Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to encourage you to consider a home exchange for a holiday?

111 replies

notanothertakeaway · 29/05/2022 18:18

We have had fantastic experiences and it ticks so many boxes for us -

Free holiday

Live like a local

No ethical dilemma about holiday lets decimating local housing stock

Plenty of comfortable houses to choose from. For many people, it's a lifestyle choice, not because they cant afford a holiday

Yes you have to clean your house before you leave, but it needn't be a show home. Just be honest about facilities, distance from town centre etc

I realise it's not for everyone, but I hope some people might consider it. I think it's a great idea

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ManateeFair · 30/05/2022 23:34

If it works for you, great. I’m glad the option is there for people who want it. But personally, I would rather not go away at all than swap houses with strangers for a week.

Not only do I not want strangers in my own house, I don’t really want to stay in a stranger’s house either. Being in someone else’s family home really wouldn’t feel like a a holiday for me. I don’t want to ‘live like a local’ on holiday, because the whole point of going on holiday for me is to feel like I’m on holiday, not to feel like I’m living someone else’s ordinary daily life.

Runorsleep · 30/05/2022 18:59

We also have 3 youngish kids so cleaning the house and organising them for a big day of travelling in the morning is really difficult too but I can see if you have older children it would be easier.

llibrollibre · 30/05/2022 18:54

I love this idea but I've looked through listings before and it doesn't seem like a wonky ex-council house like ours is really in demand!

Runorsleep · 30/05/2022 18:53

Our house is always really clean and tidy but with 3 dcs and normal day to day things it’s definitely not minimalist ! It took a lot of work to make it pristine on the day and was a bit stressful leaving it like that on the morning of travel. It can definitely work well and is a big saving as accommodation is so expensive now but it’s a lot of work before. Also we’d never get a house with a pool and we use one in the campsites two times a day so we tend to go with that more than houseswaps.

2bazookas · 30/05/2022 18:52

*I don’t want strangers in it stealing stuff.

Plus I do not think my mortgage lender or buildings insurer would be at all happy!*

We have never had anything stolen, and our insurer was fully informed and perfectly happy. From their POV, an occupied house is more secure than one left vacant.

2bazookas · 30/05/2022 18:46

We've done it, and would happily do it again.

UglyModernWindows · 30/05/2022 18:44

Thanks OP! Now I just need to convince DH..

ZaZathecat · 30/05/2022 17:30

We did it once and it was a great experience. The only downside for me was getting our place looking ship shape before leaving, as we're not the tidiest family!
We do pretty much just have IKEA type furniture, nothing to be precious about.
The people who came to ours looked after our cat so that was helpful. They also left freshly made sandwiches for us to return to as they thought we'd be tired and hungry!
Oh and we swapped cars too, saving loads of money on car hire.

notanothertakeaway · 30/05/2022 17:26

Runorsleep · 30/05/2022 15:33

We have done it and I agree with some of your points op but I do think it really depends where you live etc . Also demographic of people , do they have kids etc ? Also it’s a huge amount of work before , you didn’t mention that but it is!!! Do you have kids @notanothertakeaway and what ages ? I think that’s also a big factor as to the state of a house etc for people.
All the bedrooms cleared of clothes etc (where do you put it ? we had extra space in attic to put all the clothes and random bits in rooms and living areas but loads of work. We actually had to paint areas as place needed refreshing , deep clean , empty fridge and freezer, for people working loads and with kids this can be loads and loads of work before a holiday. Clean sheets the morning you leave on every bed, leaving for a holiday that day is manic , leaving it absolutely immaculate when you are wrangling with kids and all the logistics of travel that day is mental tbh.
Can you explain how you managed it in the morning of your travel @notanothertakeaway ?
Also we have 3 v v high energy kids so need access to a pool etc , that’s why we go to campsites as the area we go to is all villas and although our area is nice , our house wouldn’t compete with a villa with pool tbf..
Also we find we meet way less people on our own in a house vs in a campsite area where it’s v international and we also spend loads of time in the local areas too.
Its just not as simple as it sounds and can take a lot of work beforehand tbh and after!
We live in a tourist area though and can rent the place on Airbnb when travelling but still epic work before.

@Runorsleep Our house is quite minimalist, I suppose, and it's pretty clean and tidy all year round, so for us, there isn't much additional cleaning etc

I don't empty wardrobes completely. Just put underwear in a bin bag and hide it in the garage. I bought an extra sheet / duvet cover, so we can whip off our bedding before we depart, leave it in the garage and wash it on our return

On departure day, we don't really have much to do. Just a quick clean of the bathroom and kitchen surfaces, and make beds (or leave out bedding for guests to do that when they arrive). Everything else is already done

OP posts:
iklboo · 30/05/2022 17:26

I doubt where I live is on anyone's holiday destination list.

notanothertakeaway · 30/05/2022 17:19

RaisinGhost · 30/05/2022 13:06

I wouldn't mind this but no one would want to stay in my area, even as a "base" to go elsewhere - they'd just choose a base in that area.

Also surely it only works for retired people, who don't work or have kids at school so don't have many restrictions on when or how long they go for. As you need a double coincidence of wants with the dates. It's hard to even get a friend to go on holidays with you because you both won't be free at the same time, let alone being free at the same time as a stranger who also wants to stay in your house.

@RaisinGhost There's quite a bit of coming and going to find suitable dates, that's v true. It's not as simple as looking on a holiday website to see what's available on the dates you want. Plenty of initial enquiries don't get off the ground

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 30/05/2022 15:42

It is a lot of effort before you go. There is no such thing as a free lunch. We didn’t swap for the first time in 10 years last summer and wow it was lovely not having to leave the house pristine!

