Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Won’t let nephew kiss baby

237 replies

cm1010 · 29/05/2022 19:06

I just want to know if I'm being unreasonable here and if I have a reason to be upset. I went to the zoo today with my parents, other half, sister, her other half and their three year old son and my five month old daughter. My nephew loves his cousin but likes to try and kiss her which I don't like. Today he went to kiss her on the lips whilst my mum was holding her so I put my hand on his shoulder to prevent him getting closer (he always has a cough and a runny nose) and I told him to kiss her on her hair instead (where I wipe straight afterwards) so my nephews dad then mumbled 'he's just a kid no need to push him' which he didn't say to my face but so I could hear. My nephew wasn't upset but this upset me because I feel I have every right to protect my baby and I did not push him away I simply put my hand on him to stop him touching her lips. My sister also asked why he's not allowed to kiss her on the lips. I was having a lovely day but it kind of ruined it for me :(

OP posts:
nometo4 · 30/05/2022 23:24

OP, you were protecting your child. Your BIL was protecting his. You didn't do anything wrong.

Posting on Mumsnet for reassurance when you have anxiety is really counterproductive and usually makes you feel worse!

ijustcouldntthinkofausername · 30/05/2022 23:20

Sorry DD*

ijustcouldntthinkofausername · 30/05/2022 23:19

Try telling your nephew

I want DS to teach to blow kisses can you show her to blow kisses 😘

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 20:45

A) it's not a random kid tho, it's your nephew
B) if you don't let him kiss your child, you still don't have to but at least your nephews wellbeing isn't being ignored by everyone

Them being my nephew wouldn't make any difference, I'd still find it gross in the same way I would anyone else but my own DC who I am hardwired not to see that way.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/05/2022 18:58

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 10:30

@OvaryActions Personally I wouldn't just wipe DN's nose myself because

A) It's gross, frankly. I am immune to my own DC being gross but don't feel that way about other people's kids, I'm sure lots of people are the same.

B) It wouldn't fix the issue anyway, I still wouldn't want him to kiss her because the snot has revealed that he has a cold and is carrying germs. It isn't just about getting wor on her.

A) it's not a random kid tho, it's your nephew
B) if you don't let him kiss your child, you still don't have to but at least your nephews wellbeing isn't being ignored by everyone

SleepingStandingUp · 30/05/2022 18:50

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 09:26

It isn't OPs job but I wouldn't deliberately leave my nephew uncomfortable and gross because it isn't my child, but each to their own. She could have easily said let me wipe that nose and then you can kiss her on the head. For HIS sake. Even though it would clearly be a huge encumbrance upon his day and she'll never get those 5 seconds of her life back

Tbf I wouldn't actively encourage him to kiss her on the head, either. Germs are likely to spread whether he was snotty or not if he is ill. I would just distract him!

I o ly said on head as op had said she was happy with that tbh. I'm just sidetracked by all these adults letting a little kid walk around with snot down into his mouth and no one doing anything because "well I didn't give birth to him so why should I care"

cm1010 · 30/05/2022 14:17

This is it, I understand there are more likely to be complications at this age and if I don’t want my child to be kissed on the lips then that’s up to me and not my sister and her other half. My sister just has no common sense and doesn’t see danger in anything, she never did growing up and even let a little boy stroke our anxious dog once.. he was very lucky he didn’t have his hand bitten off!

OP posts:
Curiosity101 · 30/05/2022 13:18

YANBU - your baby is 5 months old. People shouldn't be getting close to a baby if they're poorly. The only ones being unreasonable are your sister, BIL and mum. I do feel for the little boy though as it'll potentially be mixed messages and it should be coming from his parents not you.

But I wouldn't want a poorly 3 y/o near my 9 month old (nevermind a 5 month old). My 9month old is (unfortunately) the second child though so he does get lots of his older (almost 3 y/o) brothers bugs. My toddler has had a stomach bug and Hand Foot and mouth recently though and through careful cleaning etc I managed to avoid myself and the baby catching them. Colds (and Covid) on the other hand... 🙄 No such luck. His brother has a habit of sneezing/coughing in the baby's face before we know he's ill. Babies are much more susceptible to developing complications at this age so if you can avoid it till they're a bit bigger I don't blame you. All bets are off when the go into childcare though.

As an aside I always give people with younger children/babies a heads up if any of us are poorly so they can decide whether they want to see us or not. I appreciate everyone has a different tolerance for illness and am happy to go by what they say if/when their child is more vulnerable than mine. So your family sound really inconsiderate to me.

lisavanderpumpscloset · 30/05/2022 12:38

Haven't read the thread because OMG.

But totally with you on this. As long as you didn't use force I don't think you did anything wrong. Your child, your rules

cm1010 · 30/05/2022 12:36

Yes! So many people on here are afraid of a toddler being told no! If he was coming at her to hit her, I wonder if I’d get the same response for preventing him getting closer..

OP posts:
cm1010 · 30/05/2022 12:35

Yep, everyone blames my anxiety but my other half doesn’t have anxiety and doesn’t want her being kissed on the lips either has he doesn’t do it, so it’s the both of us deciding that there will be no kissing on the lips!

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 12:33

Binsk · 30/05/2022 12:06

I knew this would be put down to anxiety. 🤦‍♀️ I also have anxiety OP, DP does not. Neither of us would want a snotty toddler, related or not, kissing our baby on the lips. And we also have a snotty toddler of our own who we would stop from trying to kiss a baby on the lips if he tried, without the baby's parent having to do it for us.
It doesn't matter if it's because he loves his cousin or whatnot, there are boundaries in life and you don't have to let anyone kiss your baby on the lips or wherever, whatever age they are.

Exactly!

I think a lot of the posters who are expressing outrage at Op and calling her anxious, germaphobe etc just can’t bear the idea of a toddler being told the word ‘NO’

which is far more precious IMO than the OP’s behaviour!

cm1010 · 30/05/2022 12:32

Wow, no need to be rude.. for your information I pulled myself away from my sister. She was infact trying to make up with me for a long time so I can’t be that bad..

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 12:31

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:53

I'm beginning to think this thread is just one for the germophobes and I should stay clear. I lived with a germophobe once and its no life for me.

@Franca123

oh dear

its not being a germaphobe to not want a toddler who snot all over his lips and nose and who clearly is full of cold to not kiss a five month old baby on the lips.

setting the obvious germs issue aside, it’s just minging 🤢 would you want to be kissed on the mouth or elsewhere on your head by someone who had snot on their nose and lips?

I wouldn’t! And if that makes me a germaphobe, then I’ll take that!

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 12:28

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:57

She only added the snot on the face thing in after people started telling her she was being ridiculous. She's exaggerating. I can fully see why she's fallen out with her family previously.

@Franca123

doubt it’s an exaggeration, toddlers frequently have snotty faces

cm1010 · 30/05/2022 12:24

Im wiping snot off my babies head, there’s no need for you to be ‘rude as fuck’

OP posts:
LemonSwan · 30/05/2022 12:11

I am super lax with my newborn being exposed to germs. Probably been held by over 100 people in their so far month long life.

I would not want anyone to kiss my newborns lips - that is just insane, let alone a snotty 3yo. Thankfully no one has tried to do that.

The only times I drew a line was at great grandpas forever unwashed allotment jumper (likely glyphosate covered) and funnily enough a snotty 3yo who had strings of boogers down his face and between his fingers - and grateful to the parents of the latter as they took control themselves and I didn’t need to step in.

So yanbu.

Binsk · 30/05/2022 12:06

I knew this would be put down to anxiety. 🤦‍♀️ I also have anxiety OP, DP does not. Neither of us would want a snotty toddler, related or not, kissing our baby on the lips. And we also have a snotty toddler of our own who we would stop from trying to kiss a baby on the lips if he tried, without the baby's parent having to do it for us.
It doesn't matter if it's because he loves his cousin or whatnot, there are boundaries in life and you don't have to let anyone kiss your baby on the lips or wherever, whatever age they are.

