Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog barking? What is reasonable?

33 replies

Notadogowner · 30/05/2022 12:40

I live in an apartment. They are all 1, 2 and 3 beds. Most are 2 beds but I’m not sure if the apartment in question is a 1 or 2 bed (different part of the building).

One of the residents has recently got a dog. A dog that is often out on the balcony barking. Often barking for 15 minutes to an hour, then going back in, and then coming back out again to do another round of barking throughout the day.

This happens both during the day time and at night.

I’m not a dog owner, so I have no idea what is reasonable and what is not when it comes to a dog. I guess the dog being on the balcony is equivalent to a dog being in a garden barking, so I don’t know if that’s normal or whether the owner should be doing more.

I mentioned the number of rooms in case it is reasonable for a dog living in a one bed flat to be allowed out on the balcony to bark, but I just need to suck it up.

But it is really annoying to have a dog constantly barking, that even with windows closed, I still hear it.

I’m not sure whether I should complain to the managing agents, but it all depends on whether the dog’s behaviour is normal and therefore, so be it, or if the owner should be doing more.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
knockyknees · 31/05/2022 03:06

100% unacceptable.

I'd definitely compain to the management committee/building owner.

Notadogowner · 30/05/2022 21:24

I have no idea what could be making the dog bark at night. We’re on the river, and the property in question is slightly further back so the dog’s view of the river will be limited, and there’s barely any pedestrians on the river path at night time so not much to get its attentions.

It definitely annoys other residents as I see people standing at or looking out of the window when the dog starts up again.

I’ll check the lease for any restrictions on pets.

OP posts:
XmasElf10 · 30/05/2022 21:15

I have a dog. He does not bark overnight ever. His last outing is generally 10pm. Normally when he’s in the garden he doesn’t bark. If he does bark it’s because of the bin man or post man or a cat. He barks for 10 or 20 seconds, maybe a minute. The big bark is for the Tesco man and he’ll bark at my window during the whole delivery which is bloody annoying once a week. So he probably woofs between 3 and 6 times a day depending on the number of deliveries and never before 7am or after 10pm. I think this is normal for a well behaved dog.

iamruth · 30/05/2022 21:13

Reasonable people don’t allow their dogs to bark for even 15 minutes at a time, just as they don’t let their children scream excessively outside at any time of the day (and certainly not be very loud before 10am or after 7pm)

With both children and a dog in my household (detached with quite a large garden if it matters) I actively tell my children to consider the neighbours and bring them in if they are making excessive noise (especially screaming or whining!) and don’t let the dog bark for more than a minute or two because I’m not a selfish prick.

Your neighbour is being v unreasonable.

Knifer · 30/05/2022 21:07

I loathe barking dogs!!

My dog barks outside and I hate it, I call her in. MIL has given us such a lecture on letting her be free to express herself vocally. 🙄

Absolutely not.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 30/05/2022 17:02

Completely unacceptable. I have 3 dogs and like most dogs they like a good bark, because there’s 3 of them they will set each other off. But they are told to stop as soon as they start. I’d never leave them to just bark and bark. I find it annoying so don’t want other people to have to put up with it.

there is a dog a few door down from us that is left to bark. It’s really very irritating.

Northernsoullover · 30/05/2022 16:33

You won't get anywhere with the council without an address.

PipeScatter · 30/05/2022 16:23

We had a similar issue with one of our neighbours. Was mostly resolved with a complaint to the council (well, actually, numerous complaints by many, many neighbours) plus DH standing in the garden and shouting "For gods' sake will someone shut that f*ing dog up!".

It still barks now and some days are better than others (the poor thing is kennelled in the garden at night, so any passing fox/owl/cat starts it off).

In your case @Notadogowner I'd speak with the management company. They'll be able to send a message round to everyone. It's quite possibly in contravention of the lease too - I remember when I had a flat I wasn't even allowed an indoor cat!

LivingOnTheRoad · 30/05/2022 15:59

One of our dogs barks a lot and is very loud. The other doesn’t bark. Not sure either of them is normal. 😂

Maybe speak to the agent and see what they can do.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 30/05/2022 15:30

The neighbours are unreasonable and it would drive me nuts.

DogsAndGin · 30/05/2022 15:28

As a dog owner, I consider it reasonable that a dog doesn’t bark! Especially in an apartment. My dog doesn’t bark unless the doorbell goes, and she gets immediately told off and she immediately pipes down. Definitely complain. Nothing worse that being disturbed in your one place of peace!

fyn · 30/05/2022 15:26

Our dog only barks when the door bell rings or when a cat strays into the house. Our neighbours leave their dogs outside for hours and they bark the whole time, they also bark the entire time they are out. It’s like torture.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 30/05/2022 15:14

I had that exact situation 2 flats ago. I complained to management with exact details of when it happened and for how long it happened.

They dealt with it and it never happened again.

StoneofDestiny · 30/05/2022 15:09

Unacceptable - - dogs should not be allowed to disturb others like that.

GrumpyPanda · 30/05/2022 15:03

Everything else aside, the poor thing must be bored out of its mind being essentially kept on a balcony. So not just inconsiderate, but cruelty to animals to boot.

Jammysod · 30/05/2022 14:59

It's not acceptable, at all.
One of our neighbours has a dog that it outside all day, everyday. I can hear it whimpering at the moment (it's raining). Every now & then they yell out of the window telling it to shut up.
I'm fairly certain the only reason they have it is for breeding.

howoriginal · 30/05/2022 14:53

Yeah totally not acceptable. We have a dog in an apartment and we let her out on the balcony during the day while I'm at home (which is most of the day) but when she starts barking at dogs on the street or kids on skateboards (she hates skateboards) we bring her in. She barks when our neighbours come in and out of their apartment but that's about it. I would never leave her outside overnight because she would be an absolute nightmare - if she's inside at night then the only thing she'll bark at is when the neighbours come home/go out. And I've spoken to our neighbours about her - none of the other residents in the building hear her, and the neighbours opposite that she barks at have said they're not bothered by it at all. I think that's the least your neighbors can do - be considerate of you and the other residents and definitely don't leave the dog outside overnight. If you can find out which flat it is then you should definitely have a word with them about it.

ATadConfused · 30/05/2022 14:51

It's not 'normal' & it's not acceptable. From both a neighbours point of view OR from the dogs. A dog barking that much is a stressed dog.

Amelion · 30/05/2022 14:49

Yeah, it’s unreasonable! I have a dog, and she’ll bark at the door, or when she’s playing. It’s just a few seconds/a few barks at a time. Extended periods of barking are anti-social and if she was barking and barking, I’d call her in/stop her etc.

See if you can speak to the neighbour if you can work out who it is, or the managing agent.

ATadConfused · 30/05/2022 14:44

MrMrsJones · 30/05/2022 12:42

This is unacceptable 😤

Wr have two dogs, but in a terrace, if they are barking they get brought back in and silenced.

Oooh that sound ominous!!!

'they get silenced'

LeevMarie · 30/05/2022 14:42

I think that's an unreasonable amount of time to hear barking, and actually a little concerning from a welfare point of view.

However, I've recently attempted to have a polite conversation with my neighbour who lets his dog out to bark for 15 minutes at a time to the rear of my property after 8pm, just as DS is trying to go to sleep. It didn't go well and I'm the arsehole for suggesting that he brings the dog in to avoid disturbing other neighbours. . .

In the same way that some people insist that their kids have total impunity to create excessive noise, you will likely find that this dog owner believes that everyone else should suffer because they chose to have an animal that they are not equipped to care for properly.

baroqueandblue · 30/05/2022 14:31

Sorry you're having to deal with this OP and I hope there's an amicable solution soon.

@balalake i was interested in your comment and wonder if you have any experience of tackling such a situation, or knowledge of what to do. I'm the tenant of a flat I've lived in for over 15 years. There are 18 apartments altogether spread over 3 floors, all the same size. The flat opposite mine has changed hands twice in 2 years and the new owners have a dog. According to the leasehold details they were supposed to seek approval from the building's board but made no attempt to do so. Since moving in they have regularly toileted the dog in the communal garden, and it often barks when I leave or enter my flat, and when visitors leave or enter. In all the years I've lived here there has only been one instance of a household keeping a dog, but they were tenants and the owner quickly responded. They agreed to rehome the dog locally and that was that. Since the current situation involves actual flat owners keeping a dog, I'm uncertain what the options are. My landlord knows about the situation and has contacted the building management company, who claimed they would write to the owners, but nothing has changed. The board has been a bit diminished in the last couple of years for various reasons, but even so these people made no attempt to contact anyone regarding the terms in the lease around pet ownership. Since moving in they keep themselves to themselves, but myself and some of my neighbours feel a bit like their attitude to our established set up is a bit 'fuck you' Confused

jevoudrais · 30/05/2022 13:28

I have three dogs. To me, reasonable is 'woof woof' to someone at the door, or a few excitable barks during play. But mine are told to be quiet if they bark what I deem to be excessively during play. I have an 8 week old puppy and he is allowed more lenience because he doesn't understand 'enough' yet. And I live in a four bed semi.

balalake · 30/05/2022 13:25

In your plates, are pets accepted or prohibited as part of the lease? Worth checking.

Notadogowner · 30/05/2022 12:53

Thank you everyone, that’s reassuring.

I would leave a note but I don’t know the door number (it’s a development with different entrances and I wouldn’t be able to figure out which number as I don’t know anyone who lives in that part of the building).

I did think dogs aren’t meant to just bark non stop, but I really know nothing about dogs…my interaction has always been limited to a stroke when one comes up to me!

OP posts: