Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To not understand why the 'woman' question is so hard for politicians to answer?

269 replies

Themidnightpig · 29/05/2022 15:14

Genuinely not sure if I'm missing something here.

Constantly seeing it in the news politicians being unable to answer or getting flustered over the 'do women have penises' question.

Surely the answer is as straight forward as 'No, women don't have penises but some Trans Women do and as a decent society we treat them as women in so far as possible'

Why is this so hard for everyone to grapple with?

OP posts:
minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:38

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:37

But you don't agree with it as you go along with the pretence that your TW friends are women and your TM friend is a man?

Yes, that's how I refer to them

I can still have my views on mixed spaces

tillytown · 29/05/2022 21:38

If males, no matter how they identify, are included in womens space (sports, prisons, hospital wards, rape centres, support groups, etc) then there are no more womens spaces.
If males can become women, then there are no womens issues, they are peoples issues.
If males can become women then the pay gap and pension gap disappear.
Why are so many women supporting other women being screwed over? How much do you have to hate being female to decide to destroy other women?
Trans people can't change sex. Trans men need female healthcare, trans women need male healthcare, pretending otherwise is actual transphobia, saying women have our own wants and needs, isn't.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:38

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:33

That is transphobic in itself.

Are you responsible for the actions of all women?

No.

So why are all trans people responsible for those actions?

I was making a point about the different standards people are being held to.

We see this sort of male violence coming from TRAs and we are still expected to practice 'Acceptance Without Exception' and welcome males into our spaces if that's where they 'feel most comfortable'.

Meanwhile JKR is the worst person in the history of the world ever, because she made a 'flippant' tweet about the dehumanisation of women?

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:37

But you don't agree with it as you go along with the pretence that your TW friends are women and your TM friend is a man?

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 21:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And yet...

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 21:36

I agree with it all too

And I hate to bring it up when we're making such progress, but so does Rowling.

You really should read her essay. I promise you you'll find it enlightening if you actually care about getting somewhere on this issue.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:34

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 21:33

I believe the vast majority of people are supportive of people living however they want, calling themselves what they want etc. But you cannot escape the biological reality that you cannot change sex and that women are at risk from men (and disadvantaged in sport etc). So call yourself Amy and wear a dress if you want, I'll even call you she if you really want me to, but I will not pretend that you are a woman or think that its OK for you to be in a changing room or toilet with my 10yo daughter. TRAs should be campaigning for third spaces for transpeople and not denying reality. The word women should not be stolen from women and changed to mean a man who feels like a woman (sometimes). Also women should be given the safety and dignity of same sex spaces. And lesbians should not be shamed for not wanting to have sex with men.

This. Every single word of it.

I agree with it all too..

Wonders never cease.

We are all on the same side. Some people are just harsher about it than others.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:33

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:32

Vicious! 😂

A woman who makes a point about women being dehumanised and being referred to as 'people who menstruate' is 'vicious'.

But males who send abuse including 'choke on my girl dick you transphobic cunt' and hokd up banners at Pride marches which say '#killJKRowling' are the most marginalised in society and we need to be kinder to them.

Right, got it.....

That is transphobic in itself.

Are you responsible for the actions of all women?

No.

So why are all trans people responsible for those actions?

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 21:33

I believe the vast majority of people are supportive of people living however they want, calling themselves what they want etc. But you cannot escape the biological reality that you cannot change sex and that women are at risk from men (and disadvantaged in sport etc). So call yourself Amy and wear a dress if you want, I'll even call you she if you really want me to, but I will not pretend that you are a woman or think that its OK for you to be in a changing room or toilet with my 10yo daughter. TRAs should be campaigning for third spaces for transpeople and not denying reality. The word women should not be stolen from women and changed to mean a man who feels like a woman (sometimes). Also women should be given the safety and dignity of same sex spaces. And lesbians should not be shamed for not wanting to have sex with men.

This. Every single word of it.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:32

Vicious! 😂

A woman who makes a point about women being dehumanised and being referred to as 'people who menstruate' is 'vicious'.

But males who send abuse including 'choke on my girl dick you transphobic cunt' and hokd up banners at Pride marches which say '#killJKRowling' are the most marginalised in society and we need to be kinder to them.

Right, got it.....

Penguintears · 29/05/2022 21:31

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:21

Is there no middle ground?

I definitely think there is a middle ground, and that it's what most transpeople want but TRAs have ruined it for them by being so militant that TWAW and TMAM.

I believe the vast majority of people are supportive of people living however they want, calling themselves what they want etc. But you cannot escape the biological reality that you cannot change sex and that women are at risk from men (and disadvantaged in sport etc). So call yourself Amy and wear a dress if you want, I'll even call you she if you really want me to, but I will not pretend that you are a woman or think that its OK for you to be in a changing room or toilet with my 10yo daughter. TRAs should be campaigning for third spaces for transpeople and not denying reality. The word women should not be stolen from women and changed to mean a man who feels like a woman (sometimes). Also women should be given the safety and dignity of same sex spaces. And lesbians should not be shamed for not wanting to have sex with men.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 21:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:29

I dont agree with mixed spaces, mixed sports, or mixed prisons.

Well that puts you pretty high on the transphobia scale then. Probably almost as bad as JKR in the eyes of most TRAs.

BasicBinaryBltch · 29/05/2022 21:29

I'm not going to engage with you any further because I think your posts are disgusting beyond measure.

No, @SlightlyGeordieJohn has it exactly right. Bottom surgery is a terrible idea. I love how you flounce because you don't have anything to say to the contrary.

brookstar · 29/05/2022 21:29

If you can't name women as an identifiable group then you can't analyse, argue for or protect women's rights, health and interests. And while that suits the misogynists leading this retrograde movement, it's depressing to see women buying into this self erasure.

Exactly!

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 29/05/2022 21:28

TheKeatingFive · 29/05/2022 21:14

Her being upset is her issue, it’s no different to Rachel Dolezal being told that she’s white.

I'm not sure why this point isn't made more.

Apparently “it’s different”, but no-one seems able to explain why.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:28

Back to Ops question

This is why 😂

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:27

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:27

It wasn't a joke. She was making a very serious point. Referring to women as 'people who menstruate' isn't funny.

She was being vicious.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 21:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cool. Tara.

Interesting you took on pedantic points with me but nobody addressed tbe frankly outrageous comment from a PP which broke numerous guidelines.

And you say your board isnt transphobic.

Its interesting you think I care what you think! Reminiscent of a school bully thinking people had to impress them. I dont.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:27

Gadzookerykookery · 29/05/2022 21:24

@Highlyquestionablehoumous her choice to be “flippant”. Many people found that “flippant” post to be highly offensive and dehumanising.

Flippancy (or taking the piss, or banter, or “it was just a joke, can’t you take a joke, omg you’re all so oversensitive”) does not win over people, who disagree with you.

It gets you lots of love and cookies from people who already agree with you. And makes a jolly and easily shared sound bite or screengrab for them to share.

To the people who disagree, or we’re perhaps on the fence and persuadable, it makes you look malevolent, spiteful, and of ill-intent.

It wasn't a joke. She was making a very serious point. Referring to women as 'people who menstruate' isn't funny.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 29/05/2022 21:26

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:13

A lot of women found, and still find, 'people who menstruate' to be offensive and dehumanising.

But no one seems to give a fuck about that.

Oh no JKR 'crossed a line', by calling out the offensive, dehumanising erasure of womanhood in a 'flippant' way, whatever next! Hmm

Would it have been better if rather than using humour JKR expressed the deep fury that so many women feel at our sex based language being removed and women as a sex class being excluded left right and centre by the inclusion of men in the new definition of women?
If you can't name women as an identifiable group then you can't analyse, argue for or protect women's rights, health and interests. And while that suits the misogynists leading this retrograde movement, it's depressing to see women buying into this self erasure.

Johnnysgirl · 29/05/2022 21:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Highlyquestionablehoumous · 29/05/2022 21:25

Gadzookerykookery · 29/05/2022 21:17

That's not anyone forcing their beliefs on you. What if they started forcing you to chant certain prayers or mantras (a bit like 'transwomen are women'). …Would you not start taking issue with that just a little bit?

Like for instance the requirement for all UK schools to include a daily act of worship of a broadly Christian nature?

I do take issue with that. But nonetheless it is a requirement in almost every UK school, and largely we roll with it, and allow our children to attend, daily, for their entire schooling years.

Again, if Christians started calling you a bigot because you stated you didn't believe in God, would you find that acceptable?

So why is it OK to do that to people who don't subscribe to the belief that men can become women, and that if a man says he is a woman we should accept that?

And actually, a lot of people have a problem with children being forced into acts of worship, and they don't physically and sexually violent threats thrown at them for it.

Gadzookerykookery · 29/05/2022 21:24

@Highlyquestionablehoumous her choice to be “flippant”. Many people found that “flippant” post to be highly offensive and dehumanising.

Flippancy (or taking the piss, or banter, or “it was just a joke, can’t you take a joke, omg you’re all so oversensitive”) does not win over people, who disagree with you.

It gets you lots of love and cookies from people who already agree with you. And makes a jolly and easily shared sound bite or screengrab for them to share.

To the people who disagree, or we’re perhaps on the fence and persuadable, it makes you look malevolent, spiteful, and of ill-intent.