Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want my friend to move out

167 replies

ImNotBossyImtheBoss · 30/05/2022 17:25

My friend of 20 years, Christine, has lived (lodged?) with me and my husband for the last 5 years. At the beginning we needed the extra money for the mortgage, we are both good friends with Christine and the set up worked well for us all.

The last 5 years have been intense, Christine became very physically unwell and her mental health suffered as a result, we supported her through this. (She has no living family, which is very relevant, we are her support network.) We all went through lockdowns etc. together.

Last year my husband and I had a baby, so now we have a lovely one year old DD. I have found it hard being both her support system and caring for my DD. Additionally she works shifts and trying to keep a baby quiet around someone sleeping in the day is stressful!

In general she is a happy, helpful addition to our household but I'm starting to feel a bit done with having another person about the place. However I would feel horrendous kicking her out. After such a long time this is very much her home too, I know she doesn't want to live alone or with strangers. I don't think our friendship would be the same if I asked her to leave, and I would miss her.

An aside: she has also never babysat our daughter, which she is well placed to do as she sees her everyday! We've asked twice but she said she'd prefer not, which I understand, we decided to have a baby knowing we don't have a support system nearby. But it's also sad when it's been over a year and you just want your friend to give you one night out with your spouse!

I would just like her to not be here half the time! (Reading it, I can see IABU, she isn't a friend to be there only when it's convenient to me.)

She pays a going rate to lodge with us, and this is set up as her permanent address re. electoral roll, bills, etc. I.e. this is not a casual living arrangement.

OP posts:
Astralis · 01/06/2022 23:30

Indeed! The absolute cheek of expecting poor Christine to live through the renovations and one finished, move into a granny annexe when she's used to having the house itself. The OP should just live in a tent with her family. 😂

KettrickenSmiled · 01/06/2022 22:47

PerseverancePays · 30/05/2022 17:43

Difficult conversation needs to be had. Would it be worth taking on additional debt to build her a granny annex so that she would still be part of the household but more separate?
If you were going to have a meeting to discuss this , then I would suggest the following agenda:
Arrange a mutually convenient time to have the meeting.
Outline what you think the problem is, take your time with this. Don't drag in or allow anyone else to drag in other issues , like her lack of giving anything back as in babysitting , stick to one problem, that her living with you is not working for you anymore.
Once you have the problem thrashed out, suggest solutions, don't evaluate them or shoot them down, just brainstorm.
Evaluate,
Choose a solution,
Arrange to reconvene to see if the solution is working and if it needs tweaking.

I feel for you, it's going to be a tough conversation, but ultimately it's your house and your life, and if it's not working anymore, then it's not working.

Would it be worth taking on additional debt to build her a granny annex so that she would still be part of the household but more separate?
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

drpet49 · 31/05/2022 22:57

Give her notice to move out. You have your child to think about.

milkyaqua · 31/05/2022 22:33

It's very easy to read and think: what a pair of saps. But she is our friend, she isn't some random lodger and like a lot of situations it didn't become this way over night, little by little shifts...

You don't sound like saps. You sound really warm and nice and caring, but it is time to be a warm, nice, caring family of three.

I am a bit gobsmacked that this friend has not reciprocated with even a night out for you, looking after the baby while you two relax, after all the care you've shown her. I should think anyone that resolutely self-centred should have the grit and wherewithal to find another place to lodge/live, but fully expect you will be showered with reluctance, excuses, obligation, and guilting, as she seems to be keen to protect her own comforts (at your/the baby's expense).

DFOD · 31/05/2022 17:23

There are two dynamics going on here.

First: Lodger / Land lord which seems to have worked well. Transactional in nature and suitable for both parties. The point that a PP made stating that the OP benefited more because she owned the property is wrong because it’s irrelevant to the transaction.

So overall this seems a balanced and acceptable arrangement to both parties.

Second: Friendship. This has been one sided and disappointing for at least a year. The OP has supported her friend unendingly even compromising her own experience of motherhood. The OP senses / knows now that her friend does not have the same family values or any notions of reciprocity in friendship when it came to her newborn baby daughter. That must sting.

I agree with @billy1966 (as ever) that this friend is not as “fragile” as you think. She will be fine and it’s important that you prioritise your own little family without any feelings of guilt or obligation to Christine.

Cherrysoup · 31/05/2022 15:33

I’d just add, give her a moving out date and be firm, don’t let it drag on for months. Also, don’t tolerate any nonsense re her needing to save for 6 months for a deposit etc or help her with rent. She isn’t your responsibility. I’m horrified that you’re having to subdue your child’s noise in her own house due to the lodger!

