Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:35

Trans women, who are biologically male, do not have periods. There is nothing hurtful about refusing to accept the delusion that they do.
Why are you hurt at having reality pointed out to you?

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:35

Do you mean the tweet where she said "People who menstruate.’ I’m sure there used to be a word for those people. Someone help me out. Wumben? Wimpund? Woomud?"?

You might think it's incendiary. I don't. It's clearly pointing out that the word "women" is being erased from medical literature. This is to the detriment of vulnerable women. In the same way the NHS is removing language about women and using terms such as "cervix havers" when 40% of women (especially immigrants, those of lower socio-economic status, women who don't speak English well, women with learning disabilities or poorly educated etc. etc) do not know what a cervix is. It is a completely valid point that TRAs have misrepresented as transphobic.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:34

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:25

FWIW< outside the wonderful world of MN, JKR is seen as someone who stepped over the line and bombed her own career for a few characters on twitter. It must be so terribly difficult for her with her millions.
You do know Twitter isn't the real world, right?

No, but it was certainly a stupid move from someone with such a global platform. She could have used it for good, and she didn't. But she's so terribly RIGHT.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:33

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:28

That might be her intention, but it's not what she's saying. Her tweets are incendiary, she isn't expressing herself in a way that makes people understand her points of view.

Have you read her essay explaining it?

And I, and I'd guess the vast majority of women who care, would entirely cease to care if single sex spaces were preserved (especially shelters, rape crisis and prisons), women's sports were sex-specific, children were offered good supports rather than hormones or surgery, and women were allowed to talk about women's issues (rape, FGM, abortion) without being asked to centre trans women. I couldn't give a crap about what people wear, what pronouns they use and if they'd like to change their name. Fill your boots.

If you agree with the above, you agree with most of the 'batshit feminists'.

But people aren't going to read her essay, because she's been so ridiculous on twitter.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:32

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:28

Her tweet about menstruation really hurt the trans community

In what way though? Presumably only if they think we should pretend that trans women menstruated. I don't see any slight to trans woman here, she's attacking the ridiculous narrative where we are suppose to dance around biological facts.

And, is that it, in terms of this incendiary material you're talking about?

"is that it" point proven.
It HURT people. Do you understand?

Why do you expect people to give two shits about your opinions on things whe you don't for others?

It will be a sad realisation one day when you realise that the trans community are well nested in our society and you will huff and puff abdou misogyny and woman's rights without any understanding of the fact that you, and people with views like yours, where they mock and sneer, have caused the divide.

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:28

That might be her intention, but it's not what she's saying. Her tweets are incendiary, she isn't expressing herself in a way that makes people understand her points of view.

Have you read her essay explaining it?

And I, and I'd guess the vast majority of women who care, would entirely cease to care if single sex spaces were preserved (especially shelters, rape crisis and prisons), women's sports were sex-specific, children were offered good supports rather than hormones or surgery, and women were allowed to talk about women's issues (rape, FGM, abortion) without being asked to centre trans women. I couldn't give a crap about what people wear, what pronouns they use and if they'd like to change their name. Fill your boots.

If you agree with the above, you agree with most of the 'batshit feminists'.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:28

Her tweet about menstruation really hurt the trans community

In what way though? Presumably only if they think we should pretend that trans women menstruated. I don't see any slight to trans woman here, she's attacking the ridiculous narrative where we are suppose to dance around biological facts.

And, is that it, in terms of this incendiary material you're talking about?

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:25

FWIW< outside the wonderful world of MN, JKR is seen as someone who stepped over the line and bombed her own career for a few characters on twitter. It must be so terribly difficult for her with her millions.
You do know Twitter isn't the real world, right?

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 20:25

YouSetTheTone · 29/05/2022 19:54

Trans community = ‘most marginalised’ seems hard to swallow when every major institution (including the police force, the judiciary, prisons service, the NHS, the BBC) proudly fly the trans flag at every opportunity and bend over backwards to accommodate gender ideology. There are zebra crossings painted in trans flags. Masked men can get away with assaulting women speaking in public about issues pertaining to women under the name of trans activism.

Transwomen now have access to female sporting competitions, female prizes, female bursaries, female prisons, female rape counselling services as well as male ones. So marginalised…

Women are murdered on average every two-three days in the U.K. there has not been a murder of a transperson for the past two years. So unsafe…

Society will believe a man who says he’s a woman over a woman who says he is not.

Politicians will not answer this question because they’ve been captured entirely by Stonewall and the damage is taking a long time to unpick. Watch the Nolan Investigates podcasts on how SW influenced major institutions via the back door, it’s eye opening and depressing.

Women don’t have penises. A woman is an adult human female and redefining the term to include men has catastrophic impacts on women. Politicians need to wake up fast.

This is food for thought, thank you.

OP posts:
minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:24

Her tweet about menstruation really hurt the trans communit. Not because of her point but because of how flippant it was about it. Now it didn't hurt you, because you're presumably not trans. BUt she had no reason to write it the way she did.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:22

That might be her intention, but it's not what she's saying. Her tweets are incendiary, she isn't expressing herself in a way that makes people understand her points of view.

You'll need some example tweets to back up your point. What is this 'incendiary' material.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:21

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:19

You will need to back this up by explaining how what you've said is different from what JKR has said. I put my money on you not being able to.

That might be her intention, but it's not what she's saying. Her tweets are incendiary, she isn't expressing herself in a way that makes people understand her points of view.

And before anyone else tells me she doesn't have to "be kind", "women say no", etc etc etc - that's the point.

The reason JKR by your own admission is misunderstood is because of the way she goes about it. Hence the divide.

FWIW< outside the wonderful world of MN, JKR is seen as someone who stepped over the line and bombed her own career for a few characters on twitter. It must be so terribly difficult for her with her millions.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 20:20

FoiledByTheInsect

not sure aggressively attacking people is the way to influence people.
Perhaps I should have said Conservative and Labour rather than left and right wing. And I don’t necessarily disagree that it is a capitalist thing - it does seem strange that people such as Billy Bragg are totally for it though doesn’t it?

and I have absolutely no idea why you think calling someone an ‘old school feminist’ is an insult - you seem to be projecting somewhat.
people like Julie Bindel have fought for womens rights for years (especially underprivileged ones) and are now on the pro women side of this fight.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:19

No, it doesn't.

And no, it isn't.

what do you think JKR is saying then?

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:19

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:17

No, it doesn't.

And no, it isn't.

You will need to back this up by explaining how what you've said is different from what JKR has said. I put my money on you not being able to.

Ferngreen · 29/05/2022 20:18

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

You are missing that transwomen ARE women or at least that is what the trans lobby demands.
I know it seems obvious that they are not but they insist and their supporters insist that they are - that is the problem imv. If they were happy to be transwomen who are treated like women that would be ok but they want to be women - so then they get on all-woman shortlists, into women's sports, women's prisons etc.
I know it seems like people are claiming the emperor does have new clothes after all but that is how the world is at the moment.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:17

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:15

You're wrong about that. Plenty of TRAs are adamant that trans people change sex.

good for them.
lots of batshit feminsts say ridiculous things too. good and bad in every debate.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:17

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:12

The problem is people spend so much time trying to be awfully clever (JKR included) that they miss the point. I fully support LGBTQI+, I work in a field associated with it, I am very passionate about the rights of trans people.

I don't agree with mixed spaces or trans people competing in sports. I don't agree with biological men being in with biological women in prison

@minutesturntohours you know that's the position of most women on here right? And that makes you a TERF. It is also basically what JKR said.

No, it doesn't.

And no, it isn't.

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:15

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:07

Nobody has ever actually said you can change sex.

The reason people don't want to answer your (not you personally) but 'questions' is because people aren't asking for an answer, they're asking for their next round , so they can be so terribly RIGHT.

We get it, these boards don't like trans as a concept, and aren't interested in anything except sex based rights. But at least say that and don't 'pretend' you don't understand.

The problem is people spend so much time trying to be awfully clever (JKR included) that they miss the point. I fully support LGBTQI+, I work in a field associated with it, I am very passionate about the rights of trans people.

I don't agree with mixed spaces or trans people competing in sports. I don't agree with biological men being in with biological women in prison

But I also don't start throwing out random statistics to try and make my point about women, because it's nto actually relevant. Trans is a huge concept and anyone who thinks that it will somehow go away if we say "BUT YOU CANT CHANGE SEX" loud enough is dreaming.

You're wrong about that. Plenty of TRAs are adamant that trans people change sex.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:13

We get it, these boards don't like trans as a concept, and aren't interested in anything except sex based rights

Well when we're talking about sex specific spaces and sex divided sports, then that's kinda understandable, don't you think?

I don't have an issue with anyone living, dressing, presenting how they want to. I don't think many people on here do. But yes we run into trouble when we decide gender trumps sex in sex divided spaces. How could we not?

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:12

The problem is people spend so much time trying to be awfully clever (JKR included) that they miss the point. I fully support LGBTQI+, I work in a field associated with it, I am very passionate about the rights of trans people.

I don't agree with mixed spaces or trans people competing in sports. I don't agree with biological men being in with biological women in prison

@minutesturntohours you know that's the position of most women on here right? And that makes you a TERF. It is also basically what JKR said.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:11

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:10

On here, the party line is pretending to be confused as to how a woman can possibly change sex and very graciously list your 2 percent of very generous acceptances you will allow trans people.

I'm not confused. Your sex is coded into every single cell of your body. Unless you have next-level alien tech to change that, that remains the case. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128035061000516#:~:text=Since%20sex%20chromosomes%20are%20expressed,totally%20independent%20of%20sex%20hormones.

Ah, but see im not silly enough to say that it's their gender they're changing, because then i'll get an essay on what gender is.

Not agreeing with/liking trans is fine, but don't pretend otherwise.

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:10

On here, the party line is pretending to be confused as to how a woman can possibly change sex and very graciously list your 2 percent of very generous acceptances you will allow trans people.

I'm not confused. Your sex is coded into every single cell of your body. Unless you have next-level alien tech to change that, that remains the case. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128035061000516#:~:text=Since%20sex%20chromosomes%20are%20expressed,totally%20independent%20of%20sex%20hormones.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:07

Nobody has ever actually said you can change sex.

The reason people don't want to answer your (not you personally) but 'questions' is because people aren't asking for an answer, they're asking for their next round , so they can be so terribly RIGHT.

We get it, these boards don't like trans as a concept, and aren't interested in anything except sex based rights. But at least say that and don't 'pretend' you don't understand.

The problem is people spend so much time trying to be awfully clever (JKR included) that they miss the point. I fully support LGBTQI+, I work in a field associated with it, I am very passionate about the rights of trans people.

I don't agree with mixed spaces or trans people competing in sports. I don't agree with biological men being in with biological women in prison

But I also don't start throwing out random statistics to try and make my point about women, because it's nto actually relevant. Trans is a huge concept and anyone who thinks that it will somehow go away if we say "BUT YOU CANT CHANGE SEX" loud enough is dreaming.

YouSetTheTone · 29/05/2022 20:04

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:56

But what if woman physically do have penises? now what? Is it a figment of their imagination? (I'm referring to trans men who have had reconstruction, just interested to know where you stand on that).

It is not a penis. It is an artificial construction that involves flesh from either a forearm or thigh. It is essentially radical cosmetic surgery. No transman will be able to ejaculate sperm or have a spontaneous erection. To have an ‘erection’ they need to pump up the ‘penis’.

So I would call this a woman with radical cosmetic surgery. Adding a fake penis does not turn her into a man, just as chopping off a penis does not turn a man into a woman.