Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 19:15

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 19:13

@MsEverywhere I think you raise a very interesting point but it is slightly at odds with the fact that Mumsnet is pretty middle class and not too trans friendly judging by this thread!

Ridiculous post.

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 19:13

@MsEverywhere I think you raise a very interesting point but it is slightly at odds with the fact that Mumsnet is pretty middle class and not too trans friendly judging by this thread!

OP posts:
FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 19:13

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 18:51

FoiledByTheInsect

If it is part of the ‘capitalist agenda’ why is it the right who are generally against it and the left (apart from the old school feminists) who are totally for it?

Why do people insist on pigeonholing and labelling all the time? Where are your statistics to back up those enormous generalisations you just made? Why is being "an old school feminist" a bad thing, and why are you even daring to use such a condescending term anyway, when women are still treated like absolute crap in 2021 and now have another battle to fight on top of what they already have to deal with?

Excellent point MsEverywhere about intellectual laziness and deceit.

MsEverywhere · 29/05/2022 19:04

Smartsub · 29/05/2022 17:06

Because its a difficult issue, nowhere near as clear cut as MN wants it.

I work with intelligent, educated, professional women. The overwhelming preference is for inclusion over women's rights. I don't hear the women's spaces argument ever and if I try to introduce it, people genuinely don't care.

Easier, I think, for right wingers to see it as black and white.

Yeah I’ve noticed that middle class people really don’t care about lower income people. They never meet any and have no idea or interest in the differences of life experiences. And the current ‘progressive lefty’ analysis on identity leaves no room for that class analysis. So yeah, they have no motivation to think about how this ideology disproportionately affects lower income women who are more likely to be in prison, refuges and homeless shelters. In fact they have an incentive not to, as doing so could cause them to rethink their allegiance to this ideology and put them at risk of name calling within their ‘progressive’ group.

MsEverywhere · 29/05/2022 18:55

VladmirsPoutine · 29/05/2022 16:46

I think a lot of them (politicians) also do realise that trans people are just the newest marginalised group to have a pop at. This cycle has happened in the past with gay men, ethnic minorities and so forth and have chosen not to play ball. I mean all of them but the tories. The tories would bring back public hanging if it proved a popular policy idea with the electorate.

But they are not. Gay people fought for their rights as gay people.. People of color fought for their rights as people of color. Nearly Everyone is on board for people with gender dysphoria not to be discriminated against for having gender dysphoria. Nearly everyone is on board for people not to be discriminated against for not conforming to sex based stereotypes.

The area of contention is that this particular gender ideology is not fighting for trans peopke’s rights as trans people, but is fighting for their rights as something they are not; that is the opposite sex. And that creates real implications for the rights and safeguarding of women and girls.
No other civil rights movement has fought for their rights by claiming they are something they are not ( literally women rather than trans) or has founded their rights by crushing the existing rights of others, or by fundamentally redefining another group ( women) to enable the diminution of the rights and safeguarding of that other group.
So no, this movement is nothing like the civil rights fight of any previous groups and it is intellectual laziness and moral deceit to claim it is.

lightand · 29/05/2022 18:52

Because politicians dont necessarily just act in the electorates' best interest.
They have other agendas and people to please.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 18:51

FoiledByTheInsect

If it is part of the ‘capitalist agenda’ why is it the right who are generally against it and the left (apart from the old school feminists) who are totally for it?

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 18:49

Smartsub

you mean you work with women who have luxury privilege. Who are highly unlikely to find themselves in a refuge or a prison and don’t give a shit about the women who might so they can gaily virtue signalling without it having any impact on them.

GrinAndVomit · 29/05/2022 17:54

Fear and cowardice.

ChagSameachDoreen · 29/05/2022 17:48

It's called institutional capture.

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 17:37

glamosaurus · 29/05/2022 17:17

Capitalism. Putting children on a lifetime path of medical interventions is where big pharmaceutical giants come in, then you've got the tech giants on board. Before you know it, it's ubiquitous and here we are.

People have been utterly brainwashed.

Totally this. It's part of the capitalist agenda. If they don't cripple them with sugar, junk food and wall-to-wall tech, they'll get them some other way. Children are mentally overloaded and out of touch with their bodies, forced to intellectualise everything, to me being a mother just feels like a damage limitation exercise.