QueenWatevraWaNabi · 31/05/2022 15:03

If not now, then when? You don't want to be posting on gransnet about this when you're 80 and she's still never moved out!

pigwood · 31/05/2022 13:45

@ImNotBossyImtheBoss you have both given her SO much more than lodging and there is nothing wrong with saying to her that you both want to be back on your own for the benefit of your new little family unit . If you give her excuses to make it less difficult for you to tell her , she will likely try and talk you round and give you reasons why she can't move out. I think you and your husband will have to dig your heels in and tell her up front that you need her to move out , give her a definite timeline for this or I doubly she will go. It's a hard situation and you've been a wonderful friend but she sounds a bit like an emotional drain !

Astralis · 31/05/2022 13:02

In some ways the hard part is over: you and your husband agree that now is the time to move on from having a lodger. You just need to stay on course.

I would suggest that before speaking to her, you decide between yourselves what message you will give. Be clear, give a short message, be impersonal and don't take on her problems as yours to fix.

So: "As we discussed before xx was born, life has changed a lot! It's clear that having a lodger doesn't fit with family life the way it used to, so we wanted to talk to you about moving forward. We know that lodgers only require 28 days notice to leave but we can extend that to two months. (Don't offer to help her find a place otherwise you'll get drawn into why "this one's not suitable either").
I know that this was inevitable at some point, it's not like any of us expected you to be our lodger forever, and we'll still spend time together as friends.

As an aside, you might find that moving out is the making of her. She'll probably be reluctant to make the change but she'll eventually gain a bit of independence and confidence.

Stellamar · 31/05/2022 12:50

She surely can't have imagined that she would live with you forever.

It sounds like you have given her a lot of support during what was an immensely challenging time for you as new parents. Please don't feel bad or guilty about telling her that it's time to move on.

BadLad · 31/05/2022 12:30

Inklingpot · 31/05/2022 12:05

This is right up there with the poster who told an LL she should gift the house to her tenant.

That suggestion was nowhere near as illogical as it sounds. The OP on that thread had inherited a run-down house with a tenant whom it would have been impossible to evict, who was locked into an agreement to pay a miniscule amount of rent, and for whom she would have been obliged to spend a considerable sum on renovations to keep the house in liveable condition. Giving the house to the tenant probably wasn't the best course of action but it wasn't totally without its advantages. This annex suggestion is far sillier.

Dashdotdotdash · 31/05/2022 12:14

Maybe start paving the way by allowing your child to live normally without having to be quiet during the day?

Dashdotdotdash · 31/05/2022 12:10

Tandora · 31/05/2022 09:37

This is the crux of the problem- people (including OP it seems , aren’t understanding this)- If she pays full market rent it’s her home. Tenants have rights. OP is her landlord but as long as friend is paying rent it’s her home.

She's not a tenant, she's a lodger. Completely different position legally.

Inklingpot · 31/05/2022 12:05

PerseverancePays · 30/05/2022 17:43

Difficult conversation needs to be had. Would it be worth taking on additional debt to build her a granny annex so that she would still be part of the household but more separate?
If you were going to have a meeting to discuss this , then I would suggest the following agenda:
Arrange a mutually convenient time to have the meeting.
Outline what you think the problem is, take your time with this. Don't drag in or allow anyone else to drag in other issues , like her lack of giving anything back as in babysitting , stick to one problem, that her living with you is not working for you anymore.
Once you have the problem thrashed out, suggest solutions, don't evaluate them or shoot them down, just brainstorm.
Evaluate,
Choose a solution,
Arrange to reconvene to see if the solution is working and if it needs tweaking.

I feel for you, it's going to be a tough conversation, but ultimately it's your house and your life, and if it's not working anymore, then it's not working.

This is right up there with the poster who told an LL she should gift the house to her tenant.

Flossyhair · 31/05/2022 11:11

What happens if you want to have another child or your little one has her friends round when she gets older, how will you keep everything quiet for your friend?

What happens if in the futue her health deteriorates further and you end up taking on even more responsibility for her an her declining physical and mental health?

Seriously, it's time to give her notice. This is beyond the boundaries of a healthy lodger/landlord/friendship.

Give her notice and she will have to negotiate her own wants and needs for new accommodation and compromise like everyone else has to.

Derbee · 31/05/2022 11:02

All this talk about whether she’s a tenant or a lodger are irrelevant. It’s YOUR home, and it’s only HER home until you decide it’s not.

The 6 month Covid notice periods are over anyway. The max you’d need to give her is 2 months notice, which seems fair for a friend.

