Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - BIL visiting

131 replies

Switchin · 29/05/2022 10:43

Posting in AIBU for traffic and advice - I'm absolutely certain AINBU. NC'd for this as it could be outing. Apologies that there's some background to this.

DW has 3 siblings, BIL1, BIL2 and SIL. Very close family, I get on well with everyone but BIL1 and BIL2 live abroad (in different countries from each other). MIL has always preferenced BILs as the golden children and SIL and DW were never prioritised - I think MIL potentially just prefers men because she's very similar with me and SIL's husband too (treats us as her surrogate sons etc).

DW is pregnant. She's had a seriously bad pregnancy with HG and other complications, spent a lot of time in hospital, on a lot of medication etc. She's been told she'll probably need to be induced at 38/39 weeks. She's now well into her 3rd trimester, and still weighs over a stone less than when we conceived (and she wasn't exactly huge to start with), and she's also in a wheelchair now (which has been really tough because she was very athletic before). To add stress to the situation, our house sale has been delayed and delayed and we're now scheduled to complete just 2 weeks before the due date.

BIL1 and his girlfriend have struggled TTC and are going through IVF. As a result, DW and I were told that we're not allowed to mention the pregnancy at all because it'll upset them - as far as we know, this message hasn't come from BIL1 or the girlfriend, but has been enforced by SIL and MIL. This means my wife has been in and out of hospital, really struggling and in a horrible place with no support from her family because they won't even discuss the pregnancy. No one talks about names or her bump or how anything is progressing. DW and I have both found this really isolating and difficult. For around the last six months, MIL has been trying to book a holiday to go away (abroad) with us and SIL's family (husband and children) this summer. The holiday would need to be in school holiday time for the children to go and this isn't possible for us because our due date is the start of August. Every time MIL brought it up and we tried to shut the idea down, we were reminded that we're not allowed to talk about the pregnancy.

Now, BIL2 (who's single) has announced that he's coming back to the UK from mid-July to mid-August. When he first announced this, although DW is obviously excited and happy to see him, DW was apprehensive about this because she knows it means a) a lot of obligation to spend time at MIL's house (where BIL is staying) which is many hours from our hospital and b) that she won't get any support or affection or help from MIL whilst BIL is here because he's the golden child and he'll be taking up 100% of her attention. MIL had agreed to look after our DS when DW is in labour but she's now saying she probably can't. It's also being suggested/implied that BIL will be staying with us (in our new house that's a renovation job) when the baby is born so he can "bond" - which DW and I both think will just add stress. DW didn't express any of this disappointment/frustration to her family but I think it was clear from her response that she wasn't enthralled that this had all been planned with no discussion with her and that she's, yet again, not being considered by her family.

DW has now been confronted by MIL and SIL about two issues. Firstly that BIL is upset that she isn't sufficiently excited that he's coming all the way back to the UK in order to be here for the birth. Keeping in mind that, at no point, did DW ever express that she wanted him here for the birth and his return flight is for two weeks after the due date so (if they don't induce the baby) there's a chance the baby might not even be here by the time he leaves! Secondly, they're annoyed because they've now booked a family holiday abroad (that MIL has been pushing for for months) and we're expected to "pay our share". It's booked from 3 days after the due date so, even if the baby is induced at 38 weeks (which is the earliest that they've said they'll induce) then the baby will only be two weeks old! The journey, door-to-door, will take over 12 hours to get to the resort. I tried pointing out that we wouldn't have a passport for the baby but they just sent links for how to pay lots for an on-the-day appointment. I then said that we don't have the capacity for a holiday at that time and that it's not feasible for us and now MIL and SIL are furious because we're ruining everything and apparently BIL is really upset that we're not going to be spending any time with him and he was really looking forward to this holiday.

The difficulty is that DW relies on SIL and MIL for support and friendship and she's really struggling being so isolated from them in this pregnancy. I'm prepared to be the bad guy who puts his foot down and says we cannot go but, unfortunately, they aren't accepting that I'm capable of locking DW up against her will - and DW doesn't want to cause a rift. It's also being thrown back in our face that when DS was six days old we travelled for a family wedding on my side (but that was, to my mind, different because the wedding was planned before the pregnancy, it was only a four hour journey each way, it wasn't abroad and the B&G were fully prepared for us to play it by ear and see if DW could make it - there was no pressure). As far as I'm concerned, my ILs are being completely unreasonable but DW would like to just smooth it all over.

Thank you and well done to those who managed to read this far.

OP posts:
Maurepas · 29/05/2022 13:40

They all sound like a box of frogs.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 29/05/2022 13:38

I think you need to show your wife this thread.

You say they are normally a support to her and they get on well but just some things are toxic. But this isn't just a bad habit or a little irritating thing they've done - they are withdrawing their support when she is literally the most vulnerable she has been in her entire life. They are toxic full stop, it doesn't get much worse than this, and practically no one is toxic 100% of the time or they wouldn't be able to function in society. Telling someone expressly they can't mention a difficult time they are going through, letting someone down with childcare for a hospital stay because something better has come along, and trying to force someone to travel and other things with a very young baby - these are all things that I and most people wouldn't do to a neighbour or acquaintance let alone someone who you supposedly love.

I can't emphasise enough how fucked up and damaging this is and they have obviously done this so much and she is so beaten down that she thinks this is normal and wants to try her best to stop them acting like this, rather than do what most people would do and tell them to fuck off. They are not nice to her, they don't act like they love her, and she really needs to put some distance between her and them, not just now but for ever, she shouldn't be relying on them for friendship, they will massively hurt her again and again whenever her brothers are involved. Can you imagine going out with friends if you were only invited as a back up? Can you imagine being in a relationship where you knew the person loved someone else more but were just with you as a back up because their true love was unavailable? Most people wouldnt because they would have too much self respect but unfortunately they have eroded this in your wife. She only gets on well with them because they can make an effort because her brothers are out the country and she is the back up child. This will never ultimately make her happy as her parents love will never be unconditional as it is conditional on her brothers needs being fulfilled first.

She needs to get some therapy and start separating herself from them and putting her needs first as they are never going to. Start by putting a message on the group chat saying she is really struggling with this pregnancy and has been very unwell and in hospital so won't be travelling straight after the baby and wont be having visitors around the birth though she would still like to see anyone. And then try and ignore the fall out. Concentrate on building other relationships that are based on mutual respect

DPotter · 29/05/2022 13:34

Slats
I'm guessing you're a same sex couple. Could there be a touch of homophobia going on here? Certainly sounds like it.

That's not my understanding at all - from the 1st post
I think MIL potentially just prefers men because she's very similar with me and SIL's husband too (treats us as her surrogate sons etc)

Also the op refers to himself as happy to be the 'bad guy'.

The DW'sr family is certainly toxic but I think homophobia isn't a factor

myuterusistryingtokillme · 29/05/2022 13:34

It's also very difficult for DW because she's a very, very determined person - she doesn't allow herself to be a burden or an obstacle so her family aren't used to her being obstructive. She's the one who makes sure things happen and go to plan. She doesn't like failing and she's feeling like she's failed here because she's saying she can't do something - and that's upsetting other people.

Really? She thinks she's failed because she can't do something that was completely and utterly unreasonable for them to expect in the first place? I'm mean there's people pleasing and there's this, perhaps she should look into counselling to help her deal with this fucked up family dynamic

SunshineAndFizz · 29/05/2022 13:33

Wow. I feel stressed just reading this. Can't imagine how you guys must feel.

Absolutely no to going on holiday, or having a house guest straightaway after. Just keep repeating 'no' to them.

Orgasmagorical · 29/05/2022 13:32

@SlatsandFlaps
I think MIL potentially just prefers men because she's very similar with me and SIL's husband too (treats us as her surrogate sons etc).

Tanith · 29/05/2022 13:32

I think this is one of those rare occasions when your wife will need you to step in and advocate for her. Make sure she's on board with it first.

You tell MIL that, had she allowed you both to talk about the pregnancy, she'd know how bad it's been.
You tell her what you are doing and what you are not. These are decisions you've both made for the health and wellbeing of your family and they are welcome to fit in around those plans, or make their own without involving you.

What do the midwife and doctors think of all this? I would run it by them and see if they advise strongly against it, as I think they will.

AcrossthePond55 · 29/05/2022 13:31

NeverDropYourMooncup · 29/05/2022 12:04

As you're fine with being the bad guy and MIL already prioritises men, use it.

'MY baby will not be travelling if she is here. I am NOT hosting anybody whilst I am getting to know MY daughter and cooking my wife regular meals so that she can begin to recover from 9 months of near starvation due to her illness whilst carrying MY child. I am NOT driving my temporarily disabled/recovering wife and family miles every day when I am short on sleep and still being her sole source of support because YOU have refused to provide any or even let her have any from her sister. If the baby is here, I am NOT going to be trying to get a birth registration appointment and then a passport when I could be with MY wife and children. And I AM NOT going to allow her to do all that for your benefit, either. If you try to force her to take my son out of the country whilst I stay with our daughter because she can't travel without a passport, I'll just refuse permission and they'll be stopped at passport control. The wellbeing of my wife and my children is the only thing that matters to me and I will NOT allow them to be dismissed.'

Another vote for this!!

