and petrol prices, and had a little room in my budget, I was perfectly solvent adult with adequate budgeting and definitely above average cooking skills (I made my own bread, pastry, sausages. I know how cook from scratch)

I’d eat cold food if it meant my kid could watch telly. It’s about all we’ve got left! It’s soul destroying not to be able to give your kid the most basic of treats.

mustlovegin · 01/06/2022 12:33

@auldcraw

It must be wonderful to have all that information when being in the trade.

People should experiment a lot more IMO. I've discovered by chance for instance that lots of recipies are just as good with 70% of the sugar required by the recipe, that you don't really need vanilla extract in everything (with a few exceptions like custard, maybe), pricey nuts can be replaced with raisins, lamb mince could be as effective as pork mince with the right process and spices, etc.

Eeksteek · 01/06/2022 12:11

BrightYellowDaffodil · 31/05/2022 12:02

Somewhere between YABU and YANBU.

Cooking from scratch can be more expensive on the basis that you're buying decent - and "proper" - ingredients. Yes, I could buy a cheap cake from a supermarket for a couple of quid but when I look at the ingredients it will be a shedload of crap. If I make a cake at home it will be eggs, flour, butter and sugar. No emulsifiers, no stabilisers or preservatives, no palm oil or fructose syrup. And I will have most of the ingredients left for other things.

Generally cooking from scratch is a lot cheaper - I could make tomato sauce for well under £1 using a tin of chopped tomatoes, a squeeze of tomato puree, some chopped onion and maybe a clove of garlic. A jarred sauce will cost much more. Cooking with pulses and cheaper vegetables also brings the price down considerably.

Ultimately, in my experience, it comes down to a number of things: meal planning to make sure you're using ingredients you've already got and to make things go as far as possible/avoid waste, and knowing how to make cheap ingredients taste good.

Meal planning also allows you to shop more effectively - much as many have got used to doing shopping regularly, this often means convenience stores which always charge more. I plan for the week, having looked at what I've already got, then do one shop.

Pasta sauce is 59p. And that’s without including the energy (either power which costs or human which may be needed to earn or care for children)

Also, home cooks can’t buy emulsifiers etc etc - we have no options but to cook to with real ingredients. So while I agree it isn’t comparing like-for-like, it’s still a realistic comparison, isn’t it?

I used to cook everything from scratch, even sausages, but having to cut my budget means having to change my diet somehow. If I’ve got £2.50 left in the budget this week I can’t buy ingredients for a bulk cook that will last me four weeks. I’ve only got this week’s budget, (and I’m often playing catch up with that). But I can treat myself to a ready made lasagne for one. I’ve mostly compromised by downgrading the type of food, but keeping the quality. I rarely eat meat or fish, often having homemade vegetable soup and homemade bread. It would be cheaper to buy the bread and soup themselves, but I’m not replacing like for like - I’m replacing a homemade lasagne. I still make pizza from scratch, but only plain cheese (and I bake my bread, some spuds and a dessert at the same time). But there does come a point where you can’t drop any more brackets.

Most people really don’t ‘just’ need to budget, meal plan and cook-from-scratch more. They need a more holistic solution that accounts for the fact that people with less money often have less energy, time, creativity, transport and fewer purchasing options than people who are not already worn to the bone by being poor. If you’re working two manual jobs, you legitimately have less inclination to dick about in the kitchen for hours with lentils and spices. (I’m not saying people can’t or don’t, just that energy is a barrier, too).

CupidStunt22 · 01/06/2022 11:24

BarbaraofSeville · 01/06/2022 10:55

I don't understand why sugar was rationed if people were allowed that much.
That's like a family going through a bag a week Shock. What on earth were they doing with it all?

I bake quite a lot but probably only buy a bag every couple of months or so if that.

They made all of their desserts/baking etc from scratch They used it in tea etc. It was used for preserves. When you're only getting a few ounces of meat a week you need to fill up with something. And hardly anyone was obese.

If you buy one bag of sugar a few times a year you definitely do not bake "quite a lot".

BarbaraofSeville · 01/06/2022 10:55

I don't understand why sugar was rationed if people were allowed that much.
That's like a family going through a bag a week Shock. What on earth were they doing with it all?

I bake quite a lot but probably only buy a bag every couple of months or so if that.

40andlols · 01/06/2022 10:54

Benjispruce4 · 01/06/2022 10:51

@40andlols if you can only entertain your kids with a tv and iPad, it’s time for a rethink!

