Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to encourage you to consider a home exchange for a holiday?

111 replies

notanothertakeaway · 29/05/2022 18:18

We have had fantastic experiences and it ticks so many boxes for us -

Free holiday

Live like a local

No ethical dilemma about holiday lets decimating local housing stock

Plenty of comfortable houses to choose from. For many people, it's a lifestyle choice, not because they cant afford a holiday

Yes you have to clean your house before you leave, but it needn't be a show home. Just be honest about facilities, distance from town centre etc

I realise it's not for everyone, but I hope some people might consider it. I think it's a great idea

OP posts:
crazynell · 29/05/2022 20:03

Swapped not stopped

crazynell · 29/05/2022 20:02

We did it and it was really great. Yes stopped with a Finnish family and they stayed in our 3 bedroomed London flat that we was a housing association rental.

We were met at the port and driven to their house by some friends of theirs. We met their family, although it wasn't intrusive as they left us to our own devices. The family told us to use their car and treat the house like our own. We broke a glass and replaced it but they said we didn't need to have done as some breakages were to be expected on both parts.

We learnt so much about their life and culture, as they did ours. The Finnish people went to our local south London pub and ordered what we normally have and got drunk apparently. They were were befriended by our neighbours - they spoke good English unlike us who couldn't speak or understand much Finnish.

It was an brilliant experience that we wouldn't have ever been able to afford to do if we'd stayed in hotels or self catering accommodation. You have to be open and trust them, just like they trusted us not to cause damage etc.

LaWench · 29/05/2022 20:02

Oh no I couldn't do this, I'm very territorial and would hate strangers in my house and my bed. My home is my private sanctuary.

Edderkop · 29/05/2022 19:55

@bellac11 - sounds much like our house. Lots of unfinished jobs. I couldn't subject someone else to our house and it's 'quirks' and expect them to think it's a holiday!

Nowisthemonthofmaying · 29/05/2022 19:52

I really wish I could do this, I would love it! Unfortunately dh can't cope with the thought of people staying in our house. I thought he was being a real stick in the mud but it looks like lots of mnetters agree with him! So now I'm talking my sister into it and angling to join her on holiday 😂

DuesToTheDirt · 29/05/2022 19:52

We did it lots when our children were younger, it was absolutely brilliant. As well as getting a house (always well-equiped of course, since the owners actually live there), we usually swapped cars and sometimes bikes. We mostly swapped with other people with kids, and they had plenty of toys, DVDs etc. We are lucky to live in a tourist destination, so we had plenty of choice, and sometimes we went to amazing places that I wouldn't have thought of.

The only downside is the cleaning (oh, the cleaning) - probably if we were cleaner day-to-day it wouldn't be a big job.

As for strangers sleeping in my bed, or seeing my photo albums or whatever, I really don't care.

You need a fairly upmarket house to do this, at least four bedrooms and definitely two bathrooms (we have more than one loo but only one shower).

We have 3 bedrooms, one other bathroom and one other loo. No-one ever complained about the facilities!

I also loved it that while we were having a fab holiday in someone's house, they were also (hopefully) having a fab holiday in ours.

WilsonMilson · 29/05/2022 19:48

Absolutely no way would I let strangers stay in my house,

BigChesterDraws · 29/05/2022 19:47

Not for me. Not only do I not want strangers in my home, I don’t consider it to be a holiday if I’m in a stranger’s house, who may or may not have my standards of cleaning, etc.

Fortunately we can afford good hotels and don’t need to do this.

DustyMaiden · 29/05/2022 19:47

Not in a million years. I like my home as it is. I find so many people take no care with things. Throw their keys down. Cups without coasters.

User48751490 · 29/05/2022 19:42

Just wouldn't entertain it. It's the thought of something going wrong. Someone sleeping in my bed - no!

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 19:36

Im just thinking about my half finished bathroom with no panel, half painted, ripped carpet on the stairs, laminate flooring downstairs that moves around of its own accord as we didnt fit it properly, handle falling off one of the back doors, the list continues!

riesenrad · 29/05/2022 19:31

Nobody would want to stay in my house! You need a fairly upmarket house to do this, at least four bedrooms and definitely two bathrooms (we have more than one loo but only one shower). Also our water system is quite noisy. And a few years ago we had a leak in the loft - imagine someone staying in your house while you are overseas and something goes wrong like a leak or less severe but still annoying, the hot water no longer working. No no no.

Staying in other peoples' lovely houses sounds fantastic - but sadly it's an "exchange" so not viable.

As for second homes, we don't have enough houses for many reasons, but with well over a million second homes in the UK, they are definitely a massive cause of the problem.

Albless · 29/05/2022 19:11

I’ve been doing this for a couple of years now, and agree with the OP - it’s a great way to visit other places and I love it! I’m registered with a company which lets you organise reciprocal exchanges - you stay in each other’s homes, or Guest Point exchanges - you earn so many points by letting people stay in your home, then spend them to stay in someone else’s. So far, because of Covid, mine have all been GP exchanges, but this year I’m doing a non-simultaneous reciprocal exchange. Later in the year I’m going to Spain for a week, to stay in the home of a woman who has already been to stay in my place.

The risk of your place being trashed is minuscule to zero, I would say. You are both taking an equal risk as you both are opening up your home for exchange. On the website I’m on, you can read reviews of each other as host and as a guest. You also get to know each other a bit through messaging each other.

The first time I ever went abroad was with my aunt and uncle who swapped their house with a French family. Because I live in a tied house for work, mine is a second home, but it is very much my home with my precious possessions. Everyone who’s stayed here has treated my home as if it were their own, and leaves a small gift and card to say thank you!

It really is a good experience for those who feel happy sharing their home like this, and like the OP, I definitely recommend it!

I’m with home exchange.com - there is an annual fee of about £125.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 29/05/2022 19:01

Nope, nope, nope.

I would absolutely hate to have people staying in my home while I wasn't here - this would be like my worst nightmare, lol. I definitely wouldn't be able to relax knowing there were strangers in my house either!

bellac11 · 29/05/2022 18:56

Good god no!!

I wouldnt tolerate anyone in my bed for a start and wouldnt want strangers in my house.
And wouldnt want to be in 'someone elses' personal home either.

The second home issue is a bit of a red herring for the fact that we just wont, for whatever reason, build social housing or rental housing at affordable cost for people to live in.

Luredbyapomegranate · 29/05/2022 18:52

I’ve never really thought about this. Great idea

Snowflakes1122 · 29/05/2022 18:41

Each to their own, but this is not for me! What about all your personal belongs? Some stranger having access to that? Sleeping in my bed? Nope!

rookiemere · 29/05/2022 18:39

We did UK home swaps through the NCT when DS was young.

We had a couple of great holidays, but was put off by a couple of incidents- the first one was the Chiswick house swap where the teen was still there for the first two days of our holiday because he couldn't get his Waitrose shift changed, and the other one near Legoland where the swappers left made up meals and desserts in the fridge that weren't I assume for us so went mouldy during the week as I didn't like to throw them out and didn't leave any cat litter so we had to buy it.

It's definitely something we'd consider once we retire and have more time to arrange swaps and less money to pay for holidays.

MadMadMadamMim · 29/05/2022 18:38

We did this a lot as kids. My parents were teachers and we had some fabulous holidays on the Continent with people they'd swapped with. I'm not sure if it was co-incidence, but most of the others were English teachers, I think - so fancied 3 weeks or so in England with only the cost of a ferry over to Hull (or somewhere).

We went to the same place in Amsterdam at least three times and the people became friends of my parents. We also went to Copenhagen - where the sister of the lady we'd swapped with was a ballerina with the Copenhagen Ballet Company and gave my parents free tickets to go see them. We had a month in Frankfurt at one point.

It was ace. (I'm talking about the 1970s here)

Floweryflora · 29/05/2022 18:37

notanothertakeaway · 29/05/2022 18:36

@Malariahilaria on the site we use, it's a mix of second homes and main residences

I totally understand it's not for everyone. We have a locked filing cabinet for paperwork and put anything personal in the garage while guests are here

All,your clothes, everything?

ChocolateCakeYum · 29/05/2022 18:36

Nice idea but I wouldn’t want strangers in my home and I doubt anyone would enjoy the area anyway. It’s not very touristy.

PandaOrLion · 29/05/2022 18:36

We haven’t done it but lots of friends do. One family have three children and it’s been ideal for them as they’ve stayed in some fabulous locations and often swap with other families so there are toys to share. It’s massively cheaper and they’ve all only had positive experiences.

notanothertakeaway · 29/05/2022 18:36

Malariahilaria · 29/05/2022 18:32

If I had a second home with ikea furniture and nothing too personal in it, then yes. Would never let strangers have free roam in my actual home though, very weird thought.

@Malariahilaria on the site we use, it's a mix of second homes and main residences

I totally understand it's not for everyone. We have a locked filing cabinet for paperwork and put anything personal in the garage while guests are here

OP posts:
Floweryflora · 29/05/2022 18:35

Do you leave all your clothes, paperwork, all your personal stuff? I am very happy for my friends to go anywhere in my home, I trust them implicitly but I cannot perceive a situation where I’d allow someone I’d never met stay.

notanothertakeaway · 29/05/2022 18:32

Fairislefandango · 29/05/2022 18:27

YANBU. We've done a house swap with some friends, which worked great. We do live on the edge of a very popular holiday location too, so we'd probably get quite a bit of interest. Do you do it through an organisation, OP?

@Fairislefandango yes we use homelink, only because a friend's neighbour used them. I expect there are plenty of similar sites

OP posts: