Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who was unreasonable regarding plane seat ?

244 replies

planerider · 30/05/2022 13:24

Inspired by another thread.

This happened a few years ago, but it annoyed me.

The flight was around 7 hours long. I had paid extra to have the exit seat in economy, as I was suffering from a bad back. I paid quite a lot extra for the seat, it's something I try to do, as I have back problems and it helps.

The woman behind me had quite a big child on her lap during the flight and was sat next to the child's father.

Because of this, I was unable to recline my seat for the entire flight. I tried very gently reclining it a little at some stage ( before I had seen the child ) but she was angry and swore, so I put it upright.

Who was unreasonable here ? Or do we generally think anyone reclining their seat is unreasonable ? I tend to recline my seat on very long flights, when the lights are dimmed for sleeping, as do most others on those flights. I don't recline on short hall.

OP posts:
KatherineJaneway · 01/06/2022 06:24

Ponderingwindow · 01/06/2022 02:15

I think airlines should just disable the recline feature and fix the problem forever.

Agree

HeadOnShoulders · 01/06/2022 05:50

Been flying for close to 30 years and I always recline when the option exists. As soon as we're up in the air my seat goes back, and only comes back upright for the meals and landing.

The function is there for a reason. Use it.

@easyday
Credit cards, including sign up bonuses, are the way to go.

Ponderingwindow · 01/06/2022 02:15

I think airlines should just disable the recline feature and fix the problem forever.

Mirw · 01/06/2022 02:02

I went long haul to NZ with arthritis in my spine and hips and managed not to recline the seat as there was an elderly man behind with similar issues. Sometimes you just have to suck it up in cattle class or pay the extra for business or first class.

Cejm · 01/06/2022 01:43

I have flown twice with my baby - each time I paid for a comfort seat for her as I was alone and didn’t want to be crammed and my baby moves about a lot! I couldn’t actually put her in her seat though as she is a baby and can not sit upright unaided - also the airlines do not allow it!

The two airlines I flew with had rules that under two’s must be on your lap unless you bring an airline approved forward facing car seat - this is tricky as under 2’s in the UK and EU must travel in backwards facing car seats which means you would have to spend hundreds on a brand new car seat just for the flight and carry it through the airport while juggling a baby which is why you rarely see infants in car seats on planes.

I would love if airlines made it possible for an infant to travel in his/her own seat - holding a baby for several hours is not easy or fun. I personally was terrified that the woman in front of me was going to recline at one point as a 6 month old doesn’t understand why an adult is crushing them with a seat. Thankfully she saw the baby and stopped.

I would never blame someone for having a lap infant or recline a seat on a baby - most airlines do charge for having a baby on your lap these days so they are not travelling free of charge even if they don’t buy their own seat. If you have a disability that means you must recline or you are completely shattered and there is a baby behind you I would speak to an air steward and see can he/she can accommodate either group in other seats.

FloweryCurtainTwitcher · 01/06/2022 00:15

tkwal · 01/06/2022 00:08

I thought the extra legroom seats were only to be used by people who have no mobility issues, so they can help in case of emergencies.

Not on long-haul
Most are bulk heads with the bassinets and baby face masks.

tkwal · 01/06/2022 00:08

I thought the extra legroom seats were only to be used by people who have no mobility issues, so they can help in case of emergencies.

Bellieboo33 · 31/05/2022 23:26

I generally recline my seat if I want to sleep or if the flight is a longish one.
the person behind you can always recline theirs too in order to maintain the same gap between the seats.
from my POV- YANBU

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 31/05/2022 23:18

On Mumsnet it is generally illegal to recline your seat and you should sit bolt upright for the duration

Stressybetty · 31/05/2022 22:56

Remembering a coach holiday about 20 years ago from UK to Sorrento. The first and final nights were spent overnight on the coach with curtains closed, lights off and all seats reclined. However my DSis and I had an elderly couple behind us who objected strongly to us reclining as the husband had a thrombosis in his leg. The couple in front of us apologetically reclined theirs as did the couple behind of course and we remained uncomfortably upright all night. By the end of the week most of the rest of the coach party had all commiserated with us and they were re-seated at the very front going home.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 31/05/2022 21:01

I don’t know why but I always end up reading the endless recline-or-not argument.
My stance:


  • seats are built with a recline feature

  • the only rules are not to recline during take off / landing and meals

  • reclining can cause discomfort for the person at the back but they can mitigate this by reclining themselves

  • not reclining can cause discomfort if you have back ache

-> I’ll recline. Of course slowly but without « asking » the person behind.

GoodThinkingMax · 31/05/2022 20:40

My last flight was only an hour to Amsterdam and I couldn’t resist being petty and kicking the seat back lol

Yes totally petty and childish.

ShirleyPhallus · 31/05/2022 20:36

paintingcolors · 31/05/2022 20:19

When we buy a flight we pay for our seat, not every inch of space around that seat. If you want to control what happens to the space around your seat, you can always buy a first class ticket.

I cannot work out if this means you’re for or against reclining?!

Hmm1234 · 31/05/2022 20:33

I hate when the person infront reclines there seat them it squeaks and shakes. My last flight was only an hour to Amsterdam and I couldn’t resist being petty and kicking the seat back lol
In future you should speak with cabin crew or assistance at the airport and explain your back issues

threatmatrix · 31/05/2022 20:24

Read it again.

easyday · 31/05/2022 20:24

I have long legs and it really is unbearable if someone reclines the seat in front. Therefore I buy a premium economy seat, only fly Virgin (BA premium is not worth it) when I fly long haul (usually to US). This means buying from Tesco and saving all my vouchers to buy air miles to afford it (and we only go every other year).
People are allowed to recline, the seats are not roomy, but if it's a problem for the passenger behind it's their problem. Therefore you should have been able to recline your seat, and if it was an issue for the woman behind she could figure out a solution. Though I do agree that some common sense consideration should be made like going upright at meal times.
By the way I thought emergency exit seats were for those who were physically able to move and open the doors if needed.

takemetomars · 31/05/2022 20:23

Allywill · 30/05/2022 13:36

My sister was an air stewardess for many years and dealt with this issue on several flights a week. You are entitled to recline your seat if it has the recline function. The person behind you has to deal with it - usually the best way is to recline theirs. This is what the crew would tell you and the person behind you.

Yep, I can confirm that this is what they tell you. We had this issue on a long haul flight where the woman behind my adult daughter totally lost it when she reclined her seat. She was, very nicely, informed by the flight manager that it was my daughter's right to recline. This was in prem ec. I just do not get the MN attitude towards this and I find that it is generally accepted that people recline where and when possible. They don't put their seats up for meals either

paintingcolors · 31/05/2022 20:19

When we buy a flight we pay for our seat, not every inch of space around that seat. If you want to control what happens to the space around your seat, you can always buy a first class ticket.

paintingcolors · 31/05/2022 20:15

Travis1 · 31/05/2022 11:16

Reclining is the height of ignorance in economy. I had a man in my lap for a daytime flight from jfk to Gatwick. Thankfully crew managed to move me. I couldn’t even get out my seat when he was reclined. Never mind read a book or watch the entertainment that I had paid for. So YABU

If you had also reclined your seat, you would have had more space ....

anon666 · 31/05/2022 20:15

I'm with those that think it's antisocial to recline the seat. I've noticed cheaper flights have got rid of this altogether

Insanelysilver · 31/05/2022 20:12

I one had a guy in front of me who’d inclined bus seat literally as far aS it would go. He was practically on my lap.
i called a flight attendant and showed her how much he was encroaching. It was so uncomfortable and it was impossible for me to use the table. He told the flight attendant that the seat didnt go up but it was upright during take off. She didn’t want to call him a liar and so she said there wasn’t anything she could do.

When the food arrived courtesy of another member of the cabin crew. saw I couldn’t put the table down.
He told the man to put his seat in the upright position and again the man said he couldn’t. The flight attendant made him stand uo
and sat in the seat and showed him the seat was working perfectly well.
He said
so we all know that your seat is functioning now don’t we sit, so there’s no need for you to be making this nice lady uncomfortable for 8 hours is there.
He then said loudly
let me know if passenger causes you any more problems.
i was so grateful as I’d already had 4 hours of it!

paintingcolors · 31/05/2022 20:12

I recline and have had words with someone behind me who told me not to do so. I told him he should have bought a business class ticket. I only recline after meals have been cleared so that my seat doesn't cause issues for the person behind me trying to eat off the tiny tray.

Mamaof2males · 31/05/2022 20:11

We are going away in August, providing the bloody flights don’t get cancelled / can actually board with the difficulties at present - we have all booked extra leg room. There are 6 adults and 3 children we are in the middle rows in 3’s together on the plane for this reason. The men are 6ft 3 and we want comfort so we’ve all paid.

CharlotteSt · 31/05/2022 20:03

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 30/05/2022 15:23

I'm sure I read a couple of years ago about a design of seat that reclined by moving the seat forwards not the back backwards. Solves all the issues.

Yes I've been on a flight where the seats did this. Hurrah! Can't remember which airline.

I hate sitting behind a recliner as it makes me feel claustrophobic but I accept it's their right.

I wouldn't mind so much but I think being reclined is actually less comfortable.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 31/05/2022 19:56

WibblyWobblyLane · 30/05/2022 15:06

It's interesting that MN thinks it's ok to disrupt someone else's comfort by reclining in an already cramped space, but children playing in their own gardens before 10am on a Sunday is a no because it disrupts someone else's comfort despite it being legally ok. Either the rules are there and if it disrupts other people, so what, or the comfort of other people matters, in which case you can't pick and choose.

Different people posting on different threads?

MN doesn’t have one single hive-mind - you’ll find people with lots of different experiences and opinions here.