Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that children should always get their mother's last name?

118 replies

CaptSkippy · 29/05/2022 21:22

Here me out.

99% of the burden of reproduction is on women. All the pain and discomfort that come with pregnancy and childbirth are for the woman alone. No man has to suffer physically in any way for a child to be born.

All he has to do is have an orgasm.

Therefore I think that the honor of passing on a family name should belong to women alone.

What do you think?

OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:52

Hallyup89 · 30/05/2022 08:46

Not as a blanket rule because that'll cause issues too. We had three kids before marriage. They were given their dad's name. I then took his name when married so we all matched. If the kids had been given my maiden name, we'd all have to change, or he'd have to take my name if we wanted to be the same, which is surely exactly the problem that so many women have, but in reverse.

I guess everyone should get married before kids to avoid that one...

What should be banned is the ridiculous double-barrelling of names.

Why would you all have to change if the kids had gotten your name? Your husband could have taken your name. Problem solved.

OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

I agree with you as well. I use "man's name" without thinking, because that is what I grew up with. When I was born it wasn't even possible for children to get their mother's name and it was not possible for married women to keep their own name. The law simply did not allow it. I was almost ten years old when the law changed to allow married women to keep their names. I was even older when children could get their mother's name.

OP posts:
Hallyup89 · 30/05/2022 08:46

Not as a blanket rule because that'll cause issues too. We had three kids before marriage. They were given their dad's name. I then took his name when married so we all matched. If the kids had been given my maiden name, we'd all have to change, or he'd have to take my name if we wanted to be the same, which is surely exactly the problem that so many women have, but in reverse.

I guess everyone should get married before kids to avoid that one...

What should be banned is the ridiculous double-barrelling of names.

ChiefInspectorParker · 30/05/2022 08:33

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Sirzy · 30/05/2022 08:23

We have a system now where people do have the choice. People can decide which surname to use, they can decide if they follow their cultural conventions or not.

You want to dictate what names people use so how is that any better than a system that automatically assumes the fathers name will be used?

orwellwasright · 30/05/2022 08:22

There's no law preventing it and of course if you have your baby in hospital its name tag will be the mother's name regardless of what you later decide so you could argue that most babies certainly start life with their mother's name.

It's a cultural issue that they don't, it's not one of legality or practicality.

And judging by the comments you always get on threads like these we are a loooong way from accepting this as the cultural norm.

The number of women who get the vapours that other women might not change their name on marriage or might want their baby to have their name is staggering. And that's before you even get to the patriarchy.

CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:19

maythe4thbewithme · 30/05/2022 08:09

Well it's hardly a choice for them not to be the one to carry the baby is it 🤷🏻‍♀️
If you are married - then you'd all have the same surname anyway

Exactly, it's not a choice. But naming is a choice and a privilege. I don't see why women would need to suffer so much only for that privilege to go to men.

For the longest time children legally belonged to the father and it was impossible to give the child the women's last name, as they could not even legally keep their own names when they got married.

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 30/05/2022 08:16

maythe4thbewithme · 30/05/2022 08:09

Well it's hardly a choice for them not to be the one to carry the baby is it 🤷🏻‍♀️
If you are married - then you'd all have the same surname anyway

Did you teleport from the 1950s?

Do you really think that's true? Seriously, you've never heard of a woman keeping her name?

CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:15

youdroppedthis · 29/05/2022 22:24

If you did it would still be a man's name.

You make a good point. Perhaps we should wipe the slate clean. Change all our last names to ones we picked so we can at least be sure they belong to women.

If it wasn't such an adminstrative hassle I would have done it already.

OP posts:
CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:12

Oscarthedog · 30/05/2022 07:07

Men massively disproportionate finance the child though. Women often give up work claim to be working as a sahm financially the burden falls on the man to provide. Due to sexism in reproductive rights and medicine men get no choices on contraceptives its condoms with their high failure rate or nothing. I don't begrudge the child taking the man's name.

There is no way he could supply the finances if he did not have a wife at home taking care of all his life admin stuff. And let's face it, these days many mothers work too, often fulltime. There are quite a few posters here who out-earn their male partners, yet the children still get their name.

And this does nothing to challenge my intial argument that a man has to face no physical hardship from pregnancy for 9 months and then hours, if not days, of labor to give birth.

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 30/05/2022 08:10

"If you are married - then you'd all have the same surname anyway"

Er nope!
Plenty of married couples with different surnames.
I can't believe this has to be pointed out 🙄

maythe4thbewithme · 30/05/2022 08:09

Well it's hardly a choice for them not to be the one to carry the baby is it 🤷🏻‍♀️
If you are married - then you'd all have the same surname anyway

CaptSkippy · 30/05/2022 08:04

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 22:19

You seem to have a rather unconventional view of the responsibilities of a father.

Fathers do not give birth and don't get pregnant. This has been the case for at least several hundred thousand years. How far back do you need to go before it becomes "conventional"?

OP posts:
sashh · 30/05/2022 07:59

I disagree.

One of my friends has a name that cost her a lot of embarrassment at school, she gave her son his father's surname.

There are various naming traditions around the world and some parents want to follow that here.

When I worked in hospitals it was a nightmare if we had an ECG request for a 'baby Begum', that could be any one of a number of children on a maternity ward with a large Pakistani / Bengali population. For anyone who doesn't know 'Begum' is like 'Mrs', so 'baby Begum' was 'baby of a married woman'.

Sikhs who are baptised take the names Singh or Kaur, some people are happy to pass those names on to their children but many use a family name and calling a boy 'princess' is not ideal.

Arabic tradition gives the mother her first son's name as her surname

newname12345 · 30/05/2022 07:46

VestaTilley · 29/05/2022 23:27

Agree. Mum endures pregnancy, labour, often breastfeeding and - let’s face it - often the majority of the childcare and mental load for 18+ years - and then our societal convention is that she doesn’t even get to give the child her own name? Screw that.

I told DH that DC could have both our surnames, or just mine, but that I wasn’t letting my name be left out. DH happily agreed- DS has my surname hyphenated with DH’s. Easy.

That's easy for you, not so easy for future generations if everyone does the same. You can't keep adding hyphenated names so names will need to be dropped - parts of one or both parents, or even one parent entirely. Picking surnames would become as difficult as picking first names with the adding problem of potentially causing issues with grandparents.

K0612 · 30/05/2022 07:32

Yes, and if they don't have the same name they aren't allowed to get really angry at school staff when their child's jotters, certificates etc have the name which is on the register on them as they can't later change to the mothers name after a split.

Sirzy · 30/05/2022 07:09

I voted YABU simply because I think the decision should be made by each family what works for them.

ds has my surname and I am pleased I made that decision. But that doesn’t mean that people who make a different choice are wrong.

Oscarthedog · 30/05/2022 07:07

Men massively disproportionate finance the child though. Women often give up work claim to be working as a sahm financially the burden falls on the man to provide. Due to sexism in reproductive rights and medicine men get no choices on contraceptives its condoms with their high failure rate or nothing. I don't begrudge the child taking the man's name.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 30/05/2022 07:01

Moithered · 30/05/2022 06:49

This will fuck up future generations trying to trace their ancestors

How so?

Kertrats · 30/05/2022 06:58

There's one element that hasn't been considered here: the avoidance of incest.
For example, if mother's name taken as the norm, two half - siblings could meet (same father, different mother) and gave no idea they're related.
If father name used, its more likely they'd realise 'or your surname is Bloggs, too'.
In these days of fractured families (no moral judgement here) that's not too far-fetched.
Too say it's purely about patriarchy is incorrect.

Moithered · 30/05/2022 06:49

This will fuck up future generations trying to trace their ancestors

funinthesun19 · 30/05/2022 03:41

I agree with you OP.
I do the absolute majority when bringing my children up. Ex does the bare minimum and has no ambition for the kids, and yet they have his surname. He’s loves them having his name, but doesn’t want to do half of the work I do. It’s really unfair.
They will always have a connection to my ex through his name whereas as with me - nothing. If he was a great dad and fully involved with them I would at least have that as comfort.

I’ve asked him in the past if he would double barrel which I would settle for. I said it’s fair to have both parents’ surnames. But he won’t have any of it. If I went to court to get them double barrelled on the basis that they should have that connection to me seeing as I do most of the child rearing, I would be shunned out of court. I wouldn’t get anywhere with it.

If I had my time again I would keep their surname as mine, or double barrel it. But I would never give them their father’s surname. I always just naively thought it was the “done thing.”

SlatsandFlaps · 30/05/2022 03:01

100% DISAGREE!!!!

Daneel · 30/05/2022 02:50

youdroppedthis · 29/05/2022 22:03

It's still a man's name no matter how far back you go.

Aside from the fact it's been (averaged out) just as many women's as men's, and that it doesn't really matter because the name you have grown up with is your name regardless of whether it was a matronymic or patronymic, there are matronymics such as Emmett and Merrill, that still survive as surnames today, and plenty we don't know for sure about.

Marty13 · 30/05/2022 02:20

I think people ought to be free to do what they want. But they should also ask themselves why they want their child to have the father's surname, and why the man doesn't take the woman's last name upon marriage.

I was always clear that my kids would have my name, and they do. It's my name just as much as it's my brother's name. It's the one I've had since birth. It's not about the name coming from my father or mother, it could be a totally made up name, doesn't matter - what matters is that this is the name I've identified with my whole life and I'd find changing it awkward and pointless. And I want my kids to have my names, because why shouldn't they ?

That said my SIL has given her kids my brother's last name, and his middle name as their middle names too. That's not the choice I would have made but I respect her right to decide for herself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread