Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who was unreasonable regarding plane seat ?

244 replies

planerider · 30/05/2022 13:24

Inspired by another thread.

This happened a few years ago, but it annoyed me.

The flight was around 7 hours long. I had paid extra to have the exit seat in economy, as I was suffering from a bad back. I paid quite a lot extra for the seat, it's something I try to do, as I have back problems and it helps.

The woman behind me had quite a big child on her lap during the flight and was sat next to the child's father.

Because of this, I was unable to recline my seat for the entire flight. I tried very gently reclining it a little at some stage ( before I had seen the child ) but she was angry and swore, so I put it upright.

Who was unreasonable here ? Or do we generally think anyone reclining their seat is unreasonable ? I tend to recline my seat on very long flights, when the lights are dimmed for sleeping, as do most others on those flights. I don't recline on short hall.

OP posts:
planerider · 30/05/2022 14:33

xILikeJamx · 30/05/2022 13:58

I once fell asleep on a return flight from 2 weeks clubbing in Ibiza in my early 20s.

I somehow managed to fall asleep with my palms flat on the little tray table and my cheek on top of both hands. At some point during my snooze the random person in front reclined the seat and fell asleep themselves. When I woke up I was completely stuck - head locked in place and couldn't get my hands out to punch the person in front awake. Had to shout for help for about 10 minutes before someone realised where the shouting was coming from. Was completely mortified and must have had finger marks on my face for about 12 hours after being rescued by the cabin crew.

So YABU

This made me lol. But in reality, it must have been horrific.

OP posts:
BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:33

@ComtesseDeSpair they can’t recline the seat as my knees are a barrier due to the thigh bone they are attached to not bending. It only makes me uncomfortable when they try and ram the seat backwards as they don’t understand that my legs are there stopping them. I fit in a regular seat so why would I buy extra legroom. Like someone said further up that’s the chance you take on a normal flight. Their comfort is not my concern.

Newgirls · 30/05/2022 14:32

Reclining seats in standard planes shouldn’t be a thing. They are far too cramped anyway. Just causes issues.

planerider · 30/05/2022 14:29

Watermill · 30/05/2022 14:19

I would have reclined my seat, given no fucks at her swearing, and asked the air stewards to explain to her that if she chose to restrict her own space by not paying for a separate seat for her child then that was her lookout. I don’t trade my own comfort for somebody else’s penny pinching. But, I’m good at speaking up for myself and appreciate not everyone is.

I agree with this. I don't understand why you didn't recline if that's what you wanted to do.

I just felt mean

OP posts:
GrumpyPanda · 30/05/2022 14:29

Recline is better for spine health and you have a right to use it. That mother was a walker, she could have booked an extra seat if necessary. You should have called flight attendants to assist you in reclining the seat, same as you would with assholes using those "knee defender" gadgets that are actually illegal on most airlines.

JenniferBarkley · 30/05/2022 14:29

whenwillthemadnessend · 30/05/2022 14:24

Obviously anyone that has a small child on mn trumps any one else needs period.

It's law in here

But In real life your nbu.

MN is famously unsympathetic to mothers of small children.

Irishfarmer · 30/05/2022 14:29

YANBU to recline your seat the option is there and as such you can use it. However, I think that should be removed from all seats. I am not tall but I hate when the person in front reclines their seat. I wouldn't say anything thought because I know they are allowed recline the seat.

JenniferBarkley · 30/05/2022 14:28

It's only socially acceptable to recline your seat on an overnight flight when the person behind you has also reclined theirs. Any other time means you'll burn in the fiery pits of hell.

It's like cooking fish in the office microwave - just because you technically can, doesn't mean you should.

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/05/2022 14:28

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:25

@ComtesseDeSpair the length is my legs isn’t my fault either. I have a gap of millimetres between my knees and the seat in front, therefore I fit in a standard seat. Sorry but I can’t just change my body because the person in front wants to lie in my lap.

You don’t have to change your body: you change your seat and pay for one with extra leg room. Otherwise, you accept that the person in front of you had the right to use their seat fully, which may cause you discomfort.

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:25

@ComtesseDeSpair the length is my legs isn’t my fault either. I have a gap of millimetres between my knees and the seat in front, therefore I fit in a standard seat. Sorry but I can’t just change my body because the person in front wants to lie in my lap.

whenwillthemadnessend · 30/05/2022 14:24

Obviously anyone that has a small child on mn trumps any one else needs period.

It's law in here

But In real life your nbu.

Soontobe60 · 30/05/2022 14:20

xILikeJamx · 30/05/2022 13:58

I once fell asleep on a return flight from 2 weeks clubbing in Ibiza in my early 20s.

I somehow managed to fall asleep with my palms flat on the little tray table and my cheek on top of both hands. At some point during my snooze the random person in front reclined the seat and fell asleep themselves. When I woke up I was completely stuck - head locked in place and couldn't get my hands out to punch the person in front awake. Had to shout for help for about 10 minutes before someone realised where the shouting was coming from. Was completely mortified and must have had finger marks on my face for about 12 hours after being rescued by the cabin crew.

So YABU

Utter rubbish! How far back do you think the seats recline in Economy? Why didn’t the person sitting only cms away from you not do anything???

Watermill · 30/05/2022 14:19

I would have reclined my seat, given no fucks at her swearing, and asked the air stewards to explain to her that if she chose to restrict her own space by not paying for a separate seat for her child then that was her lookout. I don’t trade my own comfort for somebody else’s penny pinching. But, I’m good at speaking up for myself and appreciate not everyone is.