Presumably you’re not holding an official deposit from her in a deposit scheme etc, so she’s a lodger with very few rights to notice etc anyway.

DockOTheBay · 31/05/2022 10:28

Tandora · 30/05/2022 23:28

I’m going to go against the grain here- it sounds like you want to evict her because you’re a bit hurt/ offended that she wont babysit? I can completely understand why she wants to keep that boundary- if she didn’t she might worry where it would end. she pays the full market rent to lodge with you , so you are in no sense doing her a favour- you are profiting from her. why should she be required to offer you free childcare (in addition to presumably paying off your mortgage).

Maybe because the OP and her husband have provided her with mental and physical support for the last 5 years when she was ill. Its not a normal lodger/landlord relationship.

Eddielizzard · 31/05/2022 10:26

Well you've given her a massive amount of support over the years with her illness: lifts, cooking, etc. and she's not prepared to do a single night's babysitting for you. That would piss me off. Yes, it's time she left. Seems the relationship is rather one sided.

Beelezebub · 31/05/2022 10:21

The fact that you discussed during the pandemic that if things weren’t working after the baby was born means you can lead into the conversation with grace now.

Don’t get drawn into extraneous details. Just tell her that as you anticipated it might, the addition of a child has changed things and the current arrangement no longer suits. If she asks why you could say that there are now 4 of you in the house, not 3, and one of them will be growing and taking up more space and making more noise as she gets older and it’s the right time to focus on family life; that an arrangement that worked a few years ago doesn’t work now.

Make sure she knows that you still want to be good and close friends, tell her you understand it may be a shock and unwelcome news, offer to be involved (not help!) in the search for somewhere new if she wants your opinion on places she’s considering, but don’t apologise and don’t take her needing to find somewhere else as your problem to fix.

Before you speak to her, do make sure that you and your husband have worked through what youll do in all the worst case scenarios, as the last thing you want is to talk to her and be blindsided by her on the day of the conversation if she flies off the handle, or a few weeks down the line if she won’t leave.

She surely can’t have expected that you would all live together forever.

BexW40 · 31/05/2022 10:20

It's your house, I think after 5years you e gone way above and beyond. I'd say now you have the DD you feel the room is needed and give her time to find a place.

Tandora · 31/05/2022 10:20

DelurkingLawyer · 31/05/2022 10:06

@Tandora - the main legal case about the difference between a lodger and a tenant, was about a woman who thought she had taken someone in as a lodger but she was in fact a tenant! So it’s easily done. And in those days the Rent Acts made it a protected tenancy so the homeowner was stuck with her for as long as she wanted….

Oh interesting!!

Dillidilly · 31/05/2022 10:17

Also, I don't think you will be doing your friend any favours if you let her stay.
You were incredibly kind to support her through physical illness/MH problems.
But her next step needs to be towards living a proper independent, adult lifestyle. Not living somewhere where she has managed to make the household revolve around her needs and preferences.
I think its very unhealthy for all of you to have a third adult living with you.
Good luck, and try to remember this will actually be beneficial for her in the long run.

bluebell34567 · 31/05/2022 10:17

SleeplessInEngland · 31/05/2022 09:47

You're the one that knows her, OP - how do you think she'll take it? Is she prone to feeling hard done by?

i wouldnt care how she feels.
op is already hard done by.

bluebell34567 · 31/05/2022 10:11

billy1966 · 31/05/2022 09:28

Since when do lodgers get emotional support, meals cooked for them and lifts when they need them?

Huge emotional support during her baby's first year. What "lodger" gets that?

This is what the OP has said has gone on.

Not a normal lodger arrangement.

So a reciprocal arrangement of the odd offer of babysitting would have been appreciated.

It hasn't happened which is what it is.

She wants her house back, she shouldn't hesitate to move her out.

OP, I strongly recommend you do NOT offer or take responsibility for finding her suitable replacement accommodation.

That would be VERY foolish.

She needs to sort herself out.

She isn't half as fragile as you think.

Anyone who could live with a couple and never once offer to even babysit for a couple of hours is NOT that fragile.

If you offer to find her a new home, you will bitterly regret it.

It is NOT your responsibility.

agree.

DelurkingLawyer · 31/05/2022 10:06

@Tandora - the main legal case about the difference between a lodger and a tenant, was about a woman who thought she had taken someone in as a lodger but she was in fact a tenant! So it’s easily done. And in those days the Rent Acts made it a protected tenancy so the homeowner was stuck with her for as long as she wanted….

Swipe left for the next trending thread