Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what on earth happened with the Leiland James case?

155 replies

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:04

Utterly horrific, but AIBU to wonder what on earth prompted a woman with no criminal history to ‘leather’ a baby? Even people who believe a good hiding won’t hurt them and other such stupid statements don’t apply it to babies.

OP posts:
Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:58

The name thing is much discussed in adoption circles. Personally I have no issue with changing a child’s name at Leiland-James’ age. I know some disagree.

OP posts:
Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:57

@10HailMarys - so odd they thought smacking a baby was all right. Who thinks that!?

I can understand the frustration on some level: it’s easy for me to say ‘of course his sleeping and eating is unsettled - his whole world is turned upside down!’ but I know on a visceral level you sometimes have a response to this which isn’t logical.

But SMACKING? I’ve had to walk away from my own DS when he’s grinding my gears and I think that’s normal.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 30/05/2022 15:57

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:55

@Sortilege its that which makes me wonder about it all. Did she genuinely think there was nothing wrong with ‘leathering’ a baby?

No, she knew. She had drawn her DH into a folie a deux.

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:55

@Sortilege its that which makes me wonder about it all. Did she genuinely think there was nothing wrong with ‘leathering’ a baby?

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 30/05/2022 15:54

My guess is that they had no history of abusing children simply because they'd never had a child of their own to abuse.

Having read the BBC news article about the case and the father's testimony in court, it sounds like they were absolutely not a couple who a) should have been parents or b) had realistic expectations of what adopting a baby would be like. They presumably said all the right things to the social workers when they were going through the process, but the father's testimony suggests that frankly the pair of them were absolutely devoid of empathy and treated adopting a baby like buying a pet.

The father said in court that they didn't bond with Leiland because he 'cried and moaned a lot', 'woke up every few hours in the night' and 'wouldn't always eat' which to me sounds like the behaviour of LITERALLY ANY BABY, let alone one who has just been moved to a new home. He said the felt he was 'a different boy to the one we saw with his foster parents', and it was annoying because they 'couldn't get any laughs out of him' as if he was some kind of item they'd bought from a shop that wasn't as described. Horrible.

They also refused to call him by his actual name. His name was Leiland-James Corkill and he was used to being called Leiland but they insisted on calling him James because they didn't like the name Leiland and they didn't want his birth mother to be able to trace him. The Council actually told them that it was important that they called by his proper name but they ignored that advice and refused to see why it was 'a big deal'.

The father also said they both smacked him - A BABY - on the hand or the bum several times a week and that Leiland 'didn't like it' and 'stuck his lip out' but that he still doesn't think there was anything wrong with that. He also said they discussed not keeping but weren't aware they could 'just hand him back'.

It's honestly like they didn't see him as a human being at all. They're fucking nuts.

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:54

@LemonPalmTree the man game is an old and well established one.

Our expectations of males and females are different and so are the ways they are programmed to behave. I’m hardly weeping in dismay for her Hmm my pity lies with the baby, but I do acknowledge something must be badly wrong within her, and that does evoke some response from me.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 30/05/2022 15:52

BeenHereForYonkyDoodles · 30/05/2022 15:22

I'll never understand why she didn't just hand him back either.
Thoroughly disgusting excuse for a woman.
I hope she gets a hard time in prison.

It’s true. Just phone SS and hand him back. But the thing about bullies and narcissists is they feel they have to maintain their public face. It’s a warped sense of priorities. I was surprised she was as candid as she was in the texts to her husband. Why he walked away without convictions I do not understand.

Merryoldgoat · 30/05/2022 15:50

It is still not illegal to hit your child. People massively underestimate the force they use and how fast they snap. It’s a conscious decision to not use physical punishment and you see on here all the time people defending it.

She may well have thought what she was doing was reasonable until one day it wasn’t.

It’s irrelevant why she did it tbh. She did it, she refused help or to admit she had problems and that poor baby was the victim.

I think you’re extremely naive about how many people hit their children.

Sortilege · 30/05/2022 15:50

All the vetting in the world is meaningless if she had never had sole charge of an infant before. Anyone can be kind to a child in a group setting for an hour or cope with an evening of babysitting. Maintaining calm in the face of a crying baby is true parenting.

LemonPalmTree · 30/05/2022 15:48

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:33

In a bizarre way I do feel for her a bit - her state of mind must have been awful. But while I can sort of understand a single loss of temper the texts seem to indicate it wasn’t just that.

You wouldn’t be saying that if a man murdered a child

ENoeuf · 30/05/2022 15:46

Her husband was cleared wasn't he? But those messages, my god if I'd sent those to dh when ours were babies he'd have been on the phone to the GP and my mum and probably taken time off to stop me being able to hurt them.

ElenaSt · 30/05/2022 15:42

Who remembers some years ago the Romanian orphans? Many were brought to the U.K. and adopted and families could not cope with these damaged children.

I imagine that people foster and adopt with good intentions but the reality of a child or infant that is perhaps more demanding than they thought it would be beings out many emotions in people, some negative.

I guess she didn't hand Leiland back because she felt a sense of shame that she was unable to cope with looking after him.

It's horrendous to see his sweet face and know that when he was distressed doe whatever reason the hands that should have been caressing and calming him were the fists that caused him pain and suffering.

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:40

It’s just horribly sad, @LadyEloise1 , isn’t it? I think I echo your ‘why oh why’.

@RewildingAmbridge you can indeed. I suppose the real horribleness here is that he was removed from his birth mother because presumably it was felt he was unsafe and yet what happened to him was so much worse. It feels like a horribly cruel twist.

OP posts:
CoralBells · 30/05/2022 15:40

ElenaSt · 30/05/2022 15:26

It's possible that due to circumstances of Leiland being fostered he may have been clingy or cried more than her perception and or experience of other people's babies and she didn't have the patience or compassion to understand and cope so vented her anger at him not being placid like she thought he would be.

Yes. It must have been hard for him being fostered at 2 months and then being moved from the foster carer at 8 months when he'd have had time to get attached. He was probably unsettled poor thing

RewildingAmbridge · 30/05/2022 15:38

If you think the average incident rate of physical domestic abuse is 7 incidents of violence before police are even called, and that often doesn't lead to conviction straight away and that's worth adult victims. You can see how child abuse can go undetected for a long time especially with very young children not yet in childcare settings, and that's just to be noticed/suspected, let alone convicted, when the only witness is a child unable to give clear testimony. This all escalated pretty quickly though.

LadyEloise1 · 30/05/2022 15:38

That gorgeous wee boy with the lovely smile. Heartbreaking.
Why oh why ?

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:37

I suppose because I can only assume that she is a hugely damaged and unstable individual, and her life will be utter hell now, not least because she has to live with what she did.

OP posts:
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 30/05/2022 15:37

I find it so difficult to understand how this happened, given they must have had a thorough adoption assessment and follow up visits as the order hadn't been granted yet.
does anyone know whether maybe they were family carers who were going to care for him permanently rather than actual adopters?

Andromachehadabadday · 30/05/2022 15:35

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:33

In a bizarre way I do feel for her a bit - her state of mind must have been awful. But while I can sort of understand a single loss of temper the texts seem to indicate it wasn’t just that.

I just don’t understand that.

She abused a child and killed that child.

How can you ‘feel for her’?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 30/05/2022 15:34

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:24

It’s not completely meaningless, @coffeecupsandfairylights

Yes, there’s a reasonable chance that she had a propensity for violence that had never been detected before, but people who go to prison for murder do often have prior convictions as well.

Horrendous.

Often, but not always.

I suppose my point is that you can't rely on a clear criminal record for anything. It's like DBS checks - all they prove is that on x date, Jane Smith hadn't done anything wrong.

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:33

In a bizarre way I do feel for her a bit - her state of mind must have been awful. But while I can sort of understand a single loss of temper the texts seem to indicate it wasn’t just that.

OP posts:
ElenaSt · 30/05/2022 15:26

It's possible that due to circumstances of Leiland being fostered he may have been clingy or cried more than her perception and or experience of other people's babies and she didn't have the patience or compassion to understand and cope so vented her anger at him not being placid like she thought he would be.

Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:24

It’s not completely meaningless, @coffeecupsandfairylights

Yes, there’s a reasonable chance that she had a propensity for violence that had never been detected before, but people who go to prison for murder do often have prior convictions as well.

Horrendous.

OP posts:
Grasscrowns · 30/05/2022 15:22

I imagine his birth mother is going through absolute hell.

OP posts:
BeenHereForYonkyDoodles · 30/05/2022 15:22

I'll never understand why she didn't just hand him back either.
Thoroughly disgusting excuse for a woman.
I hope she gets a hard time in prison.