As much as I hate the idea of 'the big strong man must take over from the poor little woman', because we can fight our own battles thank you very much, I'm afraid this is necessary in your case since your DW is endangering herself and the baby by not putting her own foot down.

You cannot control whether or not your DW actually cuts contact with her family. All you can do is control what you can and cut contact yourself. And that means no facilitating/paying for a holiday. No driving hither and thither. And no to hosting BiL, even if you have to tell DW that if she insist on him staying at yours, you and your children will not be there. Tell her that you will take 100% of the blame and she is free to say "Switchin won't let me" (just typing it makes me shudder) to all their demands. If they are all as 'male-orientated' as it appears, that should be an unanswerable argument.

There is only ONE time in our married life that my DH has 'taken control' of a situation in that way. At the time I was furious, but once the situation was resolved I realized that he was seeing the situation much more clearly than I was and that he'd done the right thing. So you do what you must to protect her and your family.

I'd also try to find ways to facilitate your DW getting support from other sources. Encourage her to join groups, see friends, and (if appropriate) get support from the women in your family. Be prepared to be her sole source of support at least for awhile. You're asking her to give up the support she knows, you need to be prepared to help her though that.

tkwal · 29/05/2022 13:30

Your post has made me angry on behalf of you and your DW. Your MIL has everything all wrapped up hasn't she. She controls all communication between your extended family. For example, who told your single BIL your wife wasn't overly thrilled about his visit ? Probably in order tomake your wife feel guilty enough to give in to her"suggestions"
There's so much more I'd love to say but you already know most of what I'd say.

If its difficult to get your MIL to listen, send her a letter. ,keep a photocopy of it (I know, old fashioned but so is she). You don't need to burn any bridges but let her know that your priority is your wife and children, how unwell she has been and how delicate she now is. That you will not be going on that particular holiday, that her brother will not be staying with you although welcome to visit before AND after the birth and that although you'd like to stay on good terms that will become increasingly difficult if she continues to belittle/disrespect/ neglect her daughters needs.
And (kindly) tell your wife to communicate with her siblings on her own , she doesn't need to have her mothers spin applied to everything

Good luck to you and your family in this new chapter in your lives 💐

SlatsandFlaps · 29/05/2022 13:25

Daleksatemyshed · 29/05/2022 13:15

Normally I'm in favour of women solving their own problems but in your case I agree it all needs to come from you. Your poor DW is too conditioned by her family to say No to them so you need to do it for her, make it very plain that nobody is staying and the holiday is a ridiculous idea.
Once the baby is a bit older, please get your DW to a therapist if you can, it will be hard for her but she needs to see her family in a clearer light.
I know someone like your MIL, she idolizes her sons but still expects her daughters to be constantly available to the point of resenting anyone outside the family taking their time. They're never allowed to be proper adults with their own friends or lives.
It will be hard but you'd be doing a great thing for your DW

I'm pretty certain OP is also female due to her saying that MIL favours BIL1 & BIL2. If male then surely there would also be an element of favouritism towards OP?

Jaxhog · 29/05/2022 13:22

Could you say that your DW's doctor has advised her not to travel for the immediate weeks after birth? A little white lie perhaps, but justified under the circumstances.

dapsnotplimsolls · 29/05/2022 13:22

No to the holiday, no to hosting BIL and arrange someone else to look after DS asap. It's bizarre and cruel of MIL and SIL to offer no support at all during such a difficult pregnancy.

SlatsandFlaps · 29/05/2022 13:22

I'm guessing you're a same sex couple. Could there be a touch of homophobia going on here? Certainly sounds like it.

By the way, your baby can't travel abroad before he/she has had their jabs anyway?

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2022 13:20

Switchin · 29/05/2022 11:08

Thanks - glad to see I'm not completely insane.

The dynamic with MIL prioritising BILs over SIL and DW is definitely toxic but, in general, they aren't toxic people - which is why the situation is so tough. DW gets on really well with MIL and SIL and they're usually very close. There's no way that DW would cut contact and, truthfully, I do think the relationships with them are overall more positive than negative but this saga is definitely highlighting the very toxic element.

DW simply does not stand up for herself to them, which I understand is very difficult because it would definitely not be met with a rational or logical or reasonable response from them - it wouldn't go down well. She's also very cautious of what I say for the same reason, and because it's clear that if I'm saying no then I'm speaking for both of us so she wouldn't avoid backlash. DW would like to be able to smooth this over without any confrontation, especially considering how tough everything else is right now. I don't really know how best to support her because she wants to not have to deal with the stress of the BIL visit and holiday but also doesn't want to have any friction with her family (either way is going to cause her stress).

It's also very difficult for DW because she's a very, very determined person - she doesn't allow herself to be a burden or an obstacle so her family aren't used to her being obstructive. She's the one who makes sure things happen and go to plan. She doesn't like failing and she's feeling like she's failed here because she's saying she can't do something - and that's upsetting other people.

They are not close!

Close family who care don't treat people the way they're treating your wife.

Look up FOG

Get this moved to Relationships and hope that Attila the Meerkat appears. She'll sort you!

The only way in the long run is to cut them out. Seriously they are utterly awful people but your wife can't see that yet

diddl · 29/05/2022 13:19

Firstly that BIL is upset that she isn't sufficiently excited that he's coming all the way back to the UK in order to be here for the birth.

I mean it's possible that that has come form MIL & not BIL.

If it's from BIL-who can be bothered with such a self absorbed twat & if it's MIL then it just shows how little she thinks of her daughter.

It's just so ridiculous & sad for your wife.

cigarettesNalcohol · 29/05/2022 13:17

Pretty sure most airlines don't accept newborns less than 14 days old anyway

Daleksatemyshed · 29/05/2022 13:15

Normally I'm in favour of women solving their own problems but in your case I agree it all needs to come from you. Your poor DW is too conditioned by her family to say No to them so you need to do it for her, make it very plain that nobody is staying and the holiday is a ridiculous idea.
Once the baby is a bit older, please get your DW to a therapist if you can, it will be hard for her but she needs to see her family in a clearer light.
I know someone like your MIL, she idolizes her sons but still expects her daughters to be constantly available to the point of resenting anyone outside the family taking their time. They're never allowed to be proper adults with their own friends or lives.
It will be hard but you'd be doing a great thing for your DW

Eddielizzard · 29/05/2022 13:14

No fucking way to the lot of them. While they might have their good points, the toxic part can't be ignored and is likely to be escalated as you witness your DC being treated differently by your MIL's misogyny. I wouldn't want my children exposed to this. Your DW's inclusion in the family is contingent on her towing the line and facilitating the nonsense. It's all a house of cards built on guilt and fear.

Alwayspaintyournails · 29/05/2022 13:11

If your DW is wheelchair bound due to HG she will most certainly need time to regain her strength after the birth.

You need to be strong for her just now. NO we will not be having a house guest, NO we will not be going on holiday or indeed paying a share for a holiday we didn’t agree to in the first place and NO we won’t be at MIL’s lots to see BIL as DW needs her rest - feel free to visit for a cup of tea!

TheCatterall · 29/05/2022 13:11

Your wife is being bullied by these people to the point that I worry about hers and the babies health.

ask her to list all these issues/demands down and review them. If this was a friend what would she be advising?

as for mil and sil bring ok normally - I bet that’s only because your DW doesn’t rock the boat and is the people pleaser.

the demands of holidays, bil staying with you, no support etc are showing their true colours as to what happens when you displease them.

go low contact.

your wife needs to start finding better support network and friends. I suggest when baby is born she tries herself into baby groups etc.

SunnyLobelia · 29/05/2022 13:08

My 78 year old father has a phrase.

'Tell 'em,... Fuck 'em'.

This is the time to use it.

I'm sorry.

LunaLights · 29/05/2022 13:07

Don’t let your precious little daughter be brought into such a toxic environment or relationships! She will suffer, just as her mother suffers due to it. You know about what is going on/how they treat your DW - how can you, in all good conscience - allow your DD to have to go through such poison too?

Blueuggboots · 29/05/2022 13:04

Tell them all to fuck if to the far side of fuck!
What a bunch of absolute arseholes.

TheFeistyFeminist · 29/05/2022 13:03

Your DW is worried about how they will react if you stand up to them as a couple, and she's worried about how she will cope if she has to go along with all the bat crap crazy stuff they are demanding.

On the basis that she's anxious either way, go for the option that has any positive outcomes at all, and put your foot down.

DW needs your support. She may want her family's approval (which IMHO she'll never get) but she needs your support.

No to the holiday.
No to hosting overnight guests for the time being.

If they are nice people apart from this, it will be a wake up call for them. If they are not nice people and this is truly who they are, your DW is better off staying at some distance from them, at least while she has the baby and recovers from the pregnancy and birth.

I wish you both well.

Borisblondboufant · 29/05/2022 13:01

Narc BIL likes to invite us to things we can’t go to. Then he can go round and tell people what terrible people we are for not turning up.
He tried to make me travel hundreds of miles 1 day after I gave birth because his wife had done that. She hasn’t, she had C sections and was in hospital for many days. But he got to go round and tell everyone how awful and difficult we were.

Thats what they want. You to pay. Not go and slag you all off.

Does BIL struggling to conceive want to go on holiday with a newborn and does other BIL want to stay in a house with one? Weird.