They're teenagers @Benjispruce4. we do a fair amount of walking, and one of them does yoga with me, the other reads quite a lot. but if you have tips for entertaining teenagers without electronics and no money for clubs you should start a thread because that advice would be golden!

Vikinga · 01/06/2022 10:52

40andlols · 01/06/2022 08:25

@Vikinga poor people aren't looking at the 58% chicken in a nugget, it's how big it looks on the plate and how long it keeps your kid quiet for. so again, no one is arguing about the nutritional value of cooking from scratch, it's the cost

That's just it. Cut it in bite size pieces and put in breadcrumbs and you don't need more chicken than the frozen kind. Because it is as filling.

Skinless and boneless chicken thighs are tastier than breast and they used to be cheaper. Not so much now I don't think.

Chicken on the bone - legs and thighs are very cheap. Cook them in a tray and have a couple with your meal with some rice/potatoes and veg/salad and it is tasty, nutritious and cheap. Take the meat out of the remaining chicken and use for other dishes or sandwiches. Use the bone to make a really tasty stock for delicious chicken soup - with veg, or noodles or vermicelli or chickpeas etc.

I make a lot of delicious and cheap meals from scratch but I know how to cook. I can make delicious gyoza and okonomiyaki with a few cheap ingredients - cabbage and carrots and flour mainly.

I toast bread that is going hard and rub with garlic and add top with half a grated tomato that is going past its best and a little oil, salt and pepper.

I make delicious potato salads very cheaply. Coleslaw is super cheap and easy yet I see it a lot for sale for upwards of £1 for a small pot.

You can make very tasty quesadillas with some sweet potato, spring onion and cheese.

These are just examples. So I think the issue is more lack of knowledge and practice than cost.

Benjispruce4 · 01/06/2022 10:51

@40andlols if you can only entertain your kids with a tv and iPad, it’s time for a rethink!

sashh · 01/06/2022 10:45

etulosba · 01/06/2022 09:29

Being Irish immigrants, in the 1940s,50s they lived on simple foods and meals involving potatoes, eggs, cheap cuts of meat and simple vegetables.

Everybody ate like that in the 1940s and early 1950s. Food was rationed.

Not everything was rationed, fruit and veg were not for a start. Whether you could get hold of any fruit is another matter, you were mostly limited to what was seasonal and grown in the UK.

I'm nt sure if offal was rationed, if it was it was still fairly cheap

Another thing not everyone realises is that rationed food still had to be paid for and during the war prices did go up.

This is a 1942 ration for an adult who wasn't working in a mine or agriculture and wasn't pregnant.

Bacon & Ham 4 oz
Other meat value of 1 shilling and 2 pence (equivalent to 2 chops)
Butter 2 oz
Cheese 2 oz
Margarine 4 oz
Cooking fat 4 oz
Milk 3 pints
Sugar 8 oz
Preserves 1 lb every 2 months
Tea 2 oz
Eggs 1 fresh egg (plus allowance of dried egg)
Sweets 12 oz every 4 weeks

40andlols · 01/06/2022 10:36

Hmm... not sure on that one @Benjispruce4. You can cook with a kettle if you have to but you can't entertain kids with an oven Smile and they can't do their homework on it.

i'm being deliberately goady because we aren't there (yet!) having to make decisions like that but people in our community actually do.

we do have a great facebook group that helps with whitegoods but another problem is pride. many won't access the help because of that

Benjispruce4 · 01/06/2022 10:29

I think I’d prioritise an oven/hob over a TV or iPad. I also think food and nutrition and budgeting should be compulsory at secondary school to GCsE standard. It’s so fundamentally important as it impacts every other aspect of our lives.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/06/2022 10:28

We make jam from picking ripe fruit growing in the woods and other areas.
Water, sugar, boil, done.

You don't need a lot of equipment, the local heart foundation has loads of gadgets for naff all. Some groups on social media are giving stuff away.

Some basic utensils and some pans and you're away. Dp's family back home doesn't even use cutlery.😂
When I met Dp she had this crazily sharp knife from back home. That cut and organized everything. Brilliant.

40andlols · 01/06/2022 10:21

thanks @auldcraw i forget about cous cous and the fact you can make it with such little energy is fantastic. mine like it with just a vegetable stock cube

Charles11 · 01/06/2022 10:14

You do need time and access to ingredients but you don't need extra gadgets or a larder full of spices to cook from scratch.
You can perk up lots of dishes with a teaspoon of dried mixed herbs or make a curry with some curry powder. You'd need some salt too and maybe pepper.
A lot of flavour comes from the vegetables and the ingredients you use.
I think it's more satisfying to eat freshly made nourishing meals so you're fuller for longer and don't need to snack as much (whether you want to is a different matter)

auldcraw · 01/06/2022 10:09

Jam sandwich to fill up kids is no more unhealthy than cake. And scones if baking use less oven time and fat than cake. Drop scones and crepes need no oven time. Keep cake in cake tins it will last longer. And if making pastry - use half butter and half lard - you won't taste it, imo get better pastry, and good for jam tarts, custard tarts and quiche - which is a great cheap tea, using up bits of bacon and oven space when you have any. Cake keeping if simple is cheapest, a batter of 8 oz each of Flour, eggs, fat (half butter and Marg) - can be turned into a lemon drizzle, or chocolate cake, banana cake or whatever, you can split the batter and make different types at once. The bigger the cake the longer the baking time, so use paper cases rather than make a big cake. Also cous cous hasn't been mentioned I think - boil the kettle, and pour into cous cous which has had a stock cube chilli powder and cumin mixed through. Use this instead of rice to save the gas. I'm getting old in the tooth - my gran was a cook, my granda a baker and I'm full of useless info which I hope might be handy to some.

40andlols · 01/06/2022 09:54

I think what we're seeing on this thread is that it probably is sustainable to cook cheaply from scratch if you have transport or local budget supermarkets, money to fill a larder with spices etc, storage for batch cooking, electronic goods (slowcooker, blender etc). no allergies. And don't want anything particularly exotic.

Otherwise it's a trade off - I like a bit of variety so i'd rather have a shop bought £1.59 jambalaya every now and again rather than another bowl of stew that i managed to make for 78p

mustlovegin · 01/06/2022 09:53

YABU OP

You need to look at like for like. It's insane to compare home made cake with £1 Cadbury brownies like someone did upthread.

Cooking from scratch will be often cheaper if you know what to make.

Also most recipies in blogs, TV, etc are full of superflous expensive ingredients for the sake of clicks and to make them seem more interesting or exotic. If you are skilled and know what you are doing, you can easily leave out or replace them without significantly affecting the flavour (or even sometimes appearance)

Benjispruce4 · 01/06/2022 09:44

@NumberCurtains you can cook from scratch using tinned or frozen food and veg.

NumberCurtains · 01/06/2022 09:43

Yanbu. It's a lie that coking from scratch is cheaper. One of my kids had a couple of allergies when she was small, so I had to cook everything we ate from scratch, until we managed to see a dietician who was able to recommend a load of precooked and processed 'safe' foods.

It was appallingly expensive to cook from scratch! Not to mention time consuming (luckily I was on maternity leave. This would not have been sustainable alongside a full time job. Despite the fact that I would batch cook and try and make meals that had a lot of the same key ingredients.

Another thing that people don't factor in is storage. And shopping time. We have a small house with a tiny fridge and freezer, so we really can't store much. Cooking from scratch also uses fresh ingredients, which go out of date sooner..if you don't live near a supermarket, this is a problem!

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/06/2022 09:42

40andlols · 01/06/2022 09:20

@Onionpatch I actually never thought of blending the chicken up. although i have no blender, and couldn't afford to buy one. But yes i concede that could eek the chicken out to make the price more comparable with frozen nuggets.

We're all having nuggets tonight.
2 frozen breasts, 1 egg, spices, flour, breadcrumbs, 2 carrots grated, beetroot grated, a dash of mayonnaise and salad cream, and a couple of garlic cloves for an Eastern European salad. No chips or bread.

The nuggets are far more filling and superior to the shop-bought bags.

Back to the op, why do people serve lasagne with chips or a jacket potato, that's adding a dense card with a dense carb?😂

Benjispruce4 · 01/06/2022 09:41

@etulosba Was it? Didn’t know that.🙄

etulosba · 01/06/2022 09:29

Being Irish immigrants, in the 1940s,50s they lived on simple foods and meals involving potatoes, eggs, cheap cuts of meat and simple vegetables.

Everybody ate like that in the 1940s and early 1950s. Food was rationed.