I agree with this. I don't understand why you didn't recline if that's what you wanted to do.

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/05/2022 14:18

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:07

@Divebar2021 i have really long legs and it does mean the person in front xantbrecline as pretty much my knees are against their seat. Didn’t stop a woman ramming her seat back to try and recline. Aye thanks for that, sorry I can’t remove my thigh bones.

But the length of your legs isn’t the fault of the completely unrelated person in front of you, who has paid for their seat with all its functions and has an expectation of using it fully. If you know you have long legs which don’t easily fit into small spaces, the onus is on you to book a seat where you have more room. Saying “I didn’t want to pay extra for a seat with more leg room, so because I want to be comfortable that means you have to be uncomfortable” is completely unacceptable on public transport.

Soontobe60 · 30/05/2022 14:17

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:07

@Divebar2021 i have really long legs and it does mean the person in front xantbrecline as pretty much my knees are against their seat. Didn’t stop a woman ramming her seat back to try and recline. Aye thanks for that, sorry I can’t remove my thigh bones.

The joy of being able to select your own seat is that you can generally avoid such a scenario. DH is 6’ 3. We always select seats beforehand.

Soontobe60 · 30/05/2022 14:15

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 30/05/2022 13:28

In theory you should be able to recline but in practice if there is a child on a knee or a very obese person then you cant.

Its a risk that you accept as a traveller. If not take a private jet.

The risk is on the person sat behind the recliner!
OP, on flights of that length, I’d be reclining my seat regardless of who was behind me.

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:07

@Divebar2021 i have really long legs and it does mean the person in front xantbrecline as pretty much my knees are against their seat. Didn’t stop a woman ramming her seat back to try and recline. Aye thanks for that, sorry I can’t remove my thigh bones.

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/05/2022 14:07

I would have reclined my seat, given no fucks at her swearing, and asked the air stewards to explain to her that if she chose to restrict her own space by not paying for a separate seat for her child then that was her lookout. I don’t trade my own comfort for somebody else’s penny pinching.

But, I’m good at speaking up for myself and appreciate not everyone is.

ShirleyPhallus · 30/05/2022 14:07

CharlotteRose90 · 30/05/2022 13:51

Unless the child was an infant you can recline your seat. If it was an infant than you can’t and that’s travellers risk when travelling. I once had it happen to me on a night flight from the states. A woman had a child on her seat and booted my chair when I tried reclining. The crew soon sorted it out. People think you can’t recline but actually if the seat reclines you can and there’s no laws against it unless there’s an infant sat there.

There is no law that says you can’t recline your seat if an infant is behind you!

Honeyroar · 30/05/2022 13:59

There are absolutely no rules about not reclining seats n a plane (including when there’s an infant behind) apart from take off and landing- where the seats must be in the upright position.

Everyone has the prerogative to recline if they want. As crew I’d ask people to try to put seats up for the meal service (on a day flight only, I wouldn’t on a night flight where many sleep without eating). If passengers have an infant on their knee we do the upmost to move them to somewhere with a spare seat, or a front row, but if it’s a full plane sometimes we can’t, and that’s the gamble you take travelling with a toddler on your knee unfortunately.

xILikeJamx · 30/05/2022 13:58

I once fell asleep on a return flight from 2 weeks clubbing in Ibiza in my early 20s.

I somehow managed to fall asleep with my palms flat on the little tray table and my cheek on top of both hands. At some point during my snooze the random person in front reclined the seat and fell asleep themselves. When I woke up I was completely stuck - head locked in place and couldn't get my hands out to punch the person in front awake. Had to shout for help for about 10 minutes before someone realised where the shouting was coming from. Was completely mortified and must have had finger marks on my face for about 12 hours after being rescued by the cabin crew.

So YABU

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 30/05/2022 13:52

We had a similar issue on a plane. We had two aisle seats and I had DD on my lap. The man in front reclined and we didn't have enough room, so I passed DD to my DH across the aisle.

The stewardess said we couldn't do this as there wasn't an extra oxygen mask in the row my DH was sitting in, so DD had to remain on my lap. She told the man to put his seat up and keep it up. He wasn't happy about it. My OH offered to swap seats with him, but he'd paid to sit next to his wife and wanted to stay there.

It was a short haul daytime flight and he wasn't tall or overweight and I couldn't see any reason why he would need to recline other than he kept complaining loudly that he wasn't getting his plane nap!

Divebar2021 · 30/05/2022 13:52

I’ve been on a night flight with a very large gentleman behind whose knees prevented me from reclining my seat - although he could recline his. Yay. That was a restful night. If the flights long haul it’s pretty fair to want to sleep at any point ( other than mealtimes). You don’t know how long their journeys been up until that point.

CharlotteRose90 · 30/05/2022 13:51

Unless the child was an infant you can recline your seat. If it was an infant than you can’t and that’s travellers risk when travelling. I once had it happen to me on a night flight from the states. A woman had a child on her seat and booted my chair when I tried reclining. The crew soon sorted it out. People think you can’t recline but actually if the seat reclines you can and there’s no laws against it unless there’s an infant sat there.

Fizzgigg · 30/05/2022 13:46

PestorPeston · 30/05/2022 13:39

I hope your bad back did not prevent you from being able to adequately act in an emergency.

That was my thought too 😂