Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL possessive over my son

107 replies

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:28

I don’t really know how to go around this with her or if this is normal grandparent behaviour. I suppose I want to know if I’m BU to be fed up with her.

MIL and I have an okay relationship, we’ve had big issues in the past but we are civil and said issues have been left in the past. My DP and I have a two month old baby, first child for us and second grandchild for MIL. DP’s nephew was born at the start of the pandemic so MIL didn’t get any time with him as a little baby which I suppose is rather upsetting as he’s her first grandchild. Now that we’ve had our baby after all restrictions have been lifted we cannot seem to catch a break from her and her possessiveness over him is too much. Every time we see her she makes an instant grab for him, takes his bottles out of his changing bag so she can make it up and then won’t give it to me or DP because she wants to feed him. We’ve been out for a couple walks with her where I’ve let her push the pram and she’s power walked way way ahead of us with the baby (I can’t walk fast or far due to a lifelong condition). Just the other day we were out for a family meal and she got visibly angry at DP’s auntie for holding him and letting him fall asleep on her because she wanted him. She fully had a go at her in front of everyone and had a face like thunder until said auntie passed him over, it was honestly very childish. She will not stop going on and on about having him overnight which both DP and I have agreed wouldn’t be a good idea (she’s not very safety conscious and is incredibly forgetful, for example leaves stove/oven on on a weekly basis, will leave front door keys on the outside of the door overnight…)

Saturday we received a £150 gift card to a nice restaurant in the post from her with a note detailing all the items she bought for DS to stay with her when we go out for food. It’s like she’s trying to bribe us into handing him over and it’s made me really uncomfortable. My DP called her and told her she shouldn’t have done that and as much as we appreciate the gesture we’re not comfortable leaving the baby to go out as he’s barely two months old. She had a strop and hung up on him and hasn’t spoken to him since.

I don’t know what to do without it causing a row that I don’t want to start. She’s just too much and she’s causing herself emotional distress by expecting him to be in her arms 24/7. I can’t let this go on though as it’s causing me serious anxiety every time we go to see her. AIBU?

OP posts:
declutteringmymind · 30/05/2022 23:19

Maybe your mum can look after him while you go for that meal.

mrsfollowill · 30/05/2022 23:18

I always remember MIL saying to me (in all seriousness) that if DH and I both died our DS should go and live with her as children 'belong' with their fathers family. Yes MIL you are 75 yrs old and FIL has dementia- would be perfect!
Never mind DH's brother/my sister who had young families and would be an obvious option.
Bloody hell she is still going and will be 90 soon! DS is a full grown adult these days so not an option. She is so blunt - it's lucky I'm v easy going- she once said to me - MrsFollowill- you are a fattish [how is that even a word!] woman! how do you feel about XYZ? I told her to bugger off Grin
Seriously be blunt with her - he is not 'hers' he is your DS- I once said this to MIL- she had her time with her babies (she had 5!) I wanted my time with my DS and it's what's up to me! I also reminded her how her own MIL treated her (as she moaned about it all the time) so how would you feel if your mil said this to you?

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 23:17

Just so you all know, Thursday is not happening at all. Not even just for the fact that I need some distance from her and to distance her from my son a little bit but because my own mother actually hasn’t seen him in a while as she’s been away. I know it sound very “my mum is better than yours” but my mum is nothing like this and DS is her first grandchild. She’s of course excited and I’ll be honest as she’s my mum I was expecting her to over step a little bit but she asks me or DP every time before lifting him out of his pram/car seat and actually does things to be helpful. Even DP says he would be 100% comfortably leaving DS with my mum because being a grandmother hasn’t made her crazy.

We left DS once with MIL for less than 5 minutes to pop to a cash machine on the corner, DS was fast asleep in his pram when we left and when we came back he was awake and being bounced around and sung to by MIL. I can’t trust her to let my baby sleep more than anything.

OP posts:
BreadInCaptivity · 30/05/2022 23:16

Firstly you need to talk to your DH and tell him quite clearly you are not having this precious time as a family ruined by his mother.

That means he needs a very straight adult conversation with her to say:

  • you will not be leaving the baby in her sole care for hours, never mind overnight
  • she needs to pack in the manipulative "gifts"
  • if you go out with her again and there is another embarrassing scene then you won't go out with her again ever
  • She's been a parent and needs to back off overall - she's not the star of this show. No more stealing the bottles and she gets to hold baby and hand them back when parents say so. If she refuses/sulks/strops then she doesn't hold him at all.

If she can't agree to this then it's not a negotiation and she doesn't see any of you until she starts behaving appropriately.

If she agrees then flouts then rules then the boundaries get even firmer.

It's good she wants to be involved and cares, but she's massively over-stepping and you need to nip this in the bud now or prepare for years of stress.

Her behaviour is not normal nor is it sustainable. Both my parents and in laws were very (still are) active in their grandchildrens's lives but leave the parenting to me and DH and have never, ever behaved in the ways you describe.

That why when the children were tiny we were happy to hand them over for cuddles because we knew they would always hand them back, never make a scene if asked to do so.

Your MIL is setting up a situation that's hurting everyone, including herself.

namnamnam22 · 30/05/2022 23:11

My DD was born in September last year and honestly the first time you say no to a family member will be the hardest but it’s worth it. My DM was very overpowering and I felt horrible that I might hurt her feelings but she’s MY child. Honestly once you stand up to people once it’s a walk in the park from then on x

shas19 · 30/05/2022 23:10

This stops now. Don't worry about upsetting her. She's not worried about upsetting you when she's hogging your newborn baby and bribing you to go out and leave him. Just tell her this behaviour isn't acceptable and it stops now, you'll always be his nan but not his parent and to take a step back. You appreciate the help and spoiling him but there are boundaries she needs to respect. Your husband needs to put his foot down as she's his mum but if he won't then that's a discussion you will need to have with him also. She definitely sounds mental though so probably won't go down well but don't make yourself feel uncomfortable just to keep the peace! Enjoy YOUR baby on YOUR terms!

Iamnotamermaid · 30/05/2022 23:09

She most definitely needs winding in. Some big boundaries need to be put in place & expectations managed here, plus a bit of respect for you as his mother. She does not grab him, she asks if she can hold him.

He is your son and you decide when MIL can see him. Return the £150 gift card with thanks but no thanks. Let her sulk - she has been completely out of order.

YarnHoarder · 30/05/2022 23:04

She sounds a little like my auntie, I'm one of the youngest cousins so my older ones were having kids as I was reaching adulthood. I remember visiting one of them when the baby was about 6 months old and my auntie (grandma to baby) wouldn't let me hold him longer than a few minutes or allow me to encourage play or read. She just wanted all his attention on her and it was hard to deal with, I eventually stopped visiting (visits were infrequent as I was 500 miles away at uni anyway) as it was just spent sat quietly making small talk. I know my auntie had some issues surrounding babies and little boys in particular having unfortunately lost a young baby boy in similar circumstances to my own birth (we also shared a birthday although I was several years younger) so I wasn't sure if it was personal about me or generally behaved a bit possessive.

I do think your husband needs to take the lead on this and it's his parent but at the same time if she won't take no for an answer you might have to say something yourself. Explain you want her to be involved but have very clear boundaries and rules. Reiterate baby won't be away from you for a long while yet (don't put a date on it) but you'll talk about it more when you feel ready. Don't be afraid to be a bit blunt, when she's speed walking away ask her to slow and stop, maybe even ask why she's doing this when you're all out together?

Don't go Thursday, while it's lovely she wants to be involved clearly the boundaries need work. Start meeting somewhere neutral (Costa, small park, etc) with a mental time limit for a few weeks so you're more in control of the situation and can leave when you're ready. I would keep any communication between you through messages, they're more easily ignored and replies considered rather than on the phone where she might be more likely to be a bit manipulative in her wordings.

LittleOwl153 · 30/05/2022 23:03

I would take a massive step back from that batshit! I assume youbare on maternity leave. This is your time with baby - and baby's time with you!

I would say no to Thursday and any other time your husband is not around for the time being clearly she doesn't respect you so I'd keep well away.

I'd discuss with your partner exactly what you are prepared to accept and outline that to her the next time you see her together. I'd write it down so you have what's agreed to return back to and hold her to.

Learn to say no. Just no. She needs to accept that baby is your child NOT hers.

OldStyleIntroductions · 30/05/2022 23:00

Is this for real? If so she sounds unhinged and to be avoided at all costs. I'm a granny and wouldn't dream of acting so demented.

Anyone reading this thread who's not yet married, take heed, you marry a family not an individual. If his family are causing major issues, walk away and save yourself decades of anguish.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 30/05/2022 22:59

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:57

@kweeble MIL and I might be civil but hell will freeze over before I spend time with her without DP there. I feel as though I need a witness every time I’m around her at the moment.

Simple fix. Stop being around her. Say no. Shut the door. And let DH handle the rest. Enjoy this time with your little one because once it's gone, it's gone x

catandcoffee · 30/05/2022 22:58

No this is not normal behavior. I say this as a very hands on Grandmother.

You are the Mother and the most important person in the babies life.

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:57

@kweeble MIL and I might be civil but hell will freeze over before I spend time with her without DP there. I feel as though I need a witness every time I’m around her at the moment.

OP posts:
Tulips21 · 30/05/2022 22:54

Ignore the demands and say no.
Reply to her recent demand of " No we wont be over Thursday' Or simply ignore and block her number

LovePoppy · 30/05/2022 22:54

You won’t be causing a row. She will

let her fall out with you. Enjoy the silence until she can be an adult

until then, stop letting her run roughshod over you.

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:53

@GlitchStitch I didn’t actually know what was going on at first as I was talking to DP’s cousin who I was meeting for the first time but I could hear her just complaining at first that she wanted to hold him and then fully throwing a fit because DS was falling asleep on DP’s aunties shoulder. DP told her to keep it down as another table was watching and she tried to tell him that the baby shouldn’t be sleeping now anyway to which I said to her he can sleep when he likes, he’s literally 8 weeks old and that he’s clearly comfortable with auntie. Said auntie (MIL’s sister) then told her he’s tired and doesn’t feel like entertaining her right now. She absolutely hated being told in front of everyone and continued to press into auntie that she wanted him to be awake when she holds him because she “doesn’t see him enough” 🙄. Safe to say I won’t be going out for food in public with her again, it was so embarrassing.

OP posts:
Isitcake · 30/05/2022 22:50

No,not bringing him over on Thursday, you need to chill out and realise we are his parents not you. Sorry to be harsh but you don't seem to understand. We still love you a d we'll see you soon.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 30/05/2022 22:50

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:43

@Isitcake I totally agree, but my DP is a bit of a sugar coater which means it never comes across to her as a serious conversation. When I say something to her she just says “I’m sorry I’ve made you feel that way” but then does the same things the next time we see her. My partner did finally man up a bit on Saturday when she started to tell him to stop being stupid and just accept her “help” which is why she now isn’t speaking to him…but she’s text me asking me to bring the baby over Thursday.

"Sorry Thursday won't work for me. Maybe some other time x"

kweeble · 30/05/2022 22:48

Don’t go on Thursday - this is your time with your baby - she’s had hers. I would avoid seeing her alone - you need distance so she doesn’t ruin this special time for you.

Regularmumnetter · 30/05/2022 22:46

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:43

@Isitcake I totally agree, but my DP is a bit of a sugar coater which means it never comes across to her as a serious conversation. When I say something to her she just says “I’m sorry I’ve made you feel that way” but then does the same things the next time we see her. My partner did finally man up a bit on Saturday when she started to tell him to stop being stupid and just accept her “help” which is why she now isn’t speaking to him…but she’s text me asking me to bring the baby over Thursday.

SAY NO!! not until she can explain her weird behaviour

toomuchlaundry · 30/05/2022 22:45

I’d be moving if you live close to her

GlitchStitch · 30/05/2022 22:44

The poor Auntie. Didn't anyone say anything when your MIL started having a go at her?

peachy3 · 30/05/2022 22:43

@Isitcake I totally agree, but my DP is a bit of a sugar coater which means it never comes across to her as a serious conversation. When I say something to her she just says “I’m sorry I’ve made you feel that way” but then does the same things the next time we see her. My partner did finally man up a bit on Saturday when she started to tell him to stop being stupid and just accept her “help” which is why she now isn’t speaking to him…but she’s text me asking me to bring the baby over Thursday.

OP posts:
declutteringmymind · 30/05/2022 22:42

This is not normal behaviour.

Is she ok???

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 22:42

You need to remind her who his parents are. If she gets annoyed at someone else holding his say ‘we’ll I’m his Mum and I’m ok with Auntie holding him.’ When she mentions overnights Laing and say ‘oh no I’d miss him too much, he’ll stay in his own wee bed.’ Stop her grabbing him by putting him in a fling or turning away candy telling her to calm down. As long as you manage her behaviour she’ll realise she’s pushing things. Let her stew if she’s not talking to you she can silk like a child but she’s the one cutting off her nose to spite her face. Leave her to not talk to you and I guarantee she’ll break first and realise that the silent treatment didn’t work.