Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Won’t let nephew kiss baby

237 replies

cm1010 · 29/05/2022 19:06

I just want to know if I'm being unreasonable here and if I have a reason to be upset. I went to the zoo today with my parents, other half, sister, her other half and their three year old son and my five month old daughter. My nephew loves his cousin but likes to try and kiss her which I don't like. Today he went to kiss her on the lips whilst my mum was holding her so I put my hand on his shoulder to prevent him getting closer (he always has a cough and a runny nose) and I told him to kiss her on her hair instead (where I wipe straight afterwards) so my nephews dad then mumbled 'he's just a kid no need to push him' which he didn't say to my face but so I could hear. My nephew wasn't upset but this upset me because I feel I have every right to protect my baby and I did not push him away I simply put my hand on him to stop him touching her lips. My sister also asked why he's not allowed to kiss her on the lips. I was having a lovely day but it kind of ruined it for me :(

OP posts:
Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:48

Also, you're incorrect about the baby having little immunity because she's not been breastfed. We're humans - the immunity passes through the placenta from mother to child. Breast feeding has a miniscule impact pm your immunity. Even at a population level it's tiny. At an individual level it's irrelevant. Hopefully that misunderstanding will help you feel better about your child's resilience.

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:48

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:38

Your baby is going to get bugs whether you let her cousin kiss her not. You're being precious. A little boy wants to shoe affection to his cousin. It's adorable. You need to work on your anxiety not on your nephews behaviour. My daughter spent the first six months of her life with a cold. This was during covid so she never saw anyone. Her brother bought the germs home from nursery and did not need kiss her on the lips to pass the bugs on. Life happens. You're better off rolling with it and enjoying the good bits - like two cousins loving each other so much.

Again, you have to ask why it is precious to not want to spend the next week with an ill baby but NOT precious to find a three year old kissing them so "adorable" that you can't bring yourself to say "please don't do that darling or they'll get poorly". It's a ridiculous angle, the latter is far more precious.

Perhaps you need to work around your anxiety around saying no to minor things with your three year old, rather than OP needing to work on hers for not wanting her baby to have a bad cold?

It is much more possible to avoid catching a cold from your cousin on a day trip, than it is to avoid catching one from your sibling who lives with you and is in close contact with the same parents. Just because babies get bugs doesn't mean there's no sense in avoiding them when they are perfectly avoidable.

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:42

Eh?! 😅 you asked me why I'm "so focused" on one point and when I explained you call me "bizarrely defensive" FFS my responding to your questions are not any of those things, nobody owes you an explanation but I gave you one anyway and you reframed it as bizarre and defensive 🤷🏽‍♀️ what do you want from me?

Look we're getting wires crossed here. You think I'm doing what I think you're doing. I didn't want any explanation from you, I wanted to politely suggest an answer to the question I noticed you'd asked several times.

From my perspective, you asked OP a question, then when it was answered you made it clear you still didn't get it because you responded "but you had to wipe the snot anyway" a couple of times. I tried to suggest why someone might not just wipe his nose and your responses since have all been very "what are you trying to say to ME", "what are you accusing ME of doing"? Hence, defensive, because I clearly wasn't accusing you personally of doing anything, nor hounding you for your POV anymore so than you were hounding OP for hers when you responded to her posts with "but I still don't get why you wouldn't just wipe his nose".

You have a pretty direct line of questioning and seem to have a real issue with people doing the same to you in return.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:39

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:21

I'm defensive about responding to the the things people say to me and then being accused of being overly focused on the subject. How is that bizarre?
Don't act as though I'm the one obsessively mentioning something, or imply I'm demanding a satisfactory answer from OP. If someone addresses an accusatory post at me I will respond

Because I didn't accuse you of anything, yet you are being really defensive. I just explained why someone might not do what you asked a few times. What is your problem?

I also explained someone implied that my family and I are ignorant and I didn't say YOU were accusatory.

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:38

Your baby is going to get bugs whether you let her cousin kiss her not. You're being precious. A little boy wants to shoe affection to his cousin. It's adorable. You need to work on your anxiety not on your nephews behaviour. My daughter spent the first six months of her life with a cold. This was during covid so she never saw anyone. Her brother bought the germs home from nursery and did not need kiss her on the lips to pass the bugs on. Life happens. You're better off rolling with it and enjoying the good bits - like two cousins loving each other so much.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:35

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:21

I'm defensive about responding to the the things people say to me and then being accused of being overly focused on the subject. How is that bizarre?
Don't act as though I'm the one obsessively mentioning something, or imply I'm demanding a satisfactory answer from OP. If someone addresses an accusatory post at me I will respond

Because I didn't accuse you of anything, yet you are being really defensive. I just explained why someone might not do what you asked a few times. What is your problem?

Eh?! 😅 you asked me why I'm "so focused" on one point and when I explained you call me "bizarrely defensive" FFS my responding to your questions are not any of those things, nobody owes you an explanation but I gave you one anyway and you reframed it as bizarre and defensive 🤷🏽‍♀️ what do you want from me? 😂

namechangetheworld · 30/05/2022 11:24

Repulsive to allow a snotty toddler to kiss a young baby. Tell the parents to do some actual parenting next time and then you won't need to do it for them.

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:21

I'm defensive about responding to the the things people say to me and then being accused of being overly focused on the subject. How is that bizarre?
Don't act as though I'm the one obsessively mentioning something, or imply I'm demanding a satisfactory answer from OP. If someone addresses an accusatory post at me I will respond

Because I didn't accuse you of anything, yet you are being really defensive. I just explained why someone might not do what you asked a few times. What is your problem?

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:19

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:11

Yeah but I didn't ask you, your input doesn't make sense seeing as OP did let him kiss her.

Oh FGS. You asked OP a question, carried on discussing it with various posters, and then mentioned again that OP had not answered your question to your satisfaction. Since it's a wide discussion with various people chipping in I thought I'd helpfully suggest why OP might not have must wiped his nose. As it turned out, you are correct!

You are bizarrely defensive about anyone responding to the things you say.

I'm defensive about responding to the the things people say to me and then being accused of being overly focused on the subject. How is that bizarre?
Don't act as though I'm the one obsessively mentioning something, or imply I'm demanding a satisfactory answer from OP. If someone addresses an accusatory post at me I will respond 🤷🏽‍♀️ Raro

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:11

Yeah but I didn't ask you, your input doesn't make sense seeing as OP did let him kiss her.

Oh FGS. You asked OP a question, carried on discussing it with various posters, and then mentioned again that OP had not answered your question to your satisfaction. Since it's a wide discussion with various people chipping in I thought I'd helpfully suggest why OP might not have must wiped his nose. As it turned out, you are correct!

You are bizarrely defensive about anyone responding to the things you say.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:07

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:04

Yeah but honestly, what point were you trying to make with "B"? I'm not the one who let a snotty child kiss my baby, so what were you saying to me?

I was explaining why I wouldn't just wipe his nose and then tell him he could kiss her, which is what you keep asking OP.

Yeah but I didn't ask you, your input doesn't make sense seeing as OP did let him kiss her.

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 11:05

orwellwasright · 30/05/2022 10:42

If a member of my family wiped her baby down after I'd dropped a kiss on its head I'd think she was a rude as fuck, prissy pita.

@orwellwasright

id think YOU were rude as fuck for kissing my baby without permission.

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:04

Yeah but honestly, what point were you trying to make with "B"? I'm not the one who let a snotty child kiss my baby, so what were you saying to me?

I was explaining why I wouldn't just wipe his nose and then tell him he could kiss her, which is what you keep asking OP.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:03

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:59

@OvaryActions A second she might not have had. He was already leaning in to do it, on this occasion, on others he may have already done it, before she had a chance to stop him.

Plus as she's said she doesn't want to be wiping someone else's nose.

Why are you so focused on this one thing?

I made ONE point in ONE post and then have been replying to people who have tagged me. I have also had someone call me ignorant and act as though I need educating for allowing people to kiss my baby..despite not passing any judgment on others for their cultural/familial norms.

So don't keep @ing me and then question why I'm "so focused" FFS 🤦🏽‍♀️ Jesus 😂

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:00

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:45

@OvaryActions Well it's obvious why she wiped her DDs head rather than wiping his nose, isn't it? It happened quickly, it was damage limitation after something she didn't want to happen, rather than her being in a position to control it happening in the first place. Plus she probably feels more qualified to clean her own DC up.

Yes she could ask him to ask his parents to clean him up, too, but again, that hinges on the kiss being a very thought out, premeditated event.

It's not clear what YOU'RE trying to say. Whether she wiped his nose or wiped her DDs head isn't really the point, is it? It doesn't change anything about whether it's reasonable for OP to not want him to kiss her and to stop him when he was leaning in.

Yeah but honestly, what point were you trying to make with "B"? I'm not the one who let a snotty child kiss my baby, so what were you saying to me?

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:59

@OvaryActions A second she might not have had. He was already leaning in to do it, on this occasion, on others he may have already done it, before she had a chance to stop him.

Plus as she's said she doesn't want to be wiping someone else's nose.

Why are you so focused on this one thing?

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 10:56

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:45

@OvaryActions Well it's obvious why she wiped her DDs head rather than wiping his nose, isn't it? It happened quickly, it was damage limitation after something she didn't want to happen, rather than her being in a position to control it happening in the first place. Plus she probably feels more qualified to clean her own DC up.

Yes she could ask him to ask his parents to clean him up, too, but again, that hinges on the kiss being a very thought out, premeditated event.

It's not clear what YOU'RE trying to say. Whether she wiped his nose or wiped her DDs head isn't really the point, is it? It doesn't change anything about whether it's reasonable for OP to not want him to kiss her and to stop him when he was leaning in.

What?? 😆

It literally takes a second, nothing premeditated about it, just "hang on a second honey, you're all snotty" whoever cleans him up isn't important.

My point is in my original reply so maybe read that 🤷🏽‍♀️ if you do that you'll notice I didn't say OP was unreasonable for not wanting her baby to be kissed on the lips.

ATadConfused · 30/05/2022 10:55

Ducksurprise · 29/05/2022 19:17

Not unreasonable to not want kid to kiss your child
Unreasonable to use force to do so.

When your dd is older you won't like people putting their hands.on her

It's her nephew not some random kid FGS

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:45

@OvaryActions Well it's obvious why she wiped her DDs head rather than wiping his nose, isn't it? It happened quickly, it was damage limitation after something she didn't want to happen, rather than her being in a position to control it happening in the first place. Plus she probably feels more qualified to clean her own DC up.

Yes she could ask him to ask his parents to clean him up, too, but again, that hinges on the kiss being a very thought out, premeditated event.

It's not clear what YOU'RE trying to say. Whether she wiped his nose or wiped her DDs head isn't really the point, is it? It doesn't change anything about whether it's reasonable for OP to not want him to kiss her and to stop him when he was leaning in.

orwellwasright · 30/05/2022 10:42

If a member of my family wiped her baby down after I'd dropped a kiss on its head I'd think she was a rude as fuck, prissy pita.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 10:42

cm1010 · 30/05/2022 10:34

@aSofaNearYou exactly this! I can only just about handle my own little ones nose, anyone else’s makes me almost throw up! And you are right, there are still germs in the mouth even after snot has been wiped!

But you still had to wipe the snot Confused just off your poor daughter's head instead of nephew's nose.

That's what I said I didn't understand, you keep saying you're concerned about the germs 🤷🏽‍♀️

Badgirlriri · 30/05/2022 10:41

I don’t think you were wrong to stop him kissing her if he was full of snot.
I don’t agree with babies shouldn’t be kissed at all, I think that’s sad.
I think you are anxious and being PFB and need to remember he’s only little himself.
But I don’t understand why you’ve posted on here just to argue with everyone who doesn’t agree with you and seemingly constant drip feed’s.
The only reason people have implied you pushed him is because you said his dad said that, who was there and present at that time.

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 10:40

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 10:27

"would you not wipe your face/head if someone left snot there??
read the thread"
@LuckySantangelo35

No, I'd wipe the child's nose before he got snot on me 🤢

@OvaryActions

i would just not let the child kiss me rather than wipe the snotty nose myself.

I don’t want to wipe someone else snotty nose, it’s gross. I don’t want contact with someone else’s bodily fluid, whether they are a child or not. As others have said, it’s different when it’s your own child. Other kids I’m just as grossed out by as I would be an adult.

i would give that child a tissue so that they can wipe themselves which at 3 they should be capable of doing.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 10:39

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:30

@OvaryActions Personally I wouldn't just wipe DN's nose myself because

A) It's gross, frankly. I am immune to my own DC being gross but don't feel that way about other people's kids, I'm sure lots of people are the same.

B) It wouldn't fix the issue anyway, I still wouldn't want him to kiss her because the snot has revealed that he has a cold and is carrying germs. It isn't just about getting wor on her.

A. But there are options other than letting your nephew kiss your baby with a snotty nose or wiping yourself if that's how you feel. OP could've said something like "ask mummy/daddy to wipe your nose first sweetie/honey/whatever". Also OP ended up wiping it from her daughter's head anyway 🤢 so either way the snot needed wiping.

B. Again, my post was in response to OP wiping the snot off the daughter's head after the kiss instead of wiping it before the kiss, so not sure what you're trying to say to me?

TangyTangerine · 30/05/2022 10:39

Also you could use COVID As an excuse or say something like the health visitor said strictly no kissing On the lips.