Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still sleep with the light on

32 replies

Nodark · 30/05/2022 00:24

I have a really deep-rooted fear of the dark after being locked in a cavity beneath my parents' house as a punishment a number of times as a child (not a punishment given to me by my parents but by someone else who would often look after us).

I'm now 35 and I still struggle to sleep with the light off. I can sometimes sleep with a nightlight on if it's bright enough. This has been an issue for many of my partners over the years and I have had arguments with exes about it.
I now have a baby and my DP is worried about not sleeping with her in darkness as he thinks it isn't good for her. I co-sleep with her and have tried but i always end up switching the light back on (or at least putting on the night light). Am I causing her damage by not sleeping in total darkness with her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UnsuitableHat · 30/05/2022 05:40

What a shit experience you had OP, and not unreasonable at all to want whatever helps you sleep. Can understand, though, that wanting a light on might be difficult for someone else in the room.
I’m scared of the dark too, but only pitch dark, so a chink of light through the curtains will be ok for me. I’ve had people not even understand that though.

Nodark · 30/05/2022 05:30

youngwildandni · 30/05/2022 04:15

@Nodark what's the minimum amount of light you can cope with? Does it have to be full on lights on or can it be a night light? Sorry if you've answered this already!

It's weird because it changes. I used to not even be able to cope with a night light but in the last few years a nightlight has been okay most of the time. Every now and again something will trigger me and I'll need a bedside light on. There's times when I'm on my own and something triggers me that I need to let the big light on and sometimes even every light in the house because I'm so scared of there being any darkness, that's rare though and I can go a long time without it happening.

I think it's hard for my partner to understand as i did go through a phase with him before the baby was born when i was able to sleep with it off if the curtains were open and the light from the moon or streetlamps was coming in. Since she was born though I struggle with that.
He says the same thing as some posters about how having light can affect the quality of sleep over time. Overall he's pretty supportive though and doesn't have an issue with the light being on if I need it, he's just trying to encourage me to go without it.

For those asking about therapy, I did go to therapy for a long time about other issues related to what happened (it massively affected me in my teens and really damaged my trust in people and relationships, particularly with my mum as I had told her other things that were happening in the run up to this and she didn't believe me but then it kept escalating and got worse). It was talking therapy though, not CBT, and we didn't ever really get onto my fear of the dark as that didn't seem as important or big an issue as some of the other things that happened as a result of that period of my life.

OP posts:
youngwildandni · 30/05/2022 04:15

@Nodark what's the minimum amount of light you can cope with? Does it have to be full on lights on or can it be a night light? Sorry if you've answered this already!

milkyaqua · 30/05/2022 04:09

Your trauma response is completely understandable, OP.

But I think it is a bit sad you are effectively training your baby to experience your difficulty in sleeping without a light on, albeit for different reasons to you.

I also think your partner's concerns are valid. The baby will not be producing the level of hormones normally associated with good sleep patterns, and that are related to light and dark cycles...

It can be hard to access suitable help, but well worth it if you can find it.

bozna · 30/05/2022 03:52

@youngwildandni I like that my son isn't in the dark and just snuggles in my bed in the bed, think I'm super soft but I love it 😐

milkyaqua · 30/05/2022 03:52

It's just essentially saying to change how you think and feel about something? Almost like, oh you're scared of the dark, just don't be!

CBT is Cognitive Behavioural Therapy. So it involves changing behaviours, as well as challenging thoughts, and so on. Some sort of graded exposure ladder would be established to deal with the fear of the dark, if the OP was seen by a competent CBT therapist. A lot of counsellors and whatnot say they do CBT. (By the way, I am not a mad fan of it, but it is the way phobias, PTSD, etc, are primarily treated.)

Unfortunately not the case for many people. Trauma requires dealing with the underlying trauma. CBT might bring temporary benefits but will not be sufficient or appropriate for most cases of trauma.

These days trauma-informed therapists etc will also utilise Somatic Experiencing techniques, and various other modalities. But the basics of CBT are used for treating phobias, whether or not they are trauma-related or induced.

youngwildandni · 30/05/2022 03:48

I'm not an expert but I don't think so. With both dd and ds I've slept with the bedroom light off but the en suite light on and door wide open. It means when they woke in the night I could see what I was doing without having to turn a light half blind us both! Dd is now 4.5 and it doesn't seem to have affected her at all, she's always been a good sleeper. Ds is a fussier sleeper but light on or off hasn't seemed to make a huge difference.

Cheesechips · 30/05/2022 03:47

Talking therapy*

Cheesechips · 30/05/2022 03:42

Some posts re CBT. I've had it for various issues but haven't found it helpful. It's just essentially saying to change how you think and feel about something? Almost like, oh you're scared of the dark, just don't be! I've always found it better to accept that you feel a certain way rather than force a different way of thinking. I think taking therapy would be a nether idea personally.

Cheesechips · 30/05/2022 03:38

I'm sorry for how you were treated as a child. I agree with other posters. Better to get used to sleeping with some light as a child anyway. We have blackout blinds in my sons room but it still looks like daylight when he goes fo bed some evenings. Thank goodness he doesn't expect blackness. I still have a fear of the dark at 37 and will sleep with the tv or lamp on if my husband isn't next to me. I've managed to ditch the nightlight gradually. Not sure where my fear stems from though.

thingymaboob · 30/05/2022 03:32

I use the tommee Tippee dreamaker which has a red light. It's ok all night. Maybe switch to red light.newborns like it

WarOnSlugs · 30/05/2022 03:01

HeddaGarbled · 30/05/2022 01:10

OP has been through trauma. CBT is usually inappropriate and unhelpful in such cases

My understanding is that CBT has been proven to be one of the most effective treatments for PTSD.

Unfortunately not the case for many people. Trauma requires dealing with the underlying trauma. CBT might bring temporary benefits but will not be sufficient or appropriate for most cases of trauma.

I feel so sad that mental health care in the UK mainly consists of recommending a short course of CBT to people because it's cheap. That is nowhere near enough to help people who are very traumatised and actually doesn't help them much, because they need to process what happened to th with proper support, not "reframe" it.

HeddaGarbled · 30/05/2022 01:10

OP has been through trauma. CBT is usually inappropriate and unhelpful in such cases

My understanding is that CBT has been proven to be one of the most effective treatments for PTSD.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/05/2022 01:06

Depends on the baby.

I didn't have curtains because my mother wouldn't have rooms in darkness. I never slept much, apparently, which continued as an adult. I could be shattered, but the moment there was a light, I'd ping awake for at least another four hours until finally sleeping the sleep of the dead through all alarms, roofs blowing off, trees falling, car alarms and full on fights outside.

I bought long blackout curtains recently for the first time - and I have never slept so well.

milkyaqua · 30/05/2022 01:06

WarOnSlugs · 30/05/2022 01:01

OP has been through trauma. CBT is usually inappropriate and unhelpful in such cases.

Well, it is what is given for trauma, PTSD, phobias, etc.

bozna · 30/05/2022 01:05

I'm not scared of dark but baby in my room always had a light on to see them, even know I always prefer to on or side light, or something, not because I'm scared it's just something I prefer. I walked down a back road a few years ago and realised how actually awful proper pitch black was. It was horrible even adults need a bit of light for security.

WarOnSlugs · 30/05/2022 01:02

Red light is good, if you must have a light on. The Lumi nightlight is good for this.

www.lumie.com/products/bedbug

GrandRapids · 30/05/2022 01:02

I hate pitch black too. Always sleep with a nightlight on in the hallway and door cracked open

WarOnSlugs · 30/05/2022 01:01

OP has been through trauma. CBT is usually inappropriate and unhelpful in such cases.

HeddaGarbled · 30/05/2022 00:59

I came on the thread to say you were being unreasonable, but obviously with your history, you’re not.

However, there is some research which suggests that sleeping with a light on all the time disrupts melatonin levels and can affect sleep patterns long term for both children and adults, and clearly your partners have had problems with this in the past.

Have you tried therapy, particularly CBT?

Plantpot75 · 30/05/2022 00:57

I’m sorry for your experience. Sleep however makes you comfortable. If you’re comfortable baby is more likely to be too. And some light will help with feeding etc anyway.

WarOnSlugs · 30/05/2022 00:57

I was terrified of the dark as a child. Both of my children are, too, although I have never mentioned my fear to them and have tried to help them get past their fear.

I am so sorry for what happened to you. Are you having any support or therapy? It sounds like you need trauma therapy, can you speak to your GP?

But no it will not mess up your child sleeping with a night light on. Most kids hate the dark. Sleeping in a pitch black room makes it much harder later to take them away anywhere.

I am amazed if your DH knows about this trauma that you went through, that he is saying these things to you. That is awful. You have clearly been through horrific things and he should be supporting you.

ShirleyPhallus · 30/05/2022 00:53

Whetheryouthinkyoucan · 30/05/2022 00:27

I think its much worse to raise a child who will only sleep in pitch black.

im sorry you had such an awful unthinkable experience. Sleep how you like.

Agreed. Sorry for your experience

ozymandiusking · 30/05/2022 00:52

If you can manage with a night light ok, but if not use a bed side light. It's awful being frightened of the dark. I have a friend who just doesn't understand,and says inane thing like " dark's just dark, there's no problem"

Sqeebling · 30/05/2022 00:48

That said. There's nothing wrong with leaving the light on and it won't affect your DC