Runorsleep · 30/05/2022 15:35

I also agree with pp , a lot of houses on house swaps we viewed were v high tend type housing.

Runorsleep · 30/05/2022 15:33

We have done it and I agree with some of your points op but I do think it really depends where you live etc . Also demographic of people , do they have kids etc ? Also it’s a huge amount of work before , you didn’t mention that but it is!!! Do you have kids @notanothertakeaway and what ages ? I think that’s also a big factor as to the state of a house etc for people.
All the bedrooms cleared of clothes etc (where do you put it ? we had extra space in attic to put all the clothes and random bits in rooms and living areas but loads of work. We actually had to paint areas as place needed refreshing , deep clean , empty fridge and freezer, for people working loads and with kids this can be loads and loads of work before a holiday. Clean sheets the morning you leave on every bed, leaving for a holiday that day is manic , leaving it absolutely immaculate when you are wrangling with kids and all the logistics of travel that day is mental tbh.
Can you explain how you managed it in the morning of your travel @notanothertakeaway ?
Also we have 3 v v high energy kids so need access to a pool etc , that’s why we go to campsites as the area we go to is all villas and although our area is nice , our house wouldn’t compete with a villa with pool tbf..
Also we find we meet way less people on our own in a house vs in a campsite area where it’s v international and we also spend loads of time in the local areas too.
Its just not as simple as it sounds and can take a lot of work beforehand tbh and after!
We live in a tourist area though and can rent the place on Airbnb when travelling but still epic work before.

MsTSwift · 30/05/2022 15:20

We tended to swap with equivalent families- when ours were primary aged we swapped with quite a few families with similar aged kids then they have each other’s toys which is a result! The best holiday ever was when the swappers cat had had a kitten. There were tears at the end of that holiday…

Puzzledandpissedoff · 30/05/2022 15:14

We wanted to spend time with relatives and friends but don't really enjoy staying in their homes

Yet another excellent reason for those who enjoy this to do it, rookiemere Smile

Also surely it only works for retired people, who don't work or have kids at school so don't have many restrictions on when or how long they go for

Not necessarily, RaisinGhost; there are a heck of a lot of families with DCs on the sites, who appreciate having a place to themselves (and of course if they swap with others who have children they can be pretty sure the home will be suitable). It's true with a lot of Americans though, because of the very restricted leave many get

PrisonerofZeroCovid · 30/05/2022 13:55

ooh- I might look into this. We do live in a touristy area and we used to rent our house out as a holiday let when we lived overseas (in fact I have to clear out in the summer as we have bookings I couldn't bring myself to cancel). I hadn't really thought about swaps but looks interesting. So long as they dont mind watering my pots I dont mind if they wear my clothes and commit acts of unspeakable depravity with my kitchen utensils Grin

rookiemere · 30/05/2022 13:53

Thanks for starting the thread OP. DH and I are starting to consider the rather large gap between our future retirement travel desires and our actual pensions. House swaps are a fantastic idea.

jamapop · 30/05/2022 13:53

I wouldn’t do this with a stranger but I was thinking recently how well this would work with family / friends.

I just don’t think I could lock all my personal items away. There are too many. All paperwork… the computer.. anything of value that we aren’t taking with us.. photos .. all underwear etc. It would be like packing up to move house almost! But yes amongst people you know.

yikesanotherbooboo · 30/05/2022 13:50

My DPs did this twice and holidays in South Africa and the USA that they would otherwise found too expensive.They liked the reciprocal nature of it.Thw biggest nuisance was all the tidying and sorting before hand ;and they were very organised and minimalist types.We live in what looks like a jumble sale most of the time so I am not sure that we could offer a good swap.DPs lived in leafy commuter belt with great access to London, coast, NT type places and airports.

MsTSwift · 30/05/2022 13:23

Actually I think the classist accusation is probably fair. We have a nice house in a beautiful tourist city and we swap with others with nice houses or flats in desirable locations around the world mainly Europe.

Doubt the Californians we swapped with would exchange their house and travel all that way for a semi in Redditch in need of modernisation. Ironically (because it’s a free holiday) it seems to be quite wealthy people with nice houses that swap with each other.

Xenia · 30/05/2022 13:08

People tend not to want outer London suburbs where it takes an hour to get anywhere even Watford and I doubt Watford is on many people's hit lists for a holiday!

RaisinGhost · 30/05/2022 13:06

I wouldn't mind this but no one would want to stay in my area, even as a "base" to go elsewhere - they'd just choose a base in that area.

Also surely it only works for retired people, who don't work or have kids at school so don't have many restrictions on when or how long they go for. As you need a double coincidence of wants with the dates. It's hard to even get a friend to go on holidays with you because you both won't be free at the same time, let alone being free at the same time as a stranger who also wants to stay in your house.

Fairislefandango · 30/05/2022 12:59

YABU because this whole concept is absolutely classist!

You might just as well say that holidays are classist full stop. Or that starting a thread recommending anything that some people might not be able to afford is classist.

The OP isn't BU to suggest a type of holiday just because some people might not be able to do it or want to do it.

KosherDill · 30/05/2022 12:53

Badqueen · 29/05/2022 18:21

Would not be comfortable with strangers in my house at all.

This.

I wouldn't dream of such a thing.

And I have no ethical qualms about the existence of holiday homes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread