Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage my dad to leave my mum

131 replies

Clementinemist · 29/05/2022 21:17

My mum (61) has always had crippling anxiety that has severely affected my family, but its to the point now where she won't do anything or go anywhere at all. But she is constantly telling me how depressed she is, and she keeps having panic attacks and calls me at random times of the day and night. All she does is sit at home and procrastinate. She's spoken to her GP, been to all kinds of therapy, done antidepressants, pills, mindfulness, all the usual things over the past 30 odd years. The fact that she's lacking any sort of life is at the heart of her problems but she seems unable, and to be honest unwilling, to do anything about it. It's like she's got comfortable just pottering around the house and doesn't care to do anything else now. She's basically just waiting to get old and die.

I honestly don't know what to do. It sounds horrible but I'm dreading the next 30 odd years of this. It's only going to get worse. My dad has floated the idea of divorce a few times over the past year. He's 64, retired recently, wants to downsize to the coast (about an hour away) and travel the world, but mum doesn't want to. (And she doesnt want him to go either). Aibu to encourage him to leave her? Might give her the wake up call she needs? Or sink her into worse depression? It's all causing such sadness and stress in our family, I just want everyone to be happy. I honestly don't know how I can support her anymore.

OP posts:
Menora · 31/05/2022 20:57

But OP personally knows the person she is talking about and in her experience, her DM is avoidant and resistant to effective change and has chosen not to participate in longer term therapy. We do not know her DM so we cannot judge that she is being abandoned, unloved or that this family arent at their wits end and find it tough supporting someone who has a very restrictive (and controlling) outlook on life. If you loved someone you would want the best for them, not just what’s best for you. Some people are inherently selfish and can’t see outside themselves

Discovereads · 31/05/2022 20:47

Ijsbear · 31/05/2022 13:18

What do you suggest then? That everyone else gets dragged down with her?

I've seen that. The other people around my mentially ill bio. mother lived in Hell. Physically, mentally and emotionally abused.

You can play the moral high ground card all you like but watching people's joy in life sucked out, they become cowed down and afraid to speak or do anything, kept up all night with her shrieking and shouting, having to climb over the tables to get away from her when she was wielding a kitchen knife .... It sounds dreadful when written down but the slow, unshowy destruction of joy in life is also terrible.

She could have helped herself only she chose not to engage with the extensive help she was offered. You really think that the people around someone like that should sacrifice their own lives at the cost of hers?

What is your solution, other than implying everyone around her is awful?

Such hyperbole saying “everyone gets dragged down with her”
It affects your life, but you don’t get dragged down. You can get help when a carer. You don’t have to cope alone. That’s what I’d suggest. I’m not implying everyone around her is awful, I’m saying that abandoning your disabled wife/mother/sister (supposed loved one) is an awful thing to do or to suggest/support to others to do. Furthermore the discussion of whether the disabled person is deserving of care or abandonment is ethically abhorrent. We have no right to judge whether a persons ongoing disabilities are due to them being lazy or not. Especially since mental health is hit or miss in terms of therapy and medication working, it’s worlds more difficult than fixing a broken arm.

farmergracey · 31/05/2022 17:31

I agree with talkingmouse. It isn't your place to encourage or discourage anything. If your Dad talks about leaving you can only say that you wouldn't judge him if he did.
However, it isn't an all or nothing situation for him. He can tell your mother that he would like her to go on holidays with him etc. but if she doesn't want to go he will be going anyway.
He can find hobbies of his own.
The only reason to go for divorce is if he wants to be free to meet a new partner, otherwise he can live his own life but be there for your mother sometimes. There are possible compromises.

Talkingmouse · 31/05/2022 13:29

It is not your place to interfere in their marriage.

But for him, it is not all or nothing. Just because you are married you don’t have to be joined at the hip. If he wants an overseas adventure and she doesn’t, he can go off on his own for a while, for example.

And for you, you need to set your own boundaries to her. It is not healthy for you to always be on call.

Ijsbear · 31/05/2022 13:18

Discovereads · 30/05/2022 20:13

So many “me first” types on here advising the OPs mum be abandoned by her family and left with no carer. I guess to some people, the disabled are subhuman and disposable.

What do you suggest then? That everyone else gets dragged down with her?

I've seen that. The other people around my mentially ill bio. mother lived in Hell. Physically, mentally and emotionally abused.

You can play the moral high ground card all you like but watching people's joy in life sucked out, they become cowed down and afraid to speak or do anything, kept up all night with her shrieking and shouting, having to climb over the tables to get away from her when she was wielding a kitchen knife .... It sounds dreadful when written down but the slow, unshowy destruction of joy in life is also terrible.

She could have helped herself only she chose not to engage with the extensive help she was offered. You really think that the people around someone like that should sacrifice their own lives at the cost of hers?

What is your solution, other than implying everyone around her is awful?

Onekidnoclue · 31/05/2022 09:29

i think the waters have been a bit muddied here. The “problem” isn’t the mothers mental illness. It’s her refusal to support the father in his passions for travel. I do not understand how anyone on here advocating for the mother think this is ok? I completely accept that she clearly has an illness and whether or not it’s within her control is a moot point. That illness or disability needs care but i fail to see why this means the father can’t have some time to pursue his passions. Other people have respite care. Why can’t this mother?
im so sorry op. It’s a very difficult position to be in. X

Sugarplumfairy65 · 31/05/2022 09:24

Stay out of it. Your father is an adult who can make his own decisions without undue influence from you.
Do you hate your mother so much that you would encourage her husband to abandon her

MakingNBaking · 31/05/2022 09:14

I'm not comfortable with the idea of actually encouraging your father to leave/divorce but I certainly think you could research and lay out some options which might give them both an acceptable way of living.
If they sold the existing house could it fund a small flat nearby which would make a nice, secure home for your mum and a base for your dad. Sheltered housing might be an option, that might make for a more engaging life for your mum as there would be a communal area where she might meet others. And there would be support there. Which might enable your father then to indulge his interest in travel.
Would that leave enough money for a holiday home by the coast (even perhaps a static caravan) that could become your dad's bolt hole?

stickygotstuck · 31/05/2022 08:41

OP I do understand your worry and frustration. But I'd stay out of it and support both your DPs to the best of your abilities, and that means withdrawing when it affects you too negatively.

All this talk of deserving and undeserving disabled is a red herring, plus only people who are children of of parents with MH problems and have or had MH problems themselves can begin to understand the OP's situation.

It's simply about when things have got to the point of no return. When enough is enough because the ill person is making everybody else ill too.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 31/05/2022 08:09

What happened to 'in sickness and in health?' Your mum is ill ffs.

Do you really think if he leaves she'll suddenly 'snap out of it?' Much more likely you will be dealing with the fall out.

Don't interfere in their marriage.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 31/05/2022 07:52

I voted yabu because I don't think you should either encourage or discourage your father to many any decisions about his marriage. It isn't your place. He is an adult and can make his own decisions.

I understand the situation with your mum. My own mum is very similar. It is difficult, but she is ill.

Their relationship is just that... their relationship. Don't stick your nose in where it doesn't belong.

Menora · 31/05/2022 07:46

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 30/05/2022 23:07

@Menora oh my lord your mum sounds so similar to mine. It’s so frustrating isn’t it! it’s interesting to hear another similar story. No one I know in real life has experienced anything similar so I often feel like I just a very harsh person for getting annoyed.

My mum has an underlying health condition that has impacted her cognitively and physically. However her condition is so much worse than it could be because she doesn’t do the things she’s needs to do to see an improvement. Even basics like going to her neurology appointment. My mum doesn’t do any of her physio, refuses to go out anywhere, does as little as possible because my dad will do everything for her. Over 30 years I’ve watched her slowly do less and less, always doing just less than she is actually capable of and then further loosing ability to do things for herself.

can I ask if you think the professionals (drs etc) address or recognise their patient is not following treatment/advice? My mums drs don’t mention it. My mum is having her shunt altered as her scores on the cognitive and mobility test they do at her neurology appointment have worsened. However since her last test she has had months not doing her physio, or indeed any form on movement (she only leaves her chair 2-3 times a day to be wheeled to the toilet) and she doesn’t do anything active to stimulate her mind. She just sits in her chair all day. I’m not sure how they could determine that worsening tests were caused by the fluid in the brain and not just by an increasing lack of activity. Obviously it could be either/or/both….but I find it odd they don’t mention life style at all.

