Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - BIL visiting

131 replies

Switchin · 29/05/2022 10:43

Posting in AIBU for traffic and advice - I'm absolutely certain AINBU. NC'd for this as it could be outing. Apologies that there's some background to this.

DW has 3 siblings, BIL1, BIL2 and SIL. Very close family, I get on well with everyone but BIL1 and BIL2 live abroad (in different countries from each other). MIL has always preferenced BILs as the golden children and SIL and DW were never prioritised - I think MIL potentially just prefers men because she's very similar with me and SIL's husband too (treats us as her surrogate sons etc).

DW is pregnant. She's had a seriously bad pregnancy with HG and other complications, spent a lot of time in hospital, on a lot of medication etc. She's been told she'll probably need to be induced at 38/39 weeks. She's now well into her 3rd trimester, and still weighs over a stone less than when we conceived (and she wasn't exactly huge to start with), and she's also in a wheelchair now (which has been really tough because she was very athletic before). To add stress to the situation, our house sale has been delayed and delayed and we're now scheduled to complete just 2 weeks before the due date.

BIL1 and his girlfriend have struggled TTC and are going through IVF. As a result, DW and I were told that we're not allowed to mention the pregnancy at all because it'll upset them - as far as we know, this message hasn't come from BIL1 or the girlfriend, but has been enforced by SIL and MIL. This means my wife has been in and out of hospital, really struggling and in a horrible place with no support from her family because they won't even discuss the pregnancy. No one talks about names or her bump or how anything is progressing. DW and I have both found this really isolating and difficult. For around the last six months, MIL has been trying to book a holiday to go away (abroad) with us and SIL's family (husband and children) this summer. The holiday would need to be in school holiday time for the children to go and this isn't possible for us because our due date is the start of August. Every time MIL brought it up and we tried to shut the idea down, we were reminded that we're not allowed to talk about the pregnancy.

Now, BIL2 (who's single) has announced that he's coming back to the UK from mid-July to mid-August. When he first announced this, although DW is obviously excited and happy to see him, DW was apprehensive about this because she knows it means a) a lot of obligation to spend time at MIL's house (where BIL is staying) which is many hours from our hospital and b) that she won't get any support or affection or help from MIL whilst BIL is here because he's the golden child and he'll be taking up 100% of her attention. MIL had agreed to look after our DS when DW is in labour but she's now saying she probably can't. It's also being suggested/implied that BIL will be staying with us (in our new house that's a renovation job) when the baby is born so he can "bond" - which DW and I both think will just add stress. DW didn't express any of this disappointment/frustration to her family but I think it was clear from her response that she wasn't enthralled that this had all been planned with no discussion with her and that she's, yet again, not being considered by her family.

DW has now been confronted by MIL and SIL about two issues. Firstly that BIL is upset that she isn't sufficiently excited that he's coming all the way back to the UK in order to be here for the birth. Keeping in mind that, at no point, did DW ever express that she wanted him here for the birth and his return flight is for two weeks after the due date so (if they don't induce the baby) there's a chance the baby might not even be here by the time he leaves! Secondly, they're annoyed because they've now booked a family holiday abroad (that MIL has been pushing for for months) and we're expected to "pay our share". It's booked from 3 days after the due date so, even if the baby is induced at 38 weeks (which is the earliest that they've said they'll induce) then the baby will only be two weeks old! The journey, door-to-door, will take over 12 hours to get to the resort. I tried pointing out that we wouldn't have a passport for the baby but they just sent links for how to pay lots for an on-the-day appointment. I then said that we don't have the capacity for a holiday at that time and that it's not feasible for us and now MIL and SIL are furious because we're ruining everything and apparently BIL is really upset that we're not going to be spending any time with him and he was really looking forward to this holiday.

The difficulty is that DW relies on SIL and MIL for support and friendship and she's really struggling being so isolated from them in this pregnancy. I'm prepared to be the bad guy who puts his foot down and says we cannot go but, unfortunately, they aren't accepting that I'm capable of locking DW up against her will - and DW doesn't want to cause a rift. It's also being thrown back in our face that when DS was six days old we travelled for a family wedding on my side (but that was, to my mind, different because the wedding was planned before the pregnancy, it was only a four hour journey each way, it wasn't abroad and the B&G were fully prepared for us to play it by ear and see if DW could make it - there was no pressure). As far as I'm concerned, my ILs are being completely unreasonable but DW would like to just smooth it all over.

Thank you and well done to those who managed to read this far.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mix56 · 30/05/2022 07:12

Actually, there is no chance in hell you will be able to get the paperwork to travel
But that aside, your wife could have complications, your baby is tiny & does not need to be exposed to 12 hours if travelling, & when you get to this place, wife will only be able to stay at home & recover.
Ask the doctor, ask the HV. They will all say No
So your wife simply has to say.

"Have any of you actually taken on board how ill I have been, I am in a fucking wheel chair, am underweight, I could die. Do you even care how incredibly ill I have been??
"The baby" , yes this forbidden word finally spoken, after your fawning over X who is sadly not pregnant, is precious, needs calm & to be in its own home environment.
No we cannot be joining you this holiday. We have already told you as much & obviously will not be paying for a holiday we have not agreed to go on in spite if the bullying.
Brother will not be "bonding" at our house, this is completely ridiculous, the only bonding will be between H, other DC & I, while I recover from my hideous pregnancy, and on top of that just having moved house,
I will not be catering, I will be recovering from this pregnancy & hoping my baby will be healthy.

Nobody decides what my family is doing, but myself, & H"

Robinni · 30/05/2022 00:47

Switchin · 29/05/2022 11:08

Thanks - glad to see I'm not completely insane.

The dynamic with MIL prioritising BILs over SIL and DW is definitely toxic but, in general, they aren't toxic people - which is why the situation is so tough. DW gets on really well with MIL and SIL and they're usually very close. There's no way that DW would cut contact and, truthfully, I do think the relationships with them are overall more positive than negative but this saga is definitely highlighting the very toxic element.

DW simply does not stand up for herself to them, which I understand is very difficult because it would definitely not be met with a rational or logical or reasonable response from them - it wouldn't go down well. She's also very cautious of what I say for the same reason, and because it's clear that if I'm saying no then I'm speaking for both of us so she wouldn't avoid backlash. DW would like to be able to smooth this over without any confrontation, especially considering how tough everything else is right now. I don't really know how best to support her because she wants to not have to deal with the stress of the BIL visit and holiday but also doesn't want to have any friction with her family (either way is going to cause her stress).

It's also very difficult for DW because she's a very, very determined person - she doesn't allow herself to be a burden or an obstacle so her family aren't used to her being obstructive. She's the one who makes sure things happen and go to plan. She doesn't like failing and she's feeling like she's failed here because she's saying she can't do something - and that's upsetting other people.

@Switchin

This sounds like faffery to me.

Your wife is pregnant and losing weight, she has been hospitalised but the pair of you are continuing to pussy foot around these relations as if their feelings matter more than your daughter.

Please do yourselves a favour and communicate to the family that

a) wife has been extremely ill
b) brother needs to find accommodation elsewhere
c) holiday cannot happen with a newborn; as somebody else said you need the birth certificate to get the passport and I’m not sure more flights will take such a young child. Besides it complete madness.

I want to emphasise this - all of this utter nonsense is risking the health of your wife and child with the stress it’s causing. They are being totally unreasonable and you need to emphasise to them how ill your wife has been and that the birth may be risky. There is no nicey nicey way around that I’m afraid. It’s the truth.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 30/05/2022 00:14

Besides being complete and utter toxic people, @Switchin, your in-laws are being utter bullies.
Your DW has been bullied for so long, she can’t recognize it any more.
You can.
Your first and your only duty is to protect your wife and your unborn child, since she seems unable to.
I’d do whatever it takes to do that, and to hell with anyone who gets in your way. Bullies are only as powerful as you allow them to be. Take away their power — simply refuse to be be bullied and refuse to allow them to bully your wife.
Stand your ground.
And congratulations on the new baby. I wish you and your wife all the best.

WingingItSince1973 · 30/05/2022 00:06

Your family is you, your wife and your dc. Your inlaws are extremely toxic and frankly beyond bonkers! Please please put your foot down for the sake of your poor wife and your newborn. She will honestly need time to rest and get her health back and your precious little baby needs to be settled into her home not whisked off abroad just to appease these weirdos that wouldn't even acknowledge her existence for 9 months. Please make this stand. You maybe surprised, they may realise they're unreasonable. I made the stand against my narc dm and even though we are close now I don't let her bully or guilt trip me anymore. I've learned to say no. Please do the same xxx

Marvellousmadness · 29/05/2022 23:11

Yabu. For agreeing not to talk about the pregnancy. And for saying that wife "depends on mil and sil for friendship and companionship"???

What bs
Why haven't you cut ties with these people yet. Its rediculous that you are allowing them how to live your life

guerrillagirl · 29/05/2022 21:57

Yeah I don’t think the OP would be on here asking for advice if he wasn’t a decent guy. Plus it’s easy to become blind to the dysfunctional behaviour of your own family when you’ve grown up with it

Painiscrap · 29/05/2022 21:00

Floweryflora · 29/05/2022 12:24

The way this is written is these people are awful. Yet there is a little nugget in there where you say she relies on them for support and friendship, which means clearly there is a side yoire not presenting. I assume as you want the answers to say they are all toxic?

yout wife is clearly close to her family. Let her decide. She’s a grown up and let her handle it.

Have you missed the part that DW is obviously unwell and really struggling with the dynamics in this family? Yet you think she should be left to handle this situation??? Any decent husband would not allow his dw to be treated like the OP’s dw is being treated! Any decent husband would not leave his dw to deal with this situation. The OP is a decent husband!

whynotwhatknot · 29/05/2022 17:01

Are they usually ok because your DW always yes to them

theyre very narcissitic and toxic she just cant see it

who asks a pregnant ill woman to shutup about her pregnancy and not even help her then demand she goes on holiday with a newborn

Thinkingblonde · 29/05/2022 16:47

One of my daughters has had three failed IVF procedures, she’s now accepted that it’s not going to happen, she can’t put herself through it again. it is distressing and heartbreaking for them. I’m her mother and I know that when a pregnancy among family and friends is announced, she puts on a brave face and congratulates them and no way would she ask anyone to keep a pregnancy secret. She’d be appalled if they did.

SpeedofaSloth · 29/05/2022 16:40

Blimey.
There will need to be confrontation at some point otherwise this won't be sorted.

Thinkingblonde · 29/05/2022 16:35

theremustonlybeone · 29/05/2022 10:56

Agree with PP. They are toxic individuals. Not being able to mention the pregnany is disgusting. They are naive too ...a holiday abroad with a new born? You have to make an appointment to register the birth and that can take weeks. Never mind the passport. You have no idea whether your wife will have a straight forward labour. If she has a c section she wont be able to travel and will be a high risk of clots. You will need to tell your wife and her family its not happening. I would be stepping back from them

This. It’s time to say “No, it’s not happening. My wife is my priority. It’s too much of a risk, for both mother and baby”
You decide who stays at your house, not MIL OR SIL! Don’t worry about upsetting them, thei don’t seem to worry about upsetting you or your wife.

Terfydactyl · 29/05/2022 16:30

Switchin · 29/05/2022 11:13

The "golden child" behaviour is definitely a concern DW has already raised. We're having a girl but all MILs other grandchildren (so far) have been boys. When we found out that we're having a girl, DW had a big cry on the way home about being worried that MIL won't treat her the same way as she treats DS, and it's something we're definitely going to be keeping a very close eye on.

Has bil stayed with any other family member who just had a baby?
I'm going to guess no and then I'm left wondering why a man who appears to not really care much for babies now wants to spend possibly weeks with a newborn girl?

Genevieva · 29/05/2022 16:28

PS the 'as you know' is to highlight the fact that you can't talk about the pregnancy, which has prevented you talking about your wife's health. They all need to know. You are the only person willing and able to defy the MiL. It might set the cat among the pigeons for a day or so, but her brothers need to know what she has been going through. They need to understand that she has been gravely ill, is exhausted and needs them to be understanding and accommodating.

Robinni · 29/05/2022 16:23

Your poor wife has been so ill!!

You both need to focus on her and the baby.

If it were me I would write a letter detailing the pregnancy complications and hospitalisations. And that it has been impossible to communicate because of this utterly unreasonable embargo on discussing the pregnancy!! Utterly unreasonable. It is one thing for you to avoid contact with the BIL and girlfriend for the duration and/or limit all the gushy chat around them……… but there is no reason whatsoever that her awful awful Mother can’t stand up and be supportive alongside SiL. Absolutely dreadful. Again - your poor wife I’m so sorry they’ve been so ghastly.

No holiday. No BIL to stay. If you are well enough collectively to see him he elsewhere. Bond indeed! What on Earth does he need to “bond” with your baby for?! He is a random uncle who will barely see the child because he lives in another country 🤷‍♀️

EwwSprouts · 29/05/2022 16:23

Your smaller family unit is expecting a child and your wife is unwell in pregnancy. There is no other priority and that extends until both are in robust good health after the birth. No other reasonable person would think otherwise. Just say no to the holiday. Let them sulk like toddlers.

MeridianB · 29/05/2022 16:20

Schoolchoicesucks · 29/05/2022 11:50

This is nuts- when your DW, MIL and SIL are together, they have to pretend your DW is not pregnant in order to avoid upsetting BIL and his girlfriend who are in another country?! How could it possibly upset them when they are not there?

3 pieces of advice

  1. Find someone else to look after your son when your wife goes into labour.
  2. Say once that you are not going on holiday and are not paying towards it, then ignore.
  3. Do not have BIL staying with you. If your DW is up to it, happily have them over/visit them but do not host. She will have just given birth, possibly have just moved. No-one who is there to do anything other than help has a place there.

It's a bit odd that BIL has to have this bonding time with his new niece that no-one has been able to talk about in case of upsetting other BIL.

Support your DW. Be the fall guy.
Once the baby is here, if they are still nuts and show signs of not treating her and your wife well, encourage your wife to make connections and support outside of her family so she is not so reliant on them.

This in spades.

You sound smart and totally aware of the unhealthy hold they have over DW. Please don’t fall into the trap of allowing them any flexibility because they family. They clearly don’t respect your DW’s health and happiness.

She has been conditioned for many years to respond as she does with them. She may find it helpful to read more about FOG: outofthefog.website/toolbox-1/2015/11/17/fog-fear-obligation-guilt

YOU need to stand up to them. They are already being vile to her, so she has nothing to lose. They are definitely not offering anything positive at a time when she needs them most.

If they kick off, block them for a while - you and your DW need to keep this stress out of your lives and make this the happy time it should be. Protect yourselves and your baby from these nasty people. Enjoy your new family. Wishing you luck.

whowhatwerewhy · 29/05/2022 16:19

I eco what others are saying .
You must now step up and be the bad guy.
No we won't be going on holiday, no BIL won't be able to stay ( unless he's willing to help ).
You will be putting your family first .
I like the idea of a group what's app addressing the Elephant in the room . Your sympathetic to not upsetting sil who's childless but surely the family can be just as sympathetic and supportive of your DW.

Genevieva · 29/05/2022 16:16

My advice, given the complex nature of the situation is that you have to use a group e-mail to the whole family. You explain that they are all loved and that your wife is extremely stressed and upset that she is apparently disappointing them by not being able to do exactly as they hoped with holidays and having BiL to stay. However, as they know, she has had an extremely traumatic, frightening, dangerous and difficult pregnancy that has resulted in her spending a considerable amount of time in hospital, using a vast amount of weight and becoming wheelchair bound. She is lucky to live in the 21st century with access to the NHS because her condition was often fatal in the past.

She is, presumably, under consultant-led care for this pregnancy, so you use her consultant's authority to say that the nature of her pregnancy and her general health mean that she must stay within easy reach of the hospital until the baby is safely delivered and that she should assume that she will need a considerable period of time to recover her health and fitness after the birth. As such, all foreign travel is off the cards for the duration of the summer.

Given your uncertain housing situation and the precarious nature of your wife's health, you will not be able to have guests to stay with you. However, your wife is very much hoping to see her brother during his visit to the UK and you hope he will be able to pop over and see you both during the day. You will, of course, have to play it by ear because she could require an emergency Caesarian with little notice, but you are sure they understand that the health of mother and baby has to be the top consideration.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 29/05/2022 15:46

I feel so sorry for your wife.

She feels close to her mother and sister, and yet they are totally unprepared to prioritise her in any way over her brothers.

They're not close, as has been said - they're just used to her being a doormat to keep the peace. This has to stop, for her own wellbeing - which will blow the smoke away and show what they really think about her.

I agree with the poster who said that you should use the fact that you can be the bad guy here - but if you or your DW really don't want to go that route, then I suggest you see the GP, or the MW, or health visitor and get a medical note that says "No, she cannot do this for her own health and safety".

The whole set up is ludicrous - they're just taking the piss massively. And they can fuck right off with the whole "you need to pay your share of the holiday" - just no! You didn't want to go, you didn't arrange it, and you're not paying for it!

HG is a fucking nightmare, it's not surprising that your DW doesn't have the energy to fight - so you do need to just say "We are not doing this and I am prepared to fight for you and for our baby and family".

Best of luck - hope this is put a stop to, pronto!

Sarahlou677 · 29/05/2022 15:44

They sound like terrible people but it sounds like your wife has good support from you. I wouldn't let them anywhere near the baby when it's born after all this.

One piece of advice I can give you is get your wife signed up to a few baby groups for when the baby is born. Might take a few till she finds the right fit but it will help her to build a new support system of other mothers

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2022 15:44

I'm having to speak up for DW as the situation is becoming too stressful & I feel unfair demands are being placed on her. So it's time - with absolute warmth & respect to you SiL - to mention the elephant in the room.
DW has been forbidden by MiL from mentioning her pregnancy. I can understand the need to minimise upset due to SiL's difficult situation right now, but what this has meant for DW is that she is now managing a difficult pregnancy which has made her very unwell. So none of you are aware of how much she is having to cope with, how tricky the birth will be, or what she is going to be dealing with post-partum.
As I hope you can imagine, this has been hard for her emotionally. So being told that she is letting the side down by being unable to confirm when her due date is, & being railroaded into a holiday she will be physically unable to attend is causing her immense stress on top of some already very unpleasant pregnancy complications.
I've therefore had to put the request to never mention her pregnancy to one side in order to help you understand why this holiday is impossible for her. I'm asking you to understand that her health is paramount, & to stop needling her about any plans in July/August, because she is simply unable to commit to anything beyond managing her own health until she is safely delivered, then dealing with the post-partum aftermath of what looks likely to be a difficult birth.

Excellent suggestion. And then be prepared to go NC when MiL and SiL erupt

I know what it's like to be ill in pregnancy and your wife's health and that of the baby is paramount.

This has to stop!

andweallsingalong · 29/05/2022 15:42

Agree with everyone else except maybe BIL visiting.

You say that DW is looking forward to seeing him and that he will very much be monopolised by MIL so having him stay with you might give DW small amounts of quality time with him before he heads off to Mils, potentially making him a powerful ally.

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2022 15:40

Goodmum1234 · 29/05/2022 14:51

As above…toxic to the core! No holidays, no visitors. Your poor dw

just a thought. What if the beautiful baby is a girl! She does not deserve this misogynistic crap.

she really needs nothing to do with them. If it’s your first child, going on holiday with a newborn would be terrible for baby and mum. She’ll just want you and to feel loved x

The new baby is a girl...

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2022 15:39

MIL potentially just prefers men because she's very similar with me and SIL's husband too (treats us as her surrogate sons etc).

For those who missed it...

Nanny0gg · 29/05/2022 15:37

SlatsandFlaps · 29/05/2022 13:22

I'm guessing you're a same sex couple. Could there be a touch of homophobia going on here? Certainly sounds like it.

By the way, your baby can't travel abroad before he/she has had their jabs anyway?

No. The OP says that he and his SiL's DH are also favoured by his MiL