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 17:37

brookstar · 29/05/2022 17:06

as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible

And where do we draw the line?
At what point do we prioritise the Safeguarding of women? Where is that line?

Thats the bit that should be up for debate I suppose.

For me the penis is a pretty clear line in certain spaces where women are vulnerable.

OP posts:
houseonthehill · 29/05/2022 17:20

Politicians probably keep an eye on polls on attitudes. YouGov results are typical - women more transfriendly, Libs and Labour voters also.

But my observation about women policing examples of deviation from TWAW etc is experience of it on social media. It really isn't just TRAs and men - in fact, I'd say that a lot of men don't much care, for obvious and privileged reasons. It is even a schism within Feminism. And also there are generational factors- for many young people, it's their Civil Rights issue and they really do see it in the terms that previous generations though of gay rights or campaigns against racism.

glamosaurus · 29/05/2022 17:17

Florenz · 29/05/2022 16:56

What power to the Trans lobby even have?

Capitalism. Putting children on a lifetime path of medical interventions is where big pharmaceutical giants come in, then you've got the tech giants on board. Before you know it, it's ubiquitous and here we are.

People have been utterly brainwashed.

Persephoned · 29/05/2022 17:08

Because trans people are a marginalised often persecuted group, and women - who have also long been marginalised - are concerned about rights and safe spaces for women being eroded, and whatever a politician says they are likely to offend/upset/enrage a sizeable proportion of people as this is a hugely emotive subject.

Smartsub · 29/05/2022 17:08

Smartsub · 29/05/2022 17:06

Because its a difficult issue, nowhere near as clear cut as MN wants it.

I work with intelligent, educated, professional women. The overwhelming preference is for inclusion over women's rights. I don't hear the women's spaces argument ever and if I try to introduce it, people genuinely don't care.

Easier, I think, for right wingers to see it as black and white.

The only context in which the women I know care is sport.

Smartsub · 29/05/2022 17:06

Because its a difficult issue, nowhere near as clear cut as MN wants it.

I work with intelligent, educated, professional women. The overwhelming preference is for inclusion over women's rights. I don't hear the women's spaces argument ever and if I try to introduce it, people genuinely don't care.

Easier, I think, for right wingers to see it as black and white.

brookstar · 29/05/2022 17:06

as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible

And where do we draw the line?
At what point do we prioritise the Safeguarding of women? Where is that line?

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 17:02

Stats to back that up, house?

houseonthehill · 29/05/2022 16:59

They wouldn't be winning votes from 50% of the population (women) by saying the Bad Thing, though - women are as split on the issue, and as vociferous in their TERFhunting as any other group.

Florenz · 29/05/2022 16:56

What power to the Trans lobby even have?

yesthatisdrizzle · 29/05/2022 16:52

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 16:45

Because patriarchal brainwashing, women really must know their place and it's unladylike to shout FUCK OFF YOU PATRIARCHAL KNOBBERS repeatedly until the menstruating women-cancellers shut up long enough for us to address that question.

Nah. It's easy. We just ask the question. In fact, I'm going onto the 'Ask Boris' thread now to do just that.

PerfectionValley · 29/05/2022 16:47

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 16:37

I don't really buy that argument.

They'd get a huge positive response by making a clear statement. Why focus on what the extremists might say.

Because it seems like the extremists have managed to manoeuvre themselves or their allies into a lot of powerful positions. In large businesses that have a lot of influence, in most English speaking governments, in almost all social media sites, it is everywhere.
They've basically manipulated people into believing that mainly white male transitioners are literally the most vulnerable people in society.
I have to admire the way it's been done behind closed doors, but it's perplexing that so many people go along with it.
I imagine that's why schools and children have been targeted with this ideology. It's much harder to argue against it when your own child is firmly on board with it.

VladmirsPoutine · 29/05/2022 16:46

I think a lot of them (politicians) also do realise that trans people are just the newest marginalised group to have a pop at. This cycle has happened in the past with gay men, ethnic minorities and so forth and have chosen not to play ball. I mean all of them but the tories. The tories would bring back public hanging if it proved a popular policy idea with the electorate.

Member869894 · 29/05/2022 16:46

Transwomen are not women though