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 12:00

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:52

@aSofaNearYou where on earth have you got the impression I have anxiety from?! And what on earth are you talking about with saying no to my 3 year old? You're all over the place. Sorry but no clue what you're saying.

Ok I'll spell it out.

OP has mentioned that she has anxiety but that doesn't mean anxiety is the only reason to avoid a small baby getting ill when it's perfectly possible to do so. It's actually very logical and many without anxiety would do the same.

The fallout of one person's preferred course of action is a little baby being ill for often upwards of a week, so that's distressed child and sleepless nights for the parents for a long period of time. The outcome of the other person's preferred course of action is a three year old being kindly asked not to kiss the baby on that occasion, and taught a bit of empathy.

Yet in your opinion, the latter outcome is unacceptable because it's too "adorable" that they want to do it, yet avoiding the first is "precious". It makes no sense. It's clearly more precious to be unable to ask the three year old not to something.

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:57

She only added the snot on the face thing in after people started telling her she was being ridiculous. She's exaggerating. I can fully see why she's fallen out with her family previously.

OvaryActions · 30/05/2022 11:55

aSofaNearYou · 30/05/2022 11:42

Eh?! 😅 you asked me why I'm "so focused" on one point and when I explained you call me "bizarrely defensive" FFS my responding to your questions are not any of those things, nobody owes you an explanation but I gave you one anyway and you reframed it as bizarre and defensive 🤷🏽‍♀️ what do you want from me?

Look we're getting wires crossed here. You think I'm doing what I think you're doing. I didn't want any explanation from you, I wanted to politely suggest an answer to the question I noticed you'd asked several times.

From my perspective, you asked OP a question, then when it was answered you made it clear you still didn't get it because you responded "but you had to wipe the snot anyway" a couple of times. I tried to suggest why someone might not just wipe his nose and your responses since have all been very "what are you trying to say to ME", "what are you accusing ME of doing"? Hence, defensive, because I clearly wasn't accusing you personally of doing anything, nor hounding you for your POV anymore so than you were hounding OP for hers when you responded to her posts with "but I still don't get why you wouldn't just wipe his nose".

You have a pretty direct line of questioning and seem to have a real issue with people doing the same to you in return.

No, my only issue is with people responding to me and then telling me I'm too focused one one issue. That's literally it. I answered several responses to me, and the only time I brought it up was when you implied I was obsessing over one point. I brought up the responses to me by way of an explanation of why I was talking about this 'one point'. I was explaining that I'm not obsessed about this one point OR bizarrely defensive about it. Actually you clearly have been flinging accusations at me 😂

My other issue was the poster calling my family ignorant because we have different cultural norms.

Not once have I acted as if I don't want people to respond to me and also note, not once did I judge anyone on their personal norms.

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 11:55

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:38

Your baby is going to get bugs whether you let her cousin kiss her not. You're being precious. A little boy wants to shoe affection to his cousin. It's adorable. You need to work on your anxiety not on your nephews behaviour. My daughter spent the first six months of her life with a cold. This was during covid so she never saw anyone. Her brother bought the germs home from nursery and did not need kiss her on the lips to pass the bugs on. Life happens. You're better off rolling with it and enjoying the good bits - like two cousins loving each other so much.

@Franca123

A child smearing his snot on a baby’s face isn’t adorable

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:53

I'm beginning to think this thread is just one for the germophobes and I should stay clear. I lived with a germophobe once and its no life for me.

HikingforScenery · 30/05/2022 11:53

LuckySantangelo35 · 30/05/2022 10:24

@HikingforScenery

would you not wipe your face/head if someone left snot there??
read the thread

I totally missed the snot bit, OP. Sorry! I struggled to deal with my own Children’s snot in the beginning and now that they can blow their noses/clean them, I’ve gone back to being grossed out.

I’d not let him kiss my baby with snot on his face. That’s pretty grim. Could you not just ask his parent to wipe his nose first?

Franca123 · 30/05/2022 11:52

@aSofaNearYou where on earth have you got the impression I have anxiety from?! And what on earth are you talking about with saying no to my 3 year old? You're all over the place. Sorry but no clue what you're saying.