Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:04

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 21:03

That’s not a penis. You presumably know this, so why be disingenuous?

IT. IS. TO. THEM.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:03

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:01

Do you believe people can change sex then?

I dont believe people can change sex but I do accept the sex they choose to be.

I dont believe in God but I accept that people do.

I dont think same sex people are attractive but I accept that others do.

Tbe thing that irritates me with 'gender critical' (egotistical term) is that people make it all about them. You dont object to trans, you object to what it means for you.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 21:03

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:56

But what if woman physically do have penises? now what? Is it a figment of their imagination? (I'm referring to trans men who have had reconstruction, just interested to know where you stand on that).

That’s not a penis. You presumably know this, so why be disingenuous?

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 21:02

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:00

Yes it is.

And spot your flippancy at tbe end. That's tbe transphobia at play.

No, it isn't. It's a genuine failure to grasp what a male living as a woman could possibly entail.
Perhaps you could enlighten us? How does a biological male live as a woman?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 29/05/2022 21:02

Will someone stand up at your funeral and say "she wrote lots of great things on the internet about trans rights?

if thats the best someone can say about me at my funeral then i have absolutely failed as a human being

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:01

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:00

Exactly. I think your friend's upset is clear displacement. The fact that having periods upsets your friend is not JKR's fault is it? Just as the fact that I struggle with extremely painful periods and endometriosis isn't her fault either. It doesn't change biological facts.

Are you reneging on your earlier assertion that your transwomen friends were hurt?

No.

Same issue but backwards- the assertion that they're not women when they feel they are.

Thetes no point having this conversation because you're not interested in any views but your own. And that's fine. The divide will this continue.

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:01

Vikinga · 29/05/2022 20:57

Well I was born female and I identify as female. I know some trans people and I think of them as the sex they identify with. I'm shocked and disgusted at MN attitude towards trans women.

Do you believe people can change sex then?

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:00

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 20:58

It’s not transphobic to say that trans women are men. That’s the whole point, they are men living “as” women (whatever that’s supposed to mean…)

Yes it is.

And spot your flippancy at tbe end. That's tbe transphobia at play.

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:00

Exactly. I think your friend's upset is clear displacement. The fact that having periods upsets your friend is not JKR's fault is it? Just as the fact that I struggle with extremely painful periods and endometriosis isn't her fault either. It doesn't change biological facts.

Are you reneging on your earlier assertion that your transwomen friends were hurt?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 20:58

It’s not transphobic to say that trans women are men. That’s the whole point, they are men living “as” women (whatever that’s supposed to mean…)

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:58

Ah yes, the 2020 Yougov poll, where the last section is always missed out. The reason that it's missed out is that it clarifies that what is being talked about when referring to 'transwoman' is a male who hasn't had SRS has has fully intact genitalia. When this clarification is included, the results are very different.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 29/05/2022 20:57

minutesturntohours

Please do some research before you make yourselves look even sillier than you already are.
there are a number of tw and activists claiming that they have actually changed sex.
India Willoughby is one of them.

if you do not believe in transwomen in female sports and prisons then you are trans exclusionary as you are excluding transwomen from spaces they wish to be in. You may not be a TERF as you are probably not a radical feminist but you cannot claim to be fully in support of the LGBTQIA+ when you don’t go along with what a large section of activists want.

You are not on the side you think you are on.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:57

The fact he has periods is a hard struggle for him.

Well that may be and I have sympathy but you can't hold Rowling responsible for biology and the clear and irrefutable differences between the sexes.

Vikinga · 29/05/2022 20:57

Well I was born female and I identify as female. I know some trans people and I think of them as the sex they identify with. I'm shocked and disgusted at MN attitude towards trans women.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:55

I find it fascinating that Rowling is being required to be 'kinder' while getting death threats from TRAs. Nothing kind about that.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:55

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 20:47

Why would your transwomen friends be hurt by JKR indirectly pointing out that only women menstruate? It's a biological fact. How is it hurtful?

Well, let's talk about my trans man friend, as you guys claim to care about biological women.

He has spent many horrible years coming to terms with his identity. He now identifies as a man and is one of the brightest, brilliant people I know.

The fact he has periods is a hard struggle for him.

JKR sat on Twitter and mocked the word 'women's based on something that causes him immense conflict

She also promoted badges which while factually correct, were spiteful.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:53

None of them condemned the disgusting abuse she was subjected to either.

How very 'kind' of them.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:53

I would like to think people thought I was a kind person.

Me too. What I object to is when we're asked to deny biological fact to be 'kind'. Ultimately I value truth above that.

I notice you haven't responded to the questions you've been asked repeatedly.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:53

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:48

Erm, the Strike books - the last of which reached number 1 in the chart, the next of which is due out in August and the series which is currently being televised?

Also, um, a little known franchise called Harry Potter which seems to still be doing pretty darn well!

The franchise that deleted her from their anniversary celebrations

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 20:53

In what way are my trans woman friends who don't bother anyone, get changed in their separate spaces and certainly aren't athletes but were hurt by those words offending you?

You're not wrong. Same with mine (plus my trans man friend who's perfectly happy to describe herself as trans and a woman). I genuinely feel for the many trans people I've known over the years who just got on with things. I think actually they've suffered badly from all this. I know you think we're all hardcore right wingers but it's just not true. I was in Madame Jojos while Emma Watson was still pooing in nappies.

But the zeitgeist now is acceptance without exception. Which means any man who says he's a woman, no matter how much in bad faith he's doing it, should be in female spaces, centred in every female endeavor and allowed to abuse this system. Those are the people who are the issue, and their TRA flying monkeys. Not old-school transsexuals or radical feminists.

Starlee · 29/05/2022 20:53

FoiledByTheInsect · 29/05/2022 16:17

Is it me then, or are politicians not only cowards but also completely shit at maths? Would they not get more votes by giving 50% of the population what they want to hear rather than spouting wiffle to pacify 1% of it?

Perhaps it's just me. After all, I am just a woman so wtf would I know about logic, maths and voting systems.

I don't think any election will be won or lost on the basis of trans acceptance, most people are much more concerned about the cost of living crisis and having a proven liar as a PM. And most of the public support trans people anyway.
The majority of Britons do, in fact, support trans rights. A 2020 YouGov survey found that 40 per cent of Brits feel that a trans woman is a woman, while 41 per cent say the same for trans men being men. This is compared to 36 per cent of people who would disagree on both. Women are generally more likely to support trans rights, despite the alarms raised by so-called “feminist” groups. Almost half happily accept the gender identities of both trans men and women. The majority of Brits also say there’s absolutely nothing wrong with a trans woman using women’s toilets, changing rooms or refuges for victims of rape.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:50

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:48

Will someone stand up at your funeral and say "she wrote lots of great things on the internet about trans rights?"

I doubt it will come up. What about your funeral, will it be a feature there?

No.

I would like to think people thought I was a kind person.

I despite this flippancy of "be kind". It's been used by feminists to try and make it out to be a bad thing.

I know what I'd like my daughter to be.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:50

BasicBinaryBltch · 29/05/2022 20:47

Is the fact that there's not a single person in her franchise wants to touch her not enough?

I doubt this is true but if it is, it's hardly anything to brag about. People are so afraid of harming their reputation or losing their job by disagreeing with gender ideology that they repress their totally sant and factual views. Wow, well done👏👏

www.insider.com/jk-rowling-harry-potter-stars-transphobic-comments-reactions-2020-6

ew.com/movies/every-harry-potter-actor-whos-spoken-out-against-j-k-rowlings-controversial-transgender-comments/

No, it isn't always that. Sometimes peopl ejust really aren't transphobic.

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 20:48

Will someone stand up at your funeral and say "she wrote lots of great things on the internet about trans rights?"

I doubt it will come up. What about your funeral, will it be a feature there?

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 20:48

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 20:45

Oh, could you tell me what she's doing in her career?

Is the fact that there's not a single person in her franchise wants to touch her not enough?

Erm, the Strike books - the last of which reached number 1 in the chart, the next of which is due out in August and the series which is currently being televised?

Also, um, a little known franchise called Harry Potter which seems to still be doing pretty darn well!

Swipe left for the next trending thread