Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who was unreasonable regarding plane seat ?

244 replies

planerider · 30/05/2022 13:24

Inspired by another thread.

This happened a few years ago, but it annoyed me.

The flight was around 7 hours long. I had paid extra to have the exit seat in economy, as I was suffering from a bad back. I paid quite a lot extra for the seat, it's something I try to do, as I have back problems and it helps.

The woman behind me had quite a big child on her lap during the flight and was sat next to the child's father.

Because of this, I was unable to recline my seat for the entire flight. I tried very gently reclining it a little at some stage ( before I had seen the child ) but she was angry and swore, so I put it upright.

Who was unreasonable here ? Or do we generally think anyone reclining their seat is unreasonable ? I tend to recline my seat on very long flights, when the lights are dimmed for sleeping, as do most others on those flights. I don't recline on short hall.

OP posts:
C152 · 30/05/2022 15:17

Neither of you were unreasonable (well, it wasn't on that the woman swore at/about you); planes just aren't made for comfort at all now. There is not enough space between rows for seats to be reclined without being in the lap of the person behind you. I personally hate it when people in front of me recline their seat, as it gives me no room whatsoever (and I hate reclining my own seat), but I wouldn't complain unless I had a small child on my lap, as it really would make the journey extraordinarily difficult.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 30/05/2022 15:15

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:25

@ComtesseDeSpair the length is my legs isn’t my fault either. I have a gap of millimetres between my knees and the seat in front, therefore I fit in a standard seat. Sorry but I can’t just change my body because the person in front wants to lie in my lap.

I’m sure no strangers on planes really want to sit in your lap, more likely they just want to recline their seat into a slightly more normal sitting position than is needed for take off and landing.

If you feel someone’s back rest getting closer to you as you recline, either accept being a little squashed, or sit with your legs straight out under the chair in front of you like every tall person I’ve ever flown with has to.

SofiaSoFar · 30/05/2022 15:12

Reclining seats are the bane of economy class (and short-haul business if using the same seat spacing). More airlines should remove the function.

If someone in front of you reclines their seat, move the ventilation nozzle above you so that it's pointing at the top of their head and turn it on full blast.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2022 15:09

At the end of the day, capitalism dictates that you get what you pay for, not what you need. This doesn’t stop just because someone is “tall”, when every other need is universally ignored.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 30/05/2022 15:09

It’s fine for you to recline your seat, especially on an eight hour flight. If it weren’t acceptable, the airline staff would tell you that, but they don’t.

If someone wants to travel with a child on their lap instead of buying them their own seat, then they take the risk of being extra squashed if the person in from of them wants to use their seat the way it was designed.

WibblyWobblyLane · 30/05/2022 15:06

It's interesting that MN thinks it's ok to disrupt someone else's comfort by reclining in an already cramped space, but children playing in their own gardens before 10am on a Sunday is a no because it disrupts someone else's comfort despite it being legally ok. Either the rules are there and if it disrupts other people, so what, or the comfort of other people matters, in which case you can't pick and choose.

ShirleyPhallus · 30/05/2022 15:05

BashfulClam · 30/05/2022 14:33

@ComtesseDeSpair they can’t recline the seat as my knees are a barrier due to the thigh bone they are attached to not bending. It only makes me uncomfortable when they try and ram the seat backwards as they don’t understand that my legs are there stopping them. I fit in a regular seat so why would I buy extra legroom. Like someone said further up that’s the chance you take on a normal flight. Their comfort is not my concern.

I’m sure your comfort isn’t their concern either, therefore they will try and recline your seat and bash in to your knees which are in their way

Meraas · 30/05/2022 15:05

nearlyspringyay · 30/05/2022 14:59

@Meraas how do you get moved if the plane is full? The seat pitches in most economy cabins long haul or otherwise aren't big enough to recline

Obviously you get moved if there's room.

Not sure what you mean, I always recline my seat on long haul.

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 30/05/2022 15:04

BunsyGirl · 30/05/2022 13:30

@FloweryCurtainTwitcher There’s no need to take a private jet; premium economy or business are far more affordable options.

Premium economy still recline
You can still have a child on a knee next to you in business particularly in the BA long hall climb over or the BA Europe when someone wants their child to go on the empty middle seat.

nearlyspringyay · 30/05/2022 14:59

@Meraas how do you get moved if the plane is full? The seat pitches in most economy cabins long haul or otherwise aren't big enough to recline

Mariposista · 30/05/2022 14:58

The fact that she swore while in charge of a young child immediately lowers her to the level of a disgusting tart. A simple excuse me costs nothing.
The child cannot have been older than 2 to be on her lap, so can't have been that enormous. YWNBU.

Meraas · 30/05/2022 14:57

Divebar2021 · 30/05/2022 13:52

I’ve been on a night flight with a very large gentleman behind whose knees prevented me from reclining my seat - although he could recline his. Yay. That was a restful night. If the flights long haul it’s pretty fair to want to sleep at any point ( other than mealtimes). You don’t know how long their journeys been up until that point.

You should have reclined! (unless you physically couldn't). I'd have asked to move.

nearlyspringyay · 30/05/2022 14:55

I don't think seats should recline at all.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2022 14:53

Why also do all these threads have one thing in common - it’s never the father holding the child? Which you’d think would be more comfortable for the child, with his bigger lap, and easier for him to do than the mother, due to being stronger and less likely to have a damaged back etc from pregnancy.

AryaStarkWolf · 30/05/2022 14:53

You absolutely should be able to recline on a long haul flight, wtf is the point of the function if it's not supposed to be used?

Funkyblues101 · 30/05/2022 14:52

The exit seats are only for strong adults who are capable of opening the emergency doors, if required. I'm shocked that you sit there.

Joystir59 · 30/05/2022 14:50

I recline on long haul flights and neither consult or inform the person behind, or complain if the person in front of me reclines. She should have paid for a seat for her child.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2022 14:47

I agree the risk is on the person behind. If seats can recline people are free to recline them.

But I also think there should be clear guidance, perhaps as signs on the aeroplane stating either “everyone may recline on this flight, don’t make a fuss” or “no one May recline, don’t try”, or even “you may only recline between x and y times, and at that point everyone is free to do so, don’t argue”.

It absolutely shouldn’t be down to any perceived features you or the person behind may be seen to have. Ie no “oh I’m tall you cant recline. Do I hear you say you have a bad back? - tough, you’re a woman and your needs don’t count”.

Barkingmadhouse · 30/05/2022 14:46

People who recline are twats

Meraas · 30/05/2022 14:44

ComtesseDeSpair · 30/05/2022 14:07

I would have reclined my seat, given no fucks at her swearing, and asked the air stewards to explain to her that if she chose to restrict her own space by not paying for a separate seat for her child then that was her lookout. I don’t trade my own comfort for somebody else’s penny pinching.

But, I’m good at speaking up for myself and appreciate not everyone is.

Agreed.

This is why I speak up, because I don't want to be kicking myself years down the line.

Brefugee · 30/05/2022 14:44

For shorthaul it's not an issue - don't recline.

For longhaul: they recline for a reason, and on most of the flights I've been on they dim the lights and close the blinds for a reason (plus blankets and pillows are a clue) so recline away.

They usually don't bother to put their seat upright whilst eating.

I've never had a problem because the stewards usually insist during mealtimes. But fellow travellers have strategically employed knees and other hard objects.

TruffleShuffles · 30/05/2022 14:41

Newgirls · 30/05/2022 14:32

Reclining seats in standard planes shouldn’t be a thing. They are far too cramped anyway. Just causes issues.

Completely agree, it makes the person behind extremely uncomfortable. If the seat in front is reclined you can’t see the entertainment screen properly or use the tray table. This is one of those mumsnet opinions that I don’t think translates to real life as on the many long haul flights I’ve been on I’ve seen very few people actually recline their seats in economy. There’s also very few extra leg room seats on planes, particularly if you are travelling with a child so just booking one to avoid this isn’t often an option.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2022 14:39

I do think that everyone should be free to recline their seats or no one. It shouldn’t be luck of the draw who is behind you/ in front of you (reclining throughout) etc.

The Mum should have passed the child to her partner for half of the flight, ideally. I’m assuming you explained politely that you needed to recline?

I once paid for front row seats hoping to be able to snatch some sleep on the plane as I was working the next day after an evening flight. Woman behind holding a toddler who was kicking the seat throughout, partner sitting beside her. I turned around to politely ask if they could try to stop the kicking, and the man beside me (in front of the partner) chipped in to the woman “no, it’s fine, don’t worry about it”, ie it’s fine for me to be kicked throughout! Well if that’s ok, you won’t mind if the toddler is kicking you mate?

This was sorted by the air crew finding me a similar seat by the emergency exit doors half way back, so I got some kip in the end!

i also have a bad back so feel your pain.

ComDummings · 30/05/2022 14:36

JenniferBarkley · 30/05/2022 14:28

It's only socially acceptable to recline your seat on an overnight flight when the person behind you has also reclined theirs. Any other time means you'll burn in the fiery pits of hell.

It's like cooking fish in the office microwave - just because you technically can, doesn't mean you should.

Agree ^

HotWashCycle · 30/05/2022 14:34

I had this on a long flight once, OP. The man behind complained loudly when I reclined my seat to sleep. He said there was no room for his knees, but that was because he insisted on sitting so that his legs made a right angle at the knee. He had plenty of foot room and could just have stretched out his legs to have total comfort, but he moaned and moaned as though that was not an option. His attitude was that his comfort was everything and mine did not count. But why do airlines provide reclining seats if they are not be used at appropriate stages of the flight?