Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:47

but were hurt by those words

Again, can you explain specifically why they were hurt?

In what way are my trans woman friends who don't bother anyone, get changed in their separate spaces and certainly aren't athletes but were hurt by those words offending you?

I have absolutely no issue with your trans friends who aren't impinging on others sex based rights, why would I?

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:47

Why would your transwomen friends be hurt by JKR indirectly pointing out that only women menstruate? It's a biological fact. How is it hurtful?

BasicBinaryBltch · 29/05/2022 20:47

Is the fact that there's not a single person in her franchise wants to touch her not enough?

I doubt this is true but if it is, it's hardly anything to brag about. People are so afraid of harming their reputation or losing their job by disagreeing with gender ideology that they repress their totally sant and factual views. Wow, well done👏👏

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:46

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:42

but you make your legacy ultimately in the end whether you are a kind person or not

oh we're back to 'be kind', got it 🙄

It's true though.

Will someone stand up at your funeral and say "she wrote lots of great things on the internet about trans rights?"

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:46

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:43

She just cares about other people apart from women. Imagine.

Not the women who's sex specific spaces and sports are being taking away from them unfortunately

ah, the old whataboutery.

In what way are my trans woman friends who don't bother anyone, get changed in their separate spaces and certainly aren't athletes but were hurt by those words offending you?

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:45

ScreamingMeMe · 29/05/2022 20:42

As if JKR's career is 'bombing'. 😆 Dream on!

Oh, could you tell me what she's doing in her career?

Is the fact that there's not a single person in her franchise wants to touch her not enough?

JustAnotherPoster00 · 29/05/2022 20:45

InChocolateWeTrust · 29/05/2022 19:44

I work with intelligent, educated, professional women. The overwhelming preference is for inclusion over women's rights. I don't hear the women's spaces argument ever and if I try to introduce it, people genuinely don't care.

This surprises me. I also work with intelligent, educated, professional women and my experience has been the reverse. The preference has been strongly for women's rights and the protection of women's spaces, to the extent that the reverse position is considered laughably woke.

Can you explain what you mean with the use of woke there?

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:43

Oh and JKRs career certainly hasn't 'bombed' in the last couple of years. People I know outside of Twitter either don't know what she has said, know and don't give a shit either way, or agree with her.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:43

She just cares about other people apart from women. Imagine.

Not the women who's sex specific spaces and sports are being taking away from them unfortunately

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 20:43

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:35

Trans women, who are biologically male, do not have periods. There is nothing hurtful about refusing to accept the delusion that they do.
Why are you hurt at having reality pointed out to you?

Apparently they do, along with "plenty of men". Periods "are not a feminine thing", apparently. Fascinating place, the internet.

Https://www.transhub.org.au/menstruation#:~:text=Trans%20people%20who%20go%20through,44%2D55%20years%20of%20age.

ScreamingMeMe · 29/05/2022 20:42

As if JKR's career is 'bombing'. 😆 Dream on!

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:42

but you make your legacy ultimately in the end whether you are a kind person or not

oh we're back to 'be kind', got it 🙄

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:42

Emma cares about women. She just cares about other people apart from women. Imagine.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:42

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:40

Emma Watson manages to be a feminist

No she isn't. God love her, she'll probably cop on when she's older.

Oh bless you.

I'm sure 30 year old Emma will give a monkeys what someone on MN thinks of her.

I'm afraid you can't tell someone else who is and isn't a feminist.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:41

It HURT people. Do you understand?

Well, I'm sorry that female biology is so HURTFUL to certain people, but JKR had and still has, every right to call out those who are trying to erase womanhood. We aren't having it, sorry.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:41

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:39

I don't read stuff by TRA's. i read the views of real trans people who were hurt
Why were they hurt? Can you be precise? (I'm guessing not).

Because of the flippancy of the "made up" words.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:40

Emma Watson manages to be a feminist

No she isn't. God love her, she'll probably cop on when she's older.

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 20:39

I don't read stuff by TRA's. i read the views of real trans people who were hurt
Why were they hurt? Can you be precise? (I'm guessing not).

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:39

An older person I know struggles with the idea of gay marriage - conflicts with their religion, generation, etc etc. Perfectly fine.

So they express that. Clearly.

They don't sit on twitter mocking and sneering at gay people.

All JKR had to do was write it in a way that wasn't flippant. And before anyone starts about her not having to tip toe, you certainly don't - but you make your legacy ultimately in the end whether you are a kind person or not, nobody in years to come will give a shit about your views.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:39

It HURT people. Do you understand?

Look I'm terribly sorry but we can't go round denying biology and riding rough shod over other people's rights because it hurts certain people's feelings.

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:38

But people aren't going to read her essay, because she's been so ridiculous on twitter.

I've read long-form Nazis and KKK and IMF and World Bank and IRA and even Shock Tories. If you can't articulate what the person you disagree with is saying, you're not mature enough to use the internet.

And I don't think her tweet about menstruation was even actually about trans people. It was about the utter stupidity of have no word to describe the group of people whose sex is female. And that is ridiculous. Without a definition for the group of people who have, may, can or used to mensurate, you don't have women's rights. You don't have women's anything. It was satirising that.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:37

orangeisthenewpuce · 29/05/2022 20:37

It's really not.

It really is.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:37

I don't read stuff by TRA's. i read the views of real trans people who were hurt.

and i give far more of a stuff about their opinion than I do hers. SHe claims to have trans friends. the 2022 equivalent of im not racist but.

The fact she was written out of her own books and films' anniversary because of her nonsense, I hope she's pleased with herself. Emma Watson manages to be a feminist without bombing her own career. well, at least she's got you lot cheering on for her, eh?

If JKR knew then what she knows now she wouldn't have written that stuff.

orangeisthenewpuce · 29/05/2022 20:37

This reply has been deleted

We've deleted this post as it broke our talk guidelines.

It's really not.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:36

No, but it was certainly a stupid move from someone with such a global platform. She could have used it for good, and she didn't. But she's so terribly RIGHT.

Well she is right. And in standing up for truth and the rights of women she is using it for good imo.

Twitter's a goddamn cesspit, theres no moral implication to getting a good reception there.