It’s like a kind of learned helplessness and avoidance of reality. No the doctors say nothing. Occasionally someone like a physio will ask her WTF is going on. I think it’s because doing anything outside her comfort zone is scary. I’m sorry to hear about your DM’s health. It must be really awful for you to watch it happen

The saddest part is my mum used to travel when she was young, she had lots of friends and potential in life. For the last 20 years she’s made no effort to keep friends and doesn’t seem to understand why her grandchildren aren’t very interested in her. She will often sit in a room with all her grandchildren who she hasn’t seen for a few months and spend the whole time talking about herself and her ailments and all the restrictions she’s placed on herself

Cameleongirl · 30/05/2022 23:35

I agree with PP's that you mustn't get involved in your parent's relationship. Your Dad is looking for your approval to potentially leave your Mum and it's none of your business, quite frankly, he's being unfair. I'd tell him that their relationship is their business and that you can't get involved - but you'll continue to love them both regardless of what he decides.

My Dad has lifelong MH problems and isn't well at the moment with crippling anxiety and depression. I've been supporting him a lot recently, but I realized a long time ago that I also need to live my own life and I can't let his problems drag me down. To do this, you need to set some boundaries, e.g., no phone calls during the night, because it's simply not fair.

It's hard, OP, but your parents need to sort out their marriage themselves and you can still be kind and supportive to your Mum without getting too embroiled. Good luck. Flowers

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 30/05/2022 23:07

@Menora oh my lord your mum sounds so similar to mine. It’s so frustrating isn’t it! it’s interesting to hear another similar story. No one I know in real life has experienced anything similar so I often feel like I just a very harsh person for getting annoyed.

My mum has an underlying health condition that has impacted her cognitively and physically. However her condition is so much worse than it could be because she doesn’t do the things she’s needs to do to see an improvement. Even basics like going to her neurology appointment. My mum doesn’t do any of her physio, refuses to go out anywhere, does as little as possible because my dad will do everything for her. Over 30 years I’ve watched her slowly do less and less, always doing just less than she is actually capable of and then further loosing ability to do things for herself.

can I ask if you think the professionals (drs etc) address or recognise their patient is not following treatment/advice? My mums drs don’t mention it. My mum is having her shunt altered as her scores on the cognitive and mobility test they do at her neurology appointment have worsened. However since her last test she has had months not doing her physio, or indeed any form on movement (she only leaves her chair 2-3 times a day to be wheeled to the toilet) and she doesn’t do anything active to stimulate her mind. She just sits in her chair all day. I’m not sure how they could determine that worsening tests were caused by the fluid in the brain and not just by an increasing lack of activity. Obviously it could be either/or/both….but I find it odd they don’t mention life style at all.

Menora · 30/05/2022 21:49

I will use my own DM as an example.

she is like Op’s mum in many ways. She is in 60’s

last year my DM had a hip replacement. We had been telling her to see a doctor for 5 years as she couldn’t walk at all anymore. Despite not being able to walk, in agony, for 5 YEARS she would not go to the GP. We had chat after chat. She couldn’t come to anything we organised with our DC, her grandchildren. For 5 years, we had to do all of our family events, everything, with her sitting down as we felt too guilty to do anything without her. She could not do a single thing. Every Xmas, birthday etc she just sat there, complaining. My Dsis cracked up in the end and told her to see a GP. She got a hip replacement on the NHS.

after the hip replacement, she wouldn’t do any of the exercises and decided she wasn’t going to do much walking even though they told her to. She told social services that she didn’t need any help and I had to go there every fucking day (despite work, kids) to do all kinds things for her, some of which she could do herself, like put food wrappers into the bin and she lied to me there was no help from social services. After 12 weeks I refused to go back to help, she still wasn’t walking and would only get up with a walking frame to walk a short distance. She also wanted to carry on wearing support stockings even though she didn’t need to. I took her to a physio appt where they gave her a massive telling off and eventually she conceded to try some crutches. She doesn’t need crutches - she’s in no pain now, takes no meds, the hip replacement is perfect - she will still not walk unless she really has to.

Even though she can WFH in her job, she’s now decided she can’t do that either and is taking early retirement to sit at home, wait to get old and die.

what a life to lead

Menora · 30/05/2022 21:32

If Op’s mum had a physical disability and didn’t take her medication, go to any physical therapy on offer, chose not to use the equipment she needed, didn’t look after herself at all this would still be a mental and emotional issue and not a physical disability that is the issue. It still would affect her family and still be hard to deal with.

Many people with a physical disability adapt their life accordingly and try to make the best of what they have in life the best way they can do. There are vast ranges of physical disabilities so I am not sure how it can be compared. Are you comparing it to someone in a wheelchair? People in wheelchairs can live very fulfilled lives and technology is now amazing, the world is very wheelchair friendly. Are you comparing it to someone with a terminal illness? That doesn’t seem comparable. Comparing it with someone who has genetic defects? Everyone will have their own challenges in life to cope and manage and navigate. Staying indoors waiting to get old and die when you are 61 and in very good health is truly tragic for OP’s DM and I can see why it is so difficult to understand.

i am quite sure it sounds like from the OP that all of the family have made many adjustments of their own for many years to cater for the DM’s fears and anxieties - OP will have had a stressful and difficult childhood worrying about her parents and now seeing them live a sad half life. it is entirely understandable to be frustrated with someone who could, but chooses not to access help and support

Discovereads · 30/05/2022 21:30

Right so we are doing the deserving disabled vs the undeserving disabled then. You think the OPs mum is undeserving. I don’t do that as it’s just as ethically hideous as distinguishing between deserving poor and undeserving poor when deciding who deserves help and who should be thrown to the wolves.

JudyGemstone · 30/05/2022 21:24

OP said her mum only goes to one therapy appt and then quits. That is definitely not trying to get better, therapy isn’t a passive thing you have done to you, it’s work! It’s a bit of a controversial term but look up ‘secondary gain’ OP.

Oh and stay off the drama triangle! Your dad is a big boy and needs to work his own stuff out.

Porcupineintherough · 30/05/2022 21:21

@Discovereads read the OPs subsequent posts. Doesn't sound like her mum has really engaged with the therapy and treatments on offer. No, not everybody can or does recover from mental illness but its even less likely if you won't make the effort.

Discovereads · 30/05/2022 21:14

ValerieDoonican · 30/05/2022 21:08

I don't think anyone views OPs Mum as subhuman. But if she had a physical disability, it would quickly be recognised that there should be provision for care, respite stays etc to share Dad's load. He wouldn't be being told by posters to cope alone.

And if Mum was physically disabled, but declining to use mobility aids and insisting Dad stayed by her side 24/7 and personally carried her everywhere, people would recognise how unreasonable that was of the disabled partner.

No one’s saying he should cope alone. That is quite different from not divorcing someone because they are disabled.

And the OPs mum hasn’t declined any of the help offered to her, in fact she has actively sought help. The OP stated She's spoken to her GP, been to all kinds of therapy, done antidepressants, pills, mindfulness, all the usual things over the past 30 odd years

I don’t think the OPs mum is being unreasonable in the slightest. People are simply judging her as undeserving disabled because she hasn’t recovered. Not everyone with MH disorders recovers. And those that are lucky enough to have recovered, tend to ignore the part luck played and scribe it solely to their hard work. It’s not different from the Tory perspective on the deserving poor and thinking people are poor because they are lazy and simply aren’t working enough hours or haven’t had the wits to get a higher paid job.

ValerieDoonican · 30/05/2022 21:08

I don't think anyone views OPs Mum as subhuman. But if she had a physical disability, it would quickly be recognised that there should be provision for care, respite stays etc to share Dad's load. He wouldn't be being told by posters to cope alone.

And if Mum was physically disabled, but declining to use mobility aids and insisting Dad stayed by her side 24/7 and personally carried her everywhere, people would recognise how unreasonable that was of the disabled partner.

Discovereads · 30/05/2022 20:13

So many “me first” types on here advising the OPs mum be abandoned by her family and left with no carer. I guess to some people, the disabled are subhuman and disposable.

40andlols · 30/05/2022 19:57

Does he need a divorce? he could do the travelling etc, without her.

I think you need to stay out of it but perhaps float the idea of some solo travel for him in a way he knows you'd support it

sonjadog · 30/05/2022 19:54

I would let your dad know that you support him if he wants to travel and if he wants to divorce. Apart from that, I wouldn't get involved.

A580Hojas · 30/05/2022 19:47

I think you should support him if he chooses to go, OP.

Swipe left for the next trending thread