Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
HeadNorth · 29/05/2022 20:03

TotalRhubarb · 29/05/2022 19:51

Absolutely this.

Younger women tend to have bought the narrative that they can do anything men can and the old sexist barriers have been torn down. I know I did.

Young men and women often have opportunities and pay that look quite similar at the start of their careers. It’s not till you get into your thirties that the gap starts to appear and having children is the absolute game changer in terms of inequality of opportunity thereafter.

Yes, I agree with these posts. Young women have not grappled with the realities of the limitations that will be imposed on them due to their physical female bodies. Motherhood is a shock in its absolute unignorable physicality and changes so much of how you engage the world and how it engages with you.

Like most people, I am completely happy with trans people wanting to to live their lives as the opposite gender on a day to day basis. I think the wicked problems are around sports, prisons and healthcare and that is where adult discussion and compromise is required all round. It certainly won’t influence the party I vote for - family poverty and insecure housing is my big ticket item.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:02

I'm referring to trans men who have had reconstruction

Then they're not actual penises, they don't function as penises do.

PerfectionValley · 29/05/2022 20:01

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:56

But what if woman physically do have penises? now what? Is it a figment of their imagination? (I'm referring to trans men who have had reconstruction, just interested to know where you stand on that).

But it's not a penis, is it? It's a roll of skin that's been harvested from an arm or leg that comes with a whole load of complications. Have you actually looked into what they do?
And they haven't changed sex in any way, they are still adult human females.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:56

YouSetTheTone · 29/05/2022 19:54

Trans community = ‘most marginalised’ seems hard to swallow when every major institution (including the police force, the judiciary, prisons service, the NHS, the BBC) proudly fly the trans flag at every opportunity and bend over backwards to accommodate gender ideology. There are zebra crossings painted in trans flags. Masked men can get away with assaulting women speaking in public about issues pertaining to women under the name of trans activism.

Transwomen now have access to female sporting competitions, female prizes, female bursaries, female prisons, female rape counselling services as well as male ones. So marginalised…

Women are murdered on average every two-three days in the U.K. there has not been a murder of a transperson for the past two years. So unsafe…

Society will believe a man who says he’s a woman over a woman who says he is not.

Politicians will not answer this question because they’ve been captured entirely by Stonewall and the damage is taking a long time to unpick. Watch the Nolan Investigates podcasts on how SW influenced major institutions via the back door, it’s eye opening and depressing.

Women don’t have penises. A woman is an adult human female and redefining the term to include men has catastrophic impacts on women. Politicians need to wake up fast.

But what if woman physically do have penises? now what? Is it a figment of their imagination? (I'm referring to trans men who have had reconstruction, just interested to know where you stand on that).

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:55

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 19:53

I'm not arguing any further with you. Your posts don't contain a glimmer of reason.

Bye.

Ah, sorry. Disrupted your echo chamber.

YouSetTheTone · 29/05/2022 19:54

Trans community = ‘most marginalised’ seems hard to swallow when every major institution (including the police force, the judiciary, prisons service, the NHS, the BBC) proudly fly the trans flag at every opportunity and bend over backwards to accommodate gender ideology. There are zebra crossings painted in trans flags. Masked men can get away with assaulting women speaking in public about issues pertaining to women under the name of trans activism.

Transwomen now have access to female sporting competitions, female prizes, female bursaries, female prisons, female rape counselling services as well as male ones. So marginalised…

Women are murdered on average every two-three days in the U.K. there has not been a murder of a transperson for the past two years. So unsafe…

Society will believe a man who says he’s a woman over a woman who says he is not.

Politicians will not answer this question because they’ve been captured entirely by Stonewall and the damage is taking a long time to unpick. Watch the Nolan Investigates podcasts on how SW influenced major institutions via the back door, it’s eye opening and depressing.

Women don’t have penises. A woman is an adult human female and redefining the term to include men has catastrophic impacts on women. Politicians need to wake up fast.

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 19:53

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:51

I'd bet my house JKR has just backed herself into a corner and now has to carry on.

@Johnnysgirl I think that's even worse.

I'm not arguing any further with you. Your posts don't contain a glimmer of reason.

Bye.

TotalRhubarb · 29/05/2022 19:51

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:35

I think a large part of it is age, not class or left/right leaning. I notice that it is mostly women of a certain age tackling this in the media. It's not surprising. It wasn't until I got to the point of having children that I realised just how much the odds are stacked against women and how important our sex based rights are.

It doesn't surprise me that young women, who haven't yet grasped the extent of the misogyny they will face in their lives are in favour of gender subsiding sex based rights. They are caught up in the idea that this is the human rights issue of their generation and they just don't understand the harm this does to the rights of their own sex.

Absolutely this.

Younger women tend to have bought the narrative that they can do anything men can and the old sexist barriers have been torn down. I know I did.

Young men and women often have opportunities and pay that look quite similar at the start of their careers. It’s not till you get into your thirties that the gap starts to appear and having children is the absolute game changer in terms of inequality of opportunity thereafter.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:51

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:47

Yeah, it's gone really well for her.

Some people have courage and principles and others don't. 🤷‍♀️

There are more important things than being lauded on Twitter.

I'd bet my house JKR has just backed herself into a corner and now has to carry on.

@Johnnysgirl I think that's even worse.

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 19:47

pretending to be confused as to how a woman can possibly change sex
I'm genuinely not pretending.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:47

Yeah, it's gone really well for her.

Some people have courage and principles and others don't. 🤷‍♀️

There are more important things than being lauded on Twitter.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:47

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 19:13

@MsEverywhere I think you raise a very interesting point but it is slightly at odds with the fact that Mumsnet is pretty middle class and not too trans friendly judging by this thread!

Put pretty respectfully, and on the money completely.

Women women women women women echo chamber.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:46

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:45

Why on earth would anyone choose to put themselves in the firing line if they have a position they want to keep?

We can't keep cowering from the bully boys. Thank fuck for JKR and her refusal to be silenced.

Yeah, it's gone really well for her.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:45

Ooft, don your hard hat OP.

On here, the party line is pretending to be confused as to how a woman can possibly change sex and very graciously list your 2 percent of very generous acceptances you will allow trans people.

The reason they can't say that is because the 'feminists' would be up in arms, but I totally agree with you.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:45

Why on earth would anyone choose to put themselves in the firing line if they have a position they want to keep?

We can't keep cowering from the bully boys. Thank fuck for JKR and her refusal to be silenced.

InChocolateWeTrust · 29/05/2022 19:44

I work with intelligent, educated, professional women. The overwhelming preference is for inclusion over women's rights. I don't hear the women's spaces argument ever and if I try to introduce it, people genuinely don't care.

This surprises me. I also work with intelligent, educated, professional women and my experience has been the reverse. The preference has been strongly for women's rights and the protection of women's spaces, to the extent that the reverse position is considered laughably woke.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:43

Given the difference in opinions about what their answer should be, even in this thread, they're not going to be able to win whatever they say.

Im not sure it's about that. Biological fact should be respected and pretty ridiculous they don't have the balls to state basic truths.

InChocolateWeTrust · 29/05/2022 19:42

"Woman do not have penises. As a society, this fact does not preclude us from acknowledging and respecting individual's gender choices, where doing so does not negatively impact others."

How's that?

saraclara · 29/05/2022 19:37

Given the difference in opinions about what their answer should be, even in this thread, they're not going to be able to win whatever they say.

If I see in the public eye on any way, if avoid answering the question too.
Jeeze, we all know what happened to JKR. Why on earth would anyone choose to put themselves in the firing line if they have a position they want to keep? There will be a lot of us in this thread who would be risking their job or their reputation if they gave an honest answer. And they're not even in the public eye.

Notaneffingcockerspaniel · 29/05/2022 19:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:36

Subsuming not subsiding - sorry

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 19:35

I think a large part of it is age, not class or left/right leaning. I notice that it is mostly women of a certain age tackling this in the media. It's not surprising. It wasn't until I got to the point of having children that I realised just how much the odds are stacked against women and how important our sex based rights are.

It doesn't surprise me that young women, who haven't yet grasped the extent of the misogyny they will face in their lives are in favour of gender subsiding sex based rights. They are caught up in the idea that this is the human rights issue of their generation and they just don't understand the harm this does to the rights of their own sex.

artisanbread · 29/05/2022 19:24

From a politician's point of view, you risk alienating a proportion of voters whatever you say. Despite the prevailing view on MN, there is a strong trans rights movement, particularly among young people including young women. There is also a vocal GC movement.

It's a difficult issue to find a compromise position on. Probably needs a complete rethink of public spaces which would be time-consuming and costly and likely still unpopular amongst different groups.

Artichokeleaves · 29/05/2022 19:19

The 'middle class' is a myth as has been debunked on multiple threads many times. This is the thing: women here are passionate about female needs, issues and rights because this is a place where people get what it's like to run with your kids at 3am in the morning with a broken nose and PTSD to a refuge, or to have friends with disabilities or faiths or cultures that make mixed sex spaces inaccessible as opposed to just having interesting TQ+ friends, or have had to quit going to women only groups for health needs because they've been TQ+ taken over, or whose lesbian group has gone underground to escape male harassment and propositioning, or who actively do safeguard kids in a range of jobs, and support things like the Deptford Women's Project, and have the breadth of knowledge and belief that things should work for everyone as opposed to 'just me and my special mates'.

Being 'un trans friendly' usually translates in practical terms as 'won't get under the bus for TQ+ politics'.

Female centric view is - can we have solutions and accomodation that equally value everyone and work for everyone, and inclusion doesn't exclude anyone? Everyone matters and everyone should be cared for equally.

The pushed ideological view is - females must lose, some will be excluded and no one cares, inclusion is about male TQ+ people's wishes and needs only, and there have to be winners and losers. And homophobia and misogyny is fine, so long as you direct them to female people not doing what we say.

Frankly I know which view I see as more ethical.

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 19:18

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 19:15

Ridiculous post.

Could you explain how please?

MN in mind is full of middle class lefties so according to the logic in the post I'm responding to, it should be pro trans inclusion everywhere as it wouldn't affect them so much